Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Planing perfect dados

Posts

Re: Planing perfect dados

#26

Re: Video of the HNT Gordon dado plane

Steve Voigt

Keep in mind he's only using a 1/4" wide cutter. With a 1/2" cutter the effort would be more noticeable. And I would assume that the thin shavings are a consequence of the bed angle. It is pretty tough to hog with a 60 bed, no matter what the application.

I totally get the utility of 60 in a single iron smoothing plane, but it doesn't make any sense to me in this application, even allowing for the crankiness of Australian timbers. We don't normally need to worry about tearout on the bottom of the dado. Are all his planes 60? If so, I'd suggest that the reason has more to do with efficient machining setup than with choosing the best geometry.

Re: Planing perfect dados

#27

Re: Video of the HNT Gordon dado plane

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I watched the Gordon video, making a dado and rabbet joint in a drawer. He says:

Back in the old days it was considered high class joinery

Maybe not here in Pennsylvania.

I can see that it would be fast if one were making many drawers in a factory. I think for a hand tool worker it would be faster and more "high class" to use dovetails. Especially back in the old days.

Re: Planing perfect dados

#28

Re: Video of the HNT Gordon dado plane

david weaver

My kitchen cabinets made in the 70s were actually made that way.

Never saw it on an older drawer (every piece of older furniture my parents have bought - none of it expensive - was dovetailed. Really cheap furniture elsewhere has been pinned with nails).

Re: Planing perfect dados

#29

Re: Video of the HNT Gordon dado plane

david weaver

I think he must go with that bed for grooves instead of dadoes (sorry to repeat).

Either that, or I guess just because I've never really seen anything that has a bed less than 55 degrees (years ago when his planes were popular over here, I bought a 55 degree "jack" plane, but found it difficult to use for anything and unloaded it quickly).

Re: Planing perfect dados

#30

Re: Video of the HNT Gordon dado plane

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have cabinets with dadoed drawers made in the 1970's also. Back then we did not call it high class joinery.

Chicken dogs might be tastier than dog food, but I would not call it gourmet.

Re: Planing perfect dados

#31

Re: Video of the HNT Gordon dado plane

david weaver

I'm familiar with the drawers on mine because I've had to remake a couple of them. For entertainment, I made them by hand exactly the way they'd been made by machine, but without pinning them with tacks (the had dadoes and were tacked, presumably when they were glued).

I'm assuming that the joint is as much for assembly as it is longevity (because it doesn't have longevity once the glue or tacks come loose - the end of the drawer sides break out at the front pretty easily).

I'm sure they lasted as long as the manufacturer expected them to, though. The dadoes on my are somewhere in the range of 3/16ths or so, IIRC, and I cut them with a plow plane without issue.

Re: Planing perfect dados

#32

Re: Video of the HNT Gordon dado plane

david weaver

(I haven't yet installed the cabinets that I made - those are all dovetail construction on the drawers of course - not fat joint overly careful dovetail joints, just banged out joints in 1/2 inch sides, but I like the way that kind of work looks. It's not gappy, but it's honest looking).

Re: Planing perfect dados

#33

Re: Video of the HNT Gordon dado plane

Steve Voigt

Chicken dogs might be tastier than dog food, but I would not call it gourmet.

That's the best thing I've read all day.

Actually, I've made quick & dirty drawers that way and they were very sturdy. My in-laws have kitchen drawers made in the 60s with nailed rabbet & dados that are still holding together fine. But yeah, high class is definitely not how I'd describe them.

Re: Planing perfect dados

#34

Re: Video of the HNT Gordon dado plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)



I watched the Gordon video, making a dado and rabbet joint in a drawer. He says:

Back in the old days it was considered high class joinery

Maybe not here in Pennsylvania.

I can see that it would be fast if one were making many drawers in a factory. I think for a hand tool worker it would be faster and more "high class" to use dovetails. Especially back in the old days.

Warren, I agree.

There are power router bits that make "lock joints".

This is a machine joint made with a hand tool. I guess that it is valid - since anything that works is valid. It is not joinery I would use for a drawer, but many do .. generally those who cannot dovetail or are looking for a speedy process.

It does make a good demonstration, and Terry is good at what he does. That is what this is. Hopefully no one believes it is the preferred way to make drawer joints.

Regards from Perth

Derek