Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

Posts

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#26

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

Brian Holcombe

Thanks David! I appreciate the offer, if you get the itch to make another let me know.

Wow those planes do go for a fortune. He’s got some work into the detailed bits for sure. the knurlings and the cap are definitely time consuming to make on a small scale.

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#27

Re: Testing just went out the door

david weaver

Well, I thought it would be interesting to see if my overhard iron can hang with a PM V11 that's probably about 60-61 hardness, but my local friend who is also a woodworker caught my video and voiced interest in the LV shooter.

For fear that I'd sell it elsewhere, he literally asked if he could have it, showed up in an hour, and it's gone. Still really like that plane (but in probably a month, it managed to already find a dot of rust in storage from an overhead drip).

Total cost to me to have a target to shoot for in terms of performance was 10% of plane value. I know someone on another forum was offended (maybe it was this one?) that I would buy a $340 plane just in case (both to aim for, and to use if I couldn't match it). I can't imagine the investment in time and thought without a bar.

When my friend stopped by, we did get to play with a bunch of infills (mine and others) on a test board along with LN and LV's efforts. I cannot deny that they sure do make fine planes - both LN and LV - and the feel of all of the infills does not exceed the bronze LN 4 smoother - and some come up short due to funny weight distribution or proportions (or in the case of a norris plane with a norris adjuster, in adjustment). I'm sure that in context, my infill shooter doesn't exceed the LV effort, either.

Comparisons like I'd like to make aren't really worth the effort to do and post, though, either - unless there's nothing else to do, and my head is still teeming with future planes to make before my brain goes bad.

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#28

Re: Testing just went out the door

roger lance

Glad to know that you regard the LV shooter to be a good tool.....since I have one.

I did build a somewhat fancy shooting board based on Derek's ramped board style.....but, it was made with plywood off-cuts and other scrap......


damn.....that is fancy.....maybe I'm some kind of dandy..... :D :D

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#29

Re: Testing just went out the door

david weaver

that's quite a nice setup roger, and looks precise. While (from the discussion above) I could never call a shooting plane a necessary item, lots of us have extra cash, and the LV sure is nice.

While I'm not a fan of spending what would've been $600 or so for someone to make that setup for you, I certainly don't see anything wrong at all with building it yourself, as making precise kit like the board you show there is always a skill builder.

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#30

Re: Testing just went out the door

roger lance

"......it's always a skill builder"

That's exactly right. I choose to build the more complicated shooting board.....a ramped board.....because it was more of a challenge to make.

I've occasionally gotten a little negative responses to having some fancy shop furniture......but, I've always felt that making certain things for the shop was an opportunity to gain some valuable experience in case building that could be used later in a real furniture piece.

Just imagine all that you have learned making that infill shooting plane.....how much more knowledgeable and insightful you are for having made it.....and how much more confident you are in taking on the next build.

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#31

Re: Testing just went out the door

david weaver

That's exactly right, it gives you confidence that you can figure things out and build something that doesn't come off of plans (and do it accurately). At some point, I will go back to building furniture, but it's going to have to be difficult furniture and not just something large where the difficulty is figuring how to glue it and get it clamped fast enough to be ahead of the glue.

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#32

Re: Testing just went out the door

roger lance

One of my primary reasons for being involved in woodworking is the mental challenge.

I go out for coffee most mornings and see other old guys like me doing cross word puzzles and such to keep their minds going. The challenge of building something.....doing design in three dimensions in your head before going to paper and pencil (or computer) is just great.....good feeling to know I figured something complex out.

Making good furniture doesn't have to be an overly complex thing.....making something well that will be in your home.....that will be used and enjoyed by your family and yourself is a very good thing.....an enjoyable thing.

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#33

Re: Testing just went out the door

david weaver

Roger, I agree with you 100%. (and not flinging my desire to make something unusual onto others, making just to give to someone is fulfilling. I just have nobody to give to at this point, and a house that doesn't need more furniture).

I am very impressed by your shop organization, and though I'm not very good at it, may take a few lessons from you as I (not to jinx myself) get to the point that I really don't need to buy more tools and worry about whether there is a place they might go.

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#34

Re: Testing just went out the door

Patrick Chase

You can use my LV shooter with O1 and PM-V11 irons for comparative testing if you want. I also have a 51 (I have a hard-core case of plane acquisition syndrome) so it's not like I'll be lacking in tools.

Email if interested.

FWIW I think that for the vast majority of real-world shooting tasks the LV is the better design. I like the idea of a shooter with a cap iron, but in practice I don't shoot enough long grain for it to matter (and bench planes are fine for those cases). The LV's superior end-grain performance wins out.

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#35

Re: Testing just went out the door

david weaver

Thanks for the offer patrick. That'd be an expensive ship back and forth, though. Hopefully, if I just don't do it for a while, I'll lose interest.

Can't criticize on the overacquisitions. As little as I shoot (which is very little), I probably should've just used a bench plane. The biggest impediment is actually wanting to bend down and pick up the shooting board and then go fetch a plane. It's almost always faster to just plane the end of a stick (even plane wedge sized stuff) by just putting it in a vise and then checking it with a square.

I bought a second rolling tool cart, long and low, and can leave the shooter and a miter saw on it - two tools I rarely use because you have to "get them out" and put them somewhere to use them.