Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

Posts

Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#1

Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

david weaver

From a topic that is probably two months ago now? Can't remember. For practical use, it's finished.

Turns out that it works a treat. Surprisingly well.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XWZE4vC8IHY&feature=youtu.be

I still need to play with it some to get the feel of how it likes to be used. I made it look like it's worse to use than it is.

(and it still has just a bit of cosmetic work to be done).

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#2

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, it's looking very good. It seems to work well enough, although your blade could do with sharpening :D

Is that a single iron? And what was the final bed angle?

Now you will need a better shooting board. The current one is really looking like its seen better days.

OK, where is the comparison with the Veritas? :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#3

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

Brian Holcombe

Beautiful work David, I like the chamfers on the metal sides especially. Works nicely, and that as the key!

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#4

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

roger lance

David.....That's an impressive looking plane!!......I really like the sound it makes cutting end grain......it's a real accomplishment......congratulations!!

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#5

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Very nice job, David. I, for one, would like to see some construction shots, if you have them. Did you use double beveled dovetails?

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#6

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

david weaver

Yes - single iron, the bed, to describe it, is 40 degrees in line with the cut (so I believe we decided that if you sat an iron on it like a turned frog, it would be considered closer to 42). The iron is 1/4" at the business end and right around a 16th thinner at the far end, and with what I learned making wooden planes, it's a hollow taper (more at the beginning and then more gradual at the end). Bedding is much easier due to that. the bed is window flat, and I finish tapered the iron after the bed was cut so that it would bed without rocking. Tapering is time consuming on an iron like this, but easy if you just mark the thickness you want at given points and then check from time to time with a caliper.

You're right, it's a step off of full sharpness. The iron is extra hard still (the lightest of straw for tempering) and is a right b to grind -it's a big iron, too - a little over 2 1/2" wide. It's been given about 5 minutes of attention to set the initial edge, regrind and work the back. Part of the incompetence in me starting and stopping is trying to get the feel of it, though, too - you can just blast it right through if you want.

As for a comparison? This one is actually a bit easier to use outside of a track because of the handle placement, and a touch heavier than the LV. I was concerned about the wedge being driven out during the cut, but it's like a vault. Adjustment is very easy - the lock up from the wedge is so tight that a tap from a hammer probably only gives about a thousandth of depth.

I'll have to learn to use the LV plane better to make a fair comparison of any type. I'm sure a new user would find the LV much easier to set up and adjust, but they would probably prefer this plane if they had enough experience to understand freehanding and freehand grinding skew *and* preferred a shoot board without a track. Thus far, this iron is at least as durable as the V11 iron, but it's harder. V11 may separate itself in abusive wood.

I don't think any of the professional makers would make this plane for $2000, though, so LV wins. It's accessible, has support, and nobody deals with things like peining the brass cross strap in only to find that it draws the center of the plane 3 or 4 hundredths above the ends (!! if you're the guy who manually removes that much mild steel - it doesn't lap off like cast iron).

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#7

as far as the shooting board...

david weaver

...this is my good one :)

It's just a little bit dirty, and the black stuff on the track is just wax clumps.

It has the unfortunate luck of being stored behind my bench, which means it's there when metal is being worked. The level of filth that occurs (due to the tool volume and the dark wood dust and filthy metal shavings and dust being everywhere) when building infills is really unmatched.

I hear that PH is about 2500 janka on the high side, and this is the hardest and dryest I've used. I marked and planed the bed with an infill smoother of my own make - and then power-sawed the back of the front infill. I prefer the hand planing, it took no more time in the end and there was no burning ( a forrest chopmaster burned a lot on a skew cut on this wood, and temperature makes really persistent burn marks).

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#8

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

Patrick Chase

That's a very, very nice plane. I for one am not surprised that you matched the Veritas' performance. Your cutting geometry is very close to theirs, the rest of it is well-executed, and you were able to customize your ergonomics "to taste".

I've always liked that your "shooting board" is basically a large, very simple bench hook.

It puts some of the contortions the rest of us have been known go to into proper context.

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#9

Forrest blades

Patrick Chase

The Forrest blades have really low side clearance, which is part of the reason they cut so cleanly out of the box. The downside is that they can generate a lot of heat due to friction.

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#10

Re: Forrest blades

david weaver

That's correct. If you are cutting something agreeable and can keep them moving, the balance of factors is in your favor. If you are cutting not quite 45 degrees to a hard PH billet....well, I guess you can force the saw a little faster, but that can reward you with less than a flat plane and a blown out back side.

I only did it once with this PH. Coarse sandpaper caused the same discoloration on the end, and I'll do everything manually next time because of that. It actually took less time to hand saw and plane than to remove the burning, and hopefully very little scraping and filing will be needed to eliminate it from the ends. either that, or I'll just have to color the entire wood area with black magic marker and used motor oil to cover it up.

As far as it working well, you just never know while you're building it. We're old enough that it's hard to accept that potential for failure after as much effort, but the payoff is worth the risk when it works out. And I guess the learning when it doesn't is also worth it. Making infills has gotten easier, but it's certainly not easy. Everything is slow and hard (not hard as in difficult, but all of the materials are hard and difficult to work with compared to making a beech plane).

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#11

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

david weaver

Thanks, Roger!

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#12

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

david weaver

Hi Bruce - the construction shots more are less on UKworkshop (there's just no reaction to them here, so I don't post them), under a thread called "a simple box".

There's really not that much reaction to them there, either.

I think any time you build something and it's not contentious, there won't be much reaction.

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#13

Re: Forgot...

david weaver

..yessir on the dovetails with the trick secondary angle filed to "grip" after peining. A great way to join metal with minimal tooling and without creating the need for an absurdly thick sole.

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#14

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

Bruce, a MN Galoot

That was a useful discussion. Thanks, David. Coupla questions.

A. How thick are the sides and sole?

B. You left the pins and tails fairly proud of the surface. Did that present any obstacles in peining? I’ve seen recommendations of no more than 1/16”, which is why I ask.

C. What steel did you use for the iron? O1?

D. Did you REALLY file the iron to a taper? You da man!

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#15

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

David weaver

Hi Bruce. I made the pins 3/32nd, and that is a bit long. In areas where there were no problems, I hit them with a vixen to knock them down before peining. Through a mis-set of a marking gauge, the tails were 1/8th proud, and I had to knock them down before peining. I went larger than a 16th because there were a few gaps to close laterally and I wanted some cushion.

The sides are1/8th thick and the bottom is 3/16th. Any thicker, and the plane would be too heavy. It's 8 1/2 pounds or so.

O1 for the iron, and a little overhard as long as it holds up. Good 01 makes a superb iron if heat treated with care. I was able to use a coffee can forge and bernzomatic ts4000 torch with mapp gas to heat this iron probably a bit hotter than it should have been.

For the taper on the iron, I used a combination of the idler on a cheap 4x36 sander, and a vixen with anything from a hacksaw to a large washer under the middle to bow it. The vixen was a huge time saver over files for the rough work given all of the metal surface.

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#16

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

david weaver

Thanks, brian. I sort of owed (term loosely used) you a skew shooting plane, but can't come up with a good way to lay out a wooden double iron plane without compromising the abutments or wood grain direction.

I think building one of these is enough for me, but if I ever get the itch to build another one, I'll let you know. Normal terms and all (cost of materials - there's about $200 in this one).

I don't think any of the pro builders will be offering any of these up at ten times that, though there are short-cutted versions for around there (brese has an all metal BCTW-ish looking thing, but no skew). I'm sure there is a market for a plane like this if Ron can sell his short square box for close to three grand. I'd probably serve it for the mid-life crisis buying crowd if I didn't have a day job, as I could make one of these in a 60 hour week. Brese finishes his planes perfectly, mine has evidence of hand work. I sort of like the life that's left by hand beveling, etc, instead of by machine. The almost-perfect look draws more interest, in my mind - it's more natural. The average market purchaser would not agree.

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#17

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

david weaver

At the risk of being rude to the shoot board crowd..

... anything other than cheap shoot boards is a complete waste of money. Someone could say the same about my plane, BUT, it's a hard case to make when you're building your own. Spending two or three grand on a plane like this would be a complete indulgence, but I used it some more last night and it lives up to that.

I place far more value on the 24 inch starrett try square that I found for $60 shipped. It makes making these throw-away large shoot boards a snap.

(without the desire to make a plane, I would generally plane the end off of even the board shot in the video. It takes me less time, as long as it's marked, and a board like this set low in the vise is easy to plane with a stanley 4. It's the tiny stuff that's a trick, especially mitered, but a model maker would probably cut and sand those little bits).

So, yeah, the $400 shoot board market makes no sense to me. It's limiting and it takes the focus off of the work and developing skills. Just like all of the sawing gadgets.

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#18

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

That's just silly logic, David.

It is OK to argue for an expensive shooting plane, but not OK to argue for a shooting board that is similar, that is, not throw away? What are you trying to justify?

The #51 came with a #52. If that's what one person finds pleasure in using, why deny them half?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#19

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

roger lance

Ahhhhh......the interphase of logic and psychology.......

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#20

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

david weaver

Let me preface this with the fact (that sometimes isn't obvious) that this is my opinion. Rather than my opinion that this is fact.

Certainly, you can buy whatever you like - anyone can. I was just thinking "I have no idea why someone would want an apple watch", but they'll sell many. I'd long for a hand-wound watch that just tells me the time of day and doesn't have such a temporal junky feel. The DSM probably has something to explain why that is - plenty of people aren't wired like that, I just am.

So, here's my opinion - a practicality opinion (for the average hand tool or partial hand tool woodworker), and all of it goes out the window when you have a group of people who can buy a Rolex Daytona at full retail as a shop watch because they don't want to get a scratch on their Langematik (or a level of those folks, there's something for everyone - perhaps to some, a Langematik is a production watch that they could pass on).

The difference between the plane and the board is fairly simple: Both (specialty plane and specialty board) are an indulgence, but the plane is relatively permanent. It's a $350 item (the veritas, top of market), with significant residual value. It won't appreciate like the S&P 500, but a decade down the road, nominal value will probably remain without issue.

* The plane is the difficult part to make.

* the plane is the part that remains constant whether or not you're shooting something large or small, miter or flat, picture frame piece, cabinet rail or music box fixture.

* The plane is the part that doesn't take damage if you mis-use it, tipping or whatever (the shooting board does). I realize that if you spend more on the shooting board than the plane, you can now get sacrificial sides.

I didn't make the plane in this video because I thought I needed to - I did it because I wanted to. The cheapest "production" shoot board costs about as much as the materials for this plane. I didn't buy the LV shoot plane because I needed to, either, but I sure do like it. Unfortunately, I think I may have obsoleted it in my shop - or is that fortunately? I think I've matched the iron, too - at least in medium hard woods, but I can actually test that (it would be interesting).

So the board itself falls into the category of beginners traps:

* expensive dovetail markers

* expensive marking knives

* expensive infilled squares

* sawing guides

* expensive infill planes (sorry to the current makers, I really admire the type and I think highly of every single current maker, but they are in indulgence with a capital I)

I haven't touched upon real pattern makers, model makers, frame makers and miniature box makers. But exceedingly few hobbyists with limited dollars are doing those things for production, and the makers of those things that I knew generally used specialty or cheap devices.

There are so many other things in woodworking that are difficult to avoid spending a lot of money on (carving tools, good lumber, for some...just a good shop space) that I can't see any sensible reason to spend a lot of money on a tool that should be made of shop scrap.

And even the Langematik crowd, I think if they want to woodwork, they'd be more satisified to hone their skills making their chute board (even if they make the mistake of taking up woodworking by learning from a machinist as I did) than they would buying one - the gratification will be delayed, but exponentially greater in the end.

All that said, if someone has progressed to the point that they're buying a shooting plane, anyway, the LV is the one.

(stanley's 51 is a bad example, because it didn't come close to parity in sales with the target market, and it's clearly aimed at model makers and pattern makers more than cabinetmakers, regardless of what their ad copy said).

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#21

I thought it would be interesting

david weaver

... to see just how expensive the Stanley 51/52 combination was when it was produced.

It was $23.45 "in the early 1920s" according to Patrick's Blood and Gore.

trending forward with CPI from 1923 (Straw year chosen as early 1920s - there was quite a lot of inflation in the 1920s in the states, so the point chose does matter) to 2018 brings an effective current price (for both) of about $345.

This is not a perfect method, but we'll go with it (there are other factors that affect price - productivity, regulation, target market, etc). We would pay more in current dollars for a plywood shooting board in some cases (actually a lot, if you have to buy "add ons" than for the entire 51/52 combination....

...and the 51/52 didn't sell that well, even in a world still filled with pattern makers, etc.

Shootenstein is to satisfy my desire to make. I'd never buy it. If I ever decide down the road to make planes for money, I'll be glad to be nice to the people who don't agree with that. I did have the conscious thought at the end of a couple of days (I can't, again, emphasize just how physical it is to manually level, square, hammer and finish that much metal), though, that "if someone offered me $2500 to make one of these for them, i don't think I'd do it if I had a day job".

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#22

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

roger lance

I'm impressed with not only your ability to work successfully in two media (wood and metal) but also your ability to write very verbal, complicate passages.

To be sure, this does not mean I'm necessarily in agreement with what you've said.....but, your verbal skills are high......very high.

I've always attempted to use as few words as possible letting a photograph do the talking.

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#23

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

Steve Voigt

That's great David. Nice job, looks like a super useful plane. You might actually get me off my ass to make something similar. I purchased some 260 brass (the kind that's well suited for forming, not like the 360 free machining brass) a few years ago and it's collecting dust. I was kind of hung up on the idea of a bevel up plane, like the veritas, but yours looks like it does a fine job.

I'm curious why you went with 1/4" for the iron?

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#24

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

David weaver

I chose 1/4th for insurance because I didn't know how good the wedge would be. 3/16ths would've worked fine knowing what i know now, but the skew drilling had me concerned, as did my ability to execute everything well.

I also have a tinfoil hat theory that vibration is what causes thin irons like a Stanley iron to have a short life in a shooting plane, and wanted to make sure there would be none of that. in cherry, the iron dulled without leaving any lines.

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

#25

Re: Skew Infill Shooting Plane - Finished - Almost

david weaver

I've always considered it to be the opposite. If I was better at communicating, I wouldn't get stuck in such long verbose passages. (difficulty knowing when too much detail is too much, you know? It's usually too much when I'm talking).

I'm OK with people disagreeing with me, though! Explanation doesn't suggest that I expect anyone to agree, but fishing through all the details is how I learn.