Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Stanley Sweetheart chisel purchase.

Posts

Stanley Sweetheart chisel purchase.

#1

Stanley Sweetheart chisel purchase.

Lee

I just got a good deal on a set of 8 Stanley Sweetheart chisels. $150 Canadian, which is considerably less then Lee Valley sells them for.

A quick read of a few reviews and they seem like a reasonably well made product.

Anybody own this set?

What are your thoughts??

Thanks

Lee

Re: Stanley Sweetheart chisel purchase.

#2

Re: Stanley Sweetheart chisel purchase.

david weaver

I've never heard a complaint about them other than that they need a little more work on the backs (they don't, you can work backs in slowly if you know how to remove a wire edge).

The whole flat back thing is a bit of a bogus complaint, especially in chisels that are $20 each. It's an invite to learn a skill.

I'd buy them over Lie Nielsen's chisels solely because they're a small fraction of the cost and they aren't A2, which is a puzzling choice for chisels in the first place (I did have LN chisels in the past, but turned them over in favor of something not A2).

The only thing I don't love about socket chisels is that they usually have short handles and if you're going to grip them at the handle while working, you're sort of half on handle and half on socket.

That said, if they sharpen nicely and work well, there's really not much more to it until you start getting very specific preferences.

Re: Stanley Sweetheart chisel purchase.

#3

Re: Stanley Sweetheart chisel purchase.

Michael Brady

I have a couple of them and use them for rougher work. The Stanleys are not as good as my Lie-Nielsen chisels; in either quality or edge holding. They are comfortable to hold, but a bit under-weight due to the blades being thin and the handles on the small side. L-N's have more mass, as do most vintage chisels. Stanleys do take an edge quickly, but you will go to the stones more often to renew them.

In my experience, chisels are priced very close to their relative value as useful tools. The only bargains are in vintage ones if you can get them for $15 or so, and then restore them with new handles and careful preparation. The disadvantage is that they will be mismatched, most likely. Be careful that you do not keep trading up in chisels until you get some you are satisfied with. When that happens, you have basically wasted money on those earlier purchases. I know this from my own experience.

Re: Stanley Sweetheart chisel purchase.

#4

Re: Stanley Sweetheart chisel purchase.

TM Stock

I'd love to hear what you think of them after a couple projects.

Re: Stanley Sweetheart chisel purchase.

#5

Re: Stanley Sweetheart chisel purchase.

Joe shelton

They are good chisels, available at a good price, and you will enjoy them.

Re: Stanley Sweetheart chisel purchase.

#6

Re: Stanley Sweetheart chisel purchase.

Patrick Chase

You've only "wasted money on earlier purchases" if you didn't learn anything, or don't consider knowledge to be valuable.

IMO they're a reasonable set for the OP's stated current objectives. Those objectives may evolve, and he may replace them as a result, but that's life.

I have a few of them that I converted to skews, and they're fine. Make sure to lightly sand the conical part that goes into the socket. They come finished, and you you'll have trouble getting the handles to stay put unless you fix that.