Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

Posts

Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

#1

Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

TM Stock

A little goes a long way for me, but one of my students sent me a recent blog by Schwarz on words for woodworking that make him barf. She suggested that the real gem was not the blog entry - which was certainly amusing - but the reply from one of his readers:

"Gather around, kids, Old Man Schwarz is going to come out on his long and wave his cane at the damned kids with their hair and their clothes and their high-falutin’ “hand tools”. What next, foot tools? Just stay off his lawn."

That cracked me up.


https://www.popularwoodworking.com/woodworking-blogs/chris-schwarz-blog/words-woodworking-make-barf

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

#2

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane

david weaver

Passion - I think he forgot that.

"I have a lot of passion" or "I have a passion for making this".

Good for you. Get a room.

"amazing", "best ever", "game changing", "first new original idea in.."

I remember when the domino came out, I heard at least a half dozen people say that it was the first new original idea in woodworking in 20 years or something.

"it's an amazing best ever game changing first new original idea in ..."

And when I saw what it was, I was kind of underwhelmed. Fancy replacement for dowels.

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

#3

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane

Michael Brady

There has been a reaction to his comments, only some of it agreeing with his viewpoint. Who's asking anyway? How about this self-title: Jack of all trades, master of none?

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

#4

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane

Joe shelton

In spite of myself, I agree with him.

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

#5

The Schwarz

Ron Harper

I see animus against him expressed frequently. I have read a lot of his stuff, and been around him a good bit. I don’t understand it

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

#6

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane

Patrick Chase

I also basically agree with him, and yet simultaneously agree with the critique.

The reason is simple: Chris Schwarz has spread as much misbegotten, ill-informed hype as anybody in the industry. For almost everything he lists there I think I can some up with a similarly egregious example in his own past.

It would be sort of like if I posted and said "forum participants like the sound of their own voices too much". It's probably true, but I'm not the right person to be delivering that message.

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

#7

Re: The Schwarz

TM Stock

Schwarz disagrees in what is an agreeably snarky fashion, which is really quite annoying for those of us that know better. Further, I suspect the presence of his large group of camp-followers (to be found scattering rose petals before him as he walks through the fair...er, woodworking show), seems a bit undeserved, given most of us have to make-do with just the one orderly-cum-spear carrier-cum-general dogsbody. Finally, let's acknowledge the fact that no guy truly likes or trusts another man with a designated latte boy on staff.

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

#8

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane

North of the Border

"Fancy replacement for dowels."

Yes, to those who have never truly used it to its full potential.

Tage Frid and James Krenov were both users of dowels in their furniture making. If they had had a chance to use a domino joiner, they would probably have included this game changing tool in their books along side the dowels.

Game changing? Oh yes for many owners of them who build case furniture and more -- with precision and speed that dowels can't match. When it first came out, I thought it was an improved biscuit joiner. How wrong was I, now a user of dominoes for close to 11 years.

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

#9

Re: The Schwarz

North of the Border

Ron,

That means he is doing something right!

Of course, I am not saying he is doing everything right.

For every cause that has no controversy, it has little relevancy. That is how I see the world. Many many people avoid dissents and go with the tide. The world becomes better when we hear divergent views and see divergent paths taken.

Chris is not content to be going with the tide on everything.

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

#10

Re: The Schwarz

Brian Holcombe

His articles are entertaining and I also feel he likes to stir the pot a bit and get people talking. He’s as guilty as anyone of writing copy which bolsters the appeal of something, but I can see that he dislikes the shortcut version which just touches on certain keywords which are quite popular but largely meaningless.

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

#11

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane

david weaver

It is a nice device, and though you haven't said it, I get the gist that I don't know enough about it to come to a super strong conclusion - that's true.

If I had paying customers and something to make that needed a ton of tiny precise tenons, I might have greater appreciation. I do recall Warren mentioning stub tenons around the same amount of time that others' quoted, and I'll have to take his word for it. A contest of M&T between Warren and I wouldn't last long - Warren would probably make four for each one I did.

But I'm sure I could make the domino appear difficult to use, too.

(and while I'm a huge fan of traditional work, I also have much appreciation for dowels in the applications I've seen them used)

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

#12

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane

Brian Holcombe

Most Festool stuff is great especially when used on-site. I don’t really find I need to rely on it heavily in the shop, except perhaps the track saw. I don’t own a domino so I can’t say much about it, but my recent student runs a commercial shop and she uses it regularly.

It surprises me that it’s found such a home in commercial shops as often you can use a stand alone machine for the work. However I would imagine the domino is considerably faster because of how the bit moves. Few commercial machines do that and the ones that do cost a lot. Few machines are as fast as the domino, IMO, unless they’re fully automated. I would imagine a machine with big table is a bit more accurate due to the larger reference.

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

#13

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane

North of the Border

The domino joiner replaces the mortising machine/mortiser (I sold mine a couple years later after I had use the dj well enough) as well as the tablesaw (ripping the loose tenons or cutting the tenons)/router.

But speed isn't its only merit, it is its ability to handle angles. Tage Frid covered the three way mitre joint in his book (vol. 1 or 2?) using the tablesaw (I think) and concluded that it was too difficult a joint...even for a master like him. However, the three way mitre joint is one of the joints covered in the domino joiner manual (sup) and it is a doable joint to an average woodworker with a good mite saw.

The angle fence of the tool allows a dj to do what a dowel jig can't do by itself.

Among all the Festool tools in my shop, the dj is the only tool I would not want to part with. It is not just for cabinets/carcase construction, frames or chair joinery, every panel construction (table tops, wide panels) is made easy with it (unlike a biscuit joiner, it self aligns with the narrow setting).

If I sound like a salesman here, my apologies. Some previous owners sold their djs, proclaiming that they did not really find them a great help. But it is like hand cutting dovetails, until you are good it, you won't understand the joy of a dovetail handcut to perfection.

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

#14

Re: Everything has a learning curve....

david weaver

..I'm sure that the people who didn't like the domino that much probably got out of it what they put into it.

I have a friend with a multi router. He makes one piece at a time, and it is a drag for me to use the thing with him because it takes so long to set up and then the cuts are over, and he's nutty about how tight the joints are, so gluing becomes a bit of a problem sometimes once a water based glue is added to the equation. I think the people who loved the multirouter are those who took the time to work up templates and stick with something fairly repetitive. I think the domino would've been a better fit for him.

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

#15

Re: Everything has a learning curve....

North of the Border

"I'm sure that the people who didn't like the domino that much probably got out of it what they put into it."

So true, not just of the domino but also of a lot of hand tools.

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

#16

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane

North of the Border

This type of build is where a dj will thrive. Lots of odd angles.

DJ to Dowel: Eat my (saw)dust.


Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

#17

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane

Brian Holcombe

I don't disagree that there are places where it is excellent. I think your project is nicely done.

I'm not a fan of floating tenons in things such as the three way mitered joint. Tens of thousands of those joints, if not considerably more, where made by Ming dynasty Chinese craftsmen and there are many contemporary furniture makers cutting the joint. Andrew Hunter, for instance. I certainly respect Tage Frid, but he's well off the mark on that one. If one studies the joint and the cutout and practices they will make that joint accurately, in fact there are a good few youtube videos of that joint being cutout.

As far as production method, there are better and faster ways of making joinery IMO. A swing chisel mortiser and tenoner/shaper are considerably faster and more accurate while making a stronger joint. They can be used to make haunched double tenons for instance with a total time of about 30 seconds devoted to the complete joint. Automated versions are faster still.

These do not rely upon the need of a third item, the tenon itself, to be separately created and they do not need end grain mortises to be cut.

So I return to feeling that a domino is of limited use for myself, I enjoy cutting tenons and prefer to work in that fashion, but I respect that people do use them to make nice work.

Some of these things are just my own reasons for being in the craft, I like the use of interlocking joinery, the floating tenon simply lacks in appeal for me. I really find it inspiring to cut and utilize traditional joinery, it's critical for me and I'd likely find something else to do with my time if that were not a part of it. I design around the use of joinery, so it is part and parcel for me.

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

#18

Re: Everything has a learning curve....

Patrick Chase

It sounds to me like your friend needs only a JointMaker Pro to be complete.

[ducks and covers]

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

#19

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane

Toolemera

After a very long absence, I return to find that:

A. I agree with the pot stirring comments as well as the mis begotten myths and mythconceptions comments and

B. It has been a few years and still people are battling over Chris and his ongoing evolution and de-evolution ?

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

#20

Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane *LINK*

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

I realize we have digressed from the original post to the merits of a Domino Vs. traditional mortise and tenon and loose tenon joinery in general. So since we're here now might I add my "poor man's loose tenon machine". A modified Jessem Mortise Mill setup. I had put the Mill aside for many years after finding it not that easy to use successfully. Dusted it off last year and was intent on getting it to work for me. This setup addresses the issues I was having and then some...

Norman


Poor Man's Slot Mortiser