Re: Old Man Schwarz Shaking His Cane
Brian Holcombe
I don't disagree that there are places where it is excellent. I think your project is nicely done.
I'm not a fan of floating tenons in things such as the three way mitered joint. Tens of thousands of those joints, if not considerably more, where made by Ming dynasty Chinese craftsmen and there are many contemporary furniture makers cutting the joint. Andrew Hunter, for instance. I certainly respect Tage Frid, but he's well off the mark on that one. If one studies the joint and the cutout and practices they will make that joint accurately, in fact there are a good few youtube videos of that joint being cutout.
As far as production method, there are better and faster ways of making joinery IMO. A swing chisel mortiser and tenoner/shaper are considerably faster and more accurate while making a stronger joint. They can be used to make haunched double tenons for instance with a total time of about 30 seconds devoted to the complete joint. Automated versions are faster still.
These do not rely upon the need of a third item, the tenon itself, to be separately created and they do not need end grain mortises to be cut.
So I return to feeling that a domino is of limited use for myself, I enjoy cutting tenons and prefer to work in that fashion, but I respect that people do use them to make nice work.
Some of these things are just my own reasons for being in the craft, I like the use of interlocking joinery, the floating tenon simply lacks in appeal for me. I really find it inspiring to cut and utilize traditional joinery, it's critical for me and I'd likely find something else to do with my time if that were not a part of it. I design around the use of joinery, so it is part and parcel for me.