Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Knew Concepts Saw ?

Posts

Knew Concepts Saw ?

#1

Knew Concepts Saw ?

Don Orr

As I look forward to retirement in a few years I am trying to acquire a few specific tools while I still have an income. One I have been lusting after is a Knew Concepts saw. I just don't know which one. I am looking for an all-around saw that I would not use all the time but want to work well when I do use it. So what do you all think-coping or fret and which size?

I did go to the website and use the "what saw for me" feature but also want to tap the wisdom of actual users. I have also read Derek's reviews over the years.

Thanks for any input.

Re: Knew Concepts Saw ?

#2

Re: Knew Concepts Saw ?

roger lance

Don.....A few months ago, I bought the 5" fret saw which was a great improvement over the French saw that I had for years.....much easier to secure the blade in the Knew Concepts saw, etc.

Much to my amusement, soon after buying, Knew Concepts evidently came out with an improved version of the saw I just bought.....literally, every major tool and most smaller tools in my shop have been improved, replaced, no longer produced, etc, etc.

But, I'm happy to have the saw I got.....as I said.....significantly better than what I had. I really can't say which model saw is the best.....only Derek, who has just about every one of them ever made, maybe able to answer that. But, you're going to like which ever one you get.

Re: Knew Concepts Saw ?

#3

Re: Knew Concepts Saw ?

William Duffield

What further recommendations could you possibly need? :) Have you watched the youtube video with Brian Meek by Adam Savage? It might help you decide. That said, I have a KC 5" fretsaw with the lever tensioner and swivel blade clamps. It is a very competent saw, and I like it. The models with swivel blade clamps are the only ones I would consider using. I agree with Derek that it needs a longer handle, with modifications to the shape. I'll get around to that real soon now. I have a coping saw which I also use a lot and am happy with, but I made it myself, so I haven't felt the need to also acquire a KC coping saw. I haven't had the opportunity to try a new MK IV saw, so I can't comment on the additional utility of the 360° swivel blade clamps.

Re: Knew Concepts Saw ?

#4

Re: Knew Concepts Saw ?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I am looking for an all-around saw that I would not use all the time but want to work well when I do use it. So what do you all think-coping or fret and which size?

Hi Don

The problem with a jack-of-all-trades is that you end up one that waters down the attributes.

If you just want a fretsaw for predominantly removing dovetail waste, I recommend the 3" version. That will cut to a depth of 2". One does not need more depth than that ...


The shallower depth also keeps down weight, increases stiffness and, since material is less important, the cheaper end of the saw range will do just fine.

On the other hand, if you want to do piercing, you have a choice of 5" and 8" frames (I am pretty much the novice in that area, so cannot make recommendations). There is also a new aluminium 8" frame, which Lee Marshall sent me about 12 months ago, which is thicker (and heavier), but extremely stiff. That's it on the left (on the right is the original titanium saw that Lee sent me many years ago, which we tweaked and he developed into the Woodworker's fretsaw) ...


This 8" saw has a 360 degree rotating blade.

For my own use, I just have an early 5" in Titanium. I really have not needed more than this.


Here is the handle I replaced on mine, with the originals in the background.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Knew Concepts Saw ?

#5

Re: Knew Concepts Saw ?

Michael Brady

I defer to Derek on most of what he said about the KC saws. Where I differ is on treatment of the handle. I don't disagree that the standard handle is far less than ideal. I had a couple of "exchanges" of ideas with Lee Marshal -God rest his soul- about this topic; and found him less that sympathetic. About this same time, another vendor introduced a fancy handle that added $75.00 to the already high cost of the KC saw, and was not as easy process to install. I bought the 5" aluminum saw and got used to the cheap handle on an expensive saw. Later, an improvement on the blade mounting screws caused me to again contact Mr. Marshall, who would only send me the new screws if I paid for the parts and shipping even though they were supplied without extra charge on the same saw, new. Honestly, this combination of circumstances left me with doubts about the respect for the customer shown by this company. Perhaps the new owner will rectify this.

Before you commit to this purchase, you may want to look at the saw being introduced soon by Dave Jesky at Blue Spruce Toolworks. His saw is designed specifically for woodworking use, not the jewelry-making trade. Dave will treat you with the respect that most other top-end woodworking tool makers have demonstrated.

Re: Knew Concepts Saw ?

#6

Re: Knew Concepts Saw ?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Michael, the reason why the KC saws came with the existing handle was to keep down costs. I discussed this many times with Lee. He provided a link to a custom handle maker on his website but, frankly, the saw is still very good with the original handle. I just believe the saw is better with the longer handle. My handles cost nil - I made them myself.

As to the extra cost for the new knobs, I know that these were costly. Only Lee Valley replace items for free when there is an upgrade. Do other companies do this?

With regard the Blue Spruce saw, which looks as stunning as do all their tools, keep in mind that it is a coping saw, and not a fretsaw. It does look to be a great design (also has the facility to turn the blade 360 degrees).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Knew Concepts Saw ?

#7

Re: Knew Concepts Saw ?

Charlie

Wow, who Knew?

Re: Knew Concepts Saw ?

#8

Re: Knew Concepts Saw ?

Don Orr

Thanks for all the helpful input !

Re: Knew Concepts Saw ?

#9

Unfair criticism

david weaver

We have gone nuts as customers (I have not, personally, I'd be ashamed), believing that someone who is running a business is required to give us their money instead of us spending ours with them.

Usually the folks making the biggest demands aren't exactly the same ones who are offering to go to their employers and give back some of their wages when they find the were doing something inefficient early on.

Think about this from the vendor's point of view. He's just trying to run his business, you tie him up with a couple of emails wanting something free, take part of an hour and then criticize him. It's really bizarre. This whole "i'm the customer and I'm always right" think is completely devoid of humanity, and it's childish. There's an exchange between us as customers and the vendors. It's a human exchange. If it's clear that it's all about the money for a vendor and they are making junk and just hyping it up, that's a different thing. If they are putting their time in and making something, and you use their time, pay them for it.

Otherwise, you ought to keep score of all of the times you ask someone for something for free, or feel you deserve it and take it, and make sure you do at least the same for someone else. I'd imagine that most don't.

Re: Knew Concepts Saw ?

#10

Re: Unfair criticism

Michael Brady

I fully accept your criticism of my comments if not the tone of your post. I know know you from several forums and certainly respect yours and others' points of view. I was merely comparing some points of service offered by other premier suppliers of goods to our mutual area of interest; and how this particular company's approach to customer satisfaction was not as accommodating as I had hoped. Since this supplier does not have multiple categories of items to offer to our market, perhaps a "once and done" sales strategy is best for them. Whereas Derek speaks of the product through his special relationship with the company, I was commenting as a ordinary customer, offering feed-back on the purchase and ownership experience. Interestingly, if you take the time to read postings on this saw going back to it's inception, you will find comments about the handle's shortcomings in almost every thread. If you re-read my post in this thread, I mentioned that I kept the original handle and still use it today. I could have easily made a new one, but that is not the point. Neither is it the point to quibble over $8.00 plus shipping for the metal knobs that replaced the original plastic ones that had been crudely re-purposed from some other intended use by sawing off the "wings". To me, that manufacturer was telling me that $98. was what they charge for a good fret saw, and that a great fret saw will cost you about $83. more plus shipping for a proper handle and metal thumb screws; and that is still my opinion.

Re: Knew Concepts Saw ?

#11

Re: the sun comes up the next day..

david weaver

..and the maker still has limited time to:

* pay both sides of social security taxes

* pay any other confiscatory local taxes that we usually don't see as employees

* answer emails, pack orders, order supplies, etc.

I think the trouble with something like this is that there is no mechanism for distribution after the fact, and I'm going to assume that when all is said and done, he wasn't making a whole lot. Even though the saws are expensive, in order to really reap much profit, you have to find someone who can produce what you're making on a large scale for very little.

If you get free parts for your saw, someone else will, then it becomes a post on a forum and a maker who is already probably making relatively little is stuck trying to spend all of his time keeping straight hundreds of folks who are getting free parts on his dime.

The fact that he'd sell the parts for $8 plus shipping is probably already a losing proposition, and we haven't even accounted for the fact that he may have had sick days or off days.

I thought the handle was kind of weak, but the saws were for metalworkers and not woodworkers. I sort of get that people don't have the taste that we have. I personally would much rather have the free handle than a $4 piece of cocobolo stick for $75, but the maker is in a thankless position either way unless he gets a duplicating lathe and starts to make his own (which again, would lead to higher costs).

We've been conditioned to believe that there is unlimited time, and that makers are stuck going down with our ships if we fire salvos at them. I think in this case, the conditioning is not appropriate because there aren't throngs of order fillers or automated bots that will just handle giving out free stuff.

All of these things have a great deal to do with why I don't make planes and sell them (something i'd love to do). I do flip razors and stones on etsy, and most of the people who buy are friendly, but from time to time, I get folks who want me to give them free stuff or send them 10 stones to try and let them keep one (which is actually market practice on really expensive natural stones, but not so much on stones that are $80).

I see this through the makers' eyes only because if he's not getting rich (which I'd assume is the case), if he's taking time off to travel to shows and then wasting money on a booth (and aside from the necessity of makers to get things in peoples' hands, the whole show circuit is a *tremendous* waste of time and money), you can only get pulled so many ways.

And no slight to Dave Jeske, but there's quite a bit of room in his tools to operate- but even for him, it's not an obligation. If he chooses to provide that kind of service, that's great, but it shouldn't be the obligation of a single maker who is probably working for a fraction of what we'd work for.

My sense on this is that if I had a saw that was outdated (and at one point, I did - from Knew Concepts), I'd be ecstatic if I could upgrade it for a few dollars. I have no idea how much of his time it takes to fill an order like that (the parts), make sure he's got stock, label a package, etc, but to me, all of those things aren't trivial. For amazon, they're accounted for. The same for LV. Filling customer service orders doesn't take a guy off the floor.

In our day jobs, if we were asked to spend a part of each year improving things we'd done earlier in the year and do it without receiving a pay check, we'd not be so happy about it. Entirely different thing than if we were buying $2 widgets off of dhgate and selling them for $20 as fast as we could.

Make a hundred of something simple and list it on etsy (you'd be surprised at what will sell on there). Take the time to fill the orders, answer emails with questions, etc, put stuff in boxes, track it, deal with lost stuff or unhappy customers and see how you feel about the prospect of sending out a couple of hundred packages with no compensation.

Re: Knew Concepts Saw ?

#12

Re: the sun comes up the next day..

Michael Brady

I appreciate your second reply and wish you would have reconsidered before sending your first. I really don't need the economics of business lesson, but I imagine that we have readers in this public forum that may not have business experience (yet) to draw upon. If you visit the Knew Concepts web site you will see photos of an manufacturing enterprise that has a considerable investment already made, and a relatively young new owner (Lee Marshall passed away this summer). I watched him make sales at HandWorks in Amana, IA to customers standing in line, aided by, I assume, one of his young children. Good, old-fashioned American commerce. Whether he operates profitably would be anyone's guess. I know he enjoys the substantial benefit of direct sales, but also has wholesale accounts to him he obviously extends wholesale pricing. I doubt that he is just trading dollars with those accounts.

For the record, I never asked Mr. Marshall for anything free. That was your assumption. Regarding the handle, I merely voiced an opinion that it was basically the equivalent of a file handle: unfinished with a cheap, crimped zinc ferrule. The thumb nuts were--well,--plastic. I had just spent over a hundred bucks for a saw whose function was to roughly remove waste from a dovetail board. It did a great job of it. I intended my criticism to be helpful. It clearly wasn't accepted that way, although both components were eventually upgraded with no change in retail price.

Re: Knew Concepts Saw ?

#13

Re: the sun comes up the next day..

david weaver

You're right, I couldn't gather from the post whether you were looking to get those items, or it was a philosophical thing and you were offended that there wasn't an equivalence between old upgraded at the seller's expense and new, and the seller wasn't willing to concede to your ideas about how they should offer their products or how they should run their business.

I just found it unfair because you bought something from the seller, later, they either offered you (or offered in general) to sell something to upgrade older model to new for a few bucks, and I find that itself to be fairly generous.

Re: Knew Concepts Saw ?

#14

Re: the sun comes up the next day..

Patrick Chase

Have we gotten to the part where we all hold hands and sing "kumbaya" yet?

Seriously, I think that everybody's opinion is crystal clear :-)