Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Dumb question

Posts

Dumb question

#1

Dumb question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi all,

We all have folding knives in our pocket, right? My question: Why are they 99.9% double bevel? Question 2: Does anyone sell single bevel folders?

Wiley

Re: Dumb question

#2

Re: Dumb question

david weaver

I have one single bevel folder, but it's for the shop. It's a sheepsfoot blade that I use as a marking knife.

That said, I've found double bevel just as good at marking most things, and less likely to climb the piece being marked against.

A single bevel knife is a bit difficult to use for general use otherwise.

Re: Dumb question

#3

My favorite - for sharpening

david weaver

is the wharncliffe blade. Not that it's important, but the edge is dead straight which makes it extremely easy to sharpen and keep sharp freehand.It never ends up with the tip being a different angle or dulled like clip blades do (and it's easier to get it sharper).

There is a local maker here who makes wharncliffe's tool hard, and had made a small lockback a few years ago (great eastern cutlery), but I don't think they have anything like it now. It's fantastic both in quality and in having respectable blade hardness.

Re: Dumb question

#5

Re: Dumb question

TM Stock

Assume we are talking about a utility knife in apron or pocket versus the bench knives we have at several work stations. My current is a Boker Congress pattern whittler, with the smaller whittling blade sharpened single bevel. Next time I put it on a stone for more than a few strokes, I will likely put the second bevel back on, as the bench knives handle most of those jobs that benefit from a single bevel.

Re: Dumb question

#6

Re: Dumb question

Joe shelton

Wiley, the only single-bevel folder I have came from Japan Woodworker in Alameda, and is a very good knife. Don't know where, or if, it is available now.

The best pocket knife I know of is the Case Seahorse whittler. Its main blade is a heavy section Wharncliffe, and it has thin, flexible pen and coping blades too. I'm with David about the Wharcliffe blade...

Re: Dumb question

#7

Re: A knife for what purpose, Wiley?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Derek and all,

Ordinary pocket knife. Lemme see what I do with it, just off the top,

1. Cut the morning paper out of its plastic wrap.

2. Head back the rose bushes, and cut creeping vines out of things.

3. Open Amazon Prime packages (lots of 'em).

4. Dig into the earth at plant borders, to put in cuttings, or replant cuttings my little dog ran over chasing around the fenced yard trying to get at the garbage truck or UPS guy or mail dude. [Digging in the ground gives rise to frequent resharpening].

5. Letter opener.

6. Cut insulation off of electrical wires I'm fixing to twist together.

7. Get splinters out of my fingers.

8. Etc etc

Here's the thing. Right now I do this with a Puma stockman with the usual 3-blade setup. I got the Puma as a cosmetic blem off of EBay, because I like that they hardness test them, tell you the Rc number, and show the dent the tester made. But the knife dulls fairly quickly, probably due to my abuse; the

Main blade is less than tight; it talks but doesn't walk, and though I don't need a lock back this main blade is loose enough that it'll rebound out of position and back toward my fingers sometimes when I'm cutting a hard whip with it.

And mainly, I like to be able to put a chisel sharp edge on any blade without much trouble. Test: Blade should slide into unsupported newsprint. Chisels and planeblades do it without a lot of detailing; knife requires lots of piddling around to get the same sharp. So a single bevel blade would be easiest; a Wharncliffe next--think I'll get a Wharncliffe.

Different subject: I'd love a multi tool that had a pruning saw, a knife, a 5 or 6 inch parallel wrench, diagonal cutter, Phillips #2 and straight slot, and needle nose pliers.

Different subject #2: Love them Knipex ratchet wrenches, but you do have to get the whole set of three. Why? The middle wrench (10") opens to 1-3/4" and so it won't get around the ~2" nuts that hold together 1-1/2" plumbing tubes. DAMHIKT.

Over and out, to copy John Aniano.

Wiley

Re: Dumb question

#8

A similar blade for sailing.....

roger lance

I have a knife from my active sailing days that has a straight blade and single bevel....


The marlinspike is for opening/closing threaded bolts/pins on shackles and loosing the occasional knot.....


Re: Dumb question

#9

Re: A knife for what purpose, Wiley?

Joe shelton

OK, you first must delete item 4 from your task list. You should be particular about what populates item 8.

You get extra credit for usage: "Fixing" is excellent and reference to a knife that 'walks and talks' is even better.

Now, go into the shop, use two scraps of a soft word, and tighten up on the pin. Then use abrasives judiciously to level the exposed end or ends of the pin, and polish to a degree that suits you and the knife. That's a good knife, and deserves a tune up even if you get one for the other pocket.

And thanks for writing about pocket knives, too.

Re: Dumb question

#10

Re: A similar blade for sailing.....

david weaver

My father has a knife like that - sheepsfoot with that spike for knot work (?). I can't remember what it was called, sailor's knife or something he referred to it as.

The knife I like the best is a bone handled "wall street knife" by tidioute. It wasn't cheap, but in the world if knives, it wasn't particularly expensive, either.

https://www.knivesshipfree.com/great-eastern-cutlery-99-tidioute-wall-street-antique-green-jigged-bone-wharncliffe/

I wish knife makers would consistently make the same thing, but they tend to rotate on things other than standard congressional knifes, stockmans, etc.

Anyway, it meets the requirements for me (which are similar to what Wiley wrote, plus the unsavory-to-some habit of using my knife to cut food if I don't feel like getting up from my chair to get a proper kitchen knife).

Re: Dumb question

#11

Is it this one?

John in NM

I've always liked this knife, but never got around to buying one.


Re: Dumb question

#12

Gotta agree with Joe

John in NM

#4 ! Eeek!

Personally, I rarely use the knife on wire I'm fixing to twist or solder. Exception is soft insulation wire with fine braid that won't stand being stripped with a pair of cutters. But that's just me, lots of people are horrified by the use of either rather than a proper wire stripper (some of which are really snazzy, btw).

Re: Dumb question

#13

Re: A similar blade for sailing.....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Roger,

Don't let that knife get away from you--they're hard to find by quality makers. I know cause I just got through looking, as it would be a good solution. The Case ones are in high demand--could only find one, and for $190. There is an Old Timer, but it's not a Schrade--someone overseas bought the brand.

Thanks for showing; brought back some search and rescue memories from Navy days.

Wiley

Re: Dumb question

#14

Re: A knife for what purpose, Wiley?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Joe,

Surely you're right about using one's pocket knife, for digging little planting holes. I suppose it's a good thing I don't have a Mont Blanc pen in my pocket to press into service. As for usage, I learned English from my dear Mother, who spoke a dialect only heard in Monroe, NC prior to 1920 or so. Sounded perfectly correct to me when I was growing up.

I did what you said and tightened up that Puma. Thank you--it never occurred to me it was such a straightforward fix. Just a skinny whisker of fine filing was needed on the pin.

I really like that Case Seahorse you pointed out. I also really liked Dave's Tidioute, but that one is not to be had, nor is a rigger's knife from a quality maker (I could use the marlinspike for the digging).

Thanks very much,

Wiley

Re: Dumb question

#15

Re: Gotta agree with Joe

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi John,

You're right of course, about the dirt and the wire stripping. I have a terrible predilection for using the tool in my hand, as opposed to the one I shoulda brought. My defense: it'll resharpen. And you get where you can strip wire--talking mostly No. 12 solid copper--with the blade barely touching any copper.

Wiley

Re: Dumb question

#16

Re: Is it this one?

Joe shelton

No, it isn't the same. But that looks like one heckuva knife. What is it?

Re: Dumb question

#17

I have a Seahorse Whittler

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

All 3 blades are shaped properly for woodwork. I don't care for the stainless steel and have not seen Case make this knife in Chrome Vanadium. I don't care for the double bevel. This knife is purposed for carving. The double bevel is counterproductive. Mora carvers are so much better but I have wanted to have a folder with a Scandi grind. I've been meaning to sharpen away the secondary bevel on the Case. A lot of work for the three blades. I agree a double beveled knife can be used for marking, but not for other woodworking tasks. I always carry a traditional folder which comes into use daily. Try sharpening a pencil with a double beveled knife. Makes it harder than it has to be.

Re: Dumb question

#18

Re: Is it this one?

John in NM

Its just a single bevel utility kind of knife, laminated blade, etc. 15 years ago most of the woodworking suppliers carried them, but I think that has changed now.

Re: Dumb question

#19

Very true

John in NM

My pocket knives often see abuse, since you can just resharpen them. Handy way to pass the time during a phone conference too, sharpen the pocket knife.

I bet if I were a gardener I would fall to the temptation of using my knife in the dirt too!

I keep a bailed knife on my electrical bag for stripping the outer sheathing on romex. Currently its an older TL-29, very commonly available on ebay for $10. Most electrical suppliers still offer them, but I wouldn't expect good steel from a modern offering.

Re: Dumb question

#20

Jeez...

david weaver

they've changed the way they look.

https://www.amazon.com/Camillus-Carbonitride-Titanium-Folding-6-5-Inch/dp/B005LHGBB4

The rigging knife my dad had was camillus (I'm sure he still has it), but bought at least 30 years ago now when the used knives could be found at auctions for a few bucks.

I see that "rough rider" sells a chinese version for $15 (I bought one of their knives at one point and one was enough, though I understand some of them are fine, I just don't have the tolerance to figure out which ones those are).

Kind of hard to tell what's still made in the USA, except by price (which suggests not much).

Re: Dumb question

#21

Re: A knife for what purpose, Wiley?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Wiley, as strange as it may appear, I do not walk around with a knife in my pocket. I have a small Swiss Army Knife in my briefcase and a combination tool in my desk drawer, but that's about it.

I do, however, have a few pocket knives that I use in the shop. My favourite is the Lee Valley "Woodworker's Knife". This has a single, double bevel blade. The original has a hooked/bent blade - I think it was intended to cut carpet. The blade is thick, and tapers down. This makes it handy to split thin boards for pegs.

Of course I modified mine - straightened the blade. Rob Lee says I am a compulsive modifier of tools. What can I say? :)


I like the wide bevels. They are as close as one can get to a single bevel blade. Easy to hold against a straight edge for striking a line, or to hone. Good steel - holds an edge for a long time.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dumb question

#22

Re: Pencil Sharpener?

William Duffield

Unless I need to sharpen a carpenter's pencil (seldom), I don't need to sharpen a pencil with a pocket knife, since I always carry a FastCap tape measure on my belt, and it comes equipped with an excellent pencil sharpener built in.

Re: Dumb question

#23

Re: A knife for what purpose, Wiley?

William Duffield

For item #4, a dedicated tool specifically designed for that purpose is a better choice. I might suggest a hori-hori. You don't need to carry it with you all the time. Keep it by the back door or the garden gate, and slip it into your back pocket when you go out there. Pt it back by the gate when you return.

Re: Dumb question

#24

Re: All Tools Are Kits


Re: Dumb question

#25

Re: A knife for what purpose, Wiley?

Joe shelton

I did that recently. I'd bought a Tidioute Appleseed knife, and though I liked it a lot as delivered, I could not sharpen the hawkbill as well as I prefer. I ground and filed the edge to straight, and am gradually sharpening to get to the long bevels that pocket knives should have.

Once had to return a Gerber folder because the wooden scales began to delaminate, shortly after I'd gotten the bevels ground wide and then polished beautifully. When it came back, the wood was perfect and the blade reground to original configuration, but coarsely and with blue discoloration.

From then on I've tended to do my own work...