Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

File and rasp recommendation

Posts

File and rasp recommendation

#1

File and rasp recommendation

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


I recently was faced with the task of shaping pulls for the display cabinet I am making. I don't have a well thought out arsenal of filing/raping tools. Mostly I have a collection of various sized files of some cut or another and some cheap hardware store rasps that are too coarse and don't seem to be sharp. They work OK for my needs but if I have to remove much material even a large file is slow.

An improvement to what I have would be something that removes wood quicker while not leaving a ragged finish that would be difficult to sand smooth.

For those that shape wood by file and rasp, what do you recommend for a basic set of files and rasps for someone that thinks a Stanley plane is sufficient quality and expense for planing. That is to say, I am not going to spend over $100 on this basic set.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#2

Re: File and rasp recommendation

Brian Holcombe

Bill,

For Rasps, I believe even basic cabinetmaker's rasps can help out quite a bit. I prefer Auriou, but they will likely blow your budget.

To start I would get half round rasps, one coarse, one fine. I also use a rat tail and find it hand on occasion.

Frankly I'd rather use other methods to shape wood, such as various planes, chisels or gouges, but they do come in handy on occasion.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#3

Comment.....

roger lance

Whatever you are currently using, I must say the results are pretty damn good.

I bought some Auriou.....but, just one of those eats up my wallet. LV has some "well made rasps with hand-cut teeth" from the Czeck Republic at a price point that would allow you to put together a set at your budget.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#4

Re: File and rasp recommendation

david weaver

A couple of the Lee Valley rasps (or other similar rasps that are about $25 - ufortunately, the LV rasps have gone up in price considerably since I bought mine), a couple of double cut files in flat and half round (like the simonds coated files - often found on ebay for a reasonable price) - bought new with fairly large teeth, and then some single cut files of the same shapes.

http://www.leevalley.com/US/garden/page.aspx?p=20133&cat=1,42524

The teeth on these rasps are sparse compared to the premium rasps, which probably makes them more aggressive and a somewhat less good finish for the tooth size. They are kind of like a skip tooth chainsaw chain vs. a standard chain in terms of their spacing vs. the premium rasps.

I don't have any expensive rasps, either, though I do have one of the saw handle maker's rasps that gramercy sold (that was $50) - there is no less expensive bent rasps of any quality.

I recall Slav Jele(can't remember the spelling of the rest of his name - he sold NOS rasps and files) suggesting stuff like what I mentioned above to do most of the work rather than using expensive rasps to do all of it.

Nicholson's super shear files are also excellent - I've got them only in flat files and don't know if they're made in anything else. Best found on ebay sold NOS if you can find them as they're about $30 new. The two I got NOS on ebay were about $10 each (a 12 inch and 10 inch, i think, are what I have). They would cut the rounded parts of your handles quickly and leave a nice surface. They have interrupted teeth and clear themselves better than bodywork files like Vixens. (I see inexpensive ones on ebay right now, but only in 8 and 14 inches). They are two sided with the shear cutting teeth larger on one side than the other.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#5

Re: File and rasp recommendation

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Slav Jelesijevich, frequently found at some MWTCA meets

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#6

Re: File and rasp recommendation

david weaver

Thanks, that's the guy. Been far too long since I was on woodnet and saw his name in type. Always liked his honesty about the workman like qualities of the coarse-work tools, and the thrift in not wasting expensive tools to do that work if it's not necessary.

(contrasted with some of the sales houses and bloggers who just push ad copy from the rasp makers suggesting that hobbyist woodworkers dump just south of a grand on rasps)

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#8

Look at Narex rasps

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I bought one recently and like it.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#9

New Old Stock - old but unused.


Re: File and rasp recommendation

#10

Re: Look at Narex rasps

david weaver

Those look nice!

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#11

Re: File and rasp recommendation

steve voigt

Ditto on super shears and mill tooth files in general.

I really don't use rasps at all, except for occasional use of the very coarse LV rasp, which is quite inexpensive. My $.02 is that even a fine rasp is not going to leave a finished surface. When making a tote, or sculpting the heel of a smoother, I try to get as close as possible with cutting tools (chisel, gouge, drawknife, etc.). If I can, I'll go straight from there to the super shear. If need be, I'll clean up a bit with the coarse rasp in between, but only if my technique was bad on the first step.

It's true as Derek said that mill tooth files grab, but that is a matter of technique. I suspect that is why the boutique rasps are so popular--they don't require much technique.

For larger convex surfaces, like the sides of a coffin smoother, I'll substitute a bed float for the mill-tooth file. The bed float also leaves a very good surface, but cuts faster than the file. It can also be quite grabby on long grain surfaces, but once again, technique is what matters.

Bottom line, a $30 mill tooth file is 1/3 or 1/4 the price of a boutique rasp and leaves a better surface that requires little or no clean up.

(Dave, this isn't really a reply to you, just general musings on the thread)

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#12

even if it was..

david weaver

I agree with all of it. If the shear file grabs, pressure or angle can often clear it up. They're lovely.

I am being stingy by trying to find them for $10 - certainly if one needs to get to business, for $30, they'll return more than $30 worth of service, easily, and they can be sharpened by boggs tool if they ever dull. Lots of tooth for subsequent sharpenings - and great to follow up the work by a straight tooth float (which in my dopey hands still sometimes leaves something that looks like planer chatter if there's no room to skew) or coarse rasp.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#13

Re: File and rasp recommendation

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Steve

I agree with the recommendation for files, and that they can offer a better finish than rasps. I mentioned this in an earlier thread. Essentially, I prefer to finish with a fine file, and this would be my recommendation for Bill. With the Iwasaki files, naively I expected that they would work as per the Auriou rasps I have used for a decade. I learned that they worked more like a dovetail saw - take off the weight and let them do the work.

For roughing out, the Shinto is another option. One side is coarse (about 10 grain) and the other is medium (about 13 grain).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#14

Re: File and rasp recommendation

Steve Voigt

Thanks Derek, I will try the shinto if I get the itch.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#15

Re: File and rasp recommendation

Kees

I am so glad to read this Steve! I've been on the fence for years to get at least one expensive rasp, but the price is always holding me back. I have a couple of the Iwasaki rasps and especially the small ones have been my tool of choice for handle making. I thought I was missing out, but maybe I shouldn't think like that.

After the Iwasaki I like scrapers, home made in all kinds of curves. And then polishing with a piece of hardwood has been a favorite finishing technique on the last handles. But sandpaper is also always an option. But scraping first saves a bunch of sandpaper and a lot of skin on my fingers.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#16

I need a decoder ring!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

To reemphasize, I will be sanding what ever I shape by file or rasp so finish only needs to be good enough to enable smoothing with sand paper, say 120 grit. What would be useful would be something that removes wood somewhat faster than a large file like I use for lawn mower blades and a second something that removes wood not quite as fast as a microplane. Maybe an aggressive file and a fine rasp?

I am sure there was some helpful advice given but I don't understand the words, which I have not encountered before.

To wit:

Super shear, mill tooth, bed float, double cut, single cut and Shinto. Which of these will shape wood some quicker than a 14" flat lawn mower blade file? And where does one find them?

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#17

Re: I need a decoder ring!

david weaver

Super Shear - find it anywhere - 12 inch. If you're really stingy, wait until one shows up in a size you like on ebay for $10. Otherwise, $20

Hand stitched half round rasp - LV for about $35 or something. The narex rasps bill showed look nice (can't vouch for their tooth size, though).

Half round and round double cut simonds files in a reasonably large size, ebay or anyone who handles them. These are fast enough to do some of the work that a round rasp would do if you only want to buy one half round rasp.

(all of those remove wood a lot faster than a mill bastard file)

The other files that you'd follow those with (single cut files), you probably already have. If you don't, obviously you can find those anywhere.

Card scraper is handy for removing rasp marks, too, and is my choice on handles, but it can sometimes tear things up a little bit in the early wood. Scrapers can remove material pretty quickly and easily on something like the ebony pieces you pictured.

You can ignore the stuff about floats, it's handy for us who are doing a lot of profile work on planes, etc, but you may not ever have something big enough to use them, and they are sort of one-trick ponies.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#18

Super Shear

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I looked this file up Looks like what I got from Lee Valley along with a lot of hype for how good it was. It is worthlessly dull. It just skidded over the Blackwood. How do you know you are getting a version that is sharp?

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#19

Re: Super Shear

david weaver

The 12" file is very sharp and if you put your fingers on it, it feels like it's grabbing your skin and would like to cut it. The 10" file is a little less so.

I remember George Wilson telling all of us that the 10" files were less sharp than the 12", and he didn't know why, he just knew it was so. Maybe the tooling for the 10" file just doesn't do as good of a job, because his comment is still true.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#20

Re: Super Shear

Kees

I don't know this super shear file but it looks a lot like the Iwasaki rasps, and they are sharp! It takes a light touch to work with these, too much pressure and they grab and tear.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#21

Re: File and rasp recommendation

steve voigt

Kees, a while back I bought one of the "saw handle" rasps. Not the super expensive one, but a good brand. It is not a bad tool, but I never use it. The whole marketing point--that the tool is bent, so you won't slam into the other side of the tote while you're shaping it--seems kind of moot if you've made a few handles; you easily develop the technique to avoid problems. The surface is somewhat better than a really coarse rasp, but it's not a finished surface, so it needs to be followed by another tool anyway, so what's the point?

Anyway, yeah, I don't think you are missing a lot. I think I'd like to try those Iwasaki files though; from reading comments here I'm starting to suspect that they are of higher quality than the super shears.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#22

Re: Super Shear

steve voigt

Bill, I have the 8", 10" and 12" super shears. The 8" and 10" are quite sharp, but the 12" is a piece of shit. The only reason I've kept it is to get it sharpened when I send a bunch of files to Boggs. I don't think it's a question of one size being better or worse; I think it's just that Nicholson's quality control has often not been very good.

It might be worth trying the Iwasakis. I've never seen a complaint about their sharpness, so maybe their quality control is better. They have an almost identical tooth design.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#23

Re: I need a decoder ring! *LINK*

steve voigt

To wit:

Super shear, mill tooth, bed float, double cut, single cut and Shinto. Which of these will shape wood some quicker than a 14" flat lawn mower blade file? And where does one find them?

All but the single and double cut files will work faster than your lawn mower file, which I assume is just a mill bastard (?)

As I said earlier, the LV coarse rasps (link below) are great for aggressive material removal. The half round (which also has a flat side) is ideal. The handles are ugly, but for the price I don't care. You would want to follow them with something finer before sanding though: a mill tooth file or a fine rasp would work.


LV coarse rasp

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#24

Re: Super Shear

david weaver

I wonder why yours is backwards from mine and george. Sounds like they're not very consistent.

Be interested to hear how you find it after it goes to boggs, as my short one is no world beater.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#25

Duh!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Did you know that files have labels stamped into the metal by the tang? Duh.......I never looked before. "Reading the label" has answered many of my questions...how embarrassing. Yes, the files I like have "Mill Bastard" stamped on them. But in addition how sharp they are is neither consistent or predictable from brand. But a sharp mill bastard is just about right for what I would call my finish file. Now I need something that would be the next increment of coarseness. The Supershear I have would be too coarse (I think) if it was sharp enough to cut anything but pine, and it is too small at 8". I tried a "plastic file" at a show on some maple and it was great....but I don't remember who made it.