Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

File and rasp recommendation

Posts

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#26

Re: Duh!

steve voigt

Now I need something that would be the next increment of coarseness. The Supershear I have would be too coarse (I think)

Bill, the super shear, or any mill-tooth cut, will leave a better finish than a mill bastard file. Coarseness of tooth does not equate to coarseness of finish. The teeth on a mill bastard, lathe bastard, or any similar file, are close together because they are designed to cut steel. The mill-tooth will cut cleanly, like a scraper, but because there is so much room for chip clearance it will also cut faster…the best of both worlds. I use mill-tooth files on brass as well as wood to get a finished or nearly-finished surface.

If you want something that works faster than a mill bastard, but don't like the mill-tooth files, get a medium rasp. The LV rasp I linked to earlier is pretty coarse. I don't have a recommendation for a medium but maybe someone who uses them does.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#27

I'm convinced

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

So, I need to try a "mill tooth" file and that would be a "super shear". I will post a picture of what I think I have that is a super shear? and see if we are talking the same tooth. It is stamped "Super" and something blurry. What I have is uselessly dull and I don't like a short file. Teeth are spaced 1/16".

I borrowed a Nicolson #50 and I would like something finer, and longer. It shredded Blackwood.

EBay has some long Supershear but it is a pack of 6 and I don't need 6.


Re: File and rasp recommendation

#28

Re: I'm convinced

steve voigt

That's a mill-tooth, but it's not a super shear. Like David said, the super shear has longitudinal relief cuts to help clear chips. The Iwasaki has the same thing.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#29

Re: File and rasp recommendation

William Duffield

I agree. I've often considered buying one of those, but I haven't had any problem shaping a saw handle or anything elxe, with a pattern maker's cabinet rasp.

The advantage of a hand stitched rasp is not that it leaves a finished surface. It does not. While a lot more expensive than a machine stitched rasp, it removes material just as fast as one of the same grain, but leaves a smoother surface that requires a lot less work with a file, scraper and/or sandpaper to get to a finished surface. I also find it is easier to judge what the final shape will be while I'm working with it, because the rows of grooves that a cheap rasp leaves are distracting to my eye and touch.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#30

Re: Duh!

William Duffield

Do you know who makes the Lee Valley hand stitched rasps?

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#31

Files bought

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you all were Watching on Ebay the 6- 14" Nickolson super shears made in the USA you are out of luck. Now I don't need 6 if anyone wants to share some..........

If they don't work as advertised I will shape a Hex with them. A curse will be applied to your saw handles and they all will spalt and become decorative art.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#32

Re: Files bought

david weaver

i'll take half of them. email me, if you would.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#33

Re: I'm convinced

david weaver

Ditto that. I have two or ten (maybe it's six) vixen type files, and while they were cheap (one of them was NOS 14" for a dollar), I have struggled to figure out what they're good at with wood. I got a pack of 6 or something at one point that have screw holes to fit on a bodywork tool. So, i'm guessing they're good for leveling bondo, and that's why they're not as sharp as they should be.

And the teeth catch.

14" is a large super shear, we'll see how big the teeth are. No matter what they are, I'm sure they'll be a lot better than a 14" vixen.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#34

Re: I'm convinced

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I picked up a vixen file a couple years back. It is wonderful at tenon faces, but don't use it on the corners of things, except maybe hardwoods. It's too coarse for use on soft stuff.

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#35

Re: File and rasp recommendation

Dennis

Dictum tools of Germany has a very inexpensive set of rasps named Hattori

Re: File and rasp recommendation

#36

Re: Pictures for you, Bill

steve voigt

I was using the aforementioned tools today and decided to take some pics. The first shows the surface left by the LV coarse rasp. Most of the material was removed with chisel and sloyd knife; the rasp just blends everything and refines the radius (basically a full 1/2" radius).

The second pic is the same surface after using the 5/8" half-round super shear. So, you can see that the super shear can remove some deep scratches, but also leave a nice surface.