Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Edge dogs.....

Posts

Edge dogs.....

#1

Edge dogs.....

roger lance

I just completed building a pair of edge dogs/edge vise clamps (see Landis' The Workbench Book p. 108 - 109).

My hope is that I'll find them to be very useful in holding drawers and allow me good access to the drawer surfaces for planning etc when building drawers. My prior methods of holding drawers to the bench needs improvement.....hopefully, this is it.

Anyone have any experience with these bench accessories.....or opinions? Please comment as you see fit.

Re: Edge dogs.....

#2

Re: Edge dogs.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A picture please. I don't have access to the book.

Re: Edge dogs.....

#3

Re: Edge dogs.....

roger lance

No can do.....I've lost my ability to post pics as I had to replace my old computer and I've not gone thru the process of working with my camera and this site to post again.....maybe, in time.

But, you being a subscriber to Fine Woodworking.....look at issue #253.

Or, go to YouTube and look at a Fine Woodworking video called Tim Coleman's Bench Puppies.

Re: Edge dogs.....

#4

Re: Edge dogs.....

Stuart Johnson

I think these might be what he made:



Re: Edge dogs.....

#5

Re: Edge dogs.....

roger lance

That is what he....I....made. Thanks for the pic. Stuart, if those are pics of your bench, what has been your experience with these devices......especially, regarding use in drawer construction?

Re: Edge dogs.....

#6

Re: Edge dogs.....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Roger,

No experience to report. Have you considered gluing rubber pads on the contact faces? Seems like it would spread the pressure, prevent any downward slippage under planing pressure, and incidentally protect the drawer sides/front.

2 cents.

Wiley

Re: Edge dogs.....

#7

Re: Edge dogs.....

roger lance

Wiley.....already applied a rubber pad.....a LV product.....very useful. :D

Re: Edge dogs.....

#8

Re: Edge dogs.....

Stuart Johnson

I wish it was my bench. I hadn't heard of edge dogs so I Googled them and found the photos.

Re: Edge dogs.....

#9

Re: Edge dogs.....

Hank Knight

Roger,

I'll be interested to hear how well those hold a drawer for planing the sides. I started to build a set but worried that they wouldn't hold well under the downward pressure of the plane. Instead, I've been using this method for a long time. It is simple and it completely supports the drawer for planing.

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/CFC%20Drawermaking/DSC_0056cropSmall.jpg.html][/URL]

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/CFC%20Drawermaking/DSC_0059cropSmall.jpg.html][/URL]

Re: Edge dogs.....

#10

Not the best way to plane a drawer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


Any drawer that is of such quality that it will be fitted will in turn have a removable bottom to enable easy follow-up repair and fitting. What is shown is the way I have seen drawers secured for fitting in many professional shops and the way I do it.

The picture is staged to show how the drawer is held. ( I usually clamp the support board). In any case, secure a board to the bench and simply hook the bottomless drawer over it. I keep on hand pieces of plywood that fit the sizes of drawers I make. The fit does not have to be exact-just wide enough to keep the drawer from tipping as it is planed.

Works easily with nothing to build. One can see the advantage in securing speed when a set of 7 drawers are to be fit.

Re: Edge dogs.....

#11

Re: Edge dogs.....

Joe shelton

Fine-looking planes on the bench there, Hank. I'd like to know more about each of them. How about, after they beat the Gators, you take a moment and describe them?

Re: Edge dogs.....

#12

Re: Edge dogs.....

roger lance

I was interested in these edge dogs when I got the Landis book many years ago....and when I watched the Coleman video and his use of them for drawers, I checked the scrap bin (time, need, curiosity, and scrap = project).

My bench has rectangular dog holes that are slanted at 3 degrees.....and since these edge dogs use a dowel as their pivot, there is slop in the fit. A bench with round dog holes would be an advantage here.

I did test their holding ability with a drawer.....but, that drawer was already finished and I didn't plane it. The edge dogs held the drawer very securely and should hold up under lite planning.

This device has been around for a long time and should be useful.....but, hopefully someone who has real experience using them will join in the discussion.

Re: Edge dogs.....

#13

Re: Edge dogs.....

Hank Knight

Hi, Joe,

I'll be spent after the ball game, so I'd better comment on the planes now. :D The planes aren't mine. They belong to Craig Vandal Stevens. I took a workshop he taught 10 or 12 years ago and the photos were taken there. He is a Japanese tool aficionado. The plane he's using in the second photo is a Japanese kanna that he was very proud of. I don't recall the details but I think it was made for him. It took remarkable wispy thin shavings and required very little effort to pull. The dark colored longer plane in the right rear of photo near the guy's arm is a plane he made when he studied under James Krenov. Krenov gave him an unidentified piece of very heavy tropical hardwood and he made the plane from it. It is fairly narrow but, like the Japanese plane it takes beautiful whips shavings. It's Stevens' favorite plane. The others in then photo I don't know about except that he made them all.

Hank

Re: Edge dogs.....

#14

Re: Edge dogs.....

roger lance

Interestingly, there is a connection between the edge dogs and College of the Redwoods (and thus Krenov). Both the Landis book and the Coleman video refer to College of the Redwoods as being the place they photographed or built a pair of edge dogs.

Re: Edge dogs.....

#15

Looks good--coupla thoughts

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Roger,

With the rubber pads, the only potential problem I see is over-tightening enough to cause deflection of the drawer side (some like thin drawer sides). If this is an issue for you, you could avoid it by placing positive support under the side being planed. For example, clamp a wide-ish board, a little thicker than the height of the dogs, across the width of the bench. That board disappears into the drawer and butts against the drawer bottom. The support board extends past the bench edge the net drawer depth, which is known to you. This support board would obviate any tendency to over-clamp, and would provide positive backing for the planing.

Procedure: Clamp the support board in place from the offside of the bench; lower the drawer firmly onto the support board, and tighten the edge dogs the Goldilocks amount (which we know from experience :) ). This would all go quickly in practice, because you already know the projection of the support board over the edge, and would need no adjustment for all drawers of the same height.

There are numerous variations on how support could be provided--the procedure above is one of many possible ways. And it may not be needed either, except in case of 1/4" to 5/16" drawer sides which I like.

Wiley