Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Wooden planes, historic prices

Posts

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#51

Beech

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There is a reason we use beech for planes. It isn't because it is the hardest or wears the best. It isn't because it is cheap or because it is handsome. It is because it has superb action. The wedge seats easily and lightly so the adjustments (depth of cut and lateral) are very easy and fast for a skilled worker.

Beech is also a very dead wood. That is to say it absorbs shock rather than transmitting shock. This makes it much easier on one's body in long term use. It is similar to the effect of standing on a wood floor rather than on concrete or having an ash baseball bat rather than hickory, which stings.

Beech is also a traditional wood for chisel handles and saw handles for the same reason. And apple, which is a little harder but still has the dead quality, not surprisingly is used for saws and planes also. Rosewood makes a nice looking plane or a handle, but the very thought of using it all day long makes my hands hurt: no shock absorption, very jarring. Taking care of one's body is a big concern for a serious worker.

You can't just pick any old material and shape it like a beech plane and expect performance. And you would need an sensitive, experienced worker just to judge any new material for action or comfort.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#52

Re: Beech

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I wasn't seriously proposing a printed plane, just pointing out the technology is available to make one. It could even be that a material and printing pattern could be found that is superior to beech. But who would care?

I'll bet Lee Valley's new plane was a printed plane before it became a metal plane. It's what is done in design now days.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#53

Re: Beech

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There is enough volume in making violins to justify printing them on the kind of machine suggested. Maybe Bill Tindall would argue that it is easier to put a cd in a machine than to actually learn to hold the bow. Back in 1987 a fellow told me that computers were so good at duplicating the violin sound that soon there would be no more need for actual violin players. How is that working out? Any guys in your orchestra holding plastic violins or little noise generating computers?

People who actually play the violin seriously want something good, not some cheap product. Likewise, those of us who actually use beech planes aren't looking for some cheap almost product designed by somebody who barely even knows how to use a plane. If someone wants to call themselves an expert in plane making, let them first learn how to use the plane.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#54

But there are plastic "violins", played by profess

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I was at a performance of the Hendersonville orchestra and noticed a different looking cello in the hands of the Principal cello player. We didn't have the best seats, front row right in front of her. I scrutinized the instrument from that short distance and concluded that it looked like graphite composite. After the concert it was a simple matter to rush the stage and get her attention. I asked about the instrument.

Sure enough, it was graphite fiber composite. She was collaborating with a group, and a boat builder, to develop the instrument. She said it was great for outdoor concerts (didn't detune with humidity changes) and sounded good enough for indoors as well. Apparently the conductor thought it ok for there it was front-left in the cello section.

I occasionally blunder into a knife forum discussion while I am searching for something about steel. That group has people pushing blade research into every corner from bashed rail spikes to the latest particle steel. I find it curious that this human trait of researching is largely absent in the woodworking community, except at Lee Valley. (I have come to prefer their saws over traditional made saws.)

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#55

An analogy

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I was in a shop where there was a discussion about carving. The shop had been approached about doing the final touch-up carving on the machine carving of some part(s) of some Period Reproduction line of furniture. It was unclear if the hand carving was to disguise the machine carving, or enhance it, or both, or some other. In any case one can see the opportunity for machines to do the grunt work and some hand work finish the task. Any customer that cared about the difference would not be buying this kind of furniture at a furniture store.

That said, the analogy collapses when it comes to planes. Those willing to settle for a machine made wood plane, or a printed one, would more likely spend the money on a lunch box planer. If there was a market you can bet Lee Valley would be making them. Given the complex parts I saw made at the organ restoration shop, parts that were once fashioned with hand tools, I have no doubt that this shop could program their CNC to make a plane body and wedge, or at least almost all of these parts.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#56

Re: But there are plastic "violins", played by pro

david weaver

The knives you talk about are used for little practical work - thus people are free to really go nuts on the theoretical stuff without ever having much proof of its utility (other than rust proofing, that's pretty easy to show if someone actually does use a knife in a way that it will rust rather than wear). As one of the knife enthusiasts mentioned to me (guy goes by the name of cliff stamp), much less of this stuff goes on in the woodworking community because the experienced users are actually using their tools, and not just carrying a knife around.

Many of the knives made out of plain steel or less expensive steel just aren't very well done (for example, the huge number of 440C knives that are hardened somewhere around saw temper, same for 1095). When you read around the knife sites, when someone does actually get a hold of a properly made knife (a good example would be a tidioute knife in 1095), they are very surprised that in cutting endurance tests, the 1095 knives do very well.

I don't think we can say too much that the woodworking community doesn't go overboard with this stuff. There is no real practical reason for us to use A2 or PM V11. The folks who use abrasive wood would probably get further if they modified their technique (take heavier shavings except for the final pass, use the cap iron more so that an iron can be used with good effect much further into the sharpening cycle, etc). Most of the other things that are common with knives (super high alloy stainless steels, etc, or even D2) don't provide a wear profile that is desirable for planes or chisels - especially not compared to their sharpenability. Fine sharpening is no practical problem, you can use some provision of diamonds, etc, but you're still left with grinding, and those steels are a pain even to grind - especially when your reward for taking the time with them is an edge that fails in tiny little chips almost immediately.

Or, in short, I think the woodworking community is filled with too many people who actually make something dull several times a day and then resharpen it to get stuck on thinking they have some sort of imagined problem.

I've noticed an interesting thing among woodworkers, too, and that is that the more someone uses hand tools, the more they seem to prefer plainer steel. And that is totally aside from comments about the sharpening methods that are most convenient not fitting very well with high alloy steels (my one comment from above would be that while diamond hones and loose diamonds are very capable, the chance for contamination is relatively high - not necessarily from larger diamonds, but from foreign things in the shop landing on the plates - and this contamination never seems to be an issue with oilstones).

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#57

Re: An analogy

david weaver

Rob has mentioned publicly before (either on a forum or in a video) that they have purchased printers to make prototypes. My memory is failing, I just can't remember the details that came along with it.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#58

A light observation

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

There is always food for thought in these debates. Many get involved, but just as warm sea water feeds hurricanes, one usually finds Bill T., Warren, and not infrequently David near the center of action. Which brings me to what I wanted to say: Despite Bill's love of the fruits of research, I notice he took quite a shine to that Norris A5 :) .

Wiley

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#59

Re: But there are plastic "violins", played by pro

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have seen graphite cellos before; I doubt they were made with 3D printers.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#60

Re: You're right

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

David,

That's a very sharp job! And a beautiful block of wood, too--what is it, cherry?

I have photos of that original beater Mathieson. Went back and looked and you have made lemon chiffon pie out of the lemon I sent you! However, that Mathieson reminds me of something. it had a 2-1/8" iron. I like long, narrow try planes for edge joining, and I thought that iron would be ideal for an edge jointer. My all time favorite for edges is a 2" x 26" try plane. Though everyone's mileage varies on that kind of thing.

You really have a talent for plane making. Looking around, there seems to be a growing demand for hand-made mechanical articles of high quality, and I suspect that demand is linked to the prevalence of commodity goods. Take a simple thing like a watch: my very practical $34 Timex keeps as good or better time than a mechanical Rolex or Patek Phillippe, but the latter two makers have nothing to worry about :)

Wiley

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#61

Well actually....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....when it came time to leveling the bridle joints for the door frame I used the #5 that I am most familiar with. The closer I get to finishing something the less experiments I am willing to do with it. Mr. Norris and I will have to get to know one another much better before it sees employment near the finish of a project.

Which brings us to the start of this all. I don't plane enough to be 100% confident in a result, especially with ash. And as I said, I get very cautious toward the finish. The Norris may never see a piece of furniture and if not it will get sold. Or it may.....

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#62

Re: Well actually....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Bill,

"The closer I get to finishing something the less experiments I am willing to do with it."

I know what you mean. You gotta be 100% sure. One thing I'm curious about, if you don't mind: Can you get the cap-iron into play on the Norris, or is the mouth too tight to permit it?

Wiley

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#63

Re: You're right

david weaver

Thanks for the nice comments, Wiley. It's thanks to your generosity that I had a good plane to take measurements off of, something I always feel more comfortable doing than going with rules of thumb. 2 1/8th has become my favorite width for jacks - I've done a bunch between 2 and 2 1/2 (the latter more of a short closed handle fore, but still a good working plane - just unusual - I copied another mathieson to make that one, too).

The plane is beech. All of the reasons Warren mentions are why I like it the best - the density, the cushion and the ability for the wedge and abutments to work themselves into a good mate once they are reasonably fitted.

Cherry, if it could be had in high density like some of the old growth cherry, would also make a decent plane, but that kind of thing is difficult to find in the right orientation. It looks really interesting when it's quartered and then ages, the figure is much more vivid than beech and the aged color is spectacular, but I've only found pieces thick enough to make moulding planes (and ultimately, beech still makes a better plane).

If you have a desire for another plane in a type that you like, but double iron, let me know. I haven't been making many planes for a while, but I know how to and don't want to forget the details! I have some beech left and it'd be for the cost of shipping. Maybe not even that.

Totally agree on the timex. I am in the same boat, I like to make things, but I don't so much like to buy expensive hand made things. I can appreciate them, though, and I'm glad the well heeled market is there to make them.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#64

Wording answer precisely....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Can you get the cap-iron into play on the Norris. I can't.

, or is the mouth too tight to permit it? I think so. Looked to me like it would jam if was as tight as I think it needs to be.

I am focused on getting the display cabinet done( and gardening, and some charity work and some unexpected opportunity to work a bit, and some teaching). Son-in-law who wants to learn woodworking, and has a need for a chest of drawers, is coming Easter and I want the shop in shape for an intense 3 days of woodworking. So, have not diddled with Mr. Noris any.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#65

Re: Wording answer precisely....

david weaver

Some modification of the cap may be necessary, or some filing of the mouth at an angle away from the opening (it should already be filed that way).