Re: But there are plastic "violins", played by pro
david weaver
The knives you talk about are used for little practical work - thus people are free to really go nuts on the theoretical stuff without ever having much proof of its utility (other than rust proofing, that's pretty easy to show if someone actually does use a knife in a way that it will rust rather than wear). As one of the knife enthusiasts mentioned to me (guy goes by the name of cliff stamp), much less of this stuff goes on in the woodworking community because the experienced users are actually using their tools, and not just carrying a knife around.
Many of the knives made out of plain steel or less expensive steel just aren't very well done (for example, the huge number of 440C knives that are hardened somewhere around saw temper, same for 1095). When you read around the knife sites, when someone does actually get a hold of a properly made knife (a good example would be a tidioute knife in 1095), they are very surprised that in cutting endurance tests, the 1095 knives do very well.
I don't think we can say too much that the woodworking community doesn't go overboard with this stuff. There is no real practical reason for us to use A2 or PM V11. The folks who use abrasive wood would probably get further if they modified their technique (take heavier shavings except for the final pass, use the cap iron more so that an iron can be used with good effect much further into the sharpening cycle, etc). Most of the other things that are common with knives (super high alloy stainless steels, etc, or even D2) don't provide a wear profile that is desirable for planes or chisels - especially not compared to their sharpenability. Fine sharpening is no practical problem, you can use some provision of diamonds, etc, but you're still left with grinding, and those steels are a pain even to grind - especially when your reward for taking the time with them is an edge that fails in tiny little chips almost immediately.
Or, in short, I think the woodworking community is filled with too many people who actually make something dull several times a day and then resharpen it to get stuck on thinking they have some sort of imagined problem.
I've noticed an interesting thing among woodworkers, too, and that is that the more someone uses hand tools, the more they seem to prefer plainer steel. And that is totally aside from comments about the sharpening methods that are most convenient not fitting very well with high alloy steels (my one comment from above would be that while diamond hones and loose diamonds are very capable, the chance for contamination is relatively high - not necessarily from larger diamonds, but from foreign things in the shop landing on the plates - and this contamination never seems to be an issue with oilstones).