Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Wooden planes, historic prices

Posts

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#26

do metal planes last longer?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I expect that a CNC machine would rough out a wooden plane in short order if there was demand. Handles for all planes are already made that way.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#27

Re: do metal planes last longer?

david weaver

I think to make a good one that wasn't ugly, it takes more than a CNC machine.

George Wilson made beautiful planes with some fixtures that he made himself (a broaching attachment custom made to cut the abutments on a plane), and he made a lot of them, but they still had to hand finish them.

A lot of handles are made on CNCs, you're right, but most of them are ugly. On a plane that's inexpensive or modern looking, that's OK, but all but the very last marples planes had handles that had a little more humanity. On a "nice" plane, they're unacceptable. Quite a lot of work was still done by hand all the way to the end at marples. Cost didn't allow someone to cut nice eyes by hand or try to get the abutments perfectly even, or to necessarily get nice wood orientation in every plane, but the planes were functional and they still came with a decent laminated double iron.

Solid steel non-laminated double irons have been around for quite a while, too, though, which I'm sure is what all of the current makers are using. I've got some thinner double irons that have less taper that are all steel. I prefer a decent laminated iron because the taper is more and the cap iron moves less with a little more taper. Less taper and you have to have a little bit more care to make sure the wedge can't grip the cap and put it forward to have a nice adjusting plane.

Anyway, several folks have tried to make inexpensive wooden planes that are bulky, and the only ones that have sold that I'm aware of are Steve Knight's. You could sell CNC made planes to beginners, but it wouldn't take long before someone pointed out that they were ugly.

All that said, in order to keep prices in line with the catalogs, one would have to make a beech try plane for about $225 when comparing to LN's large planes. Personally, I wouldn't do that. If I had to figure out how to cheapen the plane enough to be in that price range, I just wouldn't do it at all. I'm sure I could figure it out if I had a supply of beech, but I'd just have a bunch of bulky and lifeless planes, and you can hardly send out a mostly finished plane these days with the expectation of final fettling to be done by the user. The late model marples planes I have bought, except for one, have required someone who understands the profile of the cap iron and the wear to work well. It's no wonder many of them have just had the mouth hacked open to an extreme amount.

Lots of places an inexpensive CNC made good is fine (router base plates, etc), but my opinion is that a wooden plane is not a good one.

(I've never sold a plane for more than $100, except for the one that was purchased in the benefit auction on here, but that one cost me more than $100 in materials and shipping).

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#29

Re: You're right

david weaver

I don't have a better picture, but I took this off of a youtube video.

If I had to make thousands of these, power tools to size the blank and rough the handle and rough out the handle mortise might be nice. I'd hate to give up cutting the mortise, at least at this point, it's too enjoyable and roughing it out only takes about 20 minutes or a half hour.

This is made in the dimensions of the mathieson jack that you sent me, wiley, and I've kept this one. I think I've made about 15 beech planes, and either gave away or sold about 10 of them. If I've given them away, it's to settle a score with people who have been too generous with me! The rest have been the cost of materials.




Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#30

Demand is the hitch...

John in NM

If the demand were in the millions of units per year, every year for the foreseeable future, you sure could do just about everything with a CNC - not the CNC router made out of MDF in various sign maker's garages, but a real CNC machine. With that kind of volume the two biggest expenses in making one would be the wood blanks and the blades.

But the market does not support volume - it is a boutique market of hobbyists for the most part.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#31

Re: Demand is the hitch...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You don't needs millions of units, not even thousands. CNC machinery has gotten so cheap that it is demonstrated at IWF doing all sorts of short production run tasks- making a short run of molding for example, or some chair or stair parts. A local organ restoration shop has a CNC to make one-of organ parts. They even make the ebony stops, a task one might imagine would be turned on a lathe. One of the Period Furniture makers in the NE takes his blanks for a carved lip table down the street to a CNC chop and they wallow out the field. A local shop makes custom kitchen cabinets on a CNC. Metal planes are made on CNC machines.

The programing is the up front cost and programing for a plane would be almost trivial. A local college teaches programing to students by having them make an electric guitar on a CNC. No doubt once someone did the programing runs could be contracted out as needed. But there doesn't seem to be a market even for this volume.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#33

Re: Demand is the hitch...

John in NM

Depends on the machine. If you are just roughing out and finishing by hand, then small runs could be possible.

If you want to do it with large industrial machines capable of start to finish work with no hand fitting afterwards, you have a huge investment - and then you either have to keep those machines busy full time on the one product (ie millions of them) or find other produces to make after doing your run of 1,000 planes.

This is why no one does it :D

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#34

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#35

Re: as a new hand tool user..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The reason for the switch from beech to iron is low skill levels. And a guy who just uses planes just for little trimming here and there doesn't need the skill of someone who is doing production work by hand.

I wouldn't refer to that difference as being defined by "skill". I'd say that wooden planes were preferred by those who valued endurance. One may have the same skill with a wooden and a metal plane. The lighter wooden plane, however, requires less physical effort than the heavier steel plane, and therefore may be used longer.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#36

bogus claim?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Unsure of what bogus claim you are referring to, or perhaps you don't understand there is a difference between a claim and a hypothesis. The latter is speculation, opening the opportunity for alternative ideas to be discovered.

I do know a lot about the subject of building furniture. A thickness planer and jointer relieves me from doing the routine planing of squaring a piece of wood that you illustrate. This claim is undisputable.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#37

Re: Precision

David weaver

That's my thought, too. You could make a concern plane of you don't care how it looks. The plane Wiley linked to is a good example.

Pinie in (Czech company) makes one where everything is rounded in the mortises. I'm sure it works fine, but it looks terrible.

If someone looked at my planes and the acute angles in them and tight lines, the first thing they'd do is start finding compromises. Or any well made English style plane for that matter.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#38

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#39

Not really...

John in NM

I worked in a pro shop for a couple years between other jobs and there was absolutely no time for dimensioning by hand. A good parts cutter could work through 1-2 cut lists in 8 hours, maybe a third if non were mesquite that required epoxy filling. If he had to hand plane everything, that would be down to 1 in two days I bet. Separating the parts dimensioning from the joinery and assembly is part of what made that business viable by shaving a couple days off the average build time.

Planes may be romantic and sexy, but they are slow compared to power planes and jointers, and the reality of selling custom furniture is that slow=death when your shop has to make payroll for 6-10 people every week.

Honestly, if you wish to argue that hand planes have a place in a commercial shop - which means you or anyone else can dimension rough lumber faster using them - then I think you would need to provide some evidence beyond pictures of lots of shavings and a plane. They are nice planes and nice pictures, and I do often try to use hand planes because I like them and like the results, but I'm not trying to make a living at this.

Bill's point is that the bulk of tool use from 1860 through the 1960's or whenever was people trying to make a living, and that is what put power planing over hand planing as a means to that end.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#40

Re: Precision

John in NM

You could make a plane indistinguishable from a hand made one if you wanted to, using a 5 axis CNC more typically used for aerospace parts. There is simply no incentive to do so however, because the owners of such machines make vastly more money making aerospace parts.

CNC parts, or any machine made parts, need not be ugly... for some reason it is usually done with intent, and I have never understood why. Perhaps it is a way of achieving consistency from a variable material (big round overs tear out less for example).

Honestly, I find LV's line of planes kind of ugly, but I wouldn't claim that it interferes with their use. Aesthetics is pretty subjective, utility tends not to be.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#41

Re: Precision

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I imagine that printing is a possibility as well. I know that plastic is very doable (but not necessarily durable), and there are metal printers as well (which could be rather expensive). What about printing in a wood substitute?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#42

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#43

Re: Precision

david weaver

I'm sure printing wood substitutes is coming, if not soon, in the future.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#44

Re: Precision

david weaver

I agree on the aesthetics, it's subjective. I'm sure that a mill could do much of a plane, though part of that would need to be done with a broaching attachment that is sharp like a chisel, and one that's set up like a float.

In the end, there would be visual cues that would tell most well informed that the plane was not made similar to an old one (tearout at the abutments, lines meeting that are not perfect, surfaces that do not look chiseled or planed, etc). To someone who doesn't make planes or collect them, it might not be obvious.

You can tell that the milling dictates a lot of what LV does. In their videos on youtube, they describe the end result dictating minimizing milling if they can (in that the castings will relieve themselves more it more milling is done).

If at some infinite dollar scenario, you could almost come to perfect, I think I could make a plane a lot more cheaply, even if I had to do 1000 of them. Warren lives in this scenario at this point, where there are operations that he can do more cheaply than someone who is more mechanized.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#45

You didn't...

John in NM

Though that is what your pictures show, no where did you specifically limit the discussion to that operation alone. Pictures are indeed worth a thousand words, but if you wish to communicate effectively, you should add the specificity of what you intend you picture to convey.

You sir are a time waster, I won't argue with people who troll with a straw man for bait. Adios :D

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#46

Re: Precision

John in NM

Apologies in advance for all the quoting - Stewie just got me into that habit! :D

"I agree on the aesthetics, it's subjective. I'm sure that a mill could do much of a plane, though part of that would need to be done with a broaching attachment that is sharp like a chisel, and one that's set up like a float."

I would guess you could do all but the very bottom corners of the wedge mortise and mouth with a pretty standard tooling set up. In complex metal parts there is often assembly designed in to make this kind of thing easier to cut, which obviously would not go in a wooden plane.

If you really want to know, I can show my machinist a traditional wood plane and see what he thinks - though we don't do CNC here, he has 20+ years doing complex CNC setups in commercial shops.

"In the end, there would be visual cues that would tell most well informed that the plane was not made similar to an old one (tearout at the abutments, lines meeting that are not perfect, surfaces that do not look chiseled or planed, etc). To someone who doesn't make planes or collect them, it might not be obvious."

It wouldn't surprise me in the least if anyone familiar with either hand tool methods or machining methods could tell which was done which way at a glance. I'd not intended these hypothetical machine made planes to be indistinguishable from a hand made one, but I may not have been clear on that. I usually assume that function is the important part, and usually assume (often incorrectly) that most agree on that.

"You can tell that the milling dictates a lot of what LV does. In their videos on youtube, they describe the end result dictating minimizing milling if they can (in that the castings will relieve themselves more it more milling is done)."

Its usually the curves that get me on LV stuff, the curves just don't look right to me. But then I was just talking about function being the important part, wasn't I? :D I guess that is why I've never publically criticized the aesthetics of one manufacturer over another - because aesthetics are so subjective and really so unimportant to using the tool to produce furniture.

"If at some infinite dollar scenario, you could almost come to perfect, I think I could make a plane a lot more cheaply, even if I had to do 1000 of them. Warren lives in this scenario at this point, where there are operations that he can do more cheaply than someone who is more mechanized."

Yeah, that is why I said "millions" (though I'm sure 100,000 units a year could do it too). For all but the large scale operations that cater to a bulk market, it is certainly faster and more efficient to do the work by hand. The basic reason is low overhead - if I can make stuff by hand for a niche market, I don't get as wrapped up in getting a specific price as if I have a ton of money invested in tooling and modeling to run the machines. Instead I figure if I get $25 for an hour's work, it's $25 I didn't have before and a pretty pleasurable hour spent :D

The bulk of the stuff I've sold on the side over the last 10 years was done that way and for that reason.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#47

Printing...

John in NM

Metal is very expensive to print at present. As far as I recall, it's still cheaper to cast a part in gold than 3D print it in metal :D Don't remember offhand what the typically printed metal is either.... In theory the cost will come down one day soon, unless a new technology displaces it.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#48

Printing in plastic

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You can certainly print an engineering plastic stronger and more stable than wood, but who would buy a plane printed from it? Certainly not someone dimensioning wood by hand plane. You could even print the sole from a near frictionless material and the body from an engineer plastic for strength.

That said, I have a good friend doing market development in this area. It is simply amazing the resolution at which he can print. Arises are as crisp as if they were milled on a milling machine and a few micron resolution/accuracy. A plane could be made very light weight as the interior filler can be printed with any free space you want to program, yet wicked strong due to honeycomb structure.

I have seen him print Crescent type wrenches, bolts with threaded nuts, dainty structures that defy how did they do that, etc. It is amazing technology. There is a local plant with 100 printers cranking out parts.

You will see a day where to get a replacement part you go to the print shop and they simply download the program from the "supplier" and print it.

Son in law has printed for me all sorts of woodworking aids- trammels, corner clamps, guides, etc. His dovetail marking tools are dandy.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#49

Re: Precision

david weaver

We're on the same page now. I don't doubt that you could make a wood plane that is functional and that could be sold, and I don't doubt that it could get close to what an English plane would look like. Exact in every aspect would be tough, though.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#50

Re: Printing in plastic

david weaver

Bill, can you show us some pictures of the printed items you're referring to? I think it's interesting, at least.