Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Wooden planes, historic prices

Posts

Wooden planes, historic prices

#1

Wooden planes, historic prices

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi all,

The 'Decline of the Wooden Plane' subthread is about to scroll off the bottom. Ron Harper mentioned cost of wood vs. metal being a factor.

I looked up some historic wooden plane prices, which I take to be wholesale prices at the factory gate. Listed below are prices over time, for smooth/jack/fore/jointer, generally 16" for jack, 21-22" for fore plane, and 26-28" for jointer. The quotes below are for Premium planes, with double iron and lignum or ebony starts. Smooth planes unhandled; jacks with a stalk handle. I avoided razee handles, or English irons (usually 15 to 25 cents extra, when offered), and handled smooth planes.

I am curious how the Stanley Bailey prices compared with these, for roughly comparable years. In any event, here are the prices, from catalog reprints. In each set, the four prices are for smooth.....jack.......fore........jointer, double irons with starts:

Hermon Chapin, 1859 $0.90..........1.00..........1.40..........1.60

[Pre-Civil War]

Greenfield Tool Co. 1872 $1.00...........1.00.........1.60...........1.75

[Post-Civil War]

Sandusky Tool Co. 1877 $0.90...........1.25.........1.30...........1.60

[Post-Civil War]

Chapin-Stephens 1914 $0.90...........1.00.........1.70...........1.80

[Pre-WW1]

Sandusky Tool Co. 1925 $1.60............2.40........4.00...........4.40

[Post-WW1]

Note the sharp price increase after WW1 (Sandusky, 1925). This was Sandusky's last catalog. Chapin-Stephens went out of business 1928-29. Basically, in the United States, wooden planes were over as a commercial product after 1925 or so.

Feel free to correct any errors I may have made ;) . Again, it would be interesting to see comparable metal plane price data--Stanley or Stanley-alike.

Wiley

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#2

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#3

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

david weaver

I've always understood metal planes to be more expensive than wooden planes.

Here is a page from the 1902 stanley catalog. Not sure if these are wholesale or retail prices. I recall looking at this years ago, not to compare wood to metal, but to see what the price of a plane was in the early 1900s compared to income.

http://www.handplane.com/images/Catalogs/Stanley-1902-Catalog/Stanley1902Catalog5-Big.jpg

Prices in the 1920-1930 decade are subject to very high inflation. I think for the couple of decades before that, I recall them being fairly stable.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#4

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Stewie,

Thank you. It's helpful to let people see the entire catalog entry. I pulled benchmark data out of that catalog and 4 others. The different makers provided a large range of options back in the day!

Wiley

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#5

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David,

Thanks very much for the data! Those figures show the Stanley smooth, jack, fore and jointer to be roughly twice the price of comparable wooden planes. As you point out, the wooden plane prices are quite stable during the period 1859-1914, so I think the price levels may be compared to the 1902 Stanley figures.

I guess what we don't know is whether the Stanley catalog prices are prices to the trade, or some sort of MSRP. If the Stanley prices are trade (wholesale) prices, then that argues pretty strongly that it was strictly user preference for metal planes over wooden that caused the wooden planes to go out of commercial trade.

The prices I listed for wooden planes are for the 'premium' or 'extra' planes, with double irons and strike button.

Can anyone owning the 1902 Stanley catalog reprint make out whether the quoted prices are prices to the trade (wholesale)?

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#6

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

David weaver

I went back and looked more closely at the intro of that catalog, and those are list prices.

Personally, I'm guessing that metal planes probably found favor over wood because of their stability and due to the adjuster. There probably weren't a lot of new buyers doing rough work where wooden planes excel.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#7

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David,

Hi David,

By 'list', you mean list price at retail, the local hardware store, prior to any discounts? If so, that would place the wooden and metal plane prices much closer together at retail.

We need a vintage catalog reprint for Hammacher Schlemmer or one of the other big hardware stores doing retail business.

I can check the Edward Preston 1909 catalog to get a wooden vs. metal plane comparison in the UK. That might be suggestive of the situation in the US.

In any event, my guess is the same as yours, that metal planes were stable to weather, and had the adjuster. Truly, Leonard Bailey invented an amazingly efficient and effective plane.

Thanks again,

Wiley

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#8

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

david weaver

Wiley, I'll admit i'm not really sure what the "list" in the catalog represents, and I was looking for the same smoking gun that you are - a catalog that has both types of planes in it so that we can see the same basis at the same point in time from the same retailer.

I've got this so far:

http://www.alaskawoodworker.com/old-tool-catalogs-and-manuals/hibbard-spencer-bartlett-co-catalogs/

Page 79 on part 1 has wooden planes, Bartlett is the name on them:

$2.50 for a double iron coffin smoother

$2.80 for a double iron jack

$4.50 for a continental plane with double iron (!!)

$4.70 for a try plane

Page 70 for stanley bailey

Stanley #4 - $5.80

Stanley #5 - $6.75

Stanley #7 - $9.90

Notable things:

*The gage planes with OVB labeling are very expensive, both wood and metal

*The transitional stanley planes are still more expensive than the double iron beech planes.

* bedrocks are in the neighborhood of 10% more than bailey

Other than that, the catalog is just a spectacular catalog to look at, with all kinds of stuff in it.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#9

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

David and all,

Great find! I went looking for a date on that Hibbert, Spencer, Bartlett & Co. catalog No. 69. It is 1922:

https://www.pinterest.com/pin/16747829845391508/

Bailey's twice the cost of high-end wooden planes. Users really wanted them.

Wiley

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#10

reasons readily aparent

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"that argues pretty strongly that it was strictly user preference for metal planes over wooden that caused the wooden planes to go out of commercial trade."

Same answer you would get today from most people using a plane in the course of making their living making furniture. I didn't see any wood planes in the Headley shop, for example. The first moment I owned a Norris plane I was able to adjust the depth of cut a fraction of a thousandths of an inch. Still not there with my wood planes.

It would be interesting to know how many Krenov students promptly abandon their wood planes once they have to earn a living. Finck didn't, but then he couldn't make a living making furniture and now makes violins.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#11

Re: reasons readily aparent

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

I would offer another angle on this. It's probable that metal planes were favored because they were simpler to use. Also they were marketed heavier. In my lifetime, America went from double edge safety razors at pennies a blade to multi-bladed monsters at dollars a blade. Are they better? Do the results justify the price? Who's to say. They do generate more sales dollars. Better is often times more of a perception than a reality. And we all know cordless power tools are better than granddaddy's hand tools. They are, aren't they? Americans love new and improved.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#12

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#13

Pennies vs dollars

John in NM

One thing you have to remember in making this kind of comparison is that the value of currency is not static. If you play around with an inflation calculator, you'll find that a penny in the 19th century would buy you roughly what a quarter will buy you today.

While this is only one variable, it is important to keep in mind when discussing economic trends over the scale of decades and centuries.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#14

Re: reasons readily aparent

david weaver

Stewie, I don't think you know as much about the states as you think you know reading distant biased news stories.

I doubt the move to modern preference and consumerism is much different in Australia.

Modern being that which people adopted when industrialization increased our per capita output in the early part of the century, and then following that, the obsession with space and rockets and things of that type after WWII - we didn't get into a desire for antiques until the next generation sought them.

The greatest push to modernism and convenience here occurred with the generation that grew up during the depression. My grandparents had little desire for "the old ways", because they got to live them in reality. Not while working a white collar job or collecting a pension check, but as a way to live. They were glad to adopt conveniences when they were affordable (the lesson of thrift from the depression never went away).

I've noticed no less consumerism in Australia where the personal savings rate is currently about the same as the US (2017 running personal savings rate in the US is 5.5%, and Australia is 5.2%).

I doubt your stores there are filled with straight razors, Gillette super speeds and hand planes.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#15

reality

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"And we all know cordless power tools are better than granddaddy's hand tools."

Well, yes we do, or at least the people earning a living with their tools do.

I grew up in an extended family of home builders. Care to compete with one of my relatives roughing in plumbing with your bit and brace vs a 20V DeWalt drill, or your miter saw vs a chop saw, a hammer vs an air driven coil roofing nailer, or even wiring receptacles with a screw driver vs a battery driven screw driver? And the list goes on.

Workmen haven't failed to recognize the "advantages" of 19th century technology. Do you imagine the quick change from corded tools to battery tools and air tools was because these house builders were victim of slick marketing at the lumber yard, or they just had to have the latest tool fad? If you do there is money to be made cranking up your 19th century house building company and put them out of business.

That is not say that there is no place for ancient technology. I don't own an electric screw driver because I don't do enough screwing to justify one. I do own a chop saw because I built a house with it and wife was not interested in it taking longer than necessary to do so. Care to compete with me laying a floor with it? I own a router plane because I just plain like installing old fashioned hinges the old fashion way (and I am not competing with someone installing European hinges on Studio Furniture for Gallery sales). These are thought out decisions for my situation, not ignorant ones. Don't speculate otherwise.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#16

Re: reality

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

Bill, I don't disagree with you. My main point was that marketing forces were the drivers. Your argument can be reduced to the same point.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#17

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

Joe Grittani

I have a reproduction 1902 Sears catalog that carries some Stanley planes. These aren't direct comparisons because they're not bench planes, but relatively speaking here are some 1902 retail prices:

Stanley #10 1/2 Carriage Maker's Rabbet Plane $1.63

Stanley #40 Scrub Plane .68

Stanley #140 Block Plane .84

Stanley #78 Duplex Rabbet 1 1/2" .75

Stanley #55 Universal Plane 9.80

Stanley #45 Beading, Rabbet and Slitting Plane 4.90

Stanley #46 Adjustable Dado, Plow, Etc. 2.63

The catalog carries no metallic bench planes but a lot of Stanley block planes. They also carried

Sears & Roebuck & Co. Adjustable Planes (wood bodied). Oops! I just noticed that this repro catalog, although apparently complete, goes from page 508 to page 512. the wood bodied planes are at the top of p. 512 with the notation "continued" so I have no idea what was on the previous missing pages. the S & R planes that I see are 18 and 20" Fore Planes ($.90 and $.91) and Jointer Planes in 22, 24, 26, 28, and 30" sizes at $.97, $.98, $1.05, $1.08 and $1.14 respectively. again, no metallic bench planes or wood smoothers.

Where's my time machine?

Joe Grittani

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#18

Economics dictates

david weaver

As I'm sure it did in the days that the double iron took over. You could plane more material with less risk than with single iron planes, and it wouldn't have taken long first to realize you could make more money, and then second, that you couldn't survive without it because the new standard made the old standard unprofitable.

I'm reminded of a discussion I've had with George Wilson often about how it's often thought that anyone outside of our lens is uneducated and unwitting. But, the average early-on woodworker understood classics and design a lot better than we do now, even though we consider ourselves more capable because we can make higher volume.

Everyone does things for a reason, and at the work place, it's driven by economics. You don't have to early adopt new technology as a matter of profit motive early on, but you will have to adopt it later as a matter of business continuation - at least in most cases.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#19

as a new hand tool user..

Joseph Piotrowski

6 months ago i bought some wooden 18th century style planes off eBay. followed a month or so by some ece emmerich wooden planes, the primus models. they are adjustable and no hammer taps. i just cleaned up a an old Stanley #6 cast iron one and have a few new metal ones.

so now i have some assortment of styles and very little skill. but as i use each of these types of planes i notice certain pros and cons to each.

i love the silky smooth feel of the wood on wood planes. i've even become decent at setting the blade depth, however this experience ranges from easy to difficult depending on the pane.

the Stanley are very easy for the new woodworker.

now any plane can be mastered and used easily for a home diy/woodworker.

what it comes down to is timing and someone putting food on the table. if i had to use a tool all day, being new, under the pressure of the industrial revolution to produce more in less time, without a doubt, if i had to work 8 -10 hrs a day with a plane and have to use hammer tapping would drive me nuts compared to a simple twist of the knob.

now the ece seam to be a nice middle ground but only the primus models. and even then they have a few cons. one is blade changing, certainly more of a hassle than a Stanley.

so are Stanley better than woodies? the wood can't tell but i'll bet production output sure did!

did marketing come into play? of course it did. you can leverage the perceptions of one generation against the past by putting a separation in the mindset that the new way is better than your old less evolved parents!

hah! 99pct of the world falls for that nonsense but sometime a product is truly better, if only marginally.

just my .05 cents(after taxes)

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#20

Chicago retail--1891 and 1922

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David and all,

The Hibbard, Spencer, Bartlett & Co. (HSB) catalog you found clears up many questions. The Stanley catalogs and the Sandusky, Chapin, Greenfield catalogs all refer to retail list price (local hardware store prior to any discounts). The Stanley 1914 catalog spells this out; whereas the HSB catalog prices correspond generally to those given in the Sandusky, Chapin, Greenfield catalogs, as shown in the original post this thread. HSB was the largest Chicago hardware dealer.

Here is some summary data from HSB Catalog No. 4 from 1891, and Catalog No. 69 from 1922. The 1922 catalog can be found at David's link; I found the 1891 catalog at WKFineTools website. Here's the data, where as before we have smooth……..jack………fore………..jointer:

HSB, 1891

Wooden*__________$ 0.90…………1.00…………….1.40…………….1.50-1.75 (26”-30”)

Bailey_____________ 3.25 (#4) .3.75 (#5)……4.75 (#6)…….5.50 (#7)

*Catalog shows Sandusky, Ohio Tool, Auburn, Chapin, Greenfield all at these prices.

HSB, 1922

Wooden*__________$ 2.50………….2.80………….…4.30…………….4.60

Bailey_____________ 5.50 (#4)….6.75 (#5) …..8.70 (#6)……9.90 (#7)

*There is a super premium long plane at $4.70; Smooth and Jack are Bartlett brand; fore and jointer are I think marked Ogontz, but catalog reproduction hard to make out

____

As you can see, the general pattern is clear--tradesmen or retail customers were paying sharply more for the Stanley Bailey plane than for standard or premium wooden planes. Indeed, they were paying more than triple in Chicago in 1891 and double in Chicago in 1922. This relationship held even as general price levels escalated in the 1920s.

Wiley

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#21

Correction to original post

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi all,

I apologize. I said that I understood the wooden plane makers' catalog prices were wholesale. I understood wrong. At David Weaver's prompting, I went to the Hibbard, Spencer, Bartlett & Co. retail catalogs for 1891 and 1922, and found that the Sandusky, Chapin, Greenfield prices shown in their factory catalogs are about identical with the prices showing up in HSB's retail catalog. HSB was a very large Chicago tool merchant.

The Chicago price levels, at retail, for Bailey and wooden planes in the years 1891 and 1922, can be found about midway through this thread.

That is all. Over and out.

Wiley

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#22

Re: as a new hand tool user..

Warren in Lancaster, PA

You might try putting in a good number of "8-10 hour days" planing before betting on production output.

As a professional hand tool woodworker for decades, I can tell you that the beech planes are much lighter and much more comfortable to use. Extensive use of a Bailey plane is a good recipe for sore hands, wrists etc. A plane that is used regularly is also very easy to adjust.

The reason for the switch from beech to iron is low skill levels. And a guy who just uses planes just for little trimming here and there doesn't need the skill of someone who is doing production work by hand.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#23

So, it would seem.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

...that the true answer is that the invention of the thickness planer doomed the wooden plan. Most of the long day would be devoted to furniture building tasks that didn't involve hand planing. Can't argue with that hypothesis. That shoe fits my foot.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#24

Doomed

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Forty some years ago I visited a historic site with a woodworking display. There was an old man, eighty something, talking and demonstrating and there was a beech trying plane. I pointed to the plane and asked if he knew how to use it. He "Sure I have been using that all my life." Even though I knew how to use it myself, I asked him how to adjust the iron. He said "you can't adjust it, you have to take it out and start all over again." Here was a guy who started his career while beech planes were still being manufactured, but he had no clue how to use one, probably never saw anybody who did.

Today there are a lot more people who know how to use a trying plane than in the bicentennial year. And the quality of work being produced is head and shoulders above that from the mid 20th century. The trying plane is useful because it produces truer surface and a cleaner surface than a planer. This is helpful for joinery both for accuracy and for seeing layout lines. And after joinery, one or two passes with the smoothing plane to clean up scuffs an dirt and it is ready for finish.

Several of my customers have planers that cost over six figures when new. One swipe with a fine trying plane and you can see how inaccurate these big machines are.

Re: Wooden planes, historic prices

#25

Re: Correction to original post

david weaver

A little late to respond to this Wiley, but I'm glad you brought all of this up. Finally initiated some looking to find a same catalog definitive answer to a question that I sort of knew the answer to, but never went to the effort to nail down like we have.

I'm not surprised wooden planes are cheaper by a wide margin. The way I make them is slow (12 hours or so for a try plane is a rush for me), but I'm sure several per day could be made by a craftsman who had to do it for money. In a factory where most of the work is mechanized, there really isn't that much to do on a wooden plane, and beech wouldn't have been as commercially scarce 100 years ago.