New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

English Dovetails

Posts

Re: English Dovetails

#26

correct and thanks

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Had I been able to spell its name I would have provided it. BTW, they have a new manager and he is buying older stuff and nicer stuff. However, there was less reproduction stuff this time. Some of the reproduction stuff is often my favorite and historically it was made to the highest quality.

The antique part is expanding some into the rest of the store. The silver has moved there and they intend to display "man cave" furniture where the silver lived.

Re: English Dovetails

#27

Re: correct and thanks

Hank Knight

I'm having a hard time getting my mind around the concept of "man cave furniture" in the Wakefield-Scearce context! :D

Re: English Dovetails

#28

Re: Agree...

John in NM

Yes, Tage Frid it was indeed who wrote the article. You have a better memory than I! :D

Why do you doubt that another European trained in production cabinetmaking around the same time would be aware of the technique? That it is not more widely known makes me wonder if the practice has largely died out due to the evolution of both training methods and standards of work.

I know I had forgotten about it because when I read the article I didn't think it was sufficiently precise for the look I wanted to achieve - the look that I was accustomed to seeing in the 2nd and 3rd generation of FWW authors.

Now that this discussion has reminded me of the concept, I may actually give it a shot - I'm now middle aged and less prone to reject utilitarian techniques over the romance of difficult skills.

Re: English Dovetails

#29

Good data point

John in NM

The thin pins do fail eventually, given sufficient use. As I do not repair antiques, I would not know this, so it is useful info.

It reminds me of a friend who used to be a jeweler, and did a lot of repair work. I commented on how ugly estate jewelry seemed to me (I was paying attention since it was a brief period where I was trying to make a living selling cut stones).

He told me that the reason it was mostly ugly was because the nice stuff got worn a lot, and thus worn out so when it came in the stones were removed and the findings melted for scrap.

While these modest antique pieces are not quite the same - as in the ugly stuff survives - it is a good point that the degree of use could well effect the current conclusion. It may not be correct to assume that the London style dovetails are sufficiently durable just because some pieces survive 200 years or whatever. First, we don't know how many failed for each that survived, and second, we do know that the English trade continued to use hand cut techniques into the 1950's - so we don't know for certain how long those dovetails have been yanked on. There are, without a doubt, other dating methods, but unlike the USA, we shouldn't assume that every hand cut drawer is old if it's British.

Re: English Dovetails

#30

is man cave furniture old cast iron?


Re: English Dovetails

#31

Easy to date

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think the fact that dainty pins persisted for at least 150 years proves that they are adequate for the task. Certainly after even 50 years had the pins revealed insufficient robustness the practice would have been abandoned and we would not see the practice extending from the 1800's to current times.

As little experience as I have had in the matter I can usually get the date right of the stuff in this shop to within +/- 25 years based on the style, techniques and wood used.

The experts that run this shop have tags on the furniture that provides what is known about it, and typically includes the approximate date of manufacturer if it can be estimated. Drawers with huge blocky dovetails on pine sides will be early 1700's or earlier. Dainty dovetails are invariably found along with quartered white oak sides. The piece in the picture with dainty dovetails and pine sides is a first for me. It may have been country furniture where the maker didn't have the white oak available. The drawer had a scraped cock bead, not applied. If the primary wood is mahogany and the sides white oak, the piece will be later, as late as 1950's, but often sometime in the 1800's.

The quality in this shop used to be poorer with lots of pieces in need of repair. I have seen dainty pins on pieces where the slip failed and the white oak side had grooved the divider 1/8" deep. Clearly this drawer had seen some use.

I think the fact that dainty pins persisted for at least 150 years proves that they are adequate for the task.

Re: English Dovetails

#32

Re: Easy to date

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It sounds like you have only been looking at English furniture. Here in America we have lots of Federal era furniture with thin dovetails and drawer sides made of pine or poplar.

English furniture would more likely have sides made from English oak, Quercus robur. English oak is usually a bit softer and nicer texture than white oak.

Re: English Dovetails

#33

Re: Wakefield-Scearce Galleries

roger lance

Hank....thanks for the link.....beautiful pieces.....but, those prices remind me of why I began to make things for myself :D

Re: English Dovetails

#34

Re: Wakefield-Scearce Galleries

Hank Knight

Me too, Roger. I started to add a warning to my post advising guys to NOT take their wives to Wakefield-Scearce unless they had a very healthy bank account, :D

Re: English Dovetails

#35

Re: Easy to date

John in NM

Yes, adequate to the task - which is an interval of functionality in line with the moderate price....

I agree that the dovetails were done this way for a purpose. I would not agree (if you are even saying this rather than it being what I assume you are saying) that modern studio furniture would benefit from following the practice. The reason is that since studio furniture is sold at a much less moderate price, the expectation of useful life is vastly longer.

The more tightly made dovetail we see in high end modern furniture will likely outlast the factory made, tiny pin kind. Both can be argued to be or have been adequate for the task, as long as we understand that the task for each is slightly different.

And again, you do not know how many of these quickly made factory drawers failed for every one that survived. There is an inherent selection bias in antiques towards more lightly used pieces - that the piece you viewed seemed heavily used does not change that selection bias, it is just an outlier on the curve.

All that said, I can tell you I will certainly copy those quickly made, thin pin joints when appropriate. Currently I use a machine cut box joint for quick work, and it has drawbacks all it's own - I'm not sure that those quick dovetails wouldn't beat the box joint when everything is taken into account.

Re: English Dovetails

#36

Re: A problem I will never face - Zero sum games

TomD

" My drawer philosophy is to minimize risk and time in making and maximize function. So, I will never face the challenge of not damaging dainty pins when building a drawer."

There is a Woodwright where he visits Hedley, and a guy is making stacks of very fine drawers. The fine sockets that mate with the fine pins, allow him to remove waste with one tap, from one chisel, from each side. It is super fast. And of course he has plenty of room to play with the pin board as they are nealry fully excavated.

There is an assumption that fine shops had methods that were more refined and more difficult to no purpose (though today one might question whether refinement has no purpose). But the real deal is when a high end shop comes up with a more refined way of doing things, that their competition (at least at lower levels of execution) can't execute, and that takes them less time to do. That is money in the bank.

Take moldings the best shop in town can have more planes, more books of patterns, etc... They sell the sizzle, they crank out the profiles in a sec with cheap labour, cash the checks.

Re: English Dovetails

#37

Re: Agree...

TomD

Nice chisel, a putty knife also works. I can see the appeal to having a nice looking tool, it feels a little cheap using the knife.