Re: Easy to date
John in NM
Yes, adequate to the task - which is an interval of functionality in line with the moderate price....
I agree that the dovetails were done this way for a purpose. I would not agree (if you are even saying this rather than it being what I assume you are saying) that modern studio furniture would benefit from following the practice. The reason is that since studio furniture is sold at a much less moderate price, the expectation of useful life is vastly longer.
The more tightly made dovetail we see in high end modern furniture will likely outlast the factory made, tiny pin kind. Both can be argued to be or have been adequate for the task, as long as we understand that the task for each is slightly different.
And again, you do not know how many of these quickly made factory drawers failed for every one that survived. There is an inherent selection bias in antiques towards more lightly used pieces - that the piece you viewed seemed heavily used does not change that selection bias, it is just an outlier on the curve.
All that said, I can tell you I will certainly copy those quickly made, thin pin joints when appropriate. Currently I use a machine cut box joint for quick work, and it has drawbacks all it's own - I'm not sure that those quick dovetails wouldn't beat the box joint when everything is taken into account.