New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

Posts

Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#1

Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

roger lance

I already have a good set of water stones for sharpening chisels and plane blades.

Is there any real reason for also getting involved in diamond paste/steel honing plates (see LV 70M1410/05M4001)?

Wants vs. Needs.

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#2

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening syst

Brian Holcombe

Curiosity, need I say more? 😀

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#3

Re: Carving..

david weaver

If you get into carving, you'll find waterstones to be a pain. Good choices for carving tools are:

* buffer systems that always keep carving tools refreshed with power

* oilstones

If you like to use HSS or really really hard steels that are not plain carbon, a diamond plate and then something like 1 micron diamonds on steel or cast iron is always going to be more capable and faster than waterstones, but you have to take care to keep stray contaminants off of the surface as they cut hard and deep when they're sitting on the top of cast or steel.

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#4

I doubt it...

John in NM

If you are interested in trying everything, then sure, have at it. If you just want sharp, stick with what works already until it doesn't.

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#5

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening syst

Sgian Dubh

Not that I can see Roger. If you've got the sharpening of straight edges under control (standard bench planes and chisels) then I suggest all you might need would be something to sharpen less common or specialised items such as carving and turning tools, gouges, perhaps moulding planes, etc. Your existing water stones I presume are relatively easy to keep flat enough for this purpose - in my experience even a flat breeze (cinder) block can be pressed into service to take out a hollow in most water stones.

To give you something to compare with, my main workshop kit consists of basic items, i.e., a grindstone for the grinding angle and two bench stones for honing, one 'medium', and one 'extra fine' (whatever those coarseness descriptions mean), both ceramic it so happens: this takes care of all the straight blades I use. I do have a few other sharpening bits, i.e., three or four slips for gouges and other curved cutting edges, used mostly in conjunction with the ceramic stones and the grinder. I also have two combination carborundum oilstones I keep in on-site tool kits. I'm not really sure why I have two, but it's handy if I only take one tool bag out on site rather than a comprehensive site kit: I suppose that strategy means I'm fairly certain, if required, I'll be able to find at least one stone to touch up a plane, ha ha. Slainte.

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#6

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening syst

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I don't know what "a good set of water stones" means; I can't remember what you might have, Roger.

I maintain some separate stones for carving tools, small chisels, turning tools, moulding planes, et cetera. These tools are kind of rough on water stones and tend to hollow a Washita stone, so separate stones are desirable.

I think traditional English tools are extremely fine, but I would not recommend using them without the fine oil stones for which they were designed. Likewise for fine Japanese tools I would recommend Japanese water stones.

I lost interest in stainless steel and semi stainless fifty years ago, but if chrome steel is your thing that would color your choice of stones. In short, whether you use a lot of different types of tools will influence whether you want different sets of stones.

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#7

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening syst *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I already have a good set of water stones for sharpening chisels and plane blades.

Is there any real reason for also getting involved in diamond paste/steel honing plates (see LV 70M1410/05M4001)?

Wants vs. Needs.

Hi Roger

Occasionally I experiment with different systems, usually because they come recommended by others I respect. Generally I have a lowish interest in different sharpening systems. I leave the esoterics of sharpening systems to others - I just want sharp edges ... quickly and efficiently. Sharp is sharp.

I was one of the testers for the LV steel plates, having already had experience with my own cast iron plates (ex-plane soles). Diamond paste works, but I don't like the feedback, and so I rarely use it.

I put together a set of diamond mesh papers (LV sell them) as a travelling set when I demonstrate at wood shows. They also work very well, but the papers can be fragile. They are great on forms for curved/moulding blades.

I have little experience with oil stones. They are difficult to access in Australia, and so the single Washita lives in the kitchen, where it does a good job of sharpening the knives my wife dulls on a granite cutting surface!

I have used waterstones for about 25 years. They were always easy to come by, with King stones popular all those years ago. I really only upgraded them about 12 or so years ago, when I switched to Shapton Pro. These promised faster cutting and less maintenance compared to the Kings: harder stones that required little water. About 5 years ago I converted to Sigma, very similar to Shapton, but they were better at abrading the more modern steels. I'd still be using the Shaptons if I had not been experimenting with steels such as D2, M4 and CPM-3V.

If you are using simple O1-type steels, then most sharpening stones do a decent job. The upgrade cycle begins when the sharpening media encounters steel that resists it.

A year and a half ago I put together what was going to be a better travelling set. This is based on the Medium and Ultra Fine Spyderco. These are very hard ceramic stones that simply do not wear in the way that waterstones do - I may "flatten" them about one every 6 months or so. They are the oil stones of the water stone world. They can be used dry or, as I prefer, with a little soapy water to float away the swarf. It is possible to use just these two stones for all sharpening. However, the LV green compound lifts the edge to a high level and takes no time at all.

These days I tend to use the Spyderco based system because it a no-fuss system, and that meets my needs.

What I have come to appreciate is that sharpening begins with grinding in my system, and a good hollow grind sets up the stones for free-hand honing efficiency. I discovered CBN grinding wheels. These were known and used by turners for 20 years, yet few flat woodworkers used them. They are simply amazing: require no upkeep and should last for decades. They run so cool on a dry grinder that I no longer use a Tormek. See my link below for more details.

In summary, one system is really needed for chisels and plane blades. Choose this to match your steel and personality. I have variations for curved blades, but that is a discussion for another time.

Regards from Perth

Derek


The Ultimate Grinding-Sharpening Set Up?

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#8

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening syst

roger lance

Current kit is the set of Sigmas that Stu was selling......I got them a couple of years ago.....I'm happy with them given my lack of sharpening experience and real knowledge in this area.

I also have the large DMT flattening plate (a gift) which I only use to flatten water stones.....works great.....flattening is easy and quick.

I'm reluctant to use my water stones to sharpen things like a pocket knife or other such implements.....that was part of my curiosity.

But I do recognize that I'm the type of person who will buy stuff that I really don't need.....and I'm trying to guard against this tendency.

So, I appreciate your input.....maybe theres a tool buyer anonymous group that I could begin attending.

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#9

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening syst

david weaver

Personally, Roger, I would try some oilstones with an open mind if I were in your position.

They are superb for pocket knives, carving tools, awls..all of the gadgets that you're likely to not want to put on your waterstones.

You don't have to buy an extremely expensive translucent stone in 8x2 size, etc, the penultimate level of fineness (dan's calls that level "hard") is fine for most things once you get the hang of stropping on bare leather, and if it's not, metal polish on MDF or hard leather (or wood) will get you where you want to go with ease (and use of it is surprisingly sparing compared to what you'd see someone like paul sellers do to an iron on a loaded strop).

If there was a great advantage to having tons of different sharpening systems, though, I'd know it, and other than wanting something that can't be gouged like a waterstone, the rest is details that don't much affect outcome.

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#10

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening syst *LINK*

steve voigt

…You don't have to buy an extremely expensive translucent stone in 8x2 size, etc, the penultimate level of fineness (dan's calls that level "hard") is fine for most things…

This is very true and can save you a bunch of dough when you want to get slipstones. For example, at Joel's shop (link below) it's $55 for a trans ark slip stone, but only $22 for the hard ark. The India slip is under $9 ( a fantastic deal) so for about $30 you can be in business for maintaining gouges and other curved tools.

If I were carving all the time, I'd probably shell out for the pricey trans, but for the limited stuff I do the hard ark is fine, augmented, as you say, by the occasional use of green paste, sandpaper, etc.


Slipstones

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#11

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening syst

TomD

I don't need more ways of doing the same thing. But with diamond paste you can sharpen woodworking tools in conditions where you don't have water which is stuff like demos, cold shops, camping, hunting, or even just my upstairs shop which is also away from water. It also works for stuff that I don't sharpen with water stones, like razor knives, olfa cutters, head knives, sewing machine needles. The list is endless.

One can also refresh an edge and get a ton more work out of it because it sharpens smooth and fast, not one or the other. So I will take a plane blade out and give it a few strokes, eventually I need to get back on something, but I can keep a tool working with diamond.

But would I buy some fancy system with steel plates? I use the medium paste from LV on hard leather on a block of mahogany. Most versatile thing I own for sharpening.

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#12

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening syst

JDK

Plenty of reasons.

1. The technical aspects interest you, and you want examine them for yourself.

2. You're bored with your current setup and you want to try something new.

3. Your current setup doesn't perform the way you think it should, and you want to explore an alternative method.

4. You collect sharpening systems and you want to add this to your collection.

5. You need a sharpening system that doesn't require water for those times when water is not available.

6. You like the way it looks.

I'm sure there are many other reasons. Go for it.

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#13

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening syst

Ron Harper

I have tried everything. And I have spent an obscene amount of money i. Tge pursuit of an edge. I have recently become an enthusiastic convert to a method described by Steve Branam. Google two stones and a strop. It works. Is idiot proof and stupid fast i was a skeptic. I thought that it cannot be this simple. I was wrong.

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#14

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening syst

James Watriss

Diamond paste itself is pretty cheap.

You don't need to go all in on cast iron plates. I used MDF for years, and eventually upgraded to polycarbonate sheets. And I used some of it to super-charge some cheap old arkansas stones. And I use it on the 'stones' on my Lansky knife sharpening jig. (Yes, I can hand sharpen just fine. But with you're sharpening a knife in D2, it takes FOREVER.)

Truth is, you can make anything into a sharpening surface. Use a chunk of pipe to sharpen one of those concave spokeshave blades. (Brian Boggs does this) Use a hunk of maple for your drawknife. You can run a carving tool through some wood, or MDF, and charge that surface, if you want. Bizarro molding plane profile? You'd want to take your time with this, since you'd need to do it with zero clearance angle, but it would give you the option to keep re-sharpening the same profile repeatably.

Considering how cheap the paste is, if you're looking to play around with it, and see, it's not really so cost-prohibitive. Just skip the fancy substrate.

That said, for most work, I considered it to be basically a series of strops, and I reserved it for smoothing plane irons, mostly. I screwed the above mentioned lexan pieces side by side to a hunk of MDF, so I could move the honing guide from one to the next, to handle exotic steels relatively quickly.

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#15

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I explored charging diamond on plastic. I figured the hardest plastic would be best and tried acrylic (Plexiglas) . It was too sticky for the finer grits but better than cast iron for the larger particles sizes because the large rocks embedded in it deeper which held them in place.

Do you find the polycarbonate sticky with fine (1 micron for example) diamond? What do you lube it with?

The gunge that builds up on cast iron or any nonporous substrate is readily washed off with the lube. It would seem that with something porous like wood that after a while the surface would be covered by iron particles that would bury the diamond. Does anything negative happen with porous substrates with use?

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#16

Re: Eating a little crow

Hank Knight

Roger,

I have been a long tim advocate of selecting one, simple sharpening system and sticking with it. I think chasing around in search of "the best" sharpening method is silly and expensive. After exploring many alternatives, I settled on a Norton combination crystolon/india stone, an Arkansas translucent and a leather strop. It's easy, portable and it works - on most edges.

I have a bunch of A2 plane irons. I can sharpen them (most of them) on the stones, but it has been a tedious struggle and frustrating at times. I have a couple that I've never been able to sharpen satisfactorily. After much dithering around, I finally decided to give diamonds a try. This summer I acquired a large cast iron plate and a friend was kind enough to run it through his surface grinder it for me. I charged it with 3micron diamond paste and gave it a go on one of my A2 irons after having sharpened it using my regular system. The result was amazing. I am delighted. I'm sorry I waited so long to try this.

For me the answer to your question is driven by the steel you use. Most common steels can easily be sharpened with traditional sharpening media. There is no need for multiple sharpening systems for them. If you're using modern wear-resistant steel, you would probably benefit from adding diamonds to your sharpening regimen. I don't see this as a separate method, just the addition of a step with a different sharpening medium. It makes a big positive difference.

My $02

Hank

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#17

thanks for the report

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I brings to mind a question I have had for several years. Why doesn't someone sell cast iron plates? They would be cheap to prepare in quantity.

What are the details of your sharpening sequence?

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#18

An Important Insight

Ron in Sterling, CT

Hank,

Thanks for your input. I use oilstones almost exclusively, and don't have any of the harder metals to sharpen. I played around with scary sharp years ago, but ended up staying with oilstones. They do the job for me. Your analysis makes perfect sense and should serve as a bench-mark for those considering sharpening media.\

Ron

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#19

cast iron plates: junked table saws

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I've come upon several table saws of non-collectible manufacture over the years that were too worn to bother repairing. I held back (at least) one top to make diamond sharpening plates.

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#20

Re: thanks for the report

Hank Knight

Hi, Bill,

I've wondered the same thing. One would think there would be a pretty good market for flat-ground cast iron plates. You can find steel lapping and sharpening plates, but not cast iron.

My sharpening regimen is pretty straightforward. I freehand sharpen unless I need to reestablish the bevel. Then I usually use a Lee Valley sharpening jig on a coarse oil stone. I have a nice Sioux 10" bench grinder and a Tormek, but I seldom use either one. If I'm starting from really dull, I begin with the medium Crystolon side of my Norton combination stone and work the edge until I raise a burr across the entire edge. Then I flip he combo stone over and work the bevel on the fine India side until I've removed all the scratches from the medium Crystolon. From there I go to my translucent Arkansas stone and do the same thing: remove the scratches from the India stone. At this point I'll usually flip the iron over and remove the burr which is usually pretty fine after working the bevel on the translucent stone. I use a side-to-side motion on the stone to remove the burr. I'll usually go back and forth between the bevel and the back several times to make sure I get a consistent edge from the translucent stone. Sometimes the wire edge will break off prematurely and leave the edge a little ragged. This back and forth takes care of that. Finally I take a dozen or so swipes on a leaher strop charged with Lee Valley's green crayon. That takes care of most of my sharpening needs.

I try to avoid letting my edges deteriorate to the point where I have to go all the way back to my Norton combo stone. It's really easy to keep my translucent stone and the strop ready at hand to touch up an edge while I'm workng. If I discipline myself to do this routinely, my edges stay in good shape. I usually take a half day or so after I finish a big project to go through all the tools I used and sharpen them. It's easy to get lost in a project and skip the sharpening along the way. I like to walk into the shop knowing that any tool I pick up is ready to go.

Adding the cast iron plate and diamonds to my sharpening arsenal is going to cause me to rethink my sharpening regimen. I've charged the plate with 3 micron diamonds, which is pretty fine. Still, I was delighted with how fast they cut, and they left really fine edge. I haven't decided whether the diamond plate will replace the translucent Arkansas stone or fit in between it and the strop. I'm inclined to think the latter, but it's too early to tell. I really like my translucent Arkansas stone. It will ge hard to give it up.

I have always used flat bevels, but I'm going to experiment with hollow grinding my A2 irons on either the Tormek or my bench grinder. Too many people have commented, you included, on how easy it is to get a great edge on wear-resistent steel by free-handing a hollow ground bevel on diamonds for me not to try it. This old dog is still learning new tricks; tricks that, except for my heard head, I should have learned a long time ago. Thanks for pushing me to do this.

Hank

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#21

Re: An Important Insight

Hank Knight

Hi, Ron,

Thanks for your comments.

I started with oil stones way back when I was a kid sharpening my Boy Scout knife. When I got seroiusly into woodworking, I bought some Arkansas stones. They were cheap and rough and did a poor job. I knew little about sharpening then (I still know little about it), but I knew there had to be a better way. I began the journey many have taken, looking for the ideal sharpening system. I tried man-made combination stones, scary sharp, water stones, bought a Tormek - I tried it all. I ended up back where I started, with oil stones - good ones (quality matters). They work; they are simple, easy to maintain and portable. Simple is good.

During my search for the "perfect" sharpening system, I learned a few things. First and foremost, there is no "perfect" ststem. They all work; and if you stick with one long enough to master it, you will get good edges. For a long time I railed against the tendancy I see to jump from one system to another in hopes of finding sharpening "Nirvana." My point was that any system will give you good edges if you stick with it long enough to learn it. Jumping from one system to another is expensive and it prolongs the agony until you settle down with one system and master it.

On rethinking all of this, I've come to the conclusion that my railings were harsh and shortsighted. I think different people like and are comfortable with different sharpening systems. I didn't settle on oil stones until I had completed the journey and tried the other systems, most of them anyway, and weeded out the ones I didn't like. Only then was I able to settle comfortably on oil stones for the reasons I said earlier. Maybe everybody, or most, anyway, have to go through the journey to find the system they are comfortable with, and my advice to pick one and stick with it was shortsighted. This is all interesting, because, apparently, my journey is not over yet. Diamonds are gleaming on my horizon.

Please forgive this long ramble.

Hank

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#22

Try this

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

in the interest of research on this topic try the following.....

Hollow grind

3 micron on cast iron

translucent ARK, or not

green stuff

Diamond cuts so fast I think you will be able to go from hollow grind to 3 micron....but I have not tried it. Can't easily set up to try it or I would have already.

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#23

The peril of change

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I expect that if one studies the total woodworking tool package in professional shops of any era or culture one would find that the combination of technology was optimized for the materials available. For example the steel composition, its heat treatment and abrasives available were diddled with until an optimum was found that became widely adapted.

Introduce some new element to this mix, for example a new steel, new heat treatment or new abrasive and it is unlikely what worked best before still works best. Experiments must be done and experience gathered to find a new optimum.

We are in an era where a much greater breadth of technology is available. We could deal with this choice by ignoring it and sticking with old technology. While this approach can work for some the current market would quickly overwhelm the availability of old technology materials, especially so the steel. Have you priced a vintage Japanese stone lately? For most of us we need to do our own experimentation to find the optimum combination of new technology. Given the multitude of choices we likely will arrive at good enough, but not best. Thankfully, we have people on this Forum and elsewhere that report their experience to guide our choices.

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#24

Re: Try this

Hank Knight

Will do, Bill. I have an A2 iron from L-N for my Norris smoother. I've never been able to get it to work. Part of the problem, I think, is that it's considerably thicker than the original iron and it closes the mouth pretty tight. Still, there is enough space to pass a thin shaving, so it should work. I think it's a sharpening issue. It is at the top of my list to hollow grind and work with the diamonds. I'm hoping to be able to go from the Tormek directly to the 3 micron diamonds. I'll let you know how it works.

Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening systems

#25

Re: The peril of change

david weaver

I agree that the amount of "old stuff" that's out there will not be enough of the market keeps growing. I'm glad to have acquired the good stuff I wanted to get before it became too expensive, though I'll say I could stand to have more carving tools, and vintage brings compromises - not in the quality of the tools, but the ability to get anything that you actually need on any short notice.

As far as capability, I don't think "new" offers anything material to a person who has design in their mind and a desire to achieve it. New tools offer something for beginners. Irons that hold an edge some time longer put off 10 minute sharpening sessions. bevel up planes offer the ability to plane difficult wood without learning to use a cap iron. As I progress, I can't help but find the old tools more productive than the new, often the only difference being some tools that were offered in wood and now only in metal are much easier to use for a significant amount of work if the tools are wooden (bench planes, moving fillisters, rabbet planes, plow planes, etc). There are small exceptions - the LV small plow plane is easier to use and set for small grooves than any vintage plane I've used - though I suppose there are exceptions to that, too - a small quickly made single purpose grooving plane is easier yet.

I don't know how people who use mostly power tools will view things. Maybe they will always prefer something that is more new technology. I doubt most of those folks will get into much detail designing pieces that are intended to be made by hand, or carving layout, etc.

I tend to believe shops will use whatever works faster and cheaper, and if there's something that can lower the skill level required so that cheaper labor can be used, they will use that (speaking in the past, I don't know of many legitimate maker's shops that only make and use a significant amount hand tooling).

With respect to this specific thing, diamonds - I never found a diamond hone and loose diamonds to be as fast as a washita stone and a leather strop. But, it was definitely faster than an array of waterstones that needed to be made wet to work, or flattened often.