Re: Any justification for multiple sharpening syst *LINK*
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
I already have a good set of water stones for sharpening chisels and plane blades.
Is there any real reason for also getting involved in diamond paste/steel honing plates (see LV 70M1410/05M4001)?
Wants vs. Needs.
Hi Roger
Occasionally I experiment with different systems, usually because they come recommended by others I respect. Generally I have a lowish interest in different sharpening systems. I leave the esoterics of sharpening systems to others - I just want sharp edges ... quickly and efficiently. Sharp is sharp.
I was one of the testers for the LV steel plates, having already had experience with my own cast iron plates (ex-plane soles). Diamond paste works, but I don't like the feedback, and so I rarely use it.
I put together a set of diamond mesh papers (LV sell them) as a travelling set when I demonstrate at wood shows. They also work very well, but the papers can be fragile. They are great on forms for curved/moulding blades.
I have little experience with oil stones. They are difficult to access in Australia, and so the single Washita lives in the kitchen, where it does a good job of sharpening the knives my wife dulls on a granite cutting surface!
I have used waterstones for about 25 years. They were always easy to come by, with King stones popular all those years ago. I really only upgraded them about 12 or so years ago, when I switched to Shapton Pro. These promised faster cutting and less maintenance compared to the Kings: harder stones that required little water. About 5 years ago I converted to Sigma, very similar to Shapton, but they were better at abrading the more modern steels. I'd still be using the Shaptons if I had not been experimenting with steels such as D2, M4 and CPM-3V.
If you are using simple O1-type steels, then most sharpening stones do a decent job. The upgrade cycle begins when the sharpening media encounters steel that resists it.
A year and a half ago I put together what was going to be a better travelling set. This is based on the Medium and Ultra Fine Spyderco. These are very hard ceramic stones that simply do not wear in the way that waterstones do - I may "flatten" them about one every 6 months or so. They are the oil stones of the water stone world. They can be used dry or, as I prefer, with a little soapy water to float away the swarf. It is possible to use just these two stones for all sharpening. However, the LV green compound lifts the edge to a high level and takes no time at all.
These days I tend to use the Spyderco based system because it a no-fuss system, and that meets my needs.
What I have come to appreciate is that sharpening begins with grinding in my system, and a good hollow grind sets up the stones for free-hand honing efficiency. I discovered CBN grinding wheels. These were known and used by turners for 20 years, yet few flat woodworkers used them. They are simply amazing: require no upkeep and should last for decades. They run so cool on a dry grinder that I no longer use a Tormek. See my link below for more details.
In summary, one system is really needed for chisels and plane blades. Choose this to match your steel and personality. I have variations for curved blades, but that is a discussion for another time.
Regards from Perth
Derek
The Ultimate Grinding-Sharpening Set Up?