Mouth opening
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Every since my rediscovery of the cap iron effect I have opened the mouths on all my planes. With a tight cap iron I don't think it matters what the mouth is doing.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Mouth opening
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Every since my rediscovery of the cap iron effect I have opened the mouths on all my planes. With a tight cap iron I don't think it matters what the mouth is doing.
Re: Try this
david weaver
That method without the trans would be similar to using a washita, except the washita finish is a little less toothy.
Cutting speed of 3 micron diamond would be similar in speed to a settled in washita, too.
Re: Try this
TomD
I had a thread that was widely disbelieved at the time, where I said you could go from rough grind, about 80 in my shop, to green stuff. Not really ideal, but it did work. The process was as seen in a FWW tape featuring Tage Frid, not something I came up with. I have no doubt you could go from grind to the coarsest diamond that gives razor sharp which for me is 3. I have done it, but it doesn't always work. A friend asked me to grind and sharpen some broadheads for him, and it didn't work as far as the diamond stopping was concerned. My best guess is because the heads are about 55 RC (and accepting that hardness level is generous) they took the whole imprint of the 80 grit wheel and there was far too much material to remove compared to a harder tool.
Some new to me data
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I had a tiny nick in a thick LV PMV11 plane blade that I had not hollow ground yet. I rubbed away at it with a "fine" fixed diamond plate. It was proceeding slowly so I tried my 15 micron loose diamond plate, Abrasion was significantly faster and in fact in short order the nick was gone. I was surprised at the difference in rate.
Now I am wondering.........Instead of fine fixed diamond followed by 1 micron loose on cast iron should the initial sharpening be with 15 micron loose diamond followed by ??. Would stropping at this point be enough? Or follow with some fine synthetic stone?
After years of using loose diamond I am still not settled on how to best employ its fast material removal property. If I had ever been successful scraping cast iron I might go from 15 loose to 1 micron loose and when the 1 micron plate got contaminated scrape it clean again. Maybe any contamination would rub away by rubbing a contaminated plate on a fixed diamond plate? So many questions.....
Re: Some new to me data
Hank Knight
I don't know the qnswer to your question, Bill. My foray into diamonds was narow in scope. My objective was simply to find something that would give me a satisfactory edge on A2 steel without spending a week at the sharpening bench. The addition of a 3 micron diamond step to my sharpening regimen has met the objective splendidly. I plan to try your suggestion to go directly from the Tormek to the 3 micron diamond plate a try and report back, but I haven't had a chance to try it. I had a minor flood in my basement shop this weekend and it has taken several days to clean up. I'll get to it this week and lt you know how it goes.
I am curious to see any responses you get to your question about removing grit contamination from plates. I don't plan on using anything but 3 micron paste on my current CI plate. If Indecide to add more grits, I'll get dedicated plates for them. Nevertheless, it would be nice to know if plates can be cleaned successfully.
Contamination
John in NM
You could try scraping the iron plate with a straight corner of steel plate or something similar. The idea is to knock loose the contaminating grit.
Most of the stuff I've used on copper laps is very coarse, so its not much of a problem. If any of the faceting lists or forums are still active, someone who uses loose diamond for polishing could probably give you some advice (I was in the commercial realm, so quick and adequate were my polishes - cerium oxide or aluminum oxide on a tin lap).
USFG looks like it still has an active forum.
Re: It works
Hank Knight
Bill,
Last night I ground a new bevel on an A2 iron using my Tormek. I started with the coarse Tormek wheel, then used the "stone grader" to change the wheel to a finer grit and made a few passes to get rid of the coarse scratches. I went directly from the Tormek to a cast iron plate with 3 micron diamonds and finished with a leather strop charged with .5 micron diamonds. It took a little longer on the CI plate than it probably would have if I'd used a fine Arkansas stone after the Tormek, but not unreasonably so. I got a very nice, polished and very sharp edge with the diamonds. I don't know if skipping the intermediate stone is any faster, but it simplifies the process by eliminating one step. I'm going to use both approaches for a while to settle on which one I like.
Hank
Re: Thanks John
Won't solve the problem
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Some diamond particles embed in what is being sharpened. I have seen it with a microscope and it has been reported in the ancient machinist literature where this technique has been described. For those trying diamond, this contamination is greatly enhanced when too much past is used to charge a plate. These particles can then transfer to a cast iron plate charged with a finer grit where they can embed in the second plate. It is this contamination I am concerned with. I believe that only removing a layer of cast iron will remove this kind of contamination. I have found nothing in the literature that suggests an effective alternative.
Re: It works
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hank, how close to the edge are you grinding with the Tormek? The closer, the less steel to hone.
It's been a while since I used the Tormek, since I use a 180 grit CBN wheel on a half-speed grinder. However I never regraded the stone, leaving it at 220 grit. I still see no gain in a 1000 edge off the Tormek since I can do this in 2 or 3 strokes on a Shapton 1000 or a fine diamond stone.
The smaller the edge from the hollow grind, the more likely you can jump from a 1000 to a finishing stone. As the microbevel increases, so you introduce the intermediary stone.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: It works
Hank Knight
Hi, Derek,
In this case The original bevel was convex, so I ground it all the way to the edge on the Tormek. You are right, I'm sure that shortened the time on the diamond plate. I have always been a little leery of a hollow ground edge, believing a flat bevel is stronger; so I'm not entirely comfortable hollow grinding close to the edge - especially all the way to the edge like I did with this one. However, it seems to be the norm for many people who use it successfully, so I'm going to give it a go.
Hank
That is entirely possible...
John in NM
Contamination problems is the bane of the diamond polish world, whether in sharpening or lapidary.
On the other hand, the method may still be worth a try - that contaminant particle did dislodge from the first plate, stick to the blade and then dislodge from it too. The idea is that you could perhaps dislodge it from the second plate as well. Maybe, maybe not, won't know until trying. Even if it does work, it may take several iterations to get it.
The only way to avoid all that fussing is to avoid multiple grit procedures, as you do.
Maybe copper...
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I wonder if the solution is to give the transferred diamond particle something soft to transfer from the cast iron to this proposed soft sticky stuff. Copper, I wonder?
I think I can test it. If I rub copper on my 15 micron plate and diamond transfers, the copper will become somewhat abrasive and leave 15 micron scratches in a polished edge.
Re: Maybe copper...
John in NM
Worth a try, certainly. Coarse grit rolled into a copper lap is not especially prone to shedding grit, so it may work well.
Might also help to anneal the copper - just heat it up til it glows with a propane torch and let it air cool or quench it in water. I'd probably try both annealed and hard copper like a piece of grounding wire.
Re: It works
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hank, I've been hollow grinding for a long time now, and since the Tormek this has been to the edge. This pattern has continued with the CBN wheels. I have never experienced a chipped edge, even on end grain when shooting hardwood.
Regards from Perth
Derek