New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

Posts

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#51

Re: The (almost) final result..

david weaver

https://s31.postimg.org/aykvc9hrf/20160724_163837.jpg

https://s31.postimg.org/k5ccr5z8b/20160724_163746.jpg

The floor stained better than the sanded floor did, as in it took very little stain and applied very evenly. I recall staining the sanded floor with a damp rag was more annoying because there was too much desire for the wood to take more stain than I wanted to put down. This stained in 20 minutes with a stain soaked rag, I'd imagine it took a total of about 6 ounces of stain for all three parts of the hallway.

The finish was less pleasant. I have used a solvent based floor polyurethane before, and I know how they cover and finish, and it takes little effort.

I opened my can (which does not say waterbase anywhere on it on the front) and I thought it looked like waterbase, but figured maybe it was just the color of the satin solids. still didn't seem right.

I applied it with a rag instead just to get a thin first coat over an oil based stain. It raised the grain a little bit, and I thought that was odd. I read in the fine print on the back of the can that the "polyurethane" is water based. Never mind that it sat next to several water based finishes that had big raindrops on it and advertised "waterbase".

So now I have a water-based acrylic on the floor over oil based stain. There is probably enough grip that it won't matter, and nobody wears shoes in the house here, anyway. I'm not happy with the manufacturer, though. I should've had the good sense to stop when it looked like water based finishes I'd used and didn't smell like solvent, but I'd already gotten a good part of the floor done.

The one positive is that the instructions state that it can go over any stain, but they like the use of TSP or a liquid sander if the surface is old (i'm sure, the wear would burnish an old finish) and stripping of any wax. We'll see.

I've just painted subsequent strokes on so I could keep control of the brush strokes but put more on than ragging. It only takes about ten minutes per coat, and it doesn't cost me anything in materials. One short attempt with a roller left an unacceptable look, and the hall is not wide enough in the two directions it runs perpendicular to the boards to justify one of the huge finish-soaking pads.

Two more coats and I'll be done - so far this is four. They go on with a brush much thinner than they would with a pad.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#52

Re: A Couple of Stanley Tools

William Duffield

Patrick Leach describes the Stanley #74 floor plane (a plane, not a scraper)

http://www.supertool.com/StanleyBG/stan10.htm#num74

and the Stanley #85 Cabinet Maker's Scraper Plane,

http://www.supertool.com/StanleyBG/stan10.htm#num85

Which is currently being reproduced by Lie-Nielsen.

https://www.lie-nielsen.com/product/scraping-planes/cabinet-makers-scraper?node=4075

The latter has the advantage of being able to scrape all the way up against the walls of the room without scraping off the knuckles in the process, since the knob and tote can be tilted away from the wall.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#54

Re: A Couple of Stanley Tools

david weaver

Yes on the 74 - saw one at the fayetteville antique mall (a popular spot for pickers to go in south central PA, and on the way to relatives for me.

They generally are expensive with a handle, and the guy at the antique mall is pretty reasonable and he doesn't follow internet trends. From what I recall, the handled 74 that he had was around $1000 or so, maybe a little more. I think that may be above market price, but at market or even half of market, I'm not a buyer for that sort of thing, anyway.

The smaller cabinet scrapers would torture us for floor work, hands and heads would be against the wall, and you're still stuck with hand scraping at the ends of boards. If the one guy in the picture is using a continental smoother, that would make sense - you can really crank on them with two hands on them, but they're slick, and if the other guy is scraping with a bare blade, that would make sense, too. Sharpening and burnishing is frequent enough that I wouldn't want a tool that you have to remove the blade from.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#55

Re: The (almost) final result..

Brian Holcombe

Looks great!

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#56

Re: Thanks, guys..

david weaver

Sometimes a one-off project like this that is more dumb labor and less thinking is a nice change of pace to blow off steam.

The room dividers/transition pieces are proving to provide some challenge to make efficiently by hand, but I haven't resorted to nailing them to the sticking board yet and am not averse to it.