New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

Posts

Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#1

Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

david weaver

I have hardwood floors under carpet in my house, and as each carpet becomes unacceptable to my wife, we pull them up and refinish.

I've always used belt and disc sanders (not like a 5" ROS, but the dual mode type) in the past, but I remember my parents refinishing every single piece of woodwork in their house with red devil scrapers and a file (they were teachers, time wasn't an issue over the summer, but money was..to them at least).

I have a small section of hallway to do about 4 feet by 35 feet. Would I be able to use something like a stanley 82? If not, did stanley make a better scraper for the job? The finish on the floor is probably some kind of polyurethane (totally beat). The house was built in 1958 and the floor has been sanded at least once before.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#2

I have

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


Several hundred sq ft of it. A floor scraper is used and how well it goes will depend...not surprisingly....on how well you learn to sharpen it. You will acquire forearms like Popeye!

This might be a first. I know something more about a hand tool operation than most others.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#3

Re: I have

david weaver

Could be!! I'm eyeing the stanley 82 at this point because of a front handle.

We scraped a lot of square feet of cabinet and built in tables, etc, when I was a kid with those tiny little red devil scrapers. I know I could scrape the hall with those in a couple of days, but I'd rather not - I was considering making my own scraper if someone suggests that stanley's cabinet scrapers aren't up to the task due to the adjustable joints making them flimsy, etc.

One thing I have no interest in is "rustic", so I won't be scraping cross grain or any of that nonsense.

I tried a carbide scraper last floor I did, but the problem with it, I believe, was that the carbide was left very blunt. I would probably grind it on CBN now, but I can't find it, and I didn't recall at the time how well the red devil scrapers worked just being filed, though we were removing paint and we softened it with a heat gun and most of the heavy scraping was done removing the remnants could be stained. When I think about painting and what people do, 30 years later my parents still have the same stain finish on all of their kitchen cabinets (they were all built into the house in 1925 - uncommon to have that much cabinetry back then, I think, but the owners that built it were wealthy).

While I watched my carpets go from almost new (when we bought the house) to worn over the last 11 years, the first room that I refinished almost ten years ago for a total cost of about $75 still looks fresh and new.

One question, what was the finish that was on the floor when you removed it - was it polyurethane, or was it a shellac, or varnish or oil type?

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#4

Re: I have

david weaver

I ordered a stanley 82, but did some brief reading before doing it. The look of the old style doesn't look like it's up to heavy use to me because it has a wing nut fixture on smooth metal to keep the angle of the head. I can see that slipping.

Stanley made a detent design later than that, and I was able to find one on ebay with a carbon steel blade that I'm sure can be filed with a file (and replaced with simple spring steel, which I have plenty of).

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#5

Re: I have

TomD

Lee Valley sells one, and I bought it, but was at the local tool show a few days later, and they had old ones that were just as nice for 5 bucks. I am not sure it maters what you are scraping. I scrape epoxy often enough, once one is through the surface they all scrape like the underlying wood. I don't wast time on sharpening, just touch the edge to the belt sander whenever it seems like a refresh might be in order, or I try a rod on the edge first.

http://www.leevalley.com/en/wood/page.aspx?cat=1,310&p=45784

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#6

The floor was new

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I was leveling it with the scraper. Hence the large curly shavings

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#7

Here's what I came up with

david weaver



I was trying to get this done yesterday, so I didn't take pictures of scraping off the finish. This is the front part of the hall I'm redoing, and then it runs around the corner behind me and goes to the bedrooms.

It's not a large area, fortunately. It gets a little wider than the entry, but is only about 30 feet long or maybe a couple of feet more than that.

I started by sanding with 40 grit paper, but the paper loads with the finish very quickly. So I scraped the bulk of the finish with this scraper first, then sanded one pass with 40 grit, puttied the holes and now I'm scraping off the sandpaper marks. You can see the coloration difference between sanded and scraped.

To scrape will take about the same time it would've taken to sand two more grit progressions, but it looks better and it's much more pleasant work. It could've been scraped and only scraped, but the sander and 40 grit paper was useful for evening joints.

I have two sanders that aren't really perfect for the job but that will do - a 4x24 PC belt sander and to do this project, I bought a bosch dual mode ROS (their version of the festool, I guess you could say). I have never used an ROS as strong - with coarse paper, it can actually get away from you in the rotational mode and bounce around then and bite you.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#8

Looking good!

Brian Roberts

I'm curious as to which model Bosch you are using?

Thanks!

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#9

Re: Here's what I came up with

Brian Holcombe

Nice work David, I like the look of that floor.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#10

Re: Looking good!

david weaver

Hi Brian, it's the 1250DEVS. I haven't used the festool, but I can't imagine it's stronger, though it does have more holes in the disc and maybe that would help with the heat for floor stripping (I think, though, that's just a matter of getting the coarsest discs you can find).

I think you could stand on the bosch and it would not stop it, it didn't slow down when I stood over it and leaned on it.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#11

Re: Fat Man Scrapes

david weaver

Fat man scrapes....

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LjLATlAIrqw

I made a short video, I don't know that its really even worth posting, but when I wanted to see the scraping actually being done, there wasn't much of anything on youtube about it - scraper sharpening and such things. This one has to be stoned, I kind of wonder if there was a fine file designed to sharpen scrapers. My nicholson small mill file won't touch it.

Floor looks to be flat sawn white oak.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#12

Re: thanks, Brian..

david weaver

..I'm just glad the floor is already there and the house is new enough that it's not taken any major damage.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#13

Re: Fat Man Scrapes

steve voigt

Nice work! The video is awesome--those shavings are great! Want to come do some of my floors? All the beer and BBQ you can eat/drink. :D

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#14

Re: I could use the exercise!

david weaver

But after a while, it definitely feels like work. Different motion than planing, but one you could get good at by the time you finished a large job.

Would have loved to have tried a stanley floor plane for the flattening, too, but I've only seen one of those in person that still had the handle and the price was stratospheric.

Renting a floor sander is probably a good idea if you have plenty of wood left above the tongue and can stand a little bit of airborne dust. My wife is beyond strict about dust, so this turned out to be a good route - if it stains OK. It's 100% in violation of every stain prep instruction, but maybe it'll turn out to be interesting - more contrast in small areas, but the large overall area should keep it from being offensive like it might be on a small box.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#15

For the bystanders

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A floor scraper as shown in my previous post will both level and smooth an oak floor faster than a furniture sized sander (as opposed to a floor sander) and faster than the paint scraper shown above. Optimally sharpened it will peel off shavings like a hand plane, as previously illustrated. It is the preferred tool to use if you have a floor you want to finish or refinish by hand.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#16

Re: No difference...(or tradeoffs, maybe)

david weaver

between my scraper and yours. Stanley calls those blades paint scraper blades, but you can roll a burr on them the same as anything else, or turn the scraper handle up and use a flat blade.

I thought about it, after the fact, to set up the other side of the blade flatter (less camber) with a bigger burr, but the boards are set up in opposite directions and a heavier scraper shaving leaves an undesirable finish -especially on boards where there is runout.

Presumably, you were using new flooring. If you used your scraper on my floors, you'd have a lot of sections at the sides of boards that didn't get scraped (near the joints), you need the camber. It's a trade off.

I sanded off a lot of the uneven territory, but not all of it, it would've been too much sanding, both in time and undesirability.

I have a week's wait before I can stain the floor (waiting for the wife to leave with the kids), and some raised grain from wet feet to rescrape. I'm going to grind the camber off of the opposite side and set the blade up flatter

Stanley calls the U blade a paint scraper, which is confusing to me - I don't know why anyone would want a paint scraper blade that couldn't be sharpened with a file.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#17

Re: flatter and softer..

david weaver

If everyone leaves the house early enough sunday, I'm going to try a flat blade, too (this design holds either type) and turn the handle up. I think you'd have appreciated this design of scraper more than the type you were using (because of the front handle), but without trying both, I'm just guessing.

Did you find yourself leaving any toolmarks with thicker shavings?

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#18

Re: flatter and softer..

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When scraping a new floor it is far from level at the edges at the start. I presume the floor scraper is a product of some evolution and it evolved to where it became the preferred tool for scraping a floor and not a paint scraper. I have installed many hardwood floors. Most were machine sanded (not by me) and the edges tidied up with a Red Devil paint scraper. While a 2 1/2" paint scraper is dandy for tidying up edges it is not up to the task of leveling a whole floor in my hands.

The problem with machine sanding is finding someone that is sufficiently skilled to my satisfaction. So, for a room sized floor I just scrape it.

In its most aggressive application it can leave the occasional small irregularity. These can be further refined to suit one's taste. Personally I leave them in the hope that some day someone will be working on the floor and become astonished that someone originally scraped it.

Bottom line...floor scrapers are what they are because they likely evolved to be best at scraping a floor. In any case they work for me.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#19

Re: This one...

david weaver

is titled as a floor scraper with a paint blade available.

I sanded first and went with a light cut because I want no toolmarks. It was still more physically involved than it looks (I was surprised - sweaty work).

I had the same issue with someone else sanding - the last person who did it here, you can see the evidence at the edges of the walls. Inconsistent work, and too much taken off.

I'll see if I can take your suggestions and run with them in a different orientation with the scraper, but for taking out scratches, I'm pretty happy with the way it worked. Disappointed at first with the blade for not being fileable, but it held a very smooth edge and it leaves a surface almost as good as a plane - reflective in raking light.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#20

Why is that for the bystanders?


Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#21

Re: For the bystanders

david weaver

I did miss the comment about sanders. I don't know if a dual mode bosch sander is a furniture sized sander, but on raw wood, you couldn't keep up with it scraping when doing the leveling. It's a monster with 3x 40 grit installed, and it gets almost all of its dust.

Same with PCs 4x24 belt (definitely not a furniture sander, but I have used that to redo a bedroom and it'll strip and level a bedroom floor in a couple of hours max on a single 36 grit belt.

Such a floor could probably be done in 15 minutes with a floor sander, though.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#22

Re: For the bystanders

david weaver

Bill, did you sharpen your scraper with a burr or no burr?

I put a stanley 80 blade in my scraper tonight to try some shavings, but they are about the same as the ones that come off of the U shaped blade.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#23

Re:Bill - a little bit more experimentation

david weaver

I tried a flat blade, no good (it needs to be a hard blade like a plane iron). I tried the flat side of my u blade, no good (well, good result, smooth, but similar shavings). All the way, I was rolling a burr.

Then I went back to the carborundum stone and made the angle less steep on the front of the u blade and didn't work the back of the blade (it doesn't look like it's ever been worked) and that produces the shavings you're talking about.

Picture 1 is the smooth shavings that I was taking off with a small burr.


Picture 2 is shavings a little over 3 thousandths off of beech, no burr (kids are asleep, I can't experiment on the floor)


I couldn't live with the finish it leaves, though, or at least I don't want to, and I'm already sanded to 60 grit when i start. I will try this type when I do more floor the next time we pull up more carpet, though, when taking the finish off the floor. The more I can get the scraper into the wood below the finish, the longer the edge should last. Sharpening, of course, takes less time because I'm just refreshing the bevel , no back and no burr.

Interesting. I still like the design of the U blade - it's extremely strong with no chatter or marks. The second 82 design is a very solid scraper. Finding U shaped blades is not easy, though. I may take a shot at making one out of some thin O1. It is easier to sharpen the scraper with the U blades than with a flat blade.


I'm open to more experimentation - this has the potential to be a very useful tool.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#24

Re:Bill - a little bit more experimentation

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Have you considered carbide-tipped blades?

I do not know if these are available for the #82. I do have them in an inexpensive paint scraper from the local borg. I used this to scrape dried finish off Western Red Ceder cladding and Jarrah stairs, both requiring re-finish owing to living in the harsh West Australian sun. The carbide blades lasted and lasted, many time longer than non-carbide (HSS?) blades.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#25

Re:Bill - a little bit more experimentation

Brian Holcombe

Nice Work David, that hallway looks nice. Both my father and brother in law have sanded floors and regretted it, so I will have to introduce this to both of them.

Unfortunately the only thing under the carpet in my house is plywood...