New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

Posts

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#26

Our objectives appear to be vastly different

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I used a floor scraper to level the floor in preparation for finish. For those that have installed a floor you know that there will be discontinuities at the edges which must be leveled and it may take some serious material removal to achieve level. For me the floor scraper was the alternative to coarse machine sanding with a floor sander.

It's a floor not a table top. I applied three coats urethane floor varnish after scraping, the first coat thinned andh scuff sanding in between coats. The appearance is equivalent to any alternatively finished floor.

I don't understand why you are scraping. If you got the floor level with the machine sander and whatever grit, continuing to finer grits would have achieved any level of refinement desired. For a floor I would have stopped at 80 or 100 grit. I have refinished floors with machine sanding. If the wood is not damaged and the finish is a hard varnish, simply sanding with 100 grit will achieve initial preparation. But then my floor finishing philosophy is for the finish to protect the wood from damage so that only part of the finish needs to be removed for refinishing.

Again, for anyone else contemplating a do it yourself floor installation, it is practical to prepare it for finish with a floor scraper, a tool apparently developed for the task. There will be no risk that someone else with a floor sander will leave the floor with divots and other irreversible defects. However, it is strenuous. I will be doing it again on a bedroom floor as soon as I round up the lumber. I regularly sand furniture with a belt sander or air driven ROS. I would not consider either as an alternative to using the floor scraper for initial leveling.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#27

Re: Our objectives appear to be vastly different

david weaver

Bill, have you used a dual mode sander? If you had raw floor, you would not have been able to keep up with a dual mode sander with a coarse pad for leveling floors. Trust me - they don't operate like an ROS in coarse mode, they are a rotary grinder with a very long ROS stroke combined. You could do it for hours with only minor breaks and you can dump the dust in the trash when you're done.

I'm scraping floors for two reasons (I would've scraped them entirely if the leveling was as fast as the ROS and my floor didnt' have a stray staple here and there).

1) This particular floor has already been sanded once. Not really neat work done, but it could've been worse. I could refinish it 10 times the way I've done it before the tongue appears. With a drum sander and two passes, one or two more ways would be the max.

2) I would've run the sander past 100 grit, so I probably would've gone 60, 100, 150 or something like that. After 60, I scraped once. It took about the same time as it would've taken to sand two or three grits. This is where the belt sander is ideal. You can do 36 grit and then 80 and finish the floor, because all of the scratches go in the direction of the grain. with an ROS, you'd see the swirls, and that looks tacky to me. Unfortunately, I'm not in a closed off room and my wife is CRAZY about any dirt or dust, so the belt sander is out.

I'd do the same process again next time, though I will go for a heavier cut with the scraper on the first pass.

It doesn't take that much longer to do the job neatly, especially when you consider all of the time involved (pulling up carpet, pulling staples, refreshing the stain on the mouldings, taking off and reinstalling the quarter round, and building, staining and finishing transition strips). I see toolmarks and damage as commodity work or lack of care. When they're left intentionally, it's kitsch, and not the good kind.

The initial scrape wasn't too bad, the finish more or less shattered off of the surface, but it would be a little better with a deep shaving.

(if I was installing a new floor, I would use a 4x24 belt sander if I didn't want to pay to rent one. You can't scrape fast enough to keep up with a good one, and the entirely of physical exertion is just resisting the pulling that they do. You can hook a vacuum up to PCs big sander and it picks up the small dust, though the coarse hair style shavings that come off of a belt that coarse do get away - they don't go airborne, though).

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#28

Re:Bill - a little bit more experimentation

david weaver

Hi Derek - it's possible that something could be fashioned to fit (something flat), though this model of scraper will accept stuff probably about as thick as a thin plane iron because it doesn't have jaws that open very widely (in an attempt, I'd imagine, to keep from having a pincers type grip only on flat blades, as opposed to closer support of the whole blade).

I have a bahco two handed scraper that takes carbide blades, but I can't locate it. It's not as substantial or comfortable to use, and the blades are not very sharp, but I'd bet with CBN wheels and such now, we could grind a camber on those blades and make something usable out of them, and regrind them when they hit staples or partially hidden nail parts.

As for the 82, though, flat blades are not hard to find, but the U shaped blade that it works better with is exceedingly difficult to find (I see none at this point and am contemplating buying another one of these with a new blade installed to set aside, because they're not that expensive)

My short experience with the bahco scraper was fighting it and since it was straight ground, sanding places where corners dug in. it's just a tool, though, you me and everyone else could figure out how to tinker with it to make it work, and we have the materials to resharpen those things, too, which would be desirable if I was in better shape (as it is now, I appreciate the break that sharpening provides every few minutes - this is harder work than planing, or at least a physical motion - rowing - that my body is not used to doing).

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#29

Re: 1875 painting of 3 guys scraping

david weaver

I found this interesting picture on ebay, three guys.

One guy is using a plane and knocking off the centers of the boards, the second guy is scraping the low area off with a blade.

https://s32.postimg.org/ytqgtwzz9/s_l1600.jpg

Not that instructive, but I noticed the one guy who said he scrapes floors (on youtube) was working strips like this rather than working a continuous surface.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#30

carbide discussion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This reply is in the context of preparing a newly installed floor for finish or a substantial refinish of an existing floor, that is, there is substantial material removal involved.

It is odd that I find myself on the opposite side of the fence from the typical planing discussion, advocating that ancient technology is best.

Scraping a floor is a grueling exercise. The strain is on the forearms and it is substantial. I used two scraper blades. When they became dull I was tired and required a break. Sharpening provided the break. Like planing, once set up, sharpening is quick and easy and I never regarded it as something to be lessened or avoided.

Depending on how long the carbide edge lasted the cost of the carbide replacements could be great. Just as we don't use carbide plane blades or scrapers for furniture, I suspect they might not be best for a large floor job either. But, I have no experience with them. If one had a diamond wheel they could be sharpened.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#31

We have been here before

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Years ago on Badger Pond someone talked about scraping a floor. I was about to lay a clear 4" white oak plank floor from some lumber with sentimental value (cut by my sawmill friend who unexpectedly died). I was paranoid about the risk of getting someone to machine sand it. The discussion on Badger Pond provided the information for me to proceed to scrape and it was successful, so much so that I will never consider machine sanding a floor I own again.

David has made up his mind what he is going to do so there is no use to offering him an alternative. However, other potential floor levelers might benefit from an alternative approach proven to work on new floors. I am retuning the information I got years ago on Badger Pond. If you don't ever intend to scrape a floor ignore it.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#32

Re: 1875 painting of 3 guys scraping

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When using a floor scraper one scrapes a strip, in my case 3 boards wide, the length of the floor. Repeat.

Note the size of the shaving they are raising. You can do that when the bade is just right. But it takes a lot of force to pull a shaving that large. I have no idea what the person to the left is doing.

On a new floor the scarper is either removing machine marks, trivial, or removing a high spot on one plank at an edge without removing material from the adjacent low plank. It is easy to achieve the goal with a scraper, much less so with a belt sander in my hands. (I own and use a Porter Cable 504 or whatever the number is on these industrial beasts. I regard it as the most difficult to use successfully power tool I own. Other's results may differ. There is a reason drum sanders got invented for panel sanding)

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#33

Re: carbide discussion

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Depending on how long the carbide edge lasted the cost of the carbide replacements could be great. Just as we don't use carbide plane blades or scrapers for furniture, I suspect they might not be best for a large floor job either. But, I have no experience with them. If one had a diamond wheel they could be sharpened.

Bill, I have never scraped a floor, however I imagine that the finish one seeks is not at the same level as furniture. After all, sanded floors also do not exactly reach exalted heights.

I do have experience planing with carbide - not in handplane blades, but is my jointer-planer with helical head. The finish on hardwood I use is excellent - probably good enough for most to finish with. I purchased my combo machine about 4 years ago, and am still on the original carbide cutters.

The carbide scraper I have sharpened quickly on the CBN grinder I have.

I have a couple of carbide blades on turning chisels, and these are fantastic for roughing out abrasive hardwoods. They last several times that of HSS.

There is potential here, probably not for hand planes and chisels, but for tools that would benefit from hard wearing edges.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#34

Unfamiliar with this machine

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"dual mode sander" Sounds like something I should know about. Where do I learn about it?

And again, I am unclear why if you began by sanding why you didn't continue to finer grits and be done with it.

As far as a belt sander goes I quit trying to use one for leveling panels as soon as I could reliably scrape and/or hand plane. If (when :) ) I glue up a panel and there is an off-set at the edge it is extremely difficult to get the high edge ground off with a belt sander without affecting the lower adjacent board. It can be done but it can be done quicker and with less risk planing /scraping in my hands. I presume I would have the same issues on a floor so I never considered using a belt sander.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#35

Re: 1875 painting of 3 guys scraping

david weaver

I find the belt sander easy to use sitting, it's mostly doing what you're saying, nipping off parts of old boards that sit up high. The key to using it is to sit down and leave it at arm's length so that you basically twist your wrist and it will move left or right but not forward and backward. Any other way, and you're just fighting it.

A good quality one like the PC 362, will be heavy enough with a coarse belt that it doesn't need any pressure from above.

I have never even attempted to use it for anything other than floors - it would ruin things in an instant.

The shavings that I was working last night are probably similar to what they're working - and not that physically difficult to pull off of beech. Perhaps different by camber a little bit, but they are thicker than shavings I'd take with a smoothing plane. I could level the ends of boards as you're talking about with the setup I used pretty easily. The 82 scraper is a good setup for it, it reminds me of using a continental plane - it's got a good setup for one hand front and one hand back. A continental smooth plane would be a good choice for the task, too, you can push it or pull it and set the cap iron close enough to prevent disaster - the only thing it demands is a floor flat enough around it to work, and that would be a bit more troublesome if 4 boards were high and one low.

The very few videos I've seen someone scraping a floor on a commercial job (there are two on youtube) suggest to me that scraping is a lot like putting up hay. The first time you put hay up, it seems extremely demanding after about 10 minutes, but the 10th time you do it, you can do it as long as you're fed and watered - within reason.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#36

Re: Unfamiliar with this machine

david weaver

Bosch 1250DEVS - I wouldn't use it for cabinet work. It's like combining a 600 rpm rotary grinder and a really aggressive ROS, but if you switch modes, then it's just a simple ROS. It has a mechanical switch to switch between modes. You can lean all of your weight on the front handle and it won't stop turning. If it starts to bounce mid-use, it will get away from you if you don't back off. I'd consider it an architectural sized sander that can do some cabinet work if you like that sort of thing and have use for a 6" ROS. I generally do not.

Festool's Rotex series is similar if I understand it correctly. The difference is The rotex is somewhere between 2-3 times as expensive, and the Bosch sander uses standard 6 hole paper.

I was very surprised to see that the Bosch version of the sander is still made in Germany.

As I mentioned below, I would never put the porter cable 362 on a panel. It would be instant disaster. It's far too strong (12 amps) and far too heavy. Perhaps on a barn door or something, but not furniture.

I scraped because it took about the same time as working through a couple of more grits with the sander, and the corners were gotten with the scraper as part of the process. I think the net time was similar - sanding is easy, but boring. Scraping is harder, but interesting, and the finish on the floor is excellent. Whether or not the stain applies evenly will determine whether or not I have to scuff it one more time - it will be a bummer if I do.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#37

Re: Things Learned

david weaver

Bill - I am glad you spoke up. I thought maybe the 82 scraper wouldn't do what you're suggesting, but it does and would easily. Your prompting sent me to the shop last night to figure out how to prepare the hardened U-shaped blade so that it would easily remove a shaving thicker than I would generally use smoothing.

it's just not exactly what I'm doing in terms of finishing my floor, I'm looking for the scraper to get rid of the top coat so that the sander doesn't gum up, and then to final finish the floor after that.

If I had a brand new floor with no stray staples and nails in it, I would level the ends of boards with the scraper taking aggressive shavings as you've suggested, or if I was feeling a little more lazy, at arms length with a PC 362. The PC is a lot easier to control than a dual mode sander if you just let it pull the slack out of your arm and then just stay there, but the dust collection needs dictated that i couldn't use it in a hallway whereas I previously used it in a bedroom and just closed the door.

The one nice thing about the sander, of course, is that all of those little carpet staples do nothing to it, and when there is a leg of a staple left in the floor that is dull looking, the end of it is instantly shiny and bright once the sander goes over it. Finding it when you hear the scraper click as it goes over is undesirable. In a heavier cut, it would do deep damage to the edge of the blade.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#38

A horse of another color.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Whether or not the stain applies evenly"

Didn't know a stain was involved. I don't like to stain a floor. And impossible to do by someone picky about staining.

"sanding is easy, but boring. Scraping is harder, but interesting" At last we agree! :D

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#39

Re: staining..

david weaver

As a kid, my dad made nailed together and doweled together white pine articles for around the house. Book shelves, small wall cabinets, etc, nothing that needed more than cut out of a pattern and then put together. Every single thing he made was stained...I don't know what color, I'll call it solid brown. And then sprayed with something he called "clear sealer", the kind of stuff that says "indooor/outdoor" and costs a dollar or two per can.

I rarely stain anything. But I came to learn with floors that an uneven stain job that varies slightly in small areas will look fine when an amber floor finish is applied to it. I would much rather do oil and wax floors, but a floor that changes how it looks from time to time is something that my wife won't tolerate.

I'd rather leave the floors natural, but my wife chooses color in the living area of the house, so I do what she likes. In this case, that's minwax's version of gunstock. I have never stained a scraped surface, so it will be interesting to see what happens. The safe answer would be to work the surface with 220 grit paper.

I don't stain floors correctly as far as instructions go (they say to inundate the surface with stain and then wipe it off). Instead, I just use a rag dampened with stain and rub it on the surface until it looks similar to the rest of the floor around it.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#40

Re: staining..

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I don't stain floors correctly as far as instructions go "

You aren't going to get an ugly "black" floor if you insist on not following directions.

personally, I always rag-on the stain to control how much goes where.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#42

Floor scraper?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Bill, when you say "floor scraper," do you mean something like the item pictured below? That's what came up when I googled the phrase.

Bill out west


img

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#43

Re: Bystanders - stanley's 74

david weaver

Stanley put a plane on the end of a stick, but it costs the moon. My floors didn't have such an obvious high board end, but more of an issue with boards cupping slightly over the years.

I get the sense that the first planing that's done, as in the picture I linked on here, is down the center of the boards in hopes of knocking off high centers. Don't know, though.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#44

Re: Floor scraper?

david weaver

That's what comes up everywhere, when you're looking to buy, etc, but that's the type intended to remove composition tile and adhesive.

I haven't seen the term floor scraper attached to any tools except one listing of a millers falls tool.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#45

No

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What I am talking about is the tool pictured in my first post on this topic. When first reintroduced by Lee Valley some years ago it was written up in the "Dear Customer" introduction by R. Lee as a scraper for floors.

see Starrett 194 Scraper

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#46

I get it now

John in NM

"David has made up his mind what he is going to do so there is no use to offering him an alternative. However, other potential floor levelers might benefit from an alternative approach proven to work on new floors."

I must have missed that part of David's post, or it was even further back. Its been a long week down here, and its only wednesday :D

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#47

Planes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The title of the painting is Les Raboteurs du Parquet. Rabot means plane, les raboteurs means the planers plural. So the title is The Parquet Planers or The Floor Planers. I think the two on the right both have planes in their hands. Note that the center fellow has his left hand fingers across the front of the plane, not the way one would hold a scraper. You can see the fellow on the right holding a plane horn in his left hand.

I also think the first passes are along the joint between the boards. You can see the joint in some of the parts he has planed and in the unplaned boards ahead of him.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#48

Re: Planes

steve voigt

On the right, it looks like they have a bottle of planing juice to ease the work! :D

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#49

Re: Floor scraper?

steve voigt

Slightly OT, but one guy told me that the blades for those floor scrapers are 1095 and a good source for making your own scrapers or whatever. The smaller scrapers are around .030 and the big ones are a little thicker, IIRC.

Re: Anyone Scrape a Floor? What Stanley Tool?

#50

Re: Planes

david weaver

I think the guy in the middle is pulling a scraper blade, a heavy scraper blade of some sort (may even just be something similar to a plane iron) with nothing else in his hands. His shavings are thin and wide, and the other guy's shavings are narrow and thicker.