Re: A lot of variables..
david weaver
..if you're trying to plane a thousand feet at a thousandth of an inch, there is a clear advantage for abrasion resistance. I'd imagine such a thing would be won by a steel like HAP 40.
If you're taking a whole bunch of different shaving thicknesses, and only some (dimensioning by hand involves relatively few very thin shavings if the work before was done properly), then clearance is the limiting factor and not sharpness.
One of the things I've done a lot of in the last year (or more) is sizing beech billets. Because the actual act of planing involves more than just the iron, I was surprised too find that I could get more work done with a try plane (and a butcher iron) than I could with a medium sized metal plane and a V11 iron.
If the tables were turned into a contest of the most feet of 1 thousandth shavings, the V11 iron would likely win very very easily. In the context of getting work done, the fact that the butcher iron was in a plane more suited to the work easily won out. Evening the contest by using an 8 pound metal plane would've made the try plane preferable, just in a different way (the metal plane with a v11 iron might've taken more shavings, but the user would've been much more tired - especially if it was perfectly milled).
What brian is referring to in terms of the use cycle is that a good carbon steel that is in what I'll refer to as "wilson hardness" range (George Wilson always advocates irons softer than the hocks and others of the world) is that such irons will last a long time in most work, especially that which is not smoothing, wear very evenly and present a good surface even as clearance is running out. In actual use, they will last plenty long enough for you to be ready for a sharpening break of a few minutes.
I generally can size a beech try plane billet and do all of the corrective and pre-finish work on one sharpening of a butcher iron in the try plane. The only thing I use a jack for is if there is bulk removal. I can't get through a whole billet with any of my modern planes because they will not tolerate the same volume of work with the same effort. I have to resort to thinner shavings with them (not thin, but thinner).

) It would be interesting to test how fast one could freshen an edge from not cutting perfectly to back in the running. I would think 30 seconds total turn around would be doable. This would be like all extreme practices, not particularly useful except as a demo of what is possible.



