New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

Posts

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#51

Re: A lot of variables..

david weaver

..if you're trying to plane a thousand feet at a thousandth of an inch, there is a clear advantage for abrasion resistance. I'd imagine such a thing would be won by a steel like HAP 40.

If you're taking a whole bunch of different shaving thicknesses, and only some (dimensioning by hand involves relatively few very thin shavings if the work before was done properly), then clearance is the limiting factor and not sharpness.

One of the things I've done a lot of in the last year (or more) is sizing beech billets. Because the actual act of planing involves more than just the iron, I was surprised too find that I could get more work done with a try plane (and a butcher iron) than I could with a medium sized metal plane and a V11 iron.

If the tables were turned into a contest of the most feet of 1 thousandth shavings, the V11 iron would likely win very very easily. In the context of getting work done, the fact that the butcher iron was in a plane more suited to the work easily won out. Evening the contest by using an 8 pound metal plane would've made the try plane preferable, just in a different way (the metal plane with a v11 iron might've taken more shavings, but the user would've been much more tired - especially if it was perfectly milled).

What brian is referring to in terms of the use cycle is that a good carbon steel that is in what I'll refer to as "wilson hardness" range (George Wilson always advocates irons softer than the hocks and others of the world) is that such irons will last a long time in most work, especially that which is not smoothing, wear very evenly and present a good surface even as clearance is running out. In actual use, they will last plenty long enough for you to be ready for a sharpening break of a few minutes.

I generally can size a beech try plane billet and do all of the corrective and pre-finish work on one sharpening of a butcher iron in the try plane. The only thing I use a jack for is if there is bulk removal. I can't get through a whole billet with any of my modern planes because they will not tolerate the same volume of work with the same effort. I have to resort to thinner shavings with them (not thin, but thinner).

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#52

Re: Yes, I would think so... *LINK*

John in NM

The technique is used to measure the spacing between atoms in a crystal lattice, so I don't imagine there is a lower limit to the crystal size. Unfortunately, its been a very long time since I did any of this and I don't remember how the random orientation of the powder particles is accounted for.

EDIT:

Another source I read mentioned a resolution on the order of 30 Angstroms. On the other hand, the technique does not work as well for complex and impure samples - which I would bet a sample of a waterstone would be.


http://physics.bu.edu/py106/notes/Resolution.html

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#53

Re: Data is not on your side

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There are four things at issue here: Brian's plane iron, Brian's sharpening media, Brian's sharpening technique, and Brian's planing technique. Each of these plays an important role in edge performance. None of these factors shows up in the data you cite.

Even if Brian sent his materials to Tennessee, who would have the skill to test them?

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#54

Re: The gold standard...

david weaver

.. for me, the gold standard is something that looks like the eskilstuna steel edge does as it wears.

http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/bladetest.html

Something like that will cut well until the clearance is gone. I sent brian a plane that is in the "wilson hardness" range, and I'm sure if he took a thousand 1 thousandth thick shavings with it, he might be disappointed. But I knew he would use a try plane the same as I or warren would use one, so little worry there other than if he just had a personal preference for hard irons.

Brian made the comment to me that I'd agree with, something like "I can see the edge on the iron, but it still keeps planing".

I have never been that impressed with hock's carbon steel irons, they probably last almost as long as an eskilstuna iron, but they chip because they are harder than they should be. To make up for it, they need a little less clearance, and then all of the sudden they run out of clearance sooner. I had a talk about this with George Wilson ( though my opinion about it was less well formed at the time, I was just curious why they didn't last longer in use ), and he confirmed that to be the case when he was making irons as a toolmaker.

The eskilstuna iron and the blue steel iron both show the similar even wear. Almost nothing else on the page does.

That seems to be lost for the most part on Brent Beach, though he does note it a little bit. I suspect Brent doesn't do woodworking the way we think of it, he's got some funny conclusions that might occur if one did more testing and hypothesizing than actual woodworking. (being obsessed with an "inferior" edge that comes with freehand honing, obsessing on the size of the wear bevel, declaring bevel up planes to be problematic because of the wear bevel on the flat side....most of those obsessions go away when you actually do woodwork).

(I have been guilty of that in the past, and sometimes I still do it, too - I'm more wary about things that don't show up in woodwork).

If Brent Beach does any woodworking, I would call it the "at arms length" woodworking, and that is the view that everything is some level of a problem that has to be lived with rather than something to be enjoyed. Just like the obsession with the 0.5 micron film and the need for plane irons that have a small wear bevel at the expense of sense. The opposite of that school would be "take it for what it is and work with it" woodworking.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#55

Re: The gold standard...

TomD

The edge that ahows is dull, but i have had the experience of it continueing to work for a very long time. But it doesn't work at the same level. The extreme case for me was when i built my trimaran, not an activity that requires a ton of hand planing under most situations. But there are many things that work better with a plane, some of them hidious like bringing dine fiberglass, epoxy, and ply to the sitka spruce shear. This went on for 6 months with the plane that started out like a bench plane ending up as a scrub. But it kept cutting till pretty much the end on the one sharpening.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#56

Re: The gold standard...

TomD

The edge is only part of the story, the type of plane is at least as important, and a wooden plane (or something composite if one really wanted to take it that far). Correct weight, slick on the work, and stiff, and ergonomic, plus many other things. These all have a bigger influence than the minutia around the edge.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#57

Comment

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The situation of using a plane to make small size adjustments to machined parts (fitting) differs significantly from your use. I set a shaving thickness after sharpening and rarely change it until dull again. I may only need to remove a shaving or two to complete my task. If the first shaving produces torn grain I'm screwed for I will not have the opportunity to correct the situation with further material removal. By and large I only use one plane for all my planing needs, and they are occasional.

I set up an old Stanley with a camber grind to serve as something of a scrub plane. I use it to make material go away when needed and for clipping corners off boards to aid flattening. I can't recall the last time I sharpened that blade. It mows off shavings no matter how dull it seems to be. But I can't use it to fit a drawer or tenon thickness.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#58

Re: A study that has yet to be reported

Brian Holcombe

Having stones of various fineness that can all be used as 'finish' stones, I have tested them (informally) and the finer stones do produce an edge that outlasts the less fine.

For a trial period I was ending the Try plane iron on the Tsushima stone, which is really not a finish stone at all, it cut equally well in thick shavings but wore out faster than when I finish it on the Yaginoshima or Shinden suita stones. I now finish it on the Yaginoshima, it gives the best of both worlds, it's fast and the results are fine enough to keep the edge going for a long time.

The same effect happens on my paring chisels and kanna, so I routinely finish them on the Nakayama asagi, which is my finest stone. The kanna shows it quickly being bedded at 38 degrees~ and compounded by the fact that I'm always taking very thin shavings with an incredibly tight set chip breaker on hardwoods (with that plane), so I will sharpen that at the end of my panel work to take the final passes.

We can go back and forth on steel preference and stone preference, but my opinion is that you do yourself a disservice by attempting to keep a plane together as long as possible. It makes sharpening far worse when you go to do so which makes you even more reluctant to take it apart in the future. It should be like a military exercise, knock it apart so many times that you can reassemble it in a muddy ditch with mortars going off around you :D

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#59

Re: Comment

david weaver

I agree with that (that your use is a lot different). It's still a good chance not to try to keep all of the stuff at arm's length.

I would still sharpen with a washita in that case, especially if I were sanding after being done. I chased sharpness and longevity in the past when I didn't set the cap iron close. I probably have more longevity with the cap close, but my initial sharpness isn't as high with the washita.

As far as a roughing plane goes, I still like to sharpen them a couple of times per project. While they don't rely on perfect clearance as much, they work better sharp.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#60

Re: The gold standard...

david weaver

Yes, for smoothers, they would be dull. I don't know if it would be dull for a try plane, and for a jack plane, it would work for quite a while from there.

But when you refresh it, there's no nicks to remove, and the surface quality is good all the way to dull.

I agree on the design of the plane. I took up making wooden planes initially because I wanted to make a tight plane that had the weight of a metal plane but didn't act like a brake on wood.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#61

Re: A study that has yet to be reported

david weaver

Tsushima is a strange stone. It's sold, I guess, as an alternative to the very expensive large white medium nagura. I'd bet the particles as small as a washita particle, but they must be really aggressive because it makes an edge that looks pleasing to the naked eye, but doesn't feel that sharp.

It's like the opposite of washita, which makes substantial wire edge that feels like it couldn't lead to much, and then after thinning the wire edge with light pressure, and stropping it off, the edge is still not blindingly sharp, but surprisingly good for the wire edge that was created.

That was a fun stone to have and play with, but for a guy who uses a grinder, there's not much opportunity to use tsushima other than knives (and I do those up on an IM 313).

The yaginoshima will probably suffer the same fate for me, but I'm really surprised just how good the various $100 shinden/okudo shards are in terms of cutting speed vs. fineness. Some of my small shards (not sure what term you'd use for "bigger than koppa, but not geometrically elite") are better than some of the bigger more expensive stones that I have.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#62

Re: A study that has yet to be reported

Brian Holcombe

It is interesting to me as well, I see it often placed at about 5k for fineness, but it can cut at about the same rate as the 3k chosera for me.

I can see that happening with the Yaginoshima when grinders are involved, because you can just as easily finish that small edge with a Shinden or Okudo and have a slightly finer edge at no additional effort.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#63

Re: A study that has yet to be reported

david weaver

Yes, with grinder involved, quick medium stone touchup plus shinden or okudo is a very nice fast combination and the edge is excellent, clean and uniform.

I figured the tsushimas for something like a 2-3k equivalent synthetic. The binsui more like 1000. The trouble with the binsui is that it's difficult to keep it flat and it's difficult to keep water in it. It just goes right through it, but with a small bevel maintained by a grinder, binsui and suita isn't a bad way to go. Neither is a diamond hone and then suita since you can lift a little with the suita, or a slurried ark and then the suita.

The burnisher on my bench top right now is a jasper with wd40 on it. I've not looked at the edges under a microscope, but that's coming soon, because I dug out my dissection scope to look at a tick that one of the kids picked up last week. I think I might be able to get the camera mounted to the eyepiece with a little bit of finagling.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#64

Re: Mortar practice

TomD

I can never search this place, but I did publish some stats on my turn around time with my coarse Japanese plane, and it was like 10 seconds to get it out of service and back assembled and cutting, and 20 seconds if I was after a particular cut like 1 thou or whatever. This didn't raise much interest at the time. But it is a key attribute in the whole ease of use thing, if you can sharpen a plane in 20 seconds (doesn't include sharpening time :)) It would be interesting to test how fast one could freshen an edge from not cutting perfectly to back in the running. I would think 30 seconds total turn around would be doable. This would be like all extreme practices, not particularly useful except as a demo of what is possible.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#65

Re: A study that has yet to be reported

TomD

I think there are a lot of variables in this kind of test. My sense with my tools is there are thresholds in perfromance. Sorta up to cherry, even maple I can happily use pretty basic tools. More abrassive or harder woods (not sure what the factors are), that are present in many activites like instrument making, or planing stuff like plywood, epoxy, and fiberglass, I will see far better results with better steels, these can be relatiely cheap and easy to sharpen tools like Japanese White Steel from the bargain bin.

Similar thing is present with higher degrees of polish. These will considerably extend edge retension in harder to handle woods. The problem I have is getting these edges done. To really get above where I am at now, I am thinking I would need to use a lot of mechanical aids like hollow grinds and sharpening jigs. To use finer grits effectively requires a very high degree of precision, so though I think the finer edges produce better results that are pretty lasting, they aren't worth the change in work habits they would require, for me. Shaptons were available in a variety of grits well above 8K and they were not worth the effort for me, I did get a good opportunity to test them out though. I was also led to believe by people who should know, that even with accurate jigs I would need more time on task to effect the reductions these finer grits would require, which was also something not worth it to me. Buffing is an alternative however.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#66

Re: A study that has yet to be reported

Brian Holcombe

I wonder if the Binsui is very similar to an Ikarashi stone, like the green one that I have. Water basically runs through that stone, its the kind of stone that would probably do better soaking in a tub for a good while before use.

I'm interested to hear about your results with the Jasper.

Haha, I'm sure the kids were grossed out by what a tick looks like under a microscope.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#67

Re: Mortar practice

Brian Holcombe

That sounds about right. They seem to take a set after enough times in and out and the blade just finds its home straight away.

20 more seconds to set the chip breaker if I'm after a shaving that goes straight up and out.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#68

Re: A study that has yet to be reported

david weaver

Ticks are bad this year. Somehow, my son picked up 5 tick nymphs in one day, and one was attached, so my wife collected them (almost too small to see without a microscope) and called to ask what I have that she could look at them through. I pointed her to the scope and she took it to the Dr's office. She took the ticks, too, and said "I have something for you to look at through the microscope, I think it's a tick", and the lady at the peds office said "our microscope isn't very good, soo..." and my wife interrupted her and said "oh, that's OK, I brought one" :b

It's probably only about 40x, but it's got an LED light in it and it's good at focusing on the edge. At that magnification, you can see scratches left by stones that you can't see with the naked eye, and I declare success when the edge looks like a straight uninterrupted line and you can't see anything around it.

Of course, we'd never really need to look at any of these edges.

Years ago when I bought that scope, I bought it to try to tell why some of my japanese stones didn't seem to give as good of an edge as others. I didn't know how to use the stones properly to get the most out of them, and was really just looking for something finer than a shapton 15k at the time (which is a wonderful synthetic stone). That didn't work out and i shelved it.

I haven't looked at jasper, but I can predict that the edge will look like it has scratches in it from the prior stone all the way to the edge until it runs out into the tiny bit of nothingness that the Jasper creates, just at the very edge. One of the reasons I like it as a burnisher is because it removes so little metal that raising a wire edge later doesn't have that rounding to remove that you get from other things like overzealous use of honing compounds.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#69

Re: A study that has yet to be reported

Brian Holcombe

Hah, I can only imagine the look on their faces.

That is exactly what I look for on an egde with naked eye, but I've often wondered what is going on that I cant see or feel. Ive always been tempted to run one of my blades through my typical procedure then check it out under the scope to see if it looks as good.

I'd imagine the edge looks like mercury after the jasper. :D

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#70

Re: A study that has yet to be reported

david weaver

I looked last night, and unfortunately, I can't use the phone with the scope because the scope expects zero eye relief and the phone camera is a fraction of an inch from the eyepiece. Bummer!

I can't remember how much the thing cost, probably $50 or $60 or something, not something everyone needs to buy, but it has a nice big viewing area and when the light is on, you can see scratches from anything, and the tiniest piece of wire edge looks like aluminum foil hanging off of the edge.

Last night, I cleaned off the jasper (biggest risk using it is contamination), and to my surprise, with a buck chisel (which is kind of soft), it made a tiny wire edge and tiny little orderly scratches. On harder steel, it doesn't do as much. I guess it's somewhere around quartz hardness, practically poreless (more so than anything else), but if the steel is a little soft, it can still cut it some.

It's worth more experimentation (jasper slabs are so cheap, that they are definitely something to play with. I've paid between 99 cents and 16 dollars for various large pieces of biggs and owyhee - that includes shipping).

I have another one of the marker-sized USB scopes, but they're really junky and the picture is just all reflection it seems. If you use a regular scope without a light source from above, it can be hard to see anything in the scope other than black (you can still see if the edge itself looks perfect as a uniform black line).