New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

Posts

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#2

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The "slurry" seems to be an important part of sharpening with these stones. What does it do in sharpening? It would seem to be a result of new grit being exposed which will aid optimum abrasion, but it is not obvious what the slurry itself contributes.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#3

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

Brian Holcombe

The slurry does the majority of the work, people talk about natural stones and slurry very often because the slurry can be adjusted to suit your goal. If I want to create a finer edge I make certain to keep the slurry to a minimum (let the stone build a slurry in use as opposed to building one first).

I suppose it is probably somewhat similar to loose abrasive on a plate.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#4

I question your theory

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Particles suspended in a liquid will not abrade effectively and embedding them will not be any different than a fresh particle yet to be released from the stone surface.

However, the presence of a slurry indicates the surface of the rock is being renewed, exposing fresh edges of abrasive particles in their original size and shape. I can imagine that this situation leads to more aggressive cutting than a stone with worn particles not being shed from the surface.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#5

Re: I question your theory

david weaver

I can't add anything useful, but I normally don't, either, so what's the difference if I comment this time!!

I've questioned what's valuable with a slurry, and how it works, but I don't know for sure what's going on - whether it's loose particles doing some of the work rolling around, or if it's just their ability to keep the stone surface fresh. I still don't know, but the finish on a tool is different when there is slurry - it is less directional, except in coarse stones.

the other thing that puzzles me, that hasn't been brought up, is the assertion that a slurry will become very small particles. I've never seen pictures of this, but it shouldn't be that hard to capture for someone with an SEM (which sounds like a ridiculous statement, because who has an SEM.....I don't know, but the abrasives have been captured with one themselves - I think there'd be at least one picture taken from japan or something showing the particles before and after with a scale telling how much of a size change there has been.

The only thing I do know from observation is that the stone cuts differently with various slurries (how much in terms of particles, how diluted, etc), and it seems to be a stone by stone thing.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#6

My theory is questionable.

Brian Holcombe

Bill, it's probably better put is that I know when slurry exists the combination of effects creates a much faster abrasion.

However, that was the logic behind my approach to this post, I wanted to show the results and stones used to get them but I'm not offering myself as an expert on natural stones because the microscopic events are something I'm unaware of.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#7

Re: microscopic..

david weaver

..I have a dissection microscope that will show everything we need to see. It's interesting, because even microscopic views make things look much different than they are (a synthetic 8k stone bevel looks better than a suita bevel, but the qualities of the very edge are similar).

The funny thing about even looking at razor bevels is that without an SEM, you're hoping just to see nothing at all rather than something.

There is some foil and damage at 40x with lighting even on an edge sharpened by something like an 8k stone. It looks like nothing to the naked eye. The leather strop removes it, and the only difference you can see without a scope is that the edge shaves a lot more easily after the strop than before.

I'm pretty sure I could get a fairly good view of a slurried edge and a non-slurried edge (and get a picture of it through an eye piece with a phone camera). Seeing what's going on with the stone is a far bigger challenge, though.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#8

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

david weaver

A very nice write up, and the finish of the chisel off of the shinden and nakyama looks wonderfully pleasing to the eye.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#9

Re: microscopic..

Brian Holcombe

Hah, that's certainly true, one hopes to see a nice clean edge, but the reality is more of a mountain range in my understanding.

It would be very interesting to see a slurried edge vs a non slurried edge. I suspect the non slurried edge to be slightly more refined, but I am curious if that is actually true.

It's interesting that we can see the results in the work and on the edge and you can feel if its there, shaving probably makes it even more obvious especially if you have a sensitive face, but it is certainly interesting to see what that looks like under magnification.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#10

Thank you!


Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#11

Re: My theory is questionable.

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have no experience with Japanese stones but a lot with grinding wheels. The softer the bonding of the particles, the more they are shed and the faster and more aggressively the fresh sharp edged particles at the wheel surface cut. The equivalent "slurry" is the mound of ejected particles beneath the wheel. The bigger mound correlates with faster cutting, but is not the cause of it.

In a related note, are these stones composed of sea critter skeletons, silica in some form?

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#12

Re: My theory is questionable.

david weaver

They are approximately 65% silica and 15-20% natural alumina.

Other bits of things in them are what you'd expect to find in the earth, iron, calcium, water, etc.

There is a page talking about their composition online, and four different strata are tested, and all four are surprisingly uniform in composition. Most of the high-end stones (and a lot of common green stones) come off of the same mountain and the stones are apparently volcanic sediment.

https://sites.google.com/site/japanesetooldescription/tennen-toishi-tian-ran-di-shi-natural-whetstone

Decent (large and good quality) odd shaped pieces are available for about $100 from reputable dealers, but if someone is not looking to play, even that is a lot of money to experiment. Labeling the stones is no longer an exact science because most of the mines are closed. The wholesalers are guessing, though it's educated guessing based on stone characteristics, etc. That matters only because certain mine stamps command more money, and there are some exclusive stamps that are definitely being forged from time to time.

Uniformity doesn't exist like it would in actual use characteristics of something like a translucent arkansas. Stones from the same mine can vary more than stones between mines, and getting big stones is expensive (if you go with a reputable dealer who will allow you to try stones before you buy) or risky (if you don't). One dealer may ask twice or three times what another one asks for the same stone, too, depending on their opinion of a stone's characteristics.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#13

Re: microscopic..

david weaver

For edges sharpened back and forth or away (i.e., not razors), the slurried edges have a lot less trash remaining on them, and often the finish on the bevel (which is sort of meaningless unless it influences the edge) is harder to see.

Clear water/no slurry makes a more refined edge, but leaves lots of wire edge type stuff, little bits of shiny things under the lighted scope - those things can be stropped off.

If a stone is fine enough, there's not much difference in sharpness after stropping (slurry or water), but stones that have large particles or particles that can be pulled apart in clumps (like oilstones) make for a dull edge when slurrying.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#14

Re: I question your theory

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

" is the assertion that a slurry will become very small particles."

It certainly won't become small particles but the original abrasive particle may before it sheds into the slurry. Tough abrasives like aluminum oxide tend to just round off their sharp edges as they dull. Friable particles like silicon carbide fracture to doodle dust in use. This rock....don't know?

It was interesting to learn that this stone contains aluminum oxide. I wonder if it is crystalline, and hence corundum, which is near equivalent to modern aluminum oxide abrasive in hardness and toughness.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#15

Re: I question your theory

david weaver

I think the answer to that is yes, I've seen it referred to as corundum also.

The cutting power of these stones varies wildly, at least how each one responds to the same technique. Some are easier to use than others, and then there are undesirable things, like sticky or skippy feeling stones.

A stone that is a strong and fine cutter that seems to have a tough but smooth surface will usually yield a lot of money (shinden suita, okudo suita, some nakayama asagi like Brian shows. Some of the less desirable mines also make strong cutters, but it's easier to find those things out in person than it is mail ordering).

For the most part, they feel like hone slates, but with more cutting power. Educated use of anything fine enough to finish should yield a lifetime out of any reasonably sized stone, and some will do polish work on things you'd think they wouldn't cut (like T-series HSS, etc), but they are all more limited in their ability to do coarse work unless the steel is soft.

I don't think the alumina is an appreciable enough amount to make them seem remotely like any synthetic stones - most take a little bit of learning to figure out how to get speed or fineness out of them.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#16

Re: slurry particle shrinking...

david weaver

..I always figured if the slurry was assumed to get smaller, that what's actually occurring is that the slurry is loading the stone a little bit, and particles are getting duller over time. I don't know much about silica, but I would assume it will dull before it breaks, and the resulting fineness will be similar - it just gets there much much faster than alumina.

The only thing that bugs me is that I haven't seen anything, either, to prove my guess and a lot of the language from oldtimers is insistent about working the slurry finer and finer and then keeping it on the surface.

I generally only use the japanese finishers, actually they follow a washita or soft arkansas very well because neither makes deep grooves (the japanese stones are stronger cutters at fine grit by a comfortable margin if steel hardness is 60 or more).

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#17

I must have missed something...

John in NM

Where is the reference to aluminum oxide? It would be pretty unusual to find such a hard mineral in a fine grained sedimentary rock.

Two things to consider about that slurry - first it may be exhibiting some sort of chemical reaction on the steel (a well known action of oxide polishes on lapidary materials). Second, minerals like the clays that make up a traditional waterstone binder are famous for being anisotropic in many properties, including hardness.

I've long wondered, casually, about how natural waterstones could hone the super hard steels preferred by the Japanese. Most sedimentary rocks contain nothing much harder than quartz.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#18

Hmmmm....

John in NM

Just skimmed it, but the only reference I see to composition is near the end where it says the bulk is quartz and the rest is sericite. Sericite is not alumina, but it is an aluminum rich mica, a fine grained version of muscovite that is formed as an alteration product of feldspar minerals. I would expect to find lots of it in the sediments of Japan, given the type of volcanoes they have there.

Alumina in a destructive assay is not the same as corundum. Assay a coke bottle and you'll find lots of alumina (20% or so).

The way to measure alumina if it exists as an abrasive mineral in a stone is to pulverize it and run an X-ray diffraction analysis. Or make a thin section and look at it with a petrographic microscope, but as I recall these stones are too fine grained to see much with an optical scope.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#19

Armchair theory

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The notion that anyone can sit in an armchair and theorize about water stones without experience is ludicrous. It takes a lot of experience to get the slurry in condition to cut rapidly or to give a fine surface or whatever one is aiming for. Then one has to use just the right pressure and the right amount of water for the task at hand. Sharpening is an art, not a one or two dimensional problem. One cannot theorize about phenomena he has never experienced.

Of course a lot of modern stones are designed for the beginner market. A few decades ago when Norton was preparing to make water stones, they said they were aiming to make stones for the "American market". I was thinking beginner market.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#20

you missed the analysis

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

All the rocks contain aluminum oxide by analysis. It was at the very bottom of some link. About 15% as I recall.

These rocks are not one formation as best I can determine from the sparse geology I could find. Some are cemented ash, others sandstone and others compacted silica critters like the ARK stones but less fusion.

Iron carbide is not very abrasion resistant so I expect silica could cut it. If the is alumina present that would enhance abrasion.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#21

Refreshing your geology.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Feldspar is not igneous unless you classify granites as igneous. In any case it is not something found in volcanic rock. I don't know anything about the geology of Japan, whether it has/had granite intrusions, etc.

Dana lists Sericite as being an alteration (metamorphic) product of Kyanite and Corundum and other aluminum containing minerals, which are in themselves metamorphic.

Muscovite is about 40% Al2O3. So if the water stone is 18% aluminum oxide a lot of that stone is mica, if mica is the sole source of the aluminum.

No doubt there is a PhD thesis on these stones somewhere in a Japanese University. It would make an interesting read.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#22

Yeah, saw that later....

John in NM

At the bottom of David's link.

Metals in assays are typically reported as oxides because that is what the destructive nature of an assay turns them into before measurement. One of the most common in mineral exploration is the induction coupled plasma assay - it is a fancy way of getting an optical emission spectrum from a sample with a peak for the emission of radiation from each atom excited by the plasma - wavelength tells you what that atom is, peak height (intensity of emission) tells you the proportion of that atom in the sample. Metals at this point in the process are always oxides - but that does not mean they are oxides in the original sample.

Of course, I've no idea what assay method that analysis used - not all of them report metals as oxides - x-ray fluorescence for example is non-destructive (and not terribly accurate as assays go - it is usually used in processes like grade control for portland cement production, processes that only require precision to a few tenths of percent).

It is possible that the analysis indicates the presence of actual Al2O3, but not very likely considering the geology of fine grained sedimentary rock. If there were any corundum in the system, it would be far up stream from the mud, still in large (relatively) pieces due to being heavy and fairly resilient, like the garnets, magnetite, and perhaps gold nuggets and flakes one finds in streams. The mud is down in the lake or bay where the stream slows enough to finally drop all that fine grained stuff. The waterstone is this mud, hardened by the pressure of compaction as more mud is deposited on top.

The abrasive is likely silica. Hard to find a correlation between Rockwell C and the horrendously imprecise Moh's scale (used for rocks), but silica will generally cut most other materials even if very slowly. As you point out, brittleness becomes important outside of metals - even cut sapphires become abraded after 50 years of being worn on a finger - and its mostly the silica you find everywhere that does that.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#23

Re: Hmmmm....

David weaver

That might explain why they don't feel like they have 15% alumina in the same sense as a synthetic stone. Douns like it may not do much.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#24

No need....

John in NM

Granites are igneous, unless you are selling counter tops, in which case granite = rock of any type but marble. Counter top salesmen are morons.

Feldspars and their glass equivalents are certainly found in volcanic rocks. The type of feldspar varies with the type of igneous rock. Check out a 101 level textbook can confirm this if you don't believe it because I say so. Wikipedia might also be up to the task.

Since you appear to be a bit fuzzy on the details, all igneous rocks are crystallized from a magma, volcanic rocks are a subset of igneous which are ejected from a vent of some kind, anything from the explosive volcano of Mt. St Helens, the relatively calm Kilauea, or even the mid ocean ridges far under sea. Granites crystallize slowly, forming a coarse grained rock, basalts crystallize or even freeze very quickly forming a fine grained rock. Porphyries have some of each - larger crystals in a finer grained matrix.

Alteration minerals such as sericite are produced by a number of processes, from large scale metamorphism of sediments to hydrothermal alteration of just about anything containing feldspars. Most rocks contain some feldspar as it is probably the most common family of minerals in the earth's crust. Hydrothermal alteration products are an important tool in mineral exploration, particularly the porphyry deposits found in AZ where I used to look for them :D

Japan has ample igneous rock and hydrothermal alteration. Volcanoes of the type typically found there are more like those in Washington state than Hawaii, being the result of tectonic subduction than a hot spot in the earth's mantle. I would provide an example of a famous Japanese volcano, but I'm afraid the names are beyond me. Perhaps someone else can help out with that.

As to Al2O3 in muscovite, go read up on the mineral and assay methods. I've already outlined it very superficially, but believe me, there is NO corundum in sericite - its just a quirk of how the assay works and content is reported.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#25

Exactly...

John in NM

You can put whatever you like in a synthetic stone, including alumina in vast quantities if desired. I think Norton's India stones are fully alumina (synthetic without a doubt).

Easy to use it in synthetic waterstones if that would give the results desired - I'll be the first to admit I don't understand the slurry, so I've no idea if alumina would be a valuable addition.