New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

Posts

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#26

clarification

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

As to Al2O3 in muscovite, go read up on the mineral and assay methods. I've already outlined it very superficially, but believe me, there is NO corundum in sericite - its just a quirk of how the assay works and content is reported.

I didn't say it contained corundum, I said it contained about 40 Al2O3 which I got from reading up on Sericite

Dana, page 660- Muscovite " H2KAl3(SiO4)3 = 2H2O.K2O.3Al2O3.6SiO2 = Silica 45.2, alumina 38.5, etc"

The bottom line of the way Dana reports composition, which makes sense only in the perspective of how the mineral would be analyzed, if muscovite was analyzed and the Al reported as Al2O3 it would contain 38.5% alumina, not implying how this aluminum is incorporated into the crystal lattice.

Therefore, if the water stone contained 18% alumina from a mica source it would contain 18/38.5 per cent mica, which seems a lot. I expect the source of aluminum is not mica.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#27

Fair enough

John in NM

Though really "another source" is pretty vague. Where do you think it is if not in that sericite?

Probably a clay mineral of some kind, consistent with the muddy sedimentary rock - alteration is rarely complete and that sericite is likely an alteration product of clay minerals in the sediment.

Most clay minerals are derived from feldspars and contain abundant aluminum. It's not surprising to me that a waterstone would contain an abundance of the third most abundant element in the earth's crust.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#28

clay as the source seems reasonable

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When I was searching for more information on these rocks I found statements that they are not all of one kind of rock. One source sated they were lithified volcanic ash. In another case the rock was said to come from marine environment with the silica from radia...whatevers (can't remember the name of those silica assembling creatures). In yet another case it was stated some water stones were sandstone. No doubt it has been well studied and the result known with certainty, but I didn't find much fundamental.

The fact that these stones readily shed particles, which in turn reveals new particles, is an important property. It seems no different from a grinding wheel with a soft H grade binder. They cut and wear rapidly compared to a wheel with a more resilient binder.

I never could find why the quarries had been closed. Probably because there is already a huge supply of quarried rock and most of the world has moved on to synthetics would be a good guess.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#29

and

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Back in my formative years the rock that formed deep and cooled slowly was called "plutonic" so as to distinguish it from the more rapidly cooling volcanic rock. It wasn't that I didn't know the difference, I have spent many days pecking on the pegmatites in CO and NH, but rather I wanted to suggest that rock from the volcanoes themselves would not be the source of the mica.

The granites weather to a clay soil while the basalts do not. It must be that ash weathers to cay for the Monmorillionite deposits in Colorado/Wyoming are ash derived I think.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#30

Re: That is accurate..

david weaver

...they are not always point and shoot stones, and time spent with them always yields more improvement than it does with a synthetic stone.

It would be hard to describe the things you'd do with a particular stone to get the most out of it. Some like less water (or near none) and little slurry, some need slurry to cut without loading.

Hard to say. And there is the same issue that exists with oilstones, that being that steel of various hardnesses will take a different edge off of the stones. A western chisel that is softer may not take the same quality of edge off of a japanese waterstone as a japanese chisel does. The particles don't just cut a brash set of rows in anything, they work differently because most of them are in the same relative hardness range as the steels.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#31

Re: clay as the source seems reasonable

david weaver

Some shed particles and some don't. The ones that don't cut more like a burnisher if they have fine particles, and there is probably some parallel to other natural stones. The densest stones, which almost do not cut, apparently don't have much spare density to give up and water doesn't soak into them, nor do they let go of particles easily.

The softest stones shed particles at a rate too fast to be useful. The particles impede the cutting action of the stones (these used to be stones marketed for a few dollars or not at all, but now with the uptake of beginners, they are being sold as knife finishers (there already were special classes of stones for swords and knives).

I don't know what the stones are beyond the stuff shown on the link that I listed, but I'm more concerned about the use end of things and that's why. I do know that often something written in japanese is translated in google translate or without too much regard for how accurate the English is.

For a while, fujibato (a seller of stones) was calling all kinds of stones we use "Chert", but you won't find too many woodworkers referring to chert stones.

Aside from the selected specimen sandstones that would've been used for coarse work centuries ago, most of what's out there now that's of sandstone type is not very desirable for sharpening. I've got two hindostans that were mislabeled as other types by their sellers (one fine, one coarse), and they are fairly weak for their cutting ability (weaker than an arkansas stone) and the edge doesn't come off of the strop as keen - it's a coarse-ish edge for each grade of stone.

The japanese stones are different, most are capable of finishing until you go back to the stuff at the beginning of Brian's presentation of stones. They also create an edge that responds very well to a leather strop, though I'm only aware of Japanese sources stropping razors and not much talk of finishing tool edges.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#32

As with any field....

John in NM

There are many ways of saying the same thing and unfortunately they aren't always used as consistently as they should be used.

"Plutonic" as a descriptor is what I would call a subset of igneous, as is volcanic. A pluton is a large body of cooled magma, there are other types of igneous bodies as well, dikes and sills, breccia pipes, and others I've likely forgotten. All are igneous rocks, and all igneous rocks are made up of feldspars of one type or another, and all feldspars weather to clays (some faster than others).

Volcanic rocks weather the quickest, ashes more so than lava like basalts. The size of the mineral crystals has a lot to do with it, but also it has to do with how much of the rock is frozen glass rather than mineral crystals. Glasses are very weak, thermodynamically speaking. Mineral composition is also an important component.

Granites weather very slowly by comparison, having much higher silica contents - both as free quartz and as more silicic feldspars.

The important difference between a granite and a basalt is compositional more than anything else. Granites contain much more silica, making their component minerals more stable than a mafic rock like a basalt.

The slowly cooled plutonic version of a basalt is called a gabbro and the volcanic version of a granite is called a rhyolite. There are also many sub-divisions in naming conventions that reflect the relative ratios of Na, Ca, and K in the feldspars of each type also. But the names above catch the general gist of it.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#33

Re: Nagura

TomD

"The fact that these stones readily shed particles, which in turn reveals new particles, is an important property. It seems no different from a grinding wheel with a soft H grade binder. They cut and wear rapidly compared to a wheel with a more resilient binder."

Loading is a big part of it. The slurry is important on fine stones where they can clog up a bit, if you have slurry, or use a nagura to make it, you have a clean stone. I tend to regard the slurry as waste, and as an indicator of when I have correct pressure and angle, as in those conditions the stone looks very clean on passage of the tool, all slurry seemingly squeegeed to one side or other. But some sharpening experiences are quite different from others, and it may be the case that some of the difference is from the slurry, looking clean and being clean are possible two different things.

For those of you with a scientific bent, whatever the slurry does in a positive way, may mesh with the means of it's production from a nagura. Looking into what that process could, do, relative hardness, residue, could be part of the answer.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#35

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It is apparent that what was done was to analyze for Al, Ca, Fe etc. Then the analysis was converted to % of the original sample and the sum came up to something less than 100%. (not easy to analyze for oxygen in a rock) The rest is assumed to be oxygen. Rather than do something that would make chemical sense and then say that the rock contained XX% oxygen, such that oxygen plus the other elements added to 100%, a quirk of geologists was employed and the oxygen was assigned to each element to make an oxide of that element. So instead of an analysis that would read 10% Al, 40% Si, 5% Fe, 20% oxygen, etc. (making up numbers here) to add up to 100%, we are treated to SiO2 60%, Al2O3 17% etc. What benefit this chemical gymnastics adds is unknown to me, but it is a common feature of mineral analysis.

The analysis provides no clue as to what form the elements are in. The Al, Si etc may be in such a form that it is unknown what minerals are present because it is not crystalized or poorly so.

It would be interesting to see if the hardness of these stones correlates with the amount of Al present, presuming the Al is from clay. More clay, softer rock.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#36

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Reading the difficult to read translation suggests that the particle size decreases while sharpening . One can see where some experience would be necessary to use these stones to their full potential, something desirable to some and a bane to others(me for example). I have never been smitten by oriental mystique.

One would presume that the freshly prepared stone surface would be most aggressive but this scratch would be moderated as the particles fractured smaller and possibly the sludge that would be smaller particles built up on the surface of the stone . Again reading between the lines it seems that a single stone can exhibit variable scratch in the hands of an experienced user. Brain, is this what you experience?

It seems to be suggested that synthetic stones maintain a more consistent scratch in use so if you want less coarse you need to move to a finer stone.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#37

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

Brian Holcombe

Yes it can exibit a variety of traits depending on how one uses the stone. The variables being a self-made slurry, pre-made slurry with the same stone or diamond plate, nagura made slurry and finally no slurry. The amount of water used adds another variable to all of the above.

I expect the slurry does wear as it is used, at least thar would be consistent with my experience. A new slurry cuts very fast and slows down

The only thing really mystical is how enjoyable the experience is. I think that same mystic exists for arks as well

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#38

X-ray diffraction...

John in NM

Easy enough to determine the actual minerals making up the stone using X-ray diffraction, aside from then having to navigate the arcane taxonomy of clay minerals.

Fairly expensive to do since this kind of study is of little relevance to industrial geology. Assaying is inexpensive (maybe $15 last time I had one done) because it is so often done. The metals are reported as oxides for ease of stoichiometric balancing, I would imagine.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#39

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"The only thing really mystical is how enjoyable the experience is."

It's not what floats my boat. :b

What is not readily appreciated by planing enthusiasts is what a pain sharpening is to someone that isn't. Most of my planing is done in the course of fitting parts. So its a stroke here and a stroke there and the plane is retired for a while. It may be a week before more strokes are needed. And maybe a few more days to the next need. Then, without warning the plane is too dull to do what it is called upon to do.

It is the unanticipated need to stop and sharpen in the midst of wanting to get on with something else that makes sharpening an annoying interruption.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#40

Re: X-ray diffraction...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Is the silica in ARK stones and maybe water stones crystalline enough to get a pattern? It has never been clear to me what exactly the structure of these stones are. They contain silicon dioxide, but is it there as crystalline quartz? I suppose so or it would not be hard......

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#41

Yes, I would think so...

John in NM

The only time I did X-ray diffraction in a lab class we used powdered samples, so I would think it could be done with either type of sharpening stone.

I would guess the silica is crystalline, even if its microcrystalline. As you say, too soft to do much good otherwise.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#42

Pizza

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Bill, you have a chisel made from some disgusting steel, and use some nasty, harsh methods to sharpen it. Is it any wonder that sharpening is a chore?

If we select tomatoes, cheese, dough and oregano with your kind of criteria, eating pizza might be a chore also. Just an annoying interruption when we find ourselves wanting to get on with work.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#43

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

Brian Holcombe

Bill,

I touch up my chisels and planes pretty regularly and have no issue with doing so because that process is actually quite enjoyable. Alternatively, One thing that you may want to take away from planing enthusiasts is that they all have gone to great lengths to make the process easy and enjoyable.

You cite historical examples as being highly evolved design in cabinet building, similar examples exist in tools and sharpening which are equally difficult to improve upon.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#44

clarifying the point

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If I am approaching doing a bunch of drawers I anticipate I will need to touch up the chisel during the course of the preparation. The means to do so will be at hand and because I am using the chisel in a consistent way I can feel the tool dulling and anticipate the need to mend it. Ditto for the dovetail saw.

I suspect you experience something similar when preparing surfaces. But, imagine if you rarely planed a surfaces. Furthermore, the sharpness requirements vary depending on the details of however else you use the plane. Planing consists of a few strokes here and a few strokes there, with varying needs of sharpness required depending on the details of what the planing task is.

The result is that you might set the plane aside after having successfully completed a minute planing task. A week later when the need for another minute of planing arises this task is more demanding of sharpness. When you pick up the plane it is discovered it is too dull for the task at hand. The means to sharpen is not at hand because it hasn't been needed in three weeks. It is this unanticipated need to stop and sharpen that is annoying to me and it is not going to be cured by regressing to 1820 technology.

As far as time spent I doubt anyone is faster. I spritz a fixed diamond plate with lube and I'm ready to go. This operation is followed by a spritz of lube on the 1 micron loose diamond plate and again I'm ready to go. Diamond cuts very fast no matter the steel. I do have to retrieve these items from the shelf and return them. But there is essentially no maintenance.

"similar examples exist in tools and sharpening which are equally difficult to improve upon." The evidence suggests you are not correct in this statement as it applies to the vast majority of woodworkers. While almost every shop making dovetail drawers will be using the same basic construction, described in endless books and articles, you will do some searching before you find a shop using ARK or natural Japanese water stones. There has been a continuous march toward faster cutting, less maintenance and less preparation driven by a broad professional and amateur market that values these features.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#45

Re: Yes, I would think so...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The diffraction patterns that are commonly used for mineral identification and rock composition estimation are generated from finely ground material. However, the crystal size and order within these grains needs to be of some minimum size. I suppose the order would be there in an abrasive material but I have never encountered the opportunity to ask about something like those other varieties of silicon dioxide - Chalcedony, ARK stones and the like.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#46

Re: clarifying the point

david weaver

Most of what I've seen people using (who use incidental hand tools, not talking about hand tool gurus) have been pretty simple setups. Either something like two king stones, or an india and an ark stone.

I ran the whole circuit of stuff (high speed steels, and including using loose diamonds to sharpen them), but there really isn't any practical improvement over carbon steel and a washita stone (and if one can't tolerate the edge left by the washita, which is hair shaving, but not silent hair shaving type), then something like autosol or dursol on a backer will create an edge that's indistinguishable from 1 micron diamonds.

It took me a long time to realize that I wasn't solving the problem you're describing in the correct way (that is, trying to extend sharpening to long intervals and then making other compromises).

Brian was headed down the road with japanese stones, and I sort of enabled him as did other people. There's no real mysticism with them to me, perhaps with the exception of what Brian said - when you learn to use them, they are pleasing to use and they make a durable edge that is very consistent feeling until clearance runs out.

Bill, it sounds like you have a low maintenance setup already, it's more of a mindset issue. If you're using the cap iron and you have an edge that fails by uniform wear, there's really no reason to do anything other than wait for a plane to run out of clearance. I will say (having used a diamond plate and paste off and on in the past), that I have never really liked the setup compared to a washita stone for various small reasons (contamination, feel, the way the diamond hone cuts the bevel and is either brash or slow depending on what size particles you choose), but I have appreciated the diamonds the couple of times I've used an exotic chisel. Thinking back, the only time there was any benefit to using an exotic chisel was a high speed steel chisel that I used to flush wooden infills to metal. that's instant death for a carbon steel chisel except for the very highest quality japanese chisels, but any of the garden variety high speed steel chisels will handle it fine.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#47

Progress is not always progress

Brian Holcombe

Bill,

An edge under magnification shows a series of small mountain like shapes, are those with deep and severe grooves likely to remain attached longer than those with a radius between them?

Having used both alloy steels and aggressive sharpening media, then switching to HC steel and mild media, I can say that the later is much preferred both in terms of durability of a quality edge and in ease of restoration.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#48

Re: clay as the source seems reasonable

david weaver

I can't find the original post where it was mentioned, but you suggested that you saw articles describing the reduction in size of the slurry particles.

I think slurry is overthought quite often, it's more a function of nuts and bolts needs than it is a magic theoretical composition or predictable process.

For example, a razor is cut slowly (because it's not sharpened with any significant pressure - doing so bends the razor and distorts the bevel) by a stone without slurry, but often not finely enough with it. It's common (with several types of stones, not just japanese) to start a razor honing process with slurry and then gradually clear the slurry off to water to finish the razor. The slurry is necessary to get enough cutting speed to remove wear.

On something like a suita (which is more of a workman's stone, except the finest examples), you want a little bit of slurry to facilitate cutting, but not so much that the stone is sloppy. An excellent workman's stone is one that sheds particles, but does so slowly. Some of these types will cut carbon steels in the 60 range about as fast as a comparable synthetic stone. They will cut high speed steel and other diemaking steels, too, but not at a high rate. Others don't seem to want to cut much of anything unless they have an ideal semi-dry and not too thick slurry.

The subtlety of using the stones is in experience and with a goal to shoot for. You develop a technique with a stone and familiar tools, and the one thing that I think it's difficult for a lot of people new to them to accept is that they may not make a tool any sharper than synthetics, and often a preferable stone does less so. But the stone and tools seem to like each other better and work more uniformly across a sharpness cycle from beginning to end with the natural stones.

On the razor boards, there is tons and tons of pontificating about what stone might do what and what way, but it doesn't yield nearly as much data to the user as buying and trying.The road to the sharpest razor is fairly clear - surgically clean conditions and new sharpening materials all the way down to something like .09 micron iron oxide. the edge that's created and blinding - and it's transient. The edge straight off of a natural stone is less sharp, but a good linen brings it up to a comfortable and very capable and durable edge. It's different than tool sharpening, but the conclusion I've come up with is about the same - overthinking all of the stuff and searching for the edge of the envelope doesn't provide the same predictable satisfaction as just getting hands on things and finding what is the nicest to work with.

And paint by number or bullet point type analysis with the natural stones, especially the japanese natural stones, doesn't tell the whole story. I see from the composition chart, that the four stones are all very similar in composition. But my experience is that in use, the stones don't seem that similar.

One thing i'm skeptical of and want to see, though, is pictures off the particles in a slurry at the start and at the end. I don't know that I believe that there is an appreciable difference in particle size from start to finish. I just haven't seen a picture of it.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#49

Data is not on your side

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There are three quantitative edge retention studies that I am aware of- Steve Elliot, Kato and Kawai, and Lee Valley. Steve revealed his sharpening procedure. It was not revealed in the other studies. In each study a simple carbon steel was compared to other steels that had more or less alloying elements that provided abrasion resistance. The abrasion resistant steels must be sharpened with an aggressive abrasive format, so presumably in none of these studies was a silica based stone used.

In each case edge retention correlated with the abrasion resistance one would predict from composition. The improvement resulting from the addition of elements that make hard carbides was substantial. The work of Kato and Kawai is described in great detail. It was in support of developing the technology for Japanese planing machines, a tool designed to substitute for the traditional carpenter finishing exposed beams. I am confident that their criteria for finish at least equals my needs for I sand everything that is a show surface. Hence, there is no question in my mind that an abrasion resistant steel would offer me extended edge life.

That said, I just checked and what is in the plane I use the most is a Hock carbon steel blade. If someone gave me a blade from the new LV steel I would use it, but I'm too cheap to buy one.

Re: Japanese Natural Stones - A User's Perspective

#50

A study that has yet to be reported

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You broached a question I have long sought an answer to. Will a highly refined edge last longer than one less highly refined? It all hinges on the shape of a plot of sharpness vs feet planed in the first 100 feet. It may be that a less refined edge is as dull after 90' as a highly refined edge after 100 feet, an insignificant difference. Or maybe not.