Re: clay as the source seems reasonable
david weaver
I can't find the original post where it was mentioned, but you suggested that you saw articles describing the reduction in size of the slurry particles.
I think slurry is overthought quite often, it's more a function of nuts and bolts needs than it is a magic theoretical composition or predictable process.
For example, a razor is cut slowly (because it's not sharpened with any significant pressure - doing so bends the razor and distorts the bevel) by a stone without slurry, but often not finely enough with it. It's common (with several types of stones, not just japanese) to start a razor honing process with slurry and then gradually clear the slurry off to water to finish the razor. The slurry is necessary to get enough cutting speed to remove wear.
On something like a suita (which is more of a workman's stone, except the finest examples), you want a little bit of slurry to facilitate cutting, but not so much that the stone is sloppy. An excellent workman's stone is one that sheds particles, but does so slowly. Some of these types will cut carbon steels in the 60 range about as fast as a comparable synthetic stone. They will cut high speed steel and other diemaking steels, too, but not at a high rate. Others don't seem to want to cut much of anything unless they have an ideal semi-dry and not too thick slurry.
The subtlety of using the stones is in experience and with a goal to shoot for. You develop a technique with a stone and familiar tools, and the one thing that I think it's difficult for a lot of people new to them to accept is that they may not make a tool any sharper than synthetics, and often a preferable stone does less so. But the stone and tools seem to like each other better and work more uniformly across a sharpness cycle from beginning to end with the natural stones.
On the razor boards, there is tons and tons of pontificating about what stone might do what and what way, but it doesn't yield nearly as much data to the user as buying and trying.The road to the sharpest razor is fairly clear - surgically clean conditions and new sharpening materials all the way down to something like .09 micron iron oxide. the edge that's created and blinding - and it's transient. The edge straight off of a natural stone is less sharp, but a good linen brings it up to a comfortable and very capable and durable edge. It's different than tool sharpening, but the conclusion I've come up with is about the same - overthinking all of the stuff and searching for the edge of the envelope doesn't provide the same predictable satisfaction as just getting hands on things and finding what is the nicest to work with.
And paint by number or bullet point type analysis with the natural stones, especially the japanese natural stones, doesn't tell the whole story. I see from the composition chart, that the four stones are all very similar in composition. But my experience is that in use, the stones don't seem that similar.
One thing i'm skeptical of and want to see, though, is pictures off the particles in a slurry at the start and at the end. I don't know that I believe that there is an appreciable difference in particle size from start to finish. I just haven't seen a picture of it.