New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

Posts

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#51

Re: Alloying with tungsten

david weaver

Thanks for the heads up on that, Wiley. Never occurred to me to flip back through the yasuki/hitachi alloys - but should have, since they're one of the few things used in the woodworking world that was intended to be a blade steel.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#52

The analysis was likely irrelevant to performance

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Weaver's comments on coatings set me on a quest to learn about them. Patents tell all and now days it is easy to find the patents. The coatings are only applied to the blade edge and I analyzed the blade middles. The details of the edge are likely more important to performance than the steel substrate. Some highly corrosion resistant elements are added in conjunction with hardening elements to the edge, for example platinum, chromium plus a hardening element. Then Teflon is over coated to reduce friction. Boggling technology for 40 cents a blade.

Humm....platinum-Teflon coated plane blades. Now there is an idea

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#54

Re: Good steel vs. good treating

TomD

Yeah, woodworkers are a little similar in that we can move from out keyboards to our workshops usually fairly easily. But in activities where there is a fair distance between keyboard and reality, one of my favorites is bike touring, it is amazing what people dream up as necessary. When you hit the road all that stuff falls away, staying comfortable and not breaking down are pretty much all that maters. The closer people are to being doers the less they seem to need. But there is no harm in any of it. Some people play at model railways with little hope of utility.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#55

Video of Merkur Blade Production

david weaver

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e9PnTPIKd3g

Here is the video where we figured out that the coating was applied to the bevel only (with the blades stacked).

It's interesting only because of how many steps and how much inspection is required to make the blades.

And even though they're stainless, they're coated and then oiled, too, before packing.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#56

Re: The analysis was likely irrelevant to performa

William Duffield

Yabbut…

platinum-Teflon coated plane blades

Razor blades are disposable. The first time you sharpen the plane or chisel blade, the coating is gone. I don't think any of us would build or buy one of those vacuum ion deposition chambers to recoat our blades. Maybe the Rali disposable blade planes weren't such a bad idea after all. ;)

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#57

Re: The analysis was likely irrelevant to performa

Kees

Those Japanese researchers did some stuff with coated blades. They coated the bevel side of a bevel down blade. Where an uncoated blade had to be resharpened after a few hundred meters, those blades with the coating marched on for kilometers. The face side was not coated and that leads to a self sharpening effect. The coating on the bottom side effectively prevented the formation of a wear bevel that leads to loss of clearance.

Of course the blade is diposable.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#58

Re: coated blades

William Duffield

I don't see recoating plane blades in the home workshop becoming practical in the near future. Disposable blades in many of our "boutique" planes would be very expensive. It might make sense for the plane and blade manufacturers to coat the back of bevel up plane blades at the factory, as long as they included instructions: "Do Not Use Ruler Trick!" While they're at it, they may as well apply the coating to the trailing edge of their adjustable mouth blocks. It may be unwise to suggest these improvements, as they can only delay the ultimate reacceptance of the superiority of the double iron plane.

We send circular saw blades out for professional sharpening. Many of us even send hand saws to an expert for resharpening. If it meant more than an order of magnitude increase in edge life, it might make sense to send bevel down blades out to a professional service for resharpening and recoating the bevel. They could amortize the equipment costs over thousands of blades. It would certainly increase the initial demand for spare blades, but it would put stress on the water stone market. Someone might even come up with a way to apply the coating to hand saw teeth, circular saw blades, router bits, etc.