New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

Posts

More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#1

More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The leap of faith behind this effort is that what ever provides a durable edge for whiskers would be good for planing wood.

I ordered a 50 piece sample pack of double edged razor blades last year to go with a replacement safety razor. They are made everywhere- Russia, Turkey, Japan, India, etc. Some are crap, some do well and two were outstanding. I shaved with one for over a month (I'm not very fussy shaver). I recently had the opportunity to determine the composition of the best two. They were unremarkable 440 series stainless.

Are any of the custom/boutique tool makers making woodworking tools from 440 series stainless?

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#2

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

TomD

In the knife community where they have their own experts on edge holding and cutting power, and generally seem more knowledgeable than the woodworking community, 440 does not have a pride of place. 440c is a very popular steel when it is used for it's stainless properties, it is the most popular for that. While there are a range of choices, in the mainstream a steel that is widely regarded as outperforming 440C is good old O1.

Two short stories:

1) A while back we were told that the supply of 440c was caught short and all of a sudden quality knives started to show up in 420, normally the butt of jokes when 440C was being hawked. And these knives weren't half bad. How could they get away with substitution without loss of quality? "It is really all in the heat treating" came the reply. And it must have been.

2) MEC a Lee Valley of outdoor equipment up here sold the very well regarded Grohman line of knives. Given that when MEC stocks something they price it reasonably and it is accessible, I ended up buying several of the knives. I ended up with the 440C version and the O1 version. They were selling the carbon knife as an upgrade in all other than stain resistance, which sounded good to me. But the 440C knife turned out to be all around better. And the likely reason is that they knew how to heat treat it to near perfection. Sound familiar?

I have a 440c hatchet I rather like (designed by the Miracle Blade knives guy of infomercial fame, who was for real). But I don't think anyone was claiming it is a better working hatchet material wise than a Gransfor, it just doesn't bloom rust on a canoe trip. But at least I can claim actual woodworking performance knowledge with 440c. So claimed. :)

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#3

criteria

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"a steel that is widely regarded as outperforming 440C is good old O1. "

That is a meaningless statement without the criteria for performance being revealed. There is no doubt that the 440 steels will be more abrasion resistant and probably tougher for whatever these attributes are worth in an application.

The complaint I have had with knives of all stripes is that they are not heat treated to achieve high hardness and abrasion resistance. Hence, it is hard to predict what woodworking performance could be achieved from knife steel. It may well be that my razor blades could be substantially harder than the typical knife made from the 440 family.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#4

Re: criteria

Kees

I think you first need a good explanation of what is hardness, what is toughness etc. There is much confusion about these terms in woodworking circles. I am not an expert in these things, but to give some ideas:

Hardness is how difficult it is to penetrate the steel (usually meassured with a diamond)

Toughness is how well the steel survives impact force, usually tested with an impact test with a sharp object.

And then you have the yield strength and the tensile strength. When you bend a strip of steel it behaves like a spring. Meaning, it returns to the original shape when you release it. Until you get to the yield point. When the force is higher then the yield strenght the steel strip deforms and doesn't return to the original shape. Even more force and you get to the ultimate tensile strength and the strip breaks.

Increasing the hardness of a given steel, increases the yield point and the ultimate tensile strenght. It also brings the yield point and the ultimate tensile strenght closer together. In other words, it breaks easilly after it has started to deform. the material is more brittle.

Increasing the hardness also often decreases the toughness.

There are more factors. Like the grain size of the steel is an important one. There is an optimum, usually a very fine grain size. This increases the toughness of the steel. Even finer grained steel makes it more difficult to harden the steel.

Composition plays a major role too. 440C has a large amount of chromium, which tends to form relatively large carbides, not so good, but these carbides increase the abrassion resistance. Until they break out from the edge and you have a chip in the edge.

I clear the stage now for a real expert....

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#5

Re: criteria

TomD

""a steel that is widely regarded as outperforming 440C is good old O1. "

That is a meaningless statement without the criteria for performance being revealed."

No it isn't, the criteria don't mater it is the sentiment of the industry and users that is measured. There are a wide range of performance criteria, but generally edge holding and ease of sharpening are the main concerns, and 440C has limits in both. Sharpening is whatever happens when people try to sharpen them and the most common wear measure is repeated cuts in hemp rope. But that is not what I was referring to just the aggregate reason people have for using different steels.

If 440C outperformed O1 it would be silly to make O1 knives, since they have no other advantage. Since the industry includes a huge range of users, it is a very broad range of concerns, Stainless is only superior in being stainless, nothing else that I am aware of. Though A2 is somewhat stainless and has followers who believe it is the best in edge holding and toughness.

" There is no doubt that the 440 steels will be more abrasion resistant and probably tougher for whatever these attributes are worth in an application."

It is harder to sharpen but not longer wearing, is the result one hears. Toughness is normally not actually what people mean by toughness, which in a knife use sense normally means it survives ill use as opposed to the scientific definition. Of course steels tend to get pigeon holed who knows what would emerge in the hands of a Japanese smith. I don't have a huge problem with the consensus though since normally adding very large amounts of materials like nickle and chrome would not be expected to yield a lot of steel like properties.

"The complaint I have had with knives of all stripes is that they are not heat treated to achieve high hardness and abrasion resistance. Hence, it is hard to predict what woodworking performance could be achieved from knife steel. It may well be that my razor blades could be substantially harder than the typical knife made from the 440 family."

True, as I said about the upgrade of 420 it was in the heat treat. An easy way to tell is to use one of the blades to scratch test one of your hunting or pocket knives. Or maybe to start with, the other way around.

I can't imagine much useful will come out of this. Steels like 440c are not stain resistant enough for marine use where serious long term exposure will exist. They are mainly useful for situation where staining is a nuisance, or users are careless. They are overkill in the pro kitchen for the most part, and overly expensive, and at 17% chromium unlikely to be the top performer in the workshop. A canoe hatchet seems like the perfect use.

The best razor blades I know are all ones that rust. The German ones I use outperform by months the other brands I get, which are all incomparably better than brands like Wilkinson or Gillette.

You would get better results taking these questions to Blade Forums. There are tons of people there with real practical and theoretical knowledge.

http://www.azom.com/article.aspx?ArticleID=6846

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#6

Re: criteria

TomD

Good technical summary.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#7

Re: criteria

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I am familiar with knives made with 440A and 440C. Both are high chromium steels, but 440A has a lower carbon content, at the very bottom of what is considered high carbon steel. 440C is more in the mid range of carbon for a high carbon steel and since it needs a more complex heat treatment, is more expensive.

Neither one of these steels is as easy to sharpen as 1095 or cast steel, and neither one gets as sharp. Their edges may last for a very long time, but I think the best they get is still not up to a dull 1095.

People buy stainless steel knives because they like something shiny in the drawer. Woodworking tools of 440 steel? No interest.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#8

Just out of curiosity...

Chad P

What brand of German razor lasts so long?

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#9

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Given that it is impossible to find a razor blade that is not stainless in the common places people buy these items, is a claim that these steel compositions can not be sharpened to the same practical degree as a non-stainless steel credible? Elliot's work showed that it was the abrasive choice that limited sharpening of high alloy steels not the composition.

Given that the two best blades in my collection of 50 were 440 stainless seems to me convincing that this steel composition can be sharpened to as high a practical degree as necessary for woodworking. That the 440 edge stayed sharp suggests superior dulling resistance which is consistent with its composition.

(note: I have used the term "steel composition", not simply steel. Other factors in the manufacturing process affect the ability of the steel to take and hold an edge. It could likely be that all 50 of my razor blades are 440 and all the difference is in manufacturing. My interest is in what performance the composition can deliver under optimum manufacturing conditions.)

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#10

data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.



The picture is the Smoky Mountain Knife Works Store in Sevierville, TN. The store is worth some effort to see if one is in the neighborhood. Allow at least 2 hours if you want to see most of the wares. I have yet to visit it that I have not left with some knife bargain, which is a risk of visiting. (yesterday it was a boning knife, Swiss, at a close-out sale price that was irresistible).

You will be hard pressed to find a knife in there for sale that is not stainless of some sort. This fact suggests that most customers prefer stainless knives.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#11

Most customers...

John in NM

In my experience prefer cheap. Their preference for stainless is secondary, but also real to an extent. That extent is mostly driven by the requirement that professional kitchen knives be stainless, and thus it must be the ideal material for every cutting edge. Now if those stainless knives cost two or three times what a 1095 knife cost, they would still go for the cheaper one for the most part.

The other thing I've noticed - just casually - is that many people don't know how to sharpen knives any more, and just muddle along with dull ones until they buy a new knife. I attribute this to the difficulty most have in removing the wire edge on a stainless knife. Sharpening stainless kitchen knives is a pain, which is why I prefer carbon steel ones.

I would be more open to stainless pocket knives if there weren't so many good options available in 1095 or CV steels. I'm not a collector, so I don't mind a bit of patina, and the ease of sharpening is important to me on a knife that gets used daily.

My favorites are German ones - no idea what the steel is, but it patinas rather than rusts like my one 1095 knife. I suspect its some version of a CV steel, that sharpens like carbon.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#12

The current darling of the custom knife makers

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Is SV30, a custom Crucible product, particle metal technology, carbon vanadium, somewhat rust resistant, takes a wicked edge, holds it a long time, difficult to heat treat and very expensive. You'll pay a lot for it, but those guys swear by it, and their customers don't seem to care. Heck, they're paying $300+ for a custom shiv anyway...

I have no idea what kind of chisel or plane iron it would make, but it would be expensive.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#13

Re: The current darling of the custom knife makers

John in NM

yep, its all in the marketing :D

I've never been one for buying custom anything myself, though I'll buy some of the better production stuff and not worry much over the cost.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#14

Re: The current darling of the custom knife makers

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Hah! This is coming from the guy who asked and markets custom grips! :D

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#15

Re: The current darling of the custom knife makers

John in NM

:D :D :D

That's part of the reason I don't go for custom made - I figure if I want it bad enough I better figure out how to make it! The grip thing started by simply making one that no one else made and I wanted, suddenly I'm the custom guy for those.

You know the funny part? I like doing the custom work because I get to make pretty ones and see them done, but it doesn't pay well enough to do much of it. After just a couple years of individual sales I started selling plain production ones to a vendor - that's where I make any money to be made on it - I'm down to something like 35-40 minutes each and charge $30 for them.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#16

Re: question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

On May 27, 2011, on this forum, you asked me to recommend a chisel. I suggested 19th century English tools. I recommend sharpening them with Arkansas stones. My guess is you have still not even tried them. I hope you don't claim some day that nobody ever told you.

I am familiar with 440A and 440C. I don't suggest them for knives or chisels. Maybe you can find a blogger who does.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#17

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

Brian Holcombe

I like plain high carbon steels Bill, they get very very sharp, they take a clean cut for longer than A2 (in my experience) and they're easier to restore once they get dull.

I can use plain high carbon steel blades until I can literally see the edge, I take them out of the plane and it never ceases to amaze me at how dull they are and are still taking a nice shaving.

A2 (and I'm using that since it is the closest thing to stainless that I use in a plane) stays 'sharp' longer, but it displays the effects of dulling quicker, such as minute little chips at the edge that leave hairlines in the finish, and it becomes harder to start a cut sooner than plain high carbon steel.

They use stainless for feather blades, that is true, but the moment they show dullness I'm tossing it in the trash and getting another, not honing it. Straight razors, by comparison, are often plain high carbon steel.

I can restore the edge on plain carbon steel with a medium-finish stone and nothing more. A2 almost always requires a series of stones.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#18

It's the stainless cousin to CPM 3V

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It was an option years ago when we settled on CPM 3V for our batch of woodworking tools. It's stainless attribute is of little value in a woodworking tool, so 3V seemed a better choice for our tools.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#19

Re: It's the stainless cousin to CPM 3V

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Bill, did your club do the HT or did you send it to a commercial heat treating outfit?

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#20

OT-Getting further afield, but...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

what were the two winners in your razor blade test?

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#21

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

Frank D. in Montreal

The last two knives I've bought have blades that are made with CTS-XHP (Carpenter steel co.) and S110V (both Spyderco knives). They outperform any steel in any cutting instrument I've had by a long shot (I use my knives every day). Even though they have some attributes that may not be necessary in a woodworking g tool (like light weight) I'd buy a plane or chisel blade made with these steels in heartbeat. But most woodworking tool manufacturers (the ones I know of) don't seem to have changed the types of steel they work with in the last 10 or 15 years (A2 is still seen as cutting edge on some tool makers' sites), other than LV maybe. Karl Holtey works with S53, but I've never tried that.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#22

Re: question

Steve Voigt

Bill, If 440 stainless were any good for woodworking, do you think LV would have spent gazillions to develop their PM-V11? Don't you think somebody would be using it?

A couple people in this thread, including you, have raised the issue of criteria. I think we evidently don't all have the same, or even similar, criteria. As far as I can tell, your criterion is a steel that never needs to be sharpened. I suggest that, rather than chasing such an unattainable goal, you adjust your criteria instead, as Brian and Warren have suggested, and accept frequent sharpening as a perfectly reasonable price to pay for a steel that gets sharp as heck, quickly. You'll be happier in the long run.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#23

not a home hobby project

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

One does not heat treat these steels under a shade tree. We sent the fabricated blades to the heat treat shop(s) recommended by Crucible Products. In case one it was Bos, the knife people. Case two was a place in Nashville. It is cheap to do by the way.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#24

There is a coating

david weaver

There is a coating on most or maybe all blades made for shaving. It's something ultra hard that also covers the edge (and probably makes for a finer and smoother edge).

The old razor blades were uniform steel (like the old carbon steel gillette blue), but didn't last long due to the lack of coating.

Not that 440c can't be brought to shaving sharp, especially by a bunch of machines that could do a submicron lap.

I don't know what point the coating serves, but it may make a sharper and smoother edge (and it's something very hard).

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#25

A2 and other stuff

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I concluded long ago from our research into woodworking steels that A2 is a poor choice for exactly the reason you have discovered. A2 lacks toughness when heat treated to get high hardness. Lacking toughness, it is prone to chipping. It is generally recognized that chipping failure is more difficult to recover from that simple dulling or deformation. Hence, steel prone to this kind of failure is to be avoided, or mitigated by sharpening at higher angles.

For the record, the plane blades I used regularly are Hock, carbon steel. I have a CPM 3V blade but it doesn't fit the plane I use most often. If I had CPM 3V blades for the planes I use I would be using this steel. I sharpen with diamonds which cut any of these steels about the same rate.

I largely plane to fit furniture parts, never to prepare a surface. As a result my planing is in short spurts with long time gaps between. Too dull to accomplish a task sneaks up on me and arrives as an unpleasant interruption in work flow. I suppose if one is mostly planing surfaces dull is seen (felt) coming and it can be anticipated when sharpening will be needed. Work stoppage to sharpen does not arrive as an unexpected annoyance. In fact it could be a welcome break.