Re: criteria
TomD
""a steel that is widely regarded as outperforming 440C is good old O1. "
That is a meaningless statement without the criteria for performance being revealed."
No it isn't, the criteria don't mater it is the sentiment of the industry and users that is measured. There are a wide range of performance criteria, but generally edge holding and ease of sharpening are the main concerns, and 440C has limits in both. Sharpening is whatever happens when people try to sharpen them and the most common wear measure is repeated cuts in hemp rope. But that is not what I was referring to just the aggregate reason people have for using different steels.
If 440C outperformed O1 it would be silly to make O1 knives, since they have no other advantage. Since the industry includes a huge range of users, it is a very broad range of concerns, Stainless is only superior in being stainless, nothing else that I am aware of. Though A2 is somewhat stainless and has followers who believe it is the best in edge holding and toughness.
" There is no doubt that the 440 steels will be more abrasion resistant and probably tougher for whatever these attributes are worth in an application."
It is harder to sharpen but not longer wearing, is the result one hears. Toughness is normally not actually what people mean by toughness, which in a knife use sense normally means it survives ill use as opposed to the scientific definition. Of course steels tend to get pigeon holed who knows what would emerge in the hands of a Japanese smith. I don't have a huge problem with the consensus though since normally adding very large amounts of materials like nickle and chrome would not be expected to yield a lot of steel like properties.
"The complaint I have had with knives of all stripes is that they are not heat treated to achieve high hardness and abrasion resistance. Hence, it is hard to predict what woodworking performance could be achieved from knife steel. It may well be that my razor blades could be substantially harder than the typical knife made from the 440 family."
True, as I said about the upgrade of 420 it was in the heat treat. An easy way to tell is to use one of the blades to scratch test one of your hunting or pocket knives. Or maybe to start with, the other way around.
I can't imagine much useful will come out of this. Steels like 440c are not stain resistant enough for marine use where serious long term exposure will exist. They are mainly useful for situation where staining is a nuisance, or users are careless. They are overkill in the pro kitchen for the most part, and overly expensive, and at 17% chromium unlikely to be the top performer in the workshop. A canoe hatchet seems like the perfect use.
The best razor blades I know are all ones that rust. The German ones I use outperform by months the other brands I get, which are all incomparably better than brands like Wilkinson or Gillette.
You would get better results taking these questions to Blade Forums. There are tons of people there with real practical and theoretical knowledge.
http://www.azom.com/article.aspx?ArticleID=6846