Re: Good steel vs. good treating
david weaver
The knife and razor forums are full of people who "need" certain things according to them. Most of them appear to live in apartments or houses and work at a desk. most also have an affliction that requires them to buy contraptions to sharpen, which is a shame (but that stuff is peddled to beginners on those forums, to replace a skill that is pretty easily learned).
I've got various knives (hobby knives, I'll call them), some in 1095, and a bunch in 440C, and then a couple of case's knives in their chrome vanadium. All of them are a touch soft except for knives made by Great Eastern Cutlery subbrands in 1095 (I don't have any of their stainless).
The GEC (Tidioute) knives with 1095 are so hard that they must be at least 60 hardness, which is uncommon in small consumer knives.
I've got other makes in 1095, Bear and Son is one that comes to mind, and they feel like they are only just above saw temper in hardness. Natural stones cut them more easily than they should, and they don't seem remotely the same.
if I had a new user and let them sharpen both knives and use them, I could easily convince someone that they are using knives made of different steels. The impression people get with the Tidioute/Northfield GEC subbrand knives is that the knives "get sharper" because of the hardness.
Add a vintage kabar pocket knife to that, 1095 but not as well done as the tidioute knife.
The same is true for 440C, it could easily be done to 60 hardness, but most knives its made in are intended to be steeled and its potential isn't used (though if someone likes to use steels, then that softness is probably appreciated). Japanese knives of VG10, which is regarded as a substandard steel (probably very similar to 440C), are so good at 61 or 62 hardness that I can't imagine a need for anything better.
Point being, I think most people believe that certain steels aren't good enough when it's really the money spent on proper heat treating that is missing.
And most users are probably lacking in sharpening skill and speed, not wondersteel needs.