New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

Posts

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#26

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

david weaver

Feather's blades are definitely coated, and merkur and dorco are, too. I don't know about all of them, but it's hard to know what feather blades would be like without a coating - probably not nearly as good.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#27

Re: Good steel vs. good treating

david weaver

The knife and razor forums are full of people who "need" certain things according to them. Most of them appear to live in apartments or houses and work at a desk. most also have an affliction that requires them to buy contraptions to sharpen, which is a shame (but that stuff is peddled to beginners on those forums, to replace a skill that is pretty easily learned).

I've got various knives (hobby knives, I'll call them), some in 1095, and a bunch in 440C, and then a couple of case's knives in their chrome vanadium. All of them are a touch soft except for knives made by Great Eastern Cutlery subbrands in 1095 (I don't have any of their stainless).

The GEC (Tidioute) knives with 1095 are so hard that they must be at least 60 hardness, which is uncommon in small consumer knives.

I've got other makes in 1095, Bear and Son is one that comes to mind, and they feel like they are only just above saw temper in hardness. Natural stones cut them more easily than they should, and they don't seem remotely the same.

if I had a new user and let them sharpen both knives and use them, I could easily convince someone that they are using knives made of different steels. The impression people get with the Tidioute/Northfield GEC subbrand knives is that the knives "get sharper" because of the hardness.

Add a vintage kabar pocket knife to that, 1095 but not as well done as the tidioute knife.

The same is true for 440C, it could easily be done to 60 hardness, but most knives its made in are intended to be steeled and its potential isn't used (though if someone likes to use steels, then that softness is probably appreciated). Japanese knives of VG10, which is regarded as a substandard steel (probably very similar to 440C), are so good at 61 or 62 hardness that I can't imagine a need for anything better.

Point being, I think most people believe that certain steels aren't good enough when it's really the money spent on proper heat treating that is missing.

And most users are probably lacking in sharpening skill and speed, not wondersteel needs.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#28

I question the coating.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....at least for the two blades I analyzed. I didn't detect any elements that would imply a coating- titanium or vanadium nitrides for example. Additionally, these and similar coatings typically show up as some optical change in the steel's appearance.

The technique used for analysis would have been especially sensitive to detecting a coating. The blade was blasted with a fine laser beam which volatilized a shallow pit in the surface. In case the grain structure was large the process was repeated 8 times across the surface to get an average composition .

The volatilized material was heated by the laser to a high enough temperature. The hot atoms emitted characteristic photons whose energy depended on the atomic mass of the atom (like the colors of fireworks, yellow for sodium, green for copper etc.). By measuring the energy of the photons and the intensity of this energy the amount of each kind of atom present is determined. It takes but a few seconds to do the analysis. It is a handy tool for the curious, but I only get to use one once or twice a year.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#30

Wow, all those knifes!

Kees

That's a world completely remote to me. I have 1 (one) pocket knife, a stainless Opinel. Perfectly allright for peeling an apple when I'm in the office or for cutting the salami when I'm away on a climbing or skiing trip.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#31

Setting the record straight

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Don't you think somebody would be using it (common 440)?" Well, that is the question I asked. I'm isolate here in E. TN where we just started wearing shoes. Given that common 440 makes a good razor blade I wondered if anyone had tried common 440 for tools. If someone had tried it I likely would not know about the effort. That was the whole point of the post, which apparently I didn't make clear. A dozen replies avoided addressing the question.

"A couple people in this thread, including you, have raised the issue of criteria." Again, things went off the tracks as a result of my reply to Tom. To repeat and clarify, if we don't know the criteria used by the knife community Tom referenced I have no idea whether their conclusions have any bearing on using common 440 series for a plane blade, or a chisel, or whatever.

"As far as I can tell, your criterion is a steel that never needs to be sharpened." To get the record straight, we made some tools, 10 or more years ago, from CPM 3V. I am satisfied with the chisels. They are my go to chisels. I have Hock blades in my go to planes. I have no motivation to make any additional tools. If I was in need of a new chisel or plane blade I would buy one made from PMV11. (In the case of a chisel I would reshape the LV to be thinner.) My main criteria for a tool was that it be cheap, which was the motivation to make chisels. Given that the metal cost was essentially irrelevant, one might as well make them from the most optimum steel for the task. Had Warren provided a source for a set of 19th century chisels for $10 each, in the optimum shape, that is what I would be using.

That said, I have a boundless curiosity that gets satisfied by research. Additionally, I approach life with the assumption that if you learn how something works, everything can be improved. I wonder what the best razor blades are made of and when I get the opportunity to find out, I seize it. And then I logically wonder if there is any connection between razor blades and plane blades. That others approach life differently should not be an opportunity to criticize my curiosity.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#32

insufficient temptation

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you come visit me we will go to the Smoky Mt. Knife Works and I predict you will then own more than one knife.

Occasionally they set out overruns for some premium knife engraved for some occasion. If you are not bothered by the commemoration an exceptional knife can be had for $10. I just can't resist.

And then there was the occasion of gutting a deer on a near vertical ridge side with my preferred black handled Russell hunting knife. In the struggle I lost track of it in the leaves and a lengthy search was required to find it. Next trip to SMKW I got a bargain K-bar with a fluorescent green handle, easily found among the leaves.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#33

Re: A2 and other stuff

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

A2 lacks toughness when heat treated to get high hardness. Lacking toughness, it is prone to chipping.

Bill, I have plane blades in O1, A2, M2, M4, 3V, White Steel and PM-V11. None of them chip, especially the A2. I used a few A2 blades in a LV LA Jack for shooting with a 25 degree bevel for a number of years. None ever chipped.

A2 is not my favourite steel but it has a place. For abrasive woods such as our local fair in Western Australia, it outlasts O1. O1 has a "silkier" feel, but I cannot honesty say that I notice any difference in the surface quality of sharp A2 and sharp O1 blades in the same smoother.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#34

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless *LINK*

Kees

A problem with 440C is the hardness. As quinched it is less then 60 HRC. You have to temper the stuff, so you get even less then that.

But those quys in the toolsteel departments of the steel industry have develloped better versions of 440C. What you see often is a powdered metal version of 440C, like Udeholm Elmax Superclean. They added a bunch of vanadium too.

Hardness can now reliably be around 60 HRC. But I don't think we want vanadium in our woodworking tools. If chromium creates large and hard carbides, vanadium is quite a bit worse.

But there are other 440C like candidates. The PM versions don't make them any cheaper of course.


http://www.uddeholm.com/files/PB_Uddeholm_elmax_english.pdf

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#35

Re: Alloying

david weaver

I would guess if we wanted anything alloyed with plain steel, it would be tungsten.

Tungsten was marketed in straight razors for a while, and it must have sold some, but it does make a razor that's a little bit harder to sharpen.

Good carbon steel can't really be surpassed in a straight razor unless someone wants novelty, more or less because there's no reason for the steel to stay wet after use and because the linen and horse leather are nearby to stay on top of it - it can be relatively the same for 100 shaves without any issue without hitting an abrasive.

Anyway, I think if we had tungsten high speed steel instead of M2, we'd have something that would be pretty nice for hand tools.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#36

Re: Wow, all those knifes!

david weaver

I have an opinel, too, just one. And it's carbon steel. I was in search of a good hard pocket knife, and the carbon steel opinels are very hard and keen with a nice thin blade that makes for easy cutting.

George turned me on to the tidioutes (they are made very local to me, too, but I am generally too cheap for things like they are - $100+ for a fixed blade lockback knife).

The other things I got as I was remembering my grandfather carrying a half congress style knife or a stockman, and sharpening his favorite knife until the sheepsfoot blade was almost gone. Like everything else, I got too many different things, the first case stockman I had is a nice knife and that would be good enough.

My favorite knife is the Tidioute bone Wall Street knife. It's wharncliffe so it sharpens like a big utility knife blade - straight across. If someone came in and offered any appreciable amount for the rest of the knives, I'd sell them (eventually I will just sell them on ebay).

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#37

Re: Alloying

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

M2 is a tungsten steel. That is why it is so abrasion resistant. I made a M2 chisel from a jointer blade. It microchips...not good.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#38

Re: question - the real answer according to PM

TomD

All the blades I use rust. Have you tried rusting them? With razors a lot of the cutting power is the angle, though that doesn't affect the relative performance. Back when 2 blades was all there was. PM carried an article saying the real key to the increased performance of various razor gimmicks like more blades, lather strips and various other things they would announce from time to time, was just that the company was delivering sharper blades. Whether were advances occurring in sharpening tech for production, or whether it was purely a marketing issue that people wouldn't pay for improved shaprness costs, but thought an extra blade was a good deal, sorta "Super size that?" marketing, I don't know.

A test I can do with my own blades is to really make a huge effort to dry them, or even vaseline them, and they will last a lot longer. Some say you should store blades outside of the bathroom for the same reason, sounds like rust is a problem, to me.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#39

Re: data

TomD

I prefer stainless knives for general use. But let's face it, among the general knife population one has a lot of non-users, who even send knives back to be factory sharpened.

My approach to carbon knives is the same as it is to tools. I am willing to drink the Kool-aid if it allows me to work with O1 which is easier for me to work with. It's like wood. Fiberglass chairs are probably more efficient, scientific, and waterproof for that mater. But I can work wood, and am willing to make the case for using it because I know I can make a better product out of it than can be made in fiberglass. Now I have also make fiberglass chairs, and used that method when I could make a better product out of it. The only two sofas I have made where made out of fiberglass/wood composite and designed to travel over the waves at 20 knots.

These kinds of ideas are light years beyond the business represented in any roadside mega store representing mostly Chinese made products, that as good as they may be are mass market fantasy goods. In the run of a year, how many tactical folders get used for what they were designed for, or fantasy swords. Devil's brigade daggers, Wakazakis. What they make them out of really doesn't mater.

One of the great advocates of 5160 for knives, Ed Fowler, made up his mind from working the floor at a slaughterhouse. You can't buy that kind of experience in Tactical Knives.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#40

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

William Duffield

Please correct me if I'm wrong, but my understanding is that one of the main reasons for developing PM is to significantly reduce the size of the large and hard carbides. Wouldn't that eliminate the disadvantage of Vanadium?

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#41

Re: Alloying with tungsten

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David,

"I would guess if we wanted anything alloyed with plain steel, it would be tungsten."

Goood description of Hitachi aogami (blue paper steel), where tungsten = W, thoug it has a little chromium also:

http://www.paragoncode.com/temp/YSS_HCC_spec.pdf

I seem to recall the English sawmaker Spear and Jackson introduced tungsten into their saw steel back in the early 1900's. For a premium saw.

Wiley

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#42

Re: quest.- granularity of sharpening periodicity

TomD

"Brian and Warren have suggested, and accept frequent sharpening as a perfectly reasonable price to pay for a steel that gets sharp as heck, quickly. You'll be happier in the long run."

This seems to be the pro approach to sharpening, though that may have something to do with what was available when there were still pros. And it is not universal as Japanese tools are certainly an example of long wear.

With kitchen knives, leather knives, scythes, razors, the approach is very often/usually to sharpen frequently.

If one imagines a graph of edge sharpness as a line that declines as the edge dulls, then is rapidly restored during sharpening, and this cycle is repeated over and over. The graph would look a lot like the teeth on a saw, with a gradual decline followed by a rapid restoration. But the granularity could be such that the period between sharpenings is great or small, and the fall into the abyss of dullness is great or small. The graph could look like a course rip saw, or a fine dovetail saw. The less time between sharpening the sharper the blade is overall.

That is all obvious, the only real question is whether there are aspects of a tool, steel, or sharpening method, that bias the cycle to greater delay in sharpening, and a worse overall edge maintenance. If you look at woodworking practices almost everything is in the negative column, the tool steels are either downright hard to sharpen, or they are hardened to make even a simple steel hard to handle; the method of sharpening is often one that encourages waiting as long as possible and may involve several steps each in regrinding, rough sharpening, honing, and stopping; and with some of the tools, particularly planes, little weight is given to the difficulty of cycling the tools through sharpening/they are hard to disassemble and fiddly to reset. There are at least two plane types that are very easy to cycle, but they are not all that popular.

These characteristics are not random. Wood is hard and the softer end of the tool spectrum can fail to a significant degree with the first contact with some of the harder woods. Though the same tool might cut pine all day. Yet even that tool would be a lot harder than a head knife or a scythe.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#43

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

TomD

Yeah, Mercur, that is the blade I was thinking of. I have a straight razor that uses blades, and I use it traveling, and as a result much of the rest of the time. Mercur blades are excellent. I find I get about 6 good days out of them, and then I get the rest of the month at a lower level of comfort, but not all that bad. At that point in the cycle, I once left for a 2 month vacation with the one month old razor and no fresh blades in the bag. That was a rough two months, but I made it through, by the end it was not fun. Currently I am using Shark blades. I get one good day, and maybe a week total, and it is as done as the Mercur was at 2-3 months.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#44

Re: Alloying

TomD

The regular chinese HSS metal working chunks are awesome. I have made small tools out of them and they last for ever. They work steel with great efficiency also. As HSS, you can silver solder them to anything you want making your own version of something not entirely unlike a Japanese laminated tool, but a lot cheaper and very long lasting edge wise. The Japanese HSS woodworking tools are also relatively awesome, I don't know what they are, but they hold a great edge.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#45

Re: Good steel vs. good treating

TomD

"Point being, I think most people believe that certain steels aren't good enough when it's really the money spent on proper heat treating that is missing.

And most users are probably lacking in sharpening skill and speed, not wondersteel needs."

Obviously most people who buy these knives have no intention of using them. Most of us use a knife every day. But the knives that are being sold through the specialty business are all based on certain imaginative scenarios from hunting to survival, and beyond. These are created needs. One needs a knife for hunting, but when you look at the hundreds of different knives, thousands, that have been designed for that purpose, each one is a claim for a scenario, and the solution to that scenario. So simply, say the whole lock back thing, or the 2-3 inch drop point. What was wrong with the earlier knives? Well nothing but there is the freedom implied in not carrying more knife than you need, and certain performance advantages claimed. And then if you get that stuff, you must be a better knife user, or hunter, right? Even though you haven't shifted on the sofa since the whole process of realization started. It is the terrorist aesthetic but for knives. Nothing wrong with that, but one can't really make a broad analysis from these fantasies. For instance for survival some want a knife that won't go dull if at all possible, while others want one that could be sharpened on a rock, or maybe a simple sharpening stone carried in the sheath. One might imagine a certain steel would be ideal for a survival knife, but which knife? The one Tom Brown forged in a fire for Hunted? Or something different. I have 4 fantasies on the go at the moment, and mine are way out there given how oddball I am, but as Bill says it feeds curiosity.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#46

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

Kees

Relatively yes. When you make a PM version of D2, it has a lot fined chrome carbides, but the grain is still coarser then good O1 or W1.

And vanadium carbide is also rock hard, doesn't make an easy to sharpen chisel.

When you want to think about a new kind of steel for chisels, I think you would like easy to sharpen, better wear characteristics, no chipping at the edge.

Seeing that 440C is used a lot in the knife world, it migh be a good candidate to look for suitable powder metal versions. Someone mentioned CTS-XHP in this thread. I looked it up and indeed, not a lot of vanadium, a lot of chrome to help with abrasion resistance, a lot of carbon to get the hardness up, it's a powder metal so the grain is reasonably fine which should help the quality of the edge.

Someone should do some tests with this stuff.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#47

Re: T1

david weaver

I was thinking more like T1 than M2. Both have some other alloying elements, but M2 has a lot of chromium, manganese and vanadium.

T1 has less of everything to some extent, and much less vanadium and manganese.

I would guess that tungsten only either doesn't work technically or doesn't provide high speed properties. Not sure...on the old razors that say "best tungsten steel", you never get to know what's actually in the steel, but they are definitely finer than M2 by a long shot because that microchipping in 17 degree angle is toxic (and at such a slight angle, it literally happens on the stones before you ever get to use the edge).

I have to guess at a lot (well, I don't have to do anything, I guess)...I guess at a lot of things based on how they perform on natural stones. Tungsten steel razors don't get along with natural stones that well (that was probably their undoing), but the properties they have might be more useful in wood and knife blade steels. High tungsten level makes for expensive steels, though, that wouldn't be stainless.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#48

Re: Wiki's entry on razor blade steel..

david weaver

..even more interesting, the wikipedia entry (which is decidedly low on detail) suggests a steel that fits into a medium carbon steel territory.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Razor_blade_steel

I have my guesses about why this would be. The coating probably is what's really supplying the hardness for the shave, and once it's gone, the blade is trash.

Using a medium carbon base for the steel would also making hardening and tempering a bit easier, and probably yield a more flexible blade that a user is less likely to break.

I had always assumed that what was in the blades was probably something like 440C, but it looks closer to 440A if that article is correct.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#49

bridger

Re: question

Bridger

Iirc, pmv11 is powder metal 440.

Re: More on blade steel- 440 series stainless

#50

bridger

Re: Good steel vs. good treating

Bridger

I know a man who lived off of the land as a feral human for a couple of decades. He hunted all of his own meat. He said his prefered knife was a brazil made tramontina paring knife, that anything more was wasted time.