New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

Posts

Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

#1

Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

roger lance

I've just received notification from LV regarding updating their small plow plan so that it will accept blades to cut beads. Has anyone undergone this update and made use of the new beading blades ??

Appreciate your insight and feedback.

Re: Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

#2

Re: Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

William Duffield

Not yet. I've got the blades and the box to ship the plane body back to Lee Valley for the enhancement. It will go out of here tomorrow. They just arrived Friday, and I ordered them as soon as they were announced on their website, even before I received the notification letter. I don't know how long it will take, but the blades won't work in the plane without the modification. Lee Valley is very quick with their customer service issues, but they are not instantaneous. ;)

Re: Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

#3

Re: Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

Michael Brady

Don't forget the depth stop update which is available free when ordering another item or getting the beading update. I have it and it works well to secure the depth stop. I'll probably pass on the beading upgrade.

Re: Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

#4

Re: Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

TomD

I always return things for repair/enhancement in dovetailed pine boxes with lids screwed on with #5 robertsons.

Re: Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

#5

Re: Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

William Duffield

That would be a wise strategy. In this case, L-V has developed a special box just for the task, and even French fitted it to the plane.

When you send it in to regrind the skate to fit the bottom of the groove cut by the beading blades, they just automatically make the depth stop clamp enhancement at the same time.

http://www.leevalley.com/us/wood/page.aspx?p=74052&c=

It's all explained in the linked video. Amazing customer service, as we've come to expect from Lee Valley and Veritas.

Re: Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

#6

Halfway there

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

I dropped the plane at the Mother Ship (Ottawa store) two weeks ago, and got the plane body back last week. Looks like the modification involves machining a bevel at the bottom of the skate to allow for narrow beads, I haven't noticed any other visible modification, but that might just be me...

Haven't bought the beading bits yet, will do it when budget allows...

DC

Re: Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

#7

Re: Halfway there

Michael Brady

Dennis, does that modification look like it could be done with just careful filing? You describe it as a bevel at the bottom of the skate.

Re: Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

#8

A few pics

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Here are four pictures I took of the plane body. Apologies for the quality, hard to shoot bright metal...

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0BzZFBAMImVHibXRDMTFJZmYybzg/view?usp=sharing

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0BzZFBAMImVHibHJUd3ZsVzdPTUU/view?usp=sharing

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0BzZFBAMImVHiYmZNajNpa2VEaVk/view?usp=sharing

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0BzZFBAMImVHiMVFBYmxFRTFSUjQ/view?usp=sharing

I don't think one could easily file that bevel with any kind of precision, but what do I know... I measured the thickness at the bottom of the skate, difficult to gauge because of the bevel, but by comparing to setup blocks, it seems that the resulting thickness lies between 1/32 and 1/16" (3/64"?)

If anyone wants more information let me know...

Cheers,

DC

Re: Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

#9

Re: A few pics

Michael Brady

Thanks for the very nice photos Denis. That skate is ductile iron..pretty soft and fileable. I am just speculating that it could be done if you get a diamond plate involved for the final configuration and finish. I'm conscious of how much I would invest in that tool when there are alternatives coming and our updated version is a $60. premium over the same thing brand new.

Re: Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

#10

Question on narrowed skate?

David Bassett

Thanks for the pictures!

The bevel narrows the skate and will reduce support for the blade (iron) at the cutting edge. Do any of our more experienced users have thoughts on the effect on the other, e.g. grooving, blades?

Re: Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

#11

Re: A few pics

Paul M

Leave it to a Canadian company to make this look even more like a hockey skate. :D

I rarely do any beading, so I'm keeping my small plow the way it is and continue to use a beading scraper and sandpaper for the rare occasional bead.

Re: Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

#12

Re: Question on narrowed skate?

William Duffield

Why do you think there would be an adverse effect? The purpose of the skate is to keep the blade from taking a shaving that is too thick. It also supports the blade above the bevel (to minimize chatter, etc.), where the material removal of the modification is minimal. The thinning is not done in the direction of any reasonably applied force. In very soft wood, there might be a slightly noticeable increase in the denting of the wood, but it would be at the bottom of the joint, where it would not show anyhow.

I may be missing something, since my plow plane is not at hand right now, since it's on it's way back to Ottawa, but at this point I can't imagine any adverse effects during normal operation. The edge of the skate might be a little more fragile if you happened to drop it on the floor, but you could correct any functional problems from that type of damage very simply with a file.

Maybe someone else can see something I'm missing.

Re: Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

#13

Re: Question on narrowed skate?

David Bassett

I'm asking because I don't know if there will be any effect. (I'm sure LV wouldn't have made the change if they didn't think the benefits far out weigh any negatives.)

I see it said, repeatedly, that a plane cuts better when the iron has more support. (Though there seems to be disagreement on how much support is enough.) The plow plane, to allow multiple width grooves, already has limited support. (With really wide blades the conversion kit adds a second skate.) This modification, as shown in the LV video and the photo above, has an arc ground to clear the bead and allow the beading irons. That narrows the skate. It is most narrowed near the cutting edge. I'm trying to understand how significant that loss of support at the cutting edge really is so I can judge whether I want the modification in case I want to do beads or skip it for better grooving. (Skipping it of course means springing for another plane or alternate beading device, should I later want to cut beads.) Basically I'm confused and hope someone with more experience can explain the trade-off.

Re: Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

#14

Re: Question on narrowed skate?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

For what this is worth, the Stanley 45, which makes beads, has a skate that narrows pretty significantly, too. I've never had an issue with either lack of support for the iron or denting of the wood, and a lot of my work has been in pine and redwood, both very soft woods.

Because I have a 45, I'm skipping the upgrade (although I will no doubt get the upgraded depth stop attachment with my next order from LV).

Re: Updating LV Small Plow Plane......

#15

Re: Question on narrowed skate?

David Bassett

Thanks! It's good to hear your experience with a similar setup. I'll probably get the upgrade ('cuz beading is cool and I'll probably want to do it someday, not because I have any need for it right now.)