We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I doubt anyone who learns the double iron will go to something else if they continue to use hand tools.
It also doesn't make anyone any additional dollars that I'm aware of. The virtue of it is that a $25 plane without an expensive iron or freshly filed mouth will outperform anything that has been overdone from a manufacturing perspective.
I doubt there will be a following fad for one reason, one was never thought of professionally that was any better. Stopping on the double iron is just a realization of why things were what they were in a market that didn't include all machine planing.
Add a planer and a jointer that leave a surface with chatter only, and that's where you get people like Chris Schwarz (and many others) giving advice that is pretty useless to someone who actually uses a plane for more than smoothing.
It looks like I responded to the wrong post with the razor post.
re: economics - when the double iron took over, there was a significant amount of rough work. I'd imagine a skilled user probably doesn't gain much with the jack, and on the last smoother shaving they might not gain much over a single iron plane.
The gain in speed in the middle step is gigantic. I victimized Brian Holcombe with my thoughts on rough and middle planing, and heavy chip smoothing because I knew he'd benefit from it.
What your parents and my parents or even grandparents did occurred in times when people had disposable income and a large percentage of the population wasn't subsistence as it would've been 200 years ago. If I had to guess, I'd put a figure on economy of rough and middle work and initial smoothing at 20-30% faster with a double iron plane. And the work is more predictable. That frees that time up for an apprentice to do something else. And they work enough better that you can get a user to be able to dimension and hit marks with less skill (somehow, the idea that a single iron plane is harder and slower to use in the same context is held up as a medal of honor, which is sort of dopey. It's like shaving with a kamisori....it takes longer and is less convenient. But it's seen as the ultimate something...I don't know what given that western razors made a big imprint in japan (straights)....they have a longer life span and are more amenable to a strop and touch up hone....tangent here, I guess - I remember someone on a razor board asking where they could find kamisori on the ground in japan and one of the respondents in japan said "those are primarily an export good, sold to western countries. It will be difficult to find one retail in japan). Anyway...
I get the sense from context of use in larger work that the reason for replacement of the single iron planes was primarily economic, and whatever else would've been well secondary to that. The standard of living that your parents and my parents enjoyed isn't something that existed in the early 1800s.
I think if you put the time into it, it pays off well. I can tackle projects in my small shop that I think would require some serious equipment. That's where this makes sense to me, I wanted to be able to build tables and cabinets without getting a 20" wide jointer/planer and super surfacer and all of the other equipment that goes along with it and requires a warehoused sized shop and dust collection.
The part that troubles beginners is that you're putting yourself through a self-apprenticeship, which is longer and has more possibility of failure than a real apprenticeship. For instance, it's taken me some time, but I now have small mortises down to about 4 minutes per....that took some doing on my part but was worth the effort. I did not need to clear floor space for a mortising machine or spend thousands for a worthwhile one.
Same applies to tables/panels, if I had to surface a table in the same way that I did my first tables I would have given up by now, hah. What took me the entire day now takes me about 1/2 the morning and I have a better result.
It's daunting and time consuming, but I feel that the result which is self reliance without the need to constantly purchase new machinery, is worthwhile.
While the internet gives us access to many more resources than what was available back "in the day", it also makes it possible for just about anyone to get published or hang out their "guru" shingle. You might think that stuff from established publishers would be more reliable, but that isn't the case. As you (and Warren) noted there is experience in a practical sense and experience from reading/writing/publishing.
Practical experience is not valued by publishers, nor is it required to be successful. But the experience of making stuff to publish is not the same as making stuff in the real world. People in the business don't like to hear that, but I can't think of any woodworking author who wouldn't be a better writer if they had more experience in the shop, myself included.
In publishing the prevailing attitude is to pick the low-hanging fruit of those who know little or nothing. On one hand that makes sense as those are the folks most likely to be buying, be it a book, video, magazine article or website. Success is measured in sales, and if something sells it gets repeated, either by the original author/publisher or by someone who wants to be as successful or appear as knowledgeable.
On the other hand it is incredibly easy to take advantage of the audience and generate tons of information of dubious value. The knowledge of writers, editors, video stars or gurus only needs to be a little bit better than the audience to be successful. When the audience catches up and moves on, that's okay because there is a new crop of beginners to cash in on. This works as a business model, but it really doesn't further knowledge of the craft or help the beginner figure out what's important and what isn't.
I personally don't see much value in "making it easy for the beginners", but that's where the money is and that's why woodworking magazines and books are becoming less of a value and less relevant with each passing year. It's far easier to sell the latest magic trick than it is to sell "if you want to get good at this, go out to the shop and practice." If I want to learn how to do something I don't know, I look for someone who has been doing it for a long time, not writing about it for a long time.
Charlesworth. As Warren said, his method is a sharpening aid, not intended to change the attack angle of the plane. Bill is likely right, too, that the method is subtle and may be abused by the hamfisted.
I posted this below, but I think it bears repeating in this part of the discussion ...
my observation, especially with water stones, is that the suction between the stone and the back of a blade (stiction?) can be so great that pushing the blade across the sharpening media becomes very difficult, to nearly impossible.
I can readily imagine many beginners lifting the outboard end of the blade to make life easier and thereby creating the varieties of back bevel that Bill observed.
"If I want to learn how to do something I don't know, I look for someone who has been doing it for a long time, not writing about it for a long time. "
It was for this reason that I found a week in the Mack Headley and Sons shop such a game changer for my woodworking. Nothing like 4 generations of making Period Furniture to refine what works quickly and reliably.
That said, once we become acquainted and comfortable with a proven method of work, our personal situation could, if not should, cause us to explore modifications. If for no other reason, technology changes, which opens new opportunity, if adapting new technology is acceptable to the lifestyle of woodworking we have chosen.
Gee David, I'm a mechanical engineer (or at least I play one by day) and I certainly don't think that way! Actually, it was a learning curve for me. i designed race car parts for years before I got into woodworking and it took some time to realize that wood moves more than metal and wood "machines" weren't as accurate as "metal' machines, etc. Now that I have been at it a while, I don't worry too much about absolutes...if it fits it fits, if it looks straight, it is straight, etc. I still appreciate an accurate reference though (ie Starrett).
Thanks for the "insiders persepctive" Bob. Funny, I work in the corporate world (ughh) and much of what you are pointing out is relative here too - it is all perception. We have many "experts" here. Just read Dilbert...
Oh, I posted a pic of a project I made for my wife for Christmas a few weeks ago. I was digging through the magazine stack and found your article on the Limbert piece you did with the leaves. I had forgotten that - it was part of my inspiration to build her "Starry Starry Cabinet." I would like to build more similar pieces - really like the green cabinet with the iris (and I'm not really a fan of A&C style - go figure).
I carved the panel in an attempt to replicate the texture of his brush strokes before I painted it.
One great thing about the Internet, that most magazines seem slow to move on, is that you can find appeal even for the top end of a craft. You can delve deeper than the eye-catching stuff that appeals mainly to people new to the craft.
Much like when racing cars, even a few years in I found the magazines incredibly boring as they would just recycle the popular debates. I can't imagine how they would find any appeal for people that had more than a surface level interest.
.. have those habits, though I have a habit of saying I can spot an engineer in woodworking from a mile away.
I'm sure it causes kees to gnash his teeth, because like you, he's not really in that group of people who are not willing to trust his hands and eyes. I have a technical background, too, so neither should I be exempted, I guess. I had to make a lot of tools that are different than what was done from centuries of incremental improvement until I realized that I was just making tools that were not as good or as capable.
My friend has the engineer's disease, bad, though, and he almost gave it to me until I got tired of setting up machines and cutting test piece after test piece to make two joints. (the last we talked about making planes, he discussed having a plane made out of a piece of solid, machined only to have handle and knob added - I gave him a wooden plane. I think he looks at it sometimes )
I meant to compliment your cabinet the first time I saw it. Carving, coloring and combining that with solid frames and furniture is the rabbit hole I recently jumped in. Inspiration was the Byrdcliffe (not Limbert) cabinet that was on the cover of Popwood several years ago.
There is a picture of the cabinet (and some other recent stuff) on my "Member Gallery" here at WoodCentral, see the link below. You can also see images of my work on my website.
Narrow chisels are too rough on the water stone so I either use a Carborundum stone or start with the Washita stone. My soft Arkansas is quite smooth so I often skip the Black stone.
I don't use hollow grinds, grinding wheels, sandpaper or belts, secondary bevels, micro bevels, back bevels, high angles, stropping compounds, or jigs.
One of the things that governed woodwork over the years was the quality of wood, or in some cases the qualities of wood. Meaning tools improved as wood quality got worse, or at times access opened up to wood that had not been available, like tropicals, or technology allowed certain veneers. But in the main there was a linear procession. That is no longer true. The small number of people seriously working wood today, or maybe the prices they are willing to pay, guarantee that you can pretty much get any wood you want. So today I can routinely get wood that Tores could only have dreamed of, and so do I need his 19th century kludge to deal with declining wood quality.? I can have both, so yes to both. But all I am saying is the progression you note is not something we really live with. When the Japanese abandoned the chisel plane for the block style plane they were not able to count on buying all the port orford cedar in Oregon.