We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
The response I got was maybe about three words longer than that.
Based on the gizmo's page where he more or less gushes about various very complicated sharpening devices, I don't think he does much other than test irons or maybe use a smoother once in a while, either.
The time spent on some of the jigs could easily turn someone into a competent freehand sharpener, and they'd be able to sharpen skew irons and gouges, etc, at the same time.
I made the same transit (as an amatuer) away from devices as most other people do, there are just too many things to sharpen where devices just frustrate the user.
It's strange to me (as an amateur) to see people speak with such authority when they're not using tools in a productive context.
Novaculite. India stones don't cut like novaculite stones (arkansas, charnley, etc), it's a completely different feel on the stones and the resulting edge.
An india edge is much like most synthetic stones - toothy and the strop improves it some, but not like a natural stone.
Novaculite stones put a less brash edge on a stone and the wire edge fans out or forms without being broken as easily. It's long and thin rather than fragmented, more or less. When the edge is stropped, there is a gigantic gain in sharpness (presumably because the fine but wide wire edge is sitting atop a fairly thin and not toothy edge).
I am delighted to see that FWW article again, a huge thank you to Bob Lang.
It is odd to reread something written in 1988! There is little that I would change today, though the process may be better appreciated in the DVD. Incidentally the first that L-N made.
Technically the ruler trick polished area is a back bevel. But since it is approximately 2/3rds of one degree, this is hardly relevant. It is an aid to ensure proper honing away of the wire edge. This happens virtually every time and no stropping is required. (It generally floats away on the polishing stone, sponge cloth or drying towel. Failure to float away means something has gone wrong.)
Real back bevels are a totally different kettle of fish. They used to be used by skilled machinists on the planing machines, when dealing with difficult interlocked grain tropical hardwoods.
Japan Woodworker used to sell an excellent pamphlet by Luthier, Brian Burns.
I have used a small 15 degree backbevel on a regular bench plane blade, to plane difficult domestic species like ripple ash.
At the extreme, I have used a 25 degree back bevel to plane impossible dense exotics like quartered satinwood, Partridge wood, old growth Tasmanian Blackwood and some Dalbergias, many of the beautiful desert timbers from Australia. These are usually for small details, such as handles or cockbead, so the slightly increased effort of pushing the plane is of no consequence whatsoever.
Incidentally the back bevel fool the timber into thinking you have a higher pitched plane. I choose to call this effective pitch, 60 and 70 degrees respectively.
So to sum up, the ruler trick assists effective and repeatable sharpening.
Back bevels are very useful indeed, they are an alternative to chipbreaker use and have been used for over 100 years.
David has chimed in with his knowledge, so I won't say too much, except to observe that the "Ruler Technique" is probably most useful where the back of the blade is not completely flat -- rather than as being a compensation for out of flat sharpening media.
Also, my observation, especially with water stones, is that the suction between the stone and the back of a blade (stiction?) can be so great that pushing the blade across the sharpening media becomes very difficult, to nearly impossible.
I can readily imagine many beginners lifting the outboard end of the blade to make life easier and thereby creating the varieties of back bevel that Bill observed.
Question? With what ever others sharpen with, do your wire edges not get thinner and thinner and eventually float away on the finest grit used?
That is my observation as well. The wire edge mostly floats away as the media gets finer. Many of my plane blades are A2.
What I think happens is that as the scratch pattern gets finer with the higher grits, the wire edge is effectively ground off through removal of the metal holding it onto the blade.
As David suggested I was thinking about a novaculite stone. However with a fine India stone the same phenomenon applies as with the finer stones: the burr will not get beat up by the sharpening media but will continue to lengthen as the sharpening continues. What one gets is a true continuous wire, not a mishmash of fractured bits.
(in regard to the ruler trick, it was of great aid to me as a beginner, and I'm sure some prefer it indefinitely. A lot of my old tools show evidence of a "lift", though none done precisely, the lift evidence is certainly intentional).
At one micron the wire edge formed at coarser grit floats away more or less in one piece. It appears to get thinner until it breaks off. At what point it floats away depends on the steel.
My apology for correcting you here. I had not read that article, only the FWW one, as well as his posts on Old Tools over the years.
All I can say is Good Grief! He may get a sharp edge, but this must take forever, and I certainly lack the patience for his meticulous method. Happily, I appear to get edges sharp enough with my obviously (for Brent) casual and rule-breaking efforts.
Not that it matters, or has any practical application, but I think the wire edge does get thinner, at least at the point of fracture, else why would it break off? It never comes off on my coarse stone (which is a fine India), only on the hard black.
Side note: years ago, when I worked in a machine shop, I used to sharpen wood chipper blades on the surface grinder. In that circumstance I observed what Warren has talked about, the wire edge growing to ridiculous proportions. I have seen wire edges 1/8" long; you don't want to get your fingers near them.
The puzzling thing is that surface grinder wheels are more like water stones than oil stones: they are extremely friable, and there is a continuous bath of water and slurry. So I'm not sure exactly how sharpening media influences the presence or absence of burr. It's not simple (but what is?)
"I'm pretty sure that the primary reason the double iron plane took over was economic. You can work faster with it, there's no way around that - faster enough that you can easily justify the cost of making additional metal parts."
Maybe in the US, my parents never shop in discount stores, as though it was taking formula from a fly covered baby. The idea that everything is economic, not so sure. In any case it comes down to why something might be economic. If the wood you are planing either can't be effectively planed even with a breaker, or is being planed to a fineness where the shaving is diaphenous, or the wood is easily planed with a Yahri kanna, there is no economic advantage, even in finish planing, to a double bit. And then there is the universe of non-finish planing.
+1 to what Derek said. My first though regarding BT's report was ruler trick, but the terminology is more appropriate to primary planing angle changes. We don't need even more confusion. The RT is hardly a new idea in the sense that many people have done it, but the ruler itself makes it predictable.
"I have seen the recommendation for two sided bevels you're referring, to. They are a good starter on a straight plane iron for someone who just can't get the subtleties of sharpening, otherwise."
I know what you are saying and agree, but the basic issue is to get people planing right out of the gate so they can see how powerful it is, and even with planes that come precision machined and sharpened, there are quite a few ways to fail at that. In the knife biz, people send their knives to the factory for sharpening, if you can believe it. So when it come time to sharpen, and maybe they have waited too long, anything that gets them in the game is worth it. They aren't anywhere near the point where encountering subtleties is on their mind. What makes people like us is our natural reaction to complexity, or elaboration is "great!".
"The aim of the wedge is to penetrate down and forward simultaneously. In other words, a back bevel will reduce this effect."
Derek, not sure that is the purpose the wedge, it is what it does. In some cases great, in others not so great (mortising vs DT for instance). Apart from the fact that there are double bevel chisels, a closer reading of Japanese chisels and the handle angle shows that they are mild double bevels, and if you hit with the handle angle, you will reduce the undesirable effects of what the wedge does.
Back bevel sharpening method is almost exactly the same as regular sharpening.
The usual bevel is honed till a small wire edge is produced on the back bevel slope. This is felt or seen as usual.
A minimal honing of the back bevel is done till a wire edge is detected on the opposite bevel.
A few polishing strokes and then turn over to polish the regular bevel.
This work has one more step than my usual sharpening, but is not difficult at all.
It is worth pointing out that a back bevel does not need to be wide. Think of the thickness of shaving, maybe around 0.004 " max. Technically the back bevel would not need to be more than 0.008" wide. In reality it may be more like 1/32" but does not need to be wide.
I find the three blades supplied with bevel up planes to be absurd. They could all be ground at 25 degrees as usual, with tiny honed bevels at the three different angles. There is absolutely no need for three different grind angles.
Ruler technique is not a manufacturers conspiracy. When done correctly it is a useful and beneficial means of sharpening. Quick and reliable. It is recognized and used by Rob Cosman, Chris Schwarz, Tom Fidgen and many others. I don't think they are all deluded!
Traditionally minded folk are generally the ones who don't like it! And that is fine.
As you know around here the close set breaker is god to some. and 1/32 inch is not going to make them happy. I wouldn't suggest those names are shilling, but the money is in getting the newbies to buy all new gear, and anything that makes them successful will help with that. Win win. Years down the road they may be doing different things if they are still around.
Reading your article that explains the why's and hows's made it clear that using a ruler or something similar to put a tiny, and shallow, back bevel on the blade can be useful.
The "problem" that showed up in my shop in the form of "excessive ruler trickery" may have been caused by persons not having understood the theory. It is all too easy for a novice to discover that grinding on the back of the chisel or plane blade seems to be a quick way to get a sharp edge when patience at grinding away at the primary bevel ran out. It is further easy for this novice to think they are using the ruler procedure when they have obtained a third hand description of it off the Internet.
I have a knife grinder installed as part of my industrial sized surface planer. The knives are dry ground with a friable pink rock and the result is a wire edge that is not hard to see and risky to feel. The directions call for removing it by pulling a piece of aluminum across the knife tips. The steel is highly abrasion resistant M42.
I know that steel toughness plays a role. CPM 3V is exceptionally tough and it makes sturdy wire edges(great for lathe scrapers). The wire edge is difficult to get rid of on a chisel and can lead to a false sense that edge isn't getting sharp. However, by making it ever thinner on 1 micron diamond it eventually gets so thin that it breaks off. At this point it is so thin that it floats away on the lubricant. A few strokes on leather removes it but here I think the leather, which deforms some, is putting more force on it at a more favorable angle for breaking it off.
Fortunately by the time I discovered this procedure on the Internet I had learned to successfully sharpen to meet my needs and was not tempted by the Siren's call.
What I saw in my shop visitors was that they had spent too much time at the computer "learning" and not enough time in the shop "doing" to be able to judge advice relevant to their needs.
Maybe the best way to learn woodworking is to be challenging one's learning by putting it to use making. At least this plan identifies good enough.
So Cosman, Schwarz, and Fidgen use the ruler trick. What do these guys have in common? They all teach beginner's woodworking. And they are not teaching teenagers who are planning to become woodworkers so much as older guys who have sat in cubicles for maybe decades. I think this colors their choice of techniques. If a guy is frustrated with trying to learn sharpening from a video, he is not going to come back and buy the next video on mortising. So any sophisticated technique requiring skill and devotion is banished from this world, no matter how effective it is in the long run.
When we teach children music or sports or mathematics our approach is different depending on whether we are catering to the ones who will someday be elite or we are trying to ensure that the least kid is involved and interested, not frustrated.
I think the ruler trick is fine for beginners who are going to be frustrated getting a plane iron working. Or for collectors who are constantly buying new planes. For the guy who is going to use the same plane iron every day until its length is used up, I am a little skeptical that it saves time.
The guy who got me into woodworking, and who is more than 20 years older than me is almost 100% power tools.
First strike against him is he's an engineer (which isn't a sentence in itself, but it increases the odds that someone sees woodworking as best done with people removed, and with overanalysis on a technical/specificiations basis of every aspect of work and tool care).
The thing that he says that fits exactly into your description is always:
*I don't have time to learn to do that, I'll be dead before I master it
Of course, that's not true, but that's what people think. That they need to be placed somewhere further up on the curve with a bag of tricks to start. What they don't understand is that the rudimentary hand-eye work and the repetition is what gives you the tools to keep progressing on the curve. It also makes woodworking interesting, stimulating to the brain, and physically satisfying.
Pay sharpening is common in the razor community, too. It's not unusual for someone to shave with a razor for a month or two and then pay someone $20 plus shipping two ways to touch up their razor.
It baffles me, but if we were coming from a reference point where sharpening was a completely new concept entirely, maybe that's why they operate like the folks paying to ship to have their knives sharpened.
I saw a video on youtube (and made the mistake of commenting) that someone described a loaded wheel on a grinder as the absolute worst thing to sharpen knives, and that they wouldn't touch the knife being touched up with anything other than ______ (i can't remember the name, but it's some expensive gadget that holds the knife up and the stones are restricted so that you can only move them back and forth and up and down a rod).