New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

back beveled plane blades?

Posts

back beveled plane blades?

#1

back beveled plane blades?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The club had a shop tour at my shop yesterday featuring a discussion of the bed side chest of drawers I am building. Participants were invited to bring a plane if they had questions. To my surprise most planes showed up with their blades back beveled. Their owners had learned of this technique on the Internet or at a Woodcraft class.

I don't know anything about back beveling so I never use it. Some of the blades that showed up had a lot of back bevel, a bevel readily seen without aid of a 10X lens, and more of less steep. And some had secondary front bevels.

I showed some of the visitors how to hollow grind and they were enthusiastic about this aid. I had no idea how to deal with the back bevels so I just left them as they turned out after sharpening the front bevel.

What is the consensus about these extra bevels? Are they something a learning woodworker should be using or relying on?

It seemed a great help to the new to planing participants to experience what sharp felt like and what a sharp adjusted plane felt like.

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#2

Re: back beveled plane blades?

Chuck Bjorgen

At the last Lie-Nielsen hand tool event in Minneapolis, October, 2014, the LN techs seemed to be promoting the back bevel and I could definitely see it on company cutters on hand. Rob Cosman also promotes it on his sharpening videos. I tried it on one or two blades but never felt I got any advantage. My standard approach is to restore vintage blades on my Tormek for the hollow grind and freehand finish with a secondary bevel on any variety of stones that I might grab. I have purchased a few Hock irons and just finish hone those with a secondary bevel. They'll get the hollow grind eventually.

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#3

Are purveyors of planes promoting.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

...the back bevel because it is a quick way to ensure the beginner gets a sharp edge, and hence is satisfied with the plane? If done to excess it sure screws up setting the cap iron close. In a beginners hands it seems something that would be easy to conclude "if a little is good more must be better".

I don't know how to sharpen with a back bevel. When edge becomes dull, is front bevel sharpened until the back bevel goes away? If not, how does one know when to stop on the front bevel and how much to add to the back bevel? It seems to add more decisions to be made and that is not what a beginner needs, or me either.

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#4

Re: Are purveyors of planes promoting.....

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Is a back bevel just a more pronounced version of David Charlesworth's ruler trick?

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#5

Re: Method taught to beginners...

david weaver

Lie Nielsen and anyone related to selling their items or giving advice is going to be inundated with beginners. I get the sense that their thought is that beginners don't have the sense to use their senses, and thus everything is a jigged up method that in their (LN and others) eyes has no risk and that relies on some sort of setup instead of hand eye coordination.

I used to use the ruler trick, and it does work, but if you are not a neatnik, sooner or later you are going to misplace your favorite rule. That's what got me to quit doing it - fiddling around losing the rule in my mess. Admittedly, I'm messy.

It would be much more useful to teach the idea of bias to beginners - to bias their pressure where they want to abrade metal. I do use a secondary bevel of sorts on the bevel side of my tools, but I grind at around 25 degrees and just naturally hone where I've come to expect steel will hold up without chipping out.

Lie Nielsen advocates smoothing with a metal #8, also, and avoiding dry grinders. They make lovely planes. After that, I regard most of their advice as get you started advice, which is often vastly different than best thing in the long run.

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#6

Re: back beveled plane blades?

Denny

I could be totally off base here, but I seem to remember reading in Garrett Hack's book that a back bevel on a bevel-down plane was a way to essentially increase the angle of the plane blade when dealing with difficult wood grain.

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#7

Re: back beveled plane blades?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi all,

Teachings vary. However, no one I've read recommends a longish back bevel--the ones who do recommend it envision one so slight that it comes off with the next sharpening. Mr. Charlesworth's thin ruler method has been mentioned; fellow named Brent Beach has for years recommended a series of 3 or 4 back bevels, adding to a few degrees in total. I personally prefer David Weaver's biasing method, including on Japanese plane blades where you don't want to lap out the slight spring of the blade back (which figures in the way the blade is sprung in cutting position).

I once was urged by a highly knowledgeable hand tools person, who had done Japanese carpentry professionally for a while, that a slight back bevel, no more than 5 degrees and shallow, on a mortising chisel had a wonderful effect. I have never tried this, but mention it to indicate the range of informed opinion there is on the subject.

The Japanese pro's are death on anything other than a flat bevel front and rear, and will form an opinion of one's ability by examining your blade for flatness.

Wiley

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#8

Re: back beveled plane blades?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

That was what I had heard, too; but with the research that Bill Tindall has brought forward, confirming long understood trade knowledge, about the use of the chipbreaker, I wonder how necessary it is.

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#9

Re: back beveled plane blade

Brian Holcombe

I've yet to try the back bevel on the mortise chisel, but I have heard the same thing w.r.t. Japanese mortise chisels.

It's tempting, as mine can get slightly crumbly at the extreme edge after use in hardwoods.

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#10

Corrections and elaboration

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Teachings vary. However, no one I've read recommends a longish back bevel--the ones who do recommend it envision one so slight that it comes off with the next sharpening. Mr. Charlesworth's thin ruler method has been mentioned; fellow named Brent Beach has for years recommended a series of 3 or 4 back bevels, adding to a few degrees in total.

Hi Wiley

There is some confusion here, which I will correct.

Firstly, the use of "back bevel" (as used by others in this thread) may be accurate but is misleading when discussing David Charlesworth's "Ruler Trick" (or I think it is now referred to as "Ruler Technique"). A back bevel is used to significantly increase the cutting angle, and generally starts at 5 degrees and may go up to 25 (or more) degrees. For example, a common angle frog + 15 degree backbevel = 60 degree cutting angle. This has been a long standing technique for reducing tearout - possibly a few centuries.

The Ruler Trick creates a backbevel of approximately 2/3 degree. It is used to ensure that the bevel face meets the bevel back cleanly. I believe that it started as a remedy for pitted blades, but it became a tuning tip for sharpening generally. It certainly benefits beginners, who find it difficult to hone the rear of the blade, such as failing to judge that there is a wear bevel. It also can benefit some bevel up plane blades, since the wear bevel occurs in this region. This is an easy way to avoid its incursion.

There are two ways to do the RT. The way that David Charlesworth recommends is a front-and-back motion. This would create a long (but low) bevel. The other way it is done, and the way I would do it (and I gather from David that Rob Cosman does it this way as well), is a side-to-side motion along the steel rule. This creates a smaller, more localised back bevel.

I tend not to use a RT, but have done so in the past, and it is an effective way of both sharpening or even giving the plane's blade edge a second lease on life.

Now to Brent Beach. Brent does not advocate 3 or 4 back bevel in series. He advocates 3 or 4 secondary bevels (on the bevel face) using a honing guide and a series of setting blocks. I recall he presented this method in a FWW article some years ago (... very different from my preference to hollow grind and freehand on the hollow).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#11

Re: back beveled plane blade

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Backbevelling a mortice chisel - or any chisel for that matter - will change the directional action of the wedge. To take that to an extreme, one could create a perfect V (ground at an equal angle on each side). It would penetrate vertically. But do we want that? The aim of the wedge is to penetrate down and forward simultaneously. In other words, a back bevel will reduce this effect.

What advantage is there in the back bevel to which you refer?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#12

Re: back beveled plane blades?

david weaver

That's definitely true, but a little bit different than the slight angle LN and others suggest for the ruler trick.

Charlesworth's video, notwithstanding where he discusses back beveling to a very high angle.

There was an old piece of literature that I found several years ago when I thought a back bevel was better than chipbreaker use, but I don't know if I could find it now. It suggested a very heavy iron with a very steep angle as a means to work wood that is too difficult for a double iron plane.

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#13

Re: back beveled plane blades? *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I agree there is a difference between a slight bevel to aid sharpening and a more pronounced bevel to alter plane performance. The irons Bill saw could be ruler bevels or high angle bevels, or just sloppy workmanship, or a combination.

Here is a reference to the 1820's back bevel you are remembering. The inventor, a printer, seemed to be unable to use the double iron, but more interestingly was seemingly unaware in 1828 that there had ever been high angle bench planes. And the people who decorated him were unaware that high angle planing was not a novel idea.


Double bevel iron

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#14

Re: back beveled plane blades?

david weaver

Looking back now, that's such a strange thing to have been "invented" at that time (and believed to be invented).

I'm pretty sure that the primary reason the double iron plane took over was economic. You can work faster with it, there's no way around that - faster enough that you can easily justify the cost of making additional metal parts.

I thought a couple of years ago that what the guy was proposing was a decent alternative, but having mostly discarded power tool use, it would just be a large step back.

There are a lot of "societies" and professional recognition orgs now that exist to promote themselves, which leads to some easily verified things getting through (sort of how newspapers publish articles on technical subject without seeking an expert to review them). I guess that publication verifies that such things aren't new - maybe the Royal Society didn't care, as long as they had someone to award and something to print.

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#15

Power of the Press, Personalities & Promotion *LINK*

Bob Lang

The first time I heard of this was from Charlesworth's article in the November 2004 issue of Popular Woodworking. The article is online at the link below. Since then it has been repeated and promoted quite a bit as others have mentioned.

Bob Lang


Pop Wood Article

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#16

That was enlightening

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

From the plane blades that showed up at my shop I suspect the "world" has drifted well away from the original purpose and procedure.

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#17

blade backs and wire edges

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The behavior of the wire edge depends on the properties of the steel. This fact is particularly evident if you are sharpening CPM 3V where the wire edge has exceptional tenacity. Hence, I don't know how my experience relates to others using other steel.

If I understood the Charlesworth article correctly, the back beveling ruler procedure is used to remove the wire edge and it compensates for any lack of flatness of the sharpening media. My final sharpening is with 1 micron diamond on cast iron. With my steels and this media the wire edge gets thinner and thinner and eventually I see its remains float away in the lubricant. I don't need to mess with the back of the blade to remove it.

Once flat, I don't do much messing with the back of the blade. I definitely don't expose the back of the blade to any abrasive format that is not flat. It would seem that any effort to cause the back to be not flat would tend to accumulate over time, especially in inexperienced hands. Eventually a tiny back bevel could become what I saw on the novice plane blades.

Question? With what ever others sharpen with, do your wire edges not get thinner and thinner and eventually float away on the finest grit used?

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#18

Re: Corrections and elaboration

Steve Voigt

Derek, nice summary of the difference between RT and back bevel.

The FWW crowd, especially Michael Pekovitch, has been promoting the combo of high angle frog and back bevel. Pekovitch uses an LN 4 1/2 with a 55° frog and a 10° back bevel, for an effective cutting angle of 65°.

I don't doubt that this does a good job of defeating tearout. It also sounds like sheer torture to me, pushing a 5 1/2 lb. smoother with a 2 3/8" blade at that angle. I always assumed that Larry and Don (very sensibly) used narrower blades to compensate for the additional resistance of a higher pitch. But each to his own, I guess.

Anyhow, I suspect the reach of FWW, in circulation #'s, is greater than forums and most other media, so that's probably why back bevels and HAFs are all the rage now.

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#19

Re: Corrections and elaboration

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Steve

I agree, pushing a #4 1/2 with a 65 degrees cutting angle would be hard. Even when the sole is waxed (which does make a significant difference).

I just could not get along with high angles in BD planes. They are considerably more effort to push than the equivalent BU plane. The exception is a low slung HNT Gordon plane. Even so, thinner shavings are still the order of the day.

The chipbreaker has allowed for lower cutting angles, which translates to less effort.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#20

Brent Beach reference

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Derek,

This isn't a big issue with me; I was just covering part of the waterfront of back bevels.

However, I do think I'm right as to Brent Beach. I read him to recommend 3 microlevels on front and 3 on back:

http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/bevels.html

Wiley

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#21

Re: Brent Beach reference

david weaver

I attempted to inform Brent on two things:

* stropping (which degrades the edge the way he describes, but does not when it is done properly)

* the use of the cap iron to mitigate tearout

I don't think he was convinced of much either way (stropping is most easily understood when it's used with something where you can tell what works or doesn't work - straight razors).

I have seen the recommendation for two sided bevels you're referring, to. They are a good starter on a straight plane iron for someone who just can't get the subtleties of sharpening, otherwise.

Other parts of brent's research are really illuminating, though - maybe not in the way he intended. His plane iron test results show why someone using a double iron (or a japanese plane) will prefer a fine grained carbon steel. You can get a good surface with whatever is being used all the way until clearance runs out.

The edge pictures of the eskilstuna and tsunesaburo irons compared to the more highly alloyed edges are very instructive.

(some of that is tangent...apologies for that!!)

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#22

Re: A good test for the wire edge..

david weaver

..keeping in mind that I learned to sharpen from David's dvd and used the ruler trick before moving away from it.

The washita....it's not fine enough for a wire edge to just float away if using it briskly.

What I do with it (and what is referenced historically) is to work the iron back and forth lightly (and not for very long), until the wire edge is very weak and departs from the edge, or will be removed and corrected completely by bare leather.

Steel that is not plain carbon steel can follow the same process (even on a washita), and easily get hair shaving sharp, but attention to thinning the wire edge has to be paid a little bit more.

I think most of the discussion about highly alloyed steel not getting sharp enough has to do with not completely removing the wire edge (and without causing damage).

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#23

Re: blade backs and wire edges

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The wire edge does not disintegrate on fine oil stones. It continues to grow in length as you sharpen. Diamonds are abusive to the burr.

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#24

Re: Brent Beach reference

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Brent Beach wrote me an email in 2007 asking that I detail my sharpening process. I wrote sixty lines of text in response. The guy did not even thank me. He said no one he knew would sharpen like that. And "my experience with honing certainly does not reflect yours."

I could be wrong, but I don't think he really does any real life woodworking.

Re: back beveled plane blades?

#25

what is considered a "fine oil stone"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Years ago what I had for sharpening was a coarse/fine India. I think it is aluminum oxide in a hard binder. So in my limited universe a "fine" oil stone was a fine India. I still like it for knives. But I am supposing the" fine" you are referring to is something else, or not?