Re: Well said and accurate on all counts....
Brian Holcombe
Makes sense in many cases as the customers are also typically demanding consistency. They want to be able to look at a swatch and pick a 'color'. I don't necessarily always care for everything to be the same, but in many instances it makes sense, I wouldn't want kitchen cabinets will mismatched grain, but I also have the luxury of being able to chose lumber specifically geared toward something like that. Where manufactures really don't have that luxury.
I've seen a couple of furniture manufacturers that will not only mention variegation in walnut, but actually present it as a quality inherent in the wood, and the implication in my mind is that it's something that customers should be paying more for. I think this is due to years and years of the Studio Furniture crowd pushing this idea of exciting wood grain. I have two pieces of US manufactured furniture with sapwood that are not dyed.
I think this can be a weird interpretation, as I don't necessarily think that exciting grain is an improvement, unless it's a piece which specifically calls for it.
I had a feeling it would be a matter of time, top quality walnut is particularly tough to source in my area, and so the sales pitch is now for walnut with variegation. Oddly enough the last time I purchased walnut I was able to buy shorts (5ft), that were wide and had very nice straight grain, at a discount to the usual stuff.
As an aside, The experience I have with Danish manufacturers is that they have very high standards on lumber and are still using top quality and very tightly and straight grained walnut, but the premium they add onto a walnut product suggests they're paying quite a high rate for material of that quality. I think they simply apply their same value scale to walnut that they would apply to oak, ash and beech. Works for me, as I enjoy straight grained wood for that purpose.