New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

Posts

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#51

Re: steaming and air drying

AlanWS

I think it was Larry Williams who once explained that an advantage of beech for planes was the rays (parenchyma?) that allow moisture to get in and out perpendicular to the grain. This means that as humidity changes with the season, it takes less time for the wood to equilibrate, so there is less seasonal distortion caused by unequal swelling and shrinking of various parts.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#52

Rays

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Beech is not the only wood with rays. Oak has rays, osage orange has rays, basswood has rays, and on and on. That does not make them good for planes.

Beech is especially disposed to end checking, which is good evidence that most moisture travels longitudinally and exits from the end grain.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#53

Re: Try it yourself - in ther real world

david weaver

Lighten up.

Tom summed up my opinion pretty well, with clarity on the displaying being something you're not.

Otherwise, you're taking my opinions way too seriously.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#54

Re: Rays

david weaver

Ditto that, it travels from end to end.

To find out how fast liquids travel through beech, one only has to plug the mouth of a plane and put a slow drying oil in it. The oil will make it to the end grain on a long plane overnight. It will only come out of the side of the plane or the bottom at any distance from the mortise if the wood straws actually terminate in the side or bottom. if they are straight end to end, it will come out of the ends without coming out of the sides.

I got some green beech yesterday, put it in my basement last night. It came out of the box, not soaking wet - I intended to put latex paint on the end of the billets this weekend, at least one of them, but both were badly end checked this morning in a basement where the temperature is 59 degrees. The checks probably go about an inch deep - just from overnight.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#55

those second rate products...

John in NM

Funny what a difference perspective makes. I would characterize the small mill air dried stuff as "no grade" and far more likely to be inconsistent than large mill stuff.

The point of steaming and kiln drying is to improve consistency - the reasonable expectation that your next board will behave like the last one. In that context, I wouldn't say they are producing second rate at all, they are producing first rate for their big buyers - buyers that expect reasonable consistency across the thousands of board feet their factory will use in a year.

I think if you threw a couple units of walnut, air dried, and from random barnyards and backyards in with a factory's supply stream of kiln dried, steamed, forest grown wood, you would find that they would go to a different yard next time.

Us small users tend to have distinct and furiously defended preferences - that large mills do not tailor their production to suit the small user's preferences is simply the way of the world. I'm just glad I can buy any common hardwood I want in Albuquerque for less than $10 per board foot. If it weren't for the industrial suppliers I would be lucky to get anything at all for $30+

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#56

Well said and accurate on all counts....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

according to my experience. You would have had to not believe, or not read, anything I said on the topic to not agree.

I was throwing out old records last night. They burn well. I got into purchase invoices for the 1980's. We were buying about 2000 bdft of walnut a year. I was planing all of it for resale, milling some for this and that parts, and turning some into furniture. It is a material I am familiar with.

Occasionally we bought logs when they were special and this lumber often got air dried when a reliable kiln wasn't available. Personally, the differences in lumber from different logs was noticeable to me. I have seen walnut harder than the hubs of hell as well as lumber softer than poplar. Differences between KD, steamed and KD and air dried were not noticeable to me, expect sap color.

These differences persist among all the wood we processed. We bought lumber sourced from Alabama (worst oak we ever got, to New York and MN (lovely cherry). Conclusions derived from working a few boards of some species may not be representative of the species in general, or wood from a different tree, or different part of the country.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#57

Re: Well said and accurate on all counts....

david weaver

I can understand why commercial buyers would want material as uniformly made as possible, even if it doesn't have attributes that we'd want (the few of us) with very specific desires.

When I worked at aristokraft (I'm sure I've said this before), the primary reason we got cabinets back (aside from things like towmotor forks through the sides) was color matching. Uniformity is important at the commercial level. they used a lot of 4/4 lumber in those cabinets, and I doubt they would've cared too much about the width of boards, etc, unless it was a cost reason (not aesthetic).

If I was running a commercial operation, i'd want the same thing - uniform and predictable.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#58

Re: Well said and accurate on all counts....

Brian Holcombe

Makes sense in many cases as the customers are also typically demanding consistency. They want to be able to look at a swatch and pick a 'color'. I don't necessarily always care for everything to be the same, but in many instances it makes sense, I wouldn't want kitchen cabinets will mismatched grain, but I also have the luxury of being able to chose lumber specifically geared toward something like that. Where manufactures really don't have that luxury.

I've seen a couple of furniture manufacturers that will not only mention variegation in walnut, but actually present it as a quality inherent in the wood, and the implication in my mind is that it's something that customers should be paying more for. I think this is due to years and years of the Studio Furniture crowd pushing this idea of exciting wood grain. I have two pieces of US manufactured furniture with sapwood that are not dyed.

I think this can be a weird interpretation, as I don't necessarily think that exciting grain is an improvement, unless it's a piece which specifically calls for it.

I had a feeling it would be a matter of time, top quality walnut is particularly tough to source in my area, and so the sales pitch is now for walnut with variegation. Oddly enough the last time I purchased walnut I was able to buy shorts (5ft), that were wide and had very nice straight grain, at a discount to the usual stuff.

As an aside, The experience I have with Danish manufacturers is that they have very high standards on lumber and are still using top quality and very tightly and straight grained walnut, but the premium they add onto a walnut product suggests they're paying quite a high rate for material of that quality. I think they simply apply their same value scale to walnut that they would apply to oak, ash and beech. Works for me, as I enjoy straight grained wood for that purpose.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#59

It's all made uniform in the finishing room

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There can be numerous steps in the finishing room that occur before the top coats are applied. Shading lacquers, NGR dye stain, glaze, etc. are applied to uniform the color and add highlights as needed. A good finisher can make something that looks like a silk purse from a sows ear.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#60

Re: It's all made uniform in the finishing room

david weaver

Agree on this for color. Also, it's no secret that the center panels on a lot of raised panel stuff have been something other than solid wood quite often, and the quality of the faux center panels is really good from an aesthetic point of view.

Good color work before applying lacquer can make a lot of poorly matched wood look excellent.

At the time I was working at aristokraft, I couldn't tell which doors had real center panels and which didn't (the raised panel doors, not the flat panel). I don't know if I'd be able to do it now, either.

Finish quality was always good, done on mid level cabinets there, sort of goes along with the color thing. If the color is good and the finish work is smooth, the public isn't going to care whether or not the center panel is real or not, or if it is, if it's five narrow boards put together or two.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#61

Re: Well said and accurate on all counts....

TomD

I think you are right Brian that variegation is not always so wonderful. I think it works out well on guitars, that kind of thing which is not in a wall of paneling and where the left right balance can benefit from clear display, that colors can highlight. In many cases too much interest destroys the design elements. If Nakashima chair sled feet were too often piebald, we might not remember what they looked like, it is a sort of dazzle camouflage.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#62

Re: Well said and accurate on all counts....

Brian Holcombe

That has been my experience as well, sometimes I've had to tone down my aspirations with exciting wood grain. For instance, I did a series of panels for my kitchen bar, originally planning them in walnut burl, which in a vacuum looks great. In reality it looked to be in competition with the remainder of the room. I put the burl aside and chose a plain sawn material with a slight curl to it and believe it to be a better choice.