New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

Posts

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#26

Re: Baloney

TomD

That doesn't look like black walnut, though of course I take your word for it. But it seems like an irrelevant sample, the contrast that steaming eliminates is the sapwood, that most factory types do not want, while other makers emphasize it, and prefer it. There is a point to the idea that all wood is black in the end. As Keynes said: "in the long run we are all dead". And mostly we are all dead before that change ever occurs.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#27

Re: steaming and air drying

TomD

Beech is the fastest drying wood of a similar density I have ever seen. My shop is mostly unheated, and a 5 inch thick 7 foot long bench top stopped loosing weight within a year. I could hardly believe it. I didn't test the moisture level, but it was basically dry. Ostensibly this is part of the reason that it is used in planes, it dries so well that it stays straight.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#28

Re: Try it yourself - in ther real world

TomD

"All commercially sourced veneer is steamed. I don't hear furniture builders disparaging veneer color."

As you know steaming is a part of peeling, so they don't really get a choice unless they saw it themselves. In the real world, American black walnut is not a high end wood. So nobody really cares what you do with it. Nobody is paying a 1-2K for a back and sides set. A few guys like Nakashima, and Malloof spun gold out of it.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#29

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

TomD

Is 100 hours of steaming typical, that sounds very expensive.

Reduction in tensile strength is certainly a concern to me, not in some furniture, but in chairs and technical gear it would be.

I have heard it claimed that steaming/kiln drying makes it impossible to bend would by normal means. I don't really believe it, but the source, Michael Fortune is right at the top of the list.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#30

Re: the walnut steaming

TomD

Steve, it is the fastest drying heavy wood I have ever handled. I found as long as the blanks seemed clammy, even when I though they were well on their way, they might crack if exposed to the sun. On one occasion I moved a plank I had in the shop. I think it was about 10/4, into light sunlight to get at something else. I didn't immediately put it back in the shade, and it cracked. I have dried a lot of wood, and it surprised me is all I can say. But I got a very good yield overall. None of mine was stored out of doors, though in good conditions it probably wouldn't mater. Stacked and stickered with something on top, I think I would have lost a lot of it. I only did the one batch.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#31

Re: What Curtis actually said *LINK*

JDK

At about the 14 minute mark you'll see Curtis explain that his legs are turned green and he explains how he dries the top portion of the leg in his home-made kiln.


Buchanan Turning Chair Legs

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#32

It looks exactly like black walnut....

John in NM

After significant sun exposure - seen it over and over myself :D

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#33

Re: Try it yourself

John in NM

I much prefer the color of air dried walnut myself. Much as I wish that color were permanent, it simply is not.

My impression is that those woodworkers who wax rhapsodic about that color are deluding themselves unless the wood is largely kept from UV exposure. If they are saying that their enjoyment of that color is significant enough to warrant exclusive use of air dried wood in spite of the fleeting nature of the color, that I could relate to :D

One gorgeous piece of walnut I used for a table smelled like a barnyard when milled :D I suspect that some of the beauty of small mill woods is likely in their diverse growth environments as much as the drying regimen.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#34

Steaming times and other trivia

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

All that is necessary to color the sapwood of walnut is to get the wood up to around 100 C in a wet environment and it turns.

What I quoted were parts of the abstract of the paper in the wood research journal. Other times were investigated and the same trends were observed.

Actual times in a steamer vary. I consulted some for a local steamer and they steamed for about 4 days, about 35,000 bdft of walnut per charge. They steamed approximately 1000 bdft "shipping packs" (bundles) of dead packed lumber separated by 4 x 4's. It took about 4 days to get the heat into the center of all the packs. So the outside boards were at temperature the whole time and the interior boards weren't. Occasionally they had complaints of insufficient steaming.

The furniture factory we bought lumber from steamed about 1000 bdft at a time dead packed with steam from the KD drying operations. They steamed about a week. They steamed because the wood worked better after steaming, as well as color development in the sap wood.

I am sure other operations steam more or less depending on their equipment and cost of steam. The steam can be almost fee if the operation is burning wood waste. The rest is passive- no fans etc. The main cost is that the operation is wickedly corrosive and the parts of the steamer made of steel will dissolve. The doors on the steamer near me dissolved away in less than a year and they were replaced with aluminum at considerable cost. The steel banding containing the bundles will be disintegrated at the end of the steaming cycle.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#35

Re: Baloney

david weaver

I agree with John, I thought the lumber was newer, but some of the old unstained pieces around here get pretty light.

At one point, walnut was a very desirable wood here, but most of the stuff that my parents have has been stained, so it stays dark.

I guess it's still desirable to some, even though it's not garnered much regard elsewhere (aside from turkish walnut in gun stocks, etc), it still costs a lot to get here if you want large clear or figured boards.

No clue what the studio scene thinks, but walnut is a common wood in stuff that looks like it was made around turn of last century.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#36

Re: What Curtis actually said

david weaver

Is that the video where he says somewhere in it that he doesn't keep much or any kiln dried material around?

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#37

Re: the walnut steaming

david weaver

holcombe's try plane developed some end checks on the inside of the mortise and on the back of the plane without about 45 minutes. I thought I'd put his plane in the sun to get a good hard glue joint on the handle - on a day that was only about 75 degrees out.

Same KD stuff will end check in winter if the temperature gets really cold long enough for the humidity to really drop in the shop.

I can only guess it's like that because of how fast it will transfer moisture.

Fortunately, the checking on holcombe's plane was minor enough that it closed, and i hope it stays that way.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#38

Re: Amen to that advice

david weaver

I think it may have been larry (or someone else maybe) who mentioned bleaching the surface of beech when it arrives green to prevent mold.

I've had a fair amount of lower cost 5/4 beech that was allowed to mold before it goes in the kiln - what looks minor does go very deep. Not a big deal for my use, but I couldn't sell it to someone else to make moulding planes because they couldn't sell the planes.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#39

Re: Try it yourself - in ther real world

david weaver

I can't imagine judging what's a valuable wood or not based solely on what's sold expensively as guitar backs and sides. You could not, for example, sell a rosewood table and and recover the lumber.

The virtue of expensive guitars and gunstocks are an uneducated public (that is, you can sell a 5A top to a guitar buyer and charge them $750+ for it because they have no clue what the wood is actually worth).

Same thing with brazilian rosewood sides and backs, they become a buzzword "need" for white collar people who want to have a guitar that befits their bloated image of themselves. (plenty of us are white collar, but I never got the idea of a $10,000 guitar for a guy who doesn't know how to play it - being a poser is worse than having deep pockets and showing up with a cheap instrument out of stinginess).

The whole guitar thing (price for backs and sides) is the result of a dumb buying public (and really stupid superstitions about tonal qualities - ever see banjo people trying to figure out what was in the old gibson banjo rings, and pay big bucks to try to buy something that claims to be an accurate reproduction?) and a cadre of instrument makers who are dying for something to upsell because the base instrument setup is unprofitable.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#40

Re: Baloney

John in NM

I don't recall hearing that walnut was undesirable before. These things do vary a lot with changing fashions, but I don't think walnut will ever be a second best sort of wood for furniture use. Cherry was all the rage in the 1990's, presumably it is still somewhat. Walnut was a big deal in Danish modern stuff as I recall.

Gunstock blanks are a whole different animal - the expense of truly fine ones is justified by the rarity of consistent figure over a full length stock. If one is making two piece stocks it is not hard at all to find suitable material in any unit of black walnut in a lumber yard.

The funny part about stock blanks is that Claro walnut from California is a popular wood for stocks due to color mostly. But it is less dense than black walnut and really doesn't checker as well, dents very easily, and seems to me about as strong as genuine mahogany - in short, it's not really good wood for a gunstock in my opinion. Part of the appeal of Turkish and French varieties is that they are beautiful in appearance and tend to be dense wood. Whether that is due to genetics or growth environment I don't know for sure, but the "French" variety that comes from CA is denser in my limited experience, so I'm going to say genetics.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#41

Re: Steaming times and second rate products.

TomD

Thanks Bill, the reason I asked was that the quoted fall off in technical specs is significant in some uses. For instance walnut is one of my favourite woods in glass backed longbows with red elm backing. The glass is the workhorse there, but I wouldn't accept any significant reduction in specs, so I was wondering how representative their steaming time is. Sounds like it is right on the money. Though I wasn't really sure how dry the samples were that they tested after steaming, if they were kiln dried, that drop is spectacular, if they were still wet, it is a red hearing.

I guess also from your comments that I would deduce that one thing about air dried wood is that it is a consistent product, while kiln dried could be just about anything. I don't know why I would want the uncertainty of that, sounds like a lower grade product. Or more literally a no grade product. Of course the implication is that they are using science and technology to create a higher quality product, but that is clearly baloney. Of course in purely color and lumber grade terms it is fine.

The evening of the color is useful to some, and I appreciate the tidbit about about the heat required to do that.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#42

Re: the walnut steaming

TomD

Neat data point. Is H a client, or a historic maker. If it checks, for me that is pretty much the burn pile. Of course with the plank, I can cut around it. It just means some waste.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#43

Re: the walnut steaming

david weaver

Client!! haha. I've never sold a plane for more than the cost of the materials in it, so I don't have "clients".

Brian Holcombe on here, above on the posts. He's a user of tools who was using metal planes to do rough work, which seemed like a lot of extra work.

Any beech would've end checked in the cold that checked mine (the stuff that was not planes yet, stored in the garage), there's really no way around it when you go to subzero (F) temperatures and you leave the end of the wood exposed in an area that's heated. Mind you, these aren't checks that go top to bottom or end to end on a billet, just small fingernails of checking that you might be able to put the corner of a sheet of paper in.

Brian's plane was already made except for putting the oil finish on, so I was only going to throw it out of the checks stayed open. Most planes more than 100 years old have a check on them or a large crack, just because they were exposed to something at some point that caused the same thing.

I was just a little surprised to see a 75 degree day with sun cause small checks to start opening on the ends in 45 minutes - on an already finished plane.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#44

Re: Try it yourself - in ther real world

TomD

It doesn't mater what causes the price of backs and sides to rise, it is just that it is high. 40 dollars versus 2K has to get someone's attention. It is certainly true that the upcharge on fancy wood is the bread and butter of lutherie. Thank goodness there is a dodge in some aspect of fine woodworking allowing a few people to make McDonald wages. I would not really say the wood is overpriced when you take rarity and legal issues like proper documentation into account.

There is a group in Euro that is trying to analyze option for non-tropical woods, as though that would be new. But they can't easily get around the upcharge issue as average local woods cost more than tropical and for the same effort you loose out on 500-1000 pure profit on even factory guitars. So yeah, to an extent easy money.

I don't agree there aren't tonal differences, but I do agree that they are largely irrelevant, and that the people who buy expensive instruments are mostly not pro musicians, just as we are not pro cabinetmakers, but I don't accept that makes either of us posers about planes. Woodworking is a little different, because the amateurs are sometimes better than the pros, which happens rarely in pro music, and anyone can enjoy playing an expensive guitar, while refined tools are not something a hack will get much out of.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#45

Re: Try it yourself - in ther real world

david weaver

Posers in music - someone who buys a $15,000 banjo and can only play cripple creek. Someone who buys a hand made archtop or one of the one-off suhr guitars but hasn't taken lessons yet, and who loves to tell people that they play guitar and describe their guitar.

I doubt either of us are posers in woodworking in general, maybe me!! I'm not calling you one, but if either of us had just started and bought four holtey planes and spent our time describing the virtues of it over and over without learning to use it, that'd make us posers.

Definitely there is some tonal difference for different woods, and the further you get from solid body, the bigger it is. However, a well made guitar with sides in a certain density and stiffness range is going to be similar. I agree with you that if you can get brazilian sides and back for $1-2k and charge 2 to 4 times that for the upcharge, then it's senseless to try to figure out how to use a local wood that nobody wants. On blind listening, though, I have an easy time figuring out what's mahogany vs. rosewood, and a terrible time figuring out what sound clips come from an indian rosewood guitar vs. brazilian unless one is built worse than another.

When someone plugs in a plywood top (but well made) archtop and runs it through an amp, I can't figure out the difference.

On electric guitars, I have a much harder time figuring out what's what.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#46

Re: As an Aside  - Warren

david weaver

Though Beech isn't exactly common where I come from, I'm surprised to hear that it's not found *at all* in fulton county - not far away from Adams.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#47

Re: As an Aside  - Warren *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I looked up beech in Rhoads and Klein. The book has a map of Pennsylvania for each species and a dot placed on the map for each specimen in the the major herbariums of the state. There are a quarter million dots in the book. It is a little unhandy looking at the book online, but here is the beech entry. The lack of specimens does not mean that the tree will not grow in that county, but looking at the distribution gives a good indication. You can also google

Fagus grandifolia USDA

and you will get a map showing the states where it occurs; clicking on a state will usually show the counties where it is present.

When I was in school in Ohio I pointed out a small hackberry tree to my teacher. He took a specimen cutting and said it had never been found in Lorain County before. This tree was within a hundred feet of the county border. My old Ohio book showed no specimens in Lorain Co., but the newer maps show it present.


Rhoads and Klein

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#48

Re: As an Aside  - Warren

david weaver

That's an excellent source. The dots explain why I didn't see beech in adams county. I grew up on the eastern side of Gettysburg and the dots for the beech are in the southwest and/or west, which is state forest and mountains (probably more mature forests).

The land we have has been bare at least once, thus a whole bunch of red oak (which we gladly cut, split and burned).

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#49

Re: Try it yourself - in ther real world

JDK

I'm curious David. What business is it of yours if I buy a $15,000 banjo and do nothing more than put in into a case and look at from time-to-time?

This contrived self-righteous indignation about how people spend their money, what place does it have in a woodworking forum?

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#50

Re: Try it yourself - in ther real world

TomD

"Posers in music - someone who buys a $15,000 banjo and can only play cripple creek. Someone who buys a hand made archtop or one of the one-off suhr guitars but hasn't taken lessons yet, and who loves to tell people that they play guitar and describe their guitar."

It would be the last phrase that does it, you have to somehow misrepresent your situation. A while back, maybe still today, some collectors got at it and put together stunning collections of classical and archtops really before anyone was looking. I think that is great, or something, so you have collectors too. It is really an art at some level where people just appreciate something about it. I had trouble with it when I thought of doing it as a retirement thing, and I sorta felt it was an odd market, and wasn't comfortable, or maybe just lazy.

"I doubt either of us are posers in woodworking in general, maybe me!! I'm not calling you one,"

I wouldn't call you one either. I think dialectically there can be a pose, so for the purpose of a thread I might jump in as the epoxy guy, the Japanese tool guy, or whatever... At least until one shows up. But it is to contrast views, not to pretend anything. All boast are virtual when you aren't even registered.

"but if either of us had just started and bought four holtey planes and spent our time describing the virtues of it over and over without learning to use it, that'd make us posers."

Not seeing the pose in that. People will get annoyed at that guy if he really doesn't have a clue, and the scab he is picking is particularly fresh, probably unknown to him, but he thinks he knows something so it is sincere, until it isn't.

"terrible time figuring out what sound clips come from an indian rosewood guitar vs. brazilian unless one is built worse than another."

And with the popularity of some style the Brazilian is getting ground down to next to nothing an the sides laminated... Up to a point the Brazilian used to be used by better builders building for better players, and presumably there was a reason for that, but it also means that you have an even harder time figuring out what is going on since either of those parties can have a bigger influence than the sides. These days though, people will pay for Brazilian an even their first guitar, or some other very expensive wood. There is a bit of a chin up happening there, because they may have no clue what they are doing at that point.

"When someone plugs in a plywood top (but well made) archtop and runs it through an amp, I can't figure out the difference."

There is some guy who has a plugged in acoustic tenor Uke, reentrant tuning and all, and does a scorching Hendrix, on Youtube. The electronics are a lot of the picture today.