Re: Try it yourself - in ther real world
TomD
"Posers in music - someone who buys a $15,000 banjo and can only play cripple creek. Someone who buys a hand made archtop or one of the one-off suhr guitars but hasn't taken lessons yet, and who loves to tell people that they play guitar and describe their guitar."
It would be the last phrase that does it, you have to somehow misrepresent your situation. A while back, maybe still today, some collectors got at it and put together stunning collections of classical and archtops really before anyone was looking. I think that is great, or something, so you have collectors too. It is really an art at some level where people just appreciate something about it. I had trouble with it when I thought of doing it as a retirement thing, and I sorta felt it was an odd market, and wasn't comfortable, or maybe just lazy.
"I doubt either of us are posers in woodworking in general, maybe me!! I'm not calling you one,"
I wouldn't call you one either. I think dialectically there can be a pose, so for the purpose of a thread I might jump in as the epoxy guy, the Japanese tool guy, or whatever... At least until one shows up. But it is to contrast views, not to pretend anything. All boast are virtual when you aren't even registered.
"but if either of us had just started and bought four holtey planes and spent our time describing the virtues of it over and over without learning to use it, that'd make us posers."
Not seeing the pose in that. People will get annoyed at that guy if he really doesn't have a clue, and the scab he is picking is particularly fresh, probably unknown to him, but he thinks he knows something so it is sincere, until it isn't.
"terrible time figuring out what sound clips come from an indian rosewood guitar vs. brazilian unless one is built worse than another."
And with the popularity of some style the Brazilian is getting ground down to next to nothing an the sides laminated... Up to a point the Brazilian used to be used by better builders building for better players, and presumably there was a reason for that, but it also means that you have an even harder time figuring out what is going on since either of those parties can have a bigger influence than the sides. These days though, people will pay for Brazilian an even their first guitar, or some other very expensive wood. There is a bit of a chin up happening there, because they may have no clue what they are doing at that point.
"When someone plugs in a plywood top (but well made) archtop and runs it through an amp, I can't figure out the difference."
There is some guy who has a plugged in acoustic tenor Uke, reentrant tuning and all, and does a scorching Hendrix, on Youtube. The electronics are a lot of the picture today.