New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

Posts

What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#1

What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The recent discussion on steaming/boiling beech for planes perked my curiosity to find information on the topic. What fundamentally happens when the wood is steamed? These conclusions would apply to any steamed hardwood. I would conclude that steaming is good for beech plane blanks.

Below are quotes from the abstract of what seemed to be a reliable scientific study on the effects of steaming. The first paragraph summarizes why steaming is done. The second provides more detailed information on the chemistry involved.

"Subjecting beech to steaming is commonly practiced to reduce growth stress, improve dimensional stability, decrease drying time, achieve desirable color, and soften the wood. The objective of the study reported here was to determine the effect of steaming at low temperature (80[degrees]C) for varying durations on the physical, mechanical, and chemical characteristics of beech. [ what is reported are typical steaming conditions for walnut and I presume beech although I have no personal experience commercial with beech steaming]

"Following 100 hours of steaming, compression strength and modulus of elasticity decreased 13.2 and 16.5 percent, respectively. Steaming had a slight effect on radial and tangential shrinkage, and reduced density about 2 percent. Hemicelluloses in steamed wood decreased only 7 to 9 percent, but wood solubility was greatly decreased[because the stuff that was water soluble left in the steam and was no longer available to extract]. Acetyl content also decreased with steaming as hemicelluloses decreased. The lignin content of steamed wood was slightly higher than that of untreated wood[Lignin can't be made by steaming. The absolute amount remained the same, but what was left decreased thereby increasing the lignin concentration.] "

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#2

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

Kees

You can get similar results from watering the wood (leaving the fresh wood logs in a stream or a waterpond for quite some time). This is mostly done to even out the color diference between sap and heart wood.

I wouldn't worry about the reduction of hardness and tensil strength in beech after steaming. It is still plenty hard enough. And because most of this wood is killn dried, it is usually a little harder then untreated, air dried wood.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#3

adding some details

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

At least for N. American practice:

Logs are steamed prior to slicing veneer to make them easier to slice. I have never seen a log steamed prior to sawing. It is more efficient to steam the lumber than the logs for lumber coloring.

Water alone does noting to change color. Water and high temperature are required to darken walnut sapwood.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#4

Re: adding some details

Kees

Well, I just bought a bunch of cherry where the difference in color between sap and hearth is much reduced. The sawyer I bought it from explained how he gets that effect through watering the logs. The logs are in the water for a couple of months.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#5

Re: the walnut steaming

david weaver

....definitely done at high pressure and steam, and likely the beech, too.

I have seen more than one person say that they will not work steamed walnut because both the wood and the color have been changed, that it's like taking something live and making it dead.

The steamed beech has a more dry texture to it than the non-steamed beech, though that could be the wood types or even just different samples.

Personally, if I could have all of my fruit woods that are worked by hand air dried instead of kiln dried, that'd be my preference, but it's not so easy to find air dried stuff. Horizon fights with their kiln, at least it appears, when doing 16/4 beech or anything else that doesn't dry well, and I'd assume that's not necessarily because it's that hard to dry in a kiln, but that it becomes much harder to dry 16/4 if you don't want the kiln tied up for a very long time on a drying schedule that nothing else is on. Their past load honeycombed.

I have never heard someone who air dried it say much of anything about it other than that they threw it somewhere and later used it when it was dry. Much as TomD has said here.

(George Wilson said they just sawed long billets and threw it in the upstairs area of a storage building and left it there, and it came out fine).

At any rate, getting off topic. I'd personally choose no steaming based on my limited experience, though commercial users probably appreciate that the wood is deadened a little bit. (i'm sure they do, or nobody would go to the trouble to steam it).

A completely separate comment, I saw Curtis Buchanan talking about turning and he said something along the lines of that he either won't use kiln dried wood for turnings, or maybe he said that he doesn't like it in his shop at all at this point.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#6

Baloney

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I have seen more than one person say that they will not work steamed walnut because both the wood and the color have been changed, that it's like taking something live and making it dead. "

You get this kind of statement from someone that likes drying their own and feels a need to make it superior to justify the effort.

I have worked more than a thousand bdft of each over the years, and have more than a thousand bd ft each in storage, and from my experience disagree with the above statement. There is nothing in the research report above that suggests anything but that steamed wood will dry better and be less stressed, either from drying or growing, and more stable . These results agree with the owner of a company that worked more than a thousand bdft of walnut a week. What's not to like about the superior properties of steamed wood?

As far as color, it doesn't matter if it is air dried, KD or steamed and KD, it all winds up the same color after light exposure. I will repeat the results of an experiment I did some years ago with two adjacent pieces of walnut steamed and air dried, then exposed at a window for a month in July. There remains a difference after only a month but it isn't much.


Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#7

What Curtis actually said

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I saw Curtis Buchanan talking about turning and he said something along the lines of that he either won't use kiln dried wood for turnings, or maybe he said that he doesn't like it in his shop at all at this point. "

Curtis goes to extraordinary effort to keep his green billets from drying and molding. I asked him why not just use dry wood and avoid the hassle of green wood storage. The reason to use green wood was easy to see in his demonstration. Green wood turns vastly faster. He does effectively KD the tenons before assembly.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#8

Re: What Curtis actually said

david weaver

It doesn't just turn faster, it turns better (less split out of fibers).

And not just green wood, but air dried wood.

At least in fruit woods that's the case. There's less split out on rasp work and less in turning.

Perhaps that's because it never quite gets as dry as kiln dried wood, but in true hand work (rasping, carving, chiseling, finishing a turning off of a tool) it's a little different.

The wood I've seen curtis turning doesn't look that green, it looks like it's air dried instead.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#9

Re: Baloney

david weaver

I don't generally work walnut, so I'm not sure about the gray color. The walnut you're showing looks very light compared to what I get locally.

I will incidentally get a board or two when it's cheap.

I'm not sure I'd test one board and declare everything a rumor.

It's not the color that makes me prefer air dried wood, or wood that's not dried to 6-8 percent, it's how it works.

I think people working entirely by hand will have different opinions on that. I'm not talking about working green wood, either, but fully dried air dried wood that's several years old.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#10

I see countless..

david weaver

... discussions on milling forums and woodworking forums for the last 15 years from people who are milling and drying their lumber stating that they much prefer the air dried walnut because the color is better and the wood is less brittle.

Again, I don't work enough walnut to know, and in the fruitwoods, the color isn't much of an issue, but the little air dried wood I've been able to use is definitely much less brittle.

I'll believe the scads of people who mill wood discussing the color change in walnut over a one-board test of walnut that has poor color.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#11

Try it yourself

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There is nothing "poor" about the color of the test pieces. I have no doubt the air dried piece looked "great" before it got a sun tan, and the steamed piece looked darker and browner and undesirable to someone smitten by the fleeting color of a fresh walnut surface. After a sun tan what I show in the picture is what any unfinished walnut looks like. The reds and purples the air dried enthusiasts talk about will vanish in one day in the bright sun. Try it next summer and I'll eat crow if you don't confirm this claim. (Ditto for the green in poplar inexperienced woodworkers abhor, or not. It will turn brown in the time it takes to plane a stack if the planed boards are in bright sun.)

When it comes off the saw walnut will look green and purple. It is an alarming color seen the first time. This color quickly changes upon exposure to light and/or oxygen. The next fleeting color is purple to redish brown. This color then fades to brown, then yellow brown and after a few years of sun a light yellow brown. I have refinished walnut conference tables that had been lacquered but not stained that were as light as aged maple. For some reason oiled walnut doesn't bleach like lacquered walnut.

All commercially sourced veneer is steamed. I don't hear furniture builders disparaging veneer color.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#12

Re: What Curtis actually said

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have seen Curits truing many times. He lives not far away. It is always green.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#13

Re: What Curtis actually said

david weaver

Truing or turning? The video where he was talking about not using kiln dried stock was when finish turning what looked like dry wood.

I haven't seen him talk about drying when dimensioning wood, though it's certainly reasonable to do the roughest work when the wood is wet. It's an opportunity that most of us don't have.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#14

Re: Try it yourself

david weaver

I don't think you can judge what custom furniture makers sell as the banner for all things.

I sold my tablesaw to a guy who makes 100% one off stuff, and while his clients may not have any issue with paying $10,000 for a conference table, they made no condition that it actually had to be solid wood.

I'm content to rely on the prevailing wisdom in this case, partially because I have no walnut in my shop that's green in the first place, and certainly no way to steam it.

I certainly don't believe there's no difference in workability, either. In apple, the difference is enormous. Air dried apple is pleasantly waxy feeling under the tools and kiln dried is harsher and, in warren's words, a lot more musical (which is undesirable) and chippy.

I would take air dried or partially air dried every time if I had the choice.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#15

Re: the walnut steaming

Steve Voigt

"when doing 16/4 beech or anything else that doesn't dry well, ... I'd assume [it's] not necessarily because it's that hard to dry in a kiln, but that it becomes much harder to dry 16/4 if you don't want the kiln tied up for a very long time on a drying schedule that nothing else is on."

I think that is basically the whole ballgame. Having talked to several professionals who've taken a crack at drying 16/4 beech, I think that it's tricky but by no means super-difficult to dry. What's hard is getting it processed from green to dry in 90 days or so. Nobody wants to tie up their kiln, and somewhat surprisingly, nobody even wants to have the lumber sitting on the ground air-drying. I guess the real estate is too valuable. Anyway, I am going to get some green 16/4 in here in the next couple weeks, so I'll let everyone know how it goes…around September 2017! :D

Re the issue of steaming: I really enjoyed reading Bill's research and the subsequent discussion. But I think it is basically a moot issue…if you are a boutique planemaker, there is no way to justify the time and expense of steaming your blanks. Getting it done commercially would involve buying a volume that no one except perhaps Larry and Don could handle. Buying steamed QS Euro beech in 16/4 is the same…you can get it if you're able to buy an entire shipping container's worth, otherwise forget it.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#16

Re: the walnut steaming

david weaver

I gather that the steaming is done for the benefit of the lumber seller more than the user (in the case of walnut). Walnut is well behaved no matter what.

Maybe it's a different story for the beech since some of the articles describing steaming it mention stability (since the end users for upholstered furniture, etc, are using flatsawn goods).

Interesting that nobody even wants beech sitting on the ground.

Not that I'd mind having euro beech, I guess, but I'd rather have american beech and the steaming doesn't do anything for me as it wouldn't for most planemakers. the color evens out so fast (don't care about the color, anyway).

There is a boatload of beech in ohio west of me (and not very far). My entire neighborhood is wooded - 400 houses, and I've literally not seen a single beech tree here. In my youth, I don't remember ever cutting and splitting a beech tree (we lived in the woods and heated with wood...a lot of oak, cherry, walnut and locust, but no beech).

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#17

turning details

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Curtis has demonstrated chair making many times for our turning and woodworking clubs respectively. What he did on each occasion is turn green wood into a finished spindle and I was left with the impression that this is standard practice both from what he did and in answers to questions. He then dries the tenon in a sand bath before insertion. It is amazing how fast he turns a spindle but then he estimated he has done 25,000 of them.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#18

Air drying

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have had good luck air drying beech over the years. I recommend keeping it under roof in an unheated space for at least a year so that it dries gradually. In a barn or loft open to the air but not getting wet. I don't think piling up outside and just covering with tin is a good idea; keep it out of the sun, rain and snow. I like to brush the sawdust off the planks.

Beech is a late succession tree prospering in mature forests. A young tree can limp along in the understory for decades waiting for an opening. I have seen branches on young beeches that grew three inches or less in length in ten years. For this reason the wood near the pith is a little stunted and often distorts when drying. Since beech has such a smooth bark you can often read the grain from the outside of the log. Waviness in the bark is reflected in the wood grain and some beeches have persistent little branches on the trunk.

David I had trouble believing there was no beech in Adams County, so I looked in the Pennsylvania Flora Atlas. Beech actually has been found in every Pennsylvania county except Fulton, but there is a pocket with no herbarium specimens reported that includes western York county and most of Adams and Cumberland. More specimens in your present location.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#19

steaming and air drying

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


Here is several million bdft of oak occupying real estate at the Baillie mill in Greenwood SC. It is not at all uncommon to have a million or more bdf of lumber air drying at a large operation. I have seen a city block piled 20' high with stacks of oak at a mill in KY. Air drying is cheaper then KD and it is often done prior to putting in the expensively heated kiln, especially for oak where the drying cycle is long. About the only lumber I see locally dried right off the saw is poplar because it can be dried a a few days.

If there was a market large enough to attract a well run KD operation there would be no issue manufacturing KD 16/4 beech. There is a good market for 16/4 turning squares and they are done in volume. In fact there is an operation nor far from where I live that has vacuum kilns especially for rapid drying large squares.

As far as steaming it would be a trivial task to build a steamer to do plane blanks and easier yet to boil them as Warren referred to. Supposedly makes drying faster which seems desirable. Seems to be an experiment waiting to be tried by someone.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#20

Re: turning details

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Turning green is faster and easier than dry timbers. I sometimes do rough turning of cylinders green then set them aside until dry. If you are going to sand or paint the turnings, the quality doesn't matter so much, but for 18th century work on spinning wheels, finials, columns, and the like, dry stock yields cleaner crisper turnings.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#21

Amen to that advice

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Fungus loves beech and in short order it will shoot deep into a board or billet. Piles must be kept dry with adequate air circulation.

Personally I would not be trying to dry planks. Planks would become billets which will dry vastly faster.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#22

Re: steaming and air drying

Bruce, a MN Galoot

A woodturner friend of mine routinely boils green blanks to speed drying and he says it helps stabilize them as well.

I wondered about air drying prior to the KD process. The mill where I go seems to do this a lot and I haven't understood why. Thanks for the explanation.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#23

Re: Air drying

david weaver

Hi Warren, I'm sure there's beech in adams county somewhere. There's just not any on my parents' properties there, which includes about 70 acres of woods.

The neighborhood i'm in is probably about 300 acres. Safe to say, I haven't been able to walk every bit of it, but I haven't seen any beech trees here.

Someone I work with has a neighbor with one laid over, but it's about 35 miles from here. I'm sure if I went through the woods around here for a while, I'd find something, but I'd probably have better luck looking through places that have been woods for a long time, as opposed to places like my neighborhood that were not wooded at one point.

My parents' main property is the same, it was a granite mine and probably deforested more or less and then what's there is regrowth. Plenty of red oak.

It seems like southern ohio has a massive abundance of it, though, more so than here.

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#24

Re: steaming and air drying

david weaver

I'm not aware of anyone lining up for 16/4 beech other than planemakers, and it's just never going to be a big market.

I doubt that it would be that hard to dry if people just followed the suggested schedule for it rather than trying to hurry it or trying to put it in the kiln with something else and then pressing their luck on drying time.

Seems a waste. At some point, I'll run across a log and if I don't, I guess I'll just buy it green from someone else. But I'll air dry it, I can't imagine fooling with much else is necessary given how fast it is reported to air dry (2 years for 16/4, possibly 1).

Re: What steaming does to Beech (scientific)

#25

Re: What Curtis actually said

TomD

"Curtis goes to extraordinary effort to keep his green billets from drying and molding. I asked him why not just use dry wood and avoid the hassle of green wood storage. The reason to use green wood was easy to see in his demonstration. Green wood turns vastly faster. He does effectively KD the tenons before assembly."

Curtis seems to be in the mainstream of craft chair making, and they keep wet wood mostly because it is better in the dowel joints they use. It certainly turns easier, but that would no justify having to rebuild every chair sold. He isn't kiln drying the tenon, he is preparing it for differential moisture exchange and the result that is a very tightly socketed chair.