New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Mallets most used

Posts

Mallets most used

#1

Mallets most used

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

As Bob said, it has been too quiet here. I am busy building drawers, which are an interesting challenge, but will not show them here until I have done a few.

In the meantime, to get some involvement on the forum, here are the mallets I use. Hopefully you will post your favourites as well, that is, the ones you actually use.

I have added UHMW Polyethylene to the faces of all my mallets/persuaders. This has replaced the leather fronts I was using. The advantage of UHMW is that it is hard and stiff enough to provide good feedback, but has a touch of give to prevent marring the ends of unhooped chisels.

It began with using a Thor (at the rear), which became a general purpose mallet -- it is excellent when trying to keep the noise level down when morticing! Then I added it to the end of my 8 oz plane hammer, which is my go-to for tapping the backs of unhooped chisels when dovetailing. (I use a similar-sized gennou for Japanese hooped chisels). This was so successful that I added it to the 19 oz Veritas Cabinetmakers mallet (re-handled to fit my hand), which is used for morticing into softer woods, and the 36 oz monster mortice mallet (which is beefed up with inlaid brass), that is reserved for the hardest woods.


My go-to gennou has a Tenryuu gennou head, which came from So Yamashita at Japan Tool. This has a Tsuchime (hammer mark) finish and in the Daruma style, which is a broad head useful for chisels. The handle is a traditional design and fit.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Mallets most used

#2

Re: Mallets most used

roger lance

This is my one and only mallet.....from Bob's Hardware.....I added the decal.


Wood shavings are for dramatic effect and don't reflect any actual woodworking.

Re: Mallets most used

#3

Those chips are pretty dramatic! 

Re: Mallets most used

#4

Re: Mallets most used

TomD

I have tons of them. I started out using the Japanese hammers, that I have in a lot of different weights. When it comes to dovetailing, or mortising a main concern of mine is noise, and while for some reason I am not a fan of those barrel carving mallets, I now use the urethane version almost exclusively. They work great, hit great, and are quiet, and not even all that expensive.

I have a nasty plastic auto body hammer, a bit like the ones in the pics Derek shows. It is the best thing for planes. I have some fancy plane hammers, but this plastic one is the best. Studies in golf show that what people think is feel is actually a sound certain putters give. Plastic makes a nice sound in both putters and plane adjusting hammers. And since plastic is cheap, no downside. But the noise plastic makes rapidly gets too much.

Re: Mallets most used

#5

Re: About noise.

TomD

A few decades back I read an article that said that tests showed that 22 lr muzzle blast, and hammer noise were the same decibel level, but that the duration of the hammer noise was much shorter. The upshot being that the hammer was just as capable of damaging your hearing as the 22, but it might take more hammering to do it.

I never really believed that article, notwithstanding the sanctity of all science. But I was already taking protective measures so I just kept at it. Or I guess I should say, I believe the period stuff, I just didn't believe the decibel level stuff. Another thing I had heard was that gunshots were in the 160 db level.

A few years back, one of the kids got into band. I gave her earmuffs, and told here not to take any BS from teachers. As it turned out the band teacher that year lost her hearing, in one year. I started to anticipate push back on the whole earmuff thing, and was looking for a DB meter so that we could have science on our side. Guess what, all the regular DB meters topped out at 160. Turns out that is the reason (as far as I can see), that gunfire is always reported as being 160, it can apparently range up to 200. The hammers at the 140 db level are still cause for concern, but nothing like the guy at the bench next to you with the 300 Weatherby and the new muzzle brake design. Given that 22 db is a not uncommon attenuation level for muffs, and some of the sound bypasses even those, you can see the danger of being anywhere near 200 db, 160, or maybe even 140.

Re: Mallets most used

#6

Re: Mallets most used

Brian Holcombe

This is a fun topic, I have become mildly addicted to Japanese gennou...but have stopped short (for now) of the really wild stuff like Baba Masayuki.

The three on the left are same make/source as Derek's, brass one is from LN, and leather face is from Blue Spruce. Ebony handles on the Left.

The middle gennou is from Hikroki, I love it, it shows the lamination lines very clearly. White oak handle.


Re: Mallets most used

#7

Re: Mallets most used

chandler

My only mallet is a Crown beech square head like the one in the pic. I rounded over the edges on the handle for comfort and, since the wedged head had a tendency to fall back down the handle, I secured it with a couple of dowels. Since then I've beat it to hell and never wanted or needed another.


img

Re: Mallets most used

#8

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Mallets most used

Jack Guzman from Maine

These are my most used mallets. Starting from left,the first is a chunk of apple I use at the lathe for removing the live center from the lathe and tapping it into the end grain for mounting. The next is a pair of general purpose mallets with maple inserts and a piece of leather glued onto one end. The next is my froe mallet,maple also. The next one is my dedicated mallet for most chisel work ,maple also. The last is a much heavier version made of what rockler calls lignum vitae. I use this chisel for deep mortising into tough woods. I have a couple of self made square headed mallets but I never use them anymore. I prefer a round carvers style mallet for chisel work. Good topic---Jack *the black line in the photo is a picture editing error


Re: Mallets most used

#9

Re: Mallets most used

William Duffield

Probably the single worst hearing damage I've suffered was due to one of these mallets being struck against a recalcitrant dovetail joint right next to my ear. I was getting some help assembling the carcass of a piece of furniture. Several years later, I still have tinnitus from that blow.

These are the mallets I use the most.


At the top is my black locust maul that I use with a froe for riving. There are better choices for this purpose, including dogwood and elm.

From left to right:

Taiwanese dead blow mallet, mostly for setting and releasing holdfasts and for carcass assembly. The only thing I don't like about it is that it leaves black marks on the wood.

Hophornbeam carving mallet. This is my favorite. The other carving mallets I use much less often.

Plane adjusting hammer from Chester Tool Works. Head is brass and lignum vitae.

Hard Maple carving mallet. Before I made the hophornbeam mallet, this is the one I used most for carving and chopping.

Red oak and ash carpenter's mallet. I use this one mostly at the lathe and drill press, for removing Morse taper centers.

Purpleheart carving mallet. I don't use it as much, because I know it tends to splinter if struck against sharp objects.

Re: Mallets most used

#10

Darrell in Oakville

Re: Mallets most used

Darrell in Oakville

This little mallet is on the bench 95 percent of the time.

I was cutting the grass under an old apple tree that had been badly pruned years before, and the end of a branch struck me in the head. Or I struck it. Felt like being hit in the head with a hammer. So I cut the offending branch off and saved the end bit for a mallet.

That was 15 years ago, and it is my favourite hammer now.


img

Re: Mallets most used

#11

Re: Mallets most used

JDK

I'll join the crowd. From right-to-left, these are the mallets and hammers I use the most.


Re: Mallets most used

#12

Re: Mallets most used

Darren Brewster

I use the same urethane carver's mallet for almost everything, a 30 or 32 oz shop fox I got on clearance at my local Busy Bee Tools. I love working with heavier mallets, even for light weight work.

Re: Mallets most used

#13

Re: UHMW Question

William Duffield

How do you fasten the UHMW pads to the faces of your mallets? I've had difficulty finding effective adhesives, but solid fasteners could leave marks in your work unless they are deeply recessed.

Re: Mallets most used

#14

Re: UHMW Question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi William

Epoxy does hold, but it is not enough - one can still prize away the UHMW. I add either screws or nails. These are recessed below the surface, out of harms way ..

The plane hammer (also used for unhooped chisels) ..


The others are epoxied and nailed on ..


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Mallets most used

#15

Re: UHMW Question

TomD

Crown plastics sells PSA backed UHMW plastic, And industrial plastic supply makes epoxies formulated for the task. I doubt either is all that cost effective for the casual user.

Cheaper would be G-Flex, by WEST system, type 655. You need to alcohol wipe and flame prep. The latter meaning letting a clean flame play on the surface until it dulls. The dulling is oxidization, to which the epoxy can bond. Result is 1885 psi bond. Of course there are a lot of ways to fail a mallet face.

Re: Mallets most used

#16

Re: UHMW Question

William Duffield

Thanks for the advice, guys. I've filed it for future reference.

But now I'm concerned that putting UHMW on the face of a hammer may have some disadvantages. I've heard of a practical joke that is (or was, before pneumatic nail guns) supposed to be played on neophyte framing carpenters. Polishing and waxing the face of a hammer is supposed to make it very difficult to drive nails with it. The hammer is supposed to slip off the head of the nail, resulting in bent and crooked nails. Is there any scientific basis for such an effect?

Re: Mallets most used

#17

Re: UHMW Question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi William

I do not see your comparison to be realistic. A skinny and shiny nail being hit by a polished hammer head is not the same target as a chisel end.

The UHMW muffles noise while still providing good feedback. It is not soft and yielding like a rubber mallet or one faced in "hard" leather. It is not as hard as a steel or brass head - but these are loud and unfriendly when the family are snoozing in the afternoon.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Mallets most used

#18

Re: UHMW Question

Brian Holcombe

All of the Gennou I have are polished on the faces intended for nails, they're also convex.

I think that theory is just a legend.

Re: Mallets most used

#19

Re: UHMW Question

John Aniano in Central NJ

William,

I do believe the effect is real. I remember reading about "sharpening your hammer" years ago by rubbing a hammer's convex face on a piece of coarse abrasive paper on your thigh (or any other cushioned surface) to roughen up the smooth face. I've done this many times and I feel it helps my hammering inaccuraces...

John

Re: Mallets most used

#20

Re: UHMW Question

Brad Chenoweth

John,

I may have to try that to help with my hammering inaccuracies. My Dad, a life-long carpenter, routinely made fun of my innate ability to bend perfectly good nails. Then, by way of showing off, he would drive a series of nails using the claws of a ripping hammer, never missing a beat. Always impressed me.

Brad

Re: Mallets most used

#21

Clint Searl

Depends on necessary persuasion

Clint Searl


Merry Xmas

Re: Mallets most used

#22

Re: UHMW Question

AZ in Colorado Springs

Last spring I worked with a cub scout den to do a few simple projects. I thought the dads would be able to help the boys with nailing the parts together. Most of them had more trouble than their sons and I had to scurry around to help everyone complete the projects without the dads looking totally inept. I hadn't seen that one coming.

Re: Mallets most used

#23

Re: Mallets most used

Patrick Gibbons

Two self-mades. The smaller is dogwood, the larger is persimmon. Made them fast and didn't spend a lot of time making them pretty.


img

Re: Mallets most used

#24

Re: Mallets most used

Ron Harper

Left to right. For holdfasts only, to persuade joints, a couple for carving,mortising, adjusting planes. I am getting ready to make a froe maul. From an oak branch

Ron


img

Re: Mallets most used

#25

Re: UHMW Question

TomD

Not really a scientific basis. Most frames today, would use a waffle face, so waxing and polishing would be a fool's errant. There is a category of hammer called a deck hammer that is basically a framer (21 oz or more ish) that has a polished head, to leave the nail head un-penetrated so any coating is intact, and exposed heads don't rust. Framing is done to wood that is ultimately inside the building, unlike a deck. I don't personally believe the heat and impact force of a hammer head to nail would cause it to slip all that much, and the polished head is slippery, but then, before the dominance of the framer, most framing was done with 16 oz hammer with polished faces.

A beginner can make nails fly off most anywhere, regardless of the hammer face.

But I guess the existence of the waffle face does show the frictional coefficient, or the interlock, of head to nail is a factor.