New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

The Gales of November......

Posts

The Gales of November......

#1

The Gales of November......

roger lance

Tomorrow is the 40th anniversary of the loss of the Edmund Fitzgerald and Gordon Lightfoot's song still holds a certain erie feel.

Church bells around The Great Lakes will be rung 29 times tomorrow and that song will be played on the radio.

Time moves on.......

Re: The Gales of November......

#2

What is it about that song?

Hank Knight

It's not a pretty melody, not something I hum to myself, and it's long. But every time it comes on the radio, I'm compelled to listen to the whole thing. Haunting. What a sad story.

All of which bring to mind a poem by Gerard Manley Hopkins, "The Wreck of the Deutschland". Read it if you have a place in your heart for this stuff.

On Saturday sailed from Bremen,

American-outward-bound,

Take settler and seamen, tell men with women,

Two hundred souls in the round—

O Father, not under thy feathers nor ever as guessing

The goal was a shoal, of a fourth the doom to be drowned;

Yet did the dark side of the bay of thy blessing

Not vault them, the million of rounds of thy mercy not reeve even them in?

Re: The Gales of November......

#3

I'm reminded why I nearly failed English

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I didn't understand it. No clue. But I get the red neck Lightfoot "poem".

Re: The Gales of November......

#4

Kent B

Re: The Gales of November......

Kent B

Does anyone know where the love of God goes

When the waves turn the minutes to hours?

Read up on it - again - earlier today. Very detailed scientific analysis of the events, with a "most probable" conclusion on what caused it.

Best science says 24' waves, with a 7.5 second period between waves.

I've been on the shores of Superior during storms before, but these were garden-variety storms - and they were damn scary enough in their own right.

Re: The Gales of November......

#5

Re: I'm reminded why I nearly failed English

TomD

You could have graduated with honours today, given the many online sources that dissect this poem. It is hard to imagine students brought up on South Park wadding through it.

Re: The Gales of November......

#6

Re: The Gales of November......

TomD

That is interesting, 40 years. She was 729 feet long, and could carry 54.24 million pounds of cargo. The numbers are astonishing.

That said, I will be anticipating remembrance day ceremonies the following day, and thinking of the dead, and the people from my family who served.

Re: The Gales of November......

#7

Re: The Gales of November......

CJ in MPLS

That is kind of the interesting thing about the storm. Public radio had its captive meteorologist on talking about this yesterday and the records appear to show that while the storm was big, it wasn't abnormally so. What this suggests then, is that bad luck played a large role in sinking. Bad hatches or freakishly large rogue wave perhaps.

It isn't the math itself, but I must say that statistics are a real bear, particularly when one finds oneself at the edge of the bell curve.

Re: The Gales of November......

#8

Also . . .

CJ in MPLS

Interestingly, the same meteorologist is on right now talking about something called 'bomb cyclogenesis', which is a one of the more dramatic scientific terms I've heard in a while. The big storm heading into the midwest just now is going to kick off a lot of rain and 40-60 mph winds in the area. Probably won't get all the way north to the lake, but a nice reminder that this kind of stuff can happen more than once.

Re: The Gales of November......

#9

Kent B

Re: The Gales of November...... *LINK*

Kent B

With all due respect to the local meteorologist, this bit may be outside their comfort zone.

I read 2 articles. Searching for the 2d. Here is the first, though: NOAA re-analysis of that storm.

EDIT: Found the 2d. Don't know the chops of Computer Sciences Corporation on thsi topic, but they pounded it to death in analytics. Go to the end - they evaluate the 4 common theories on p30, and conclude it was " Breakup On Surface, Failures Of First And Second Hatch Covers":

http://assets1.csc.com/innovation/downloads/Edmund_Fitzgerald.pdf

When you finally get to p 14, there is a summary [my bold emphasis]:

"Conditions on Lake Superior deteriorated rapidly

during the afternoon of 10 November 1975, as

the Edmund Fitzgerald made its southward journey

toward the shelter of Whitefish Bay. By that evening,

sustained winds near 50 kt (25 m s–1) encompassed

most of southeast Lake Superior, with more localized

sustained winds in excess of 60 kt (30 m s–1).

These winds generated waves in excess of 7.5 m,

which moved from west to east across southeast Lake

Superior, nearly perpendicular to the documented

track of the Edmund Fitzgerald.
At around 0015 UTC

11 November 1975, the Edmund Fitzgerald was lost

with all hands, coincident in both time and location

with the most severe simulated and observed conditions

on Lake Superior during the storm. A ship

following a similar course to the Edmund Fitzgerald,

but six hours earlier or later, would have avoided the

worst conditions associated with the storm."

Eariler in the report, it discussed how rare it was that seas of this type came from west-to-east, surmising that Capt McSorley had never seen conditions like this - as he radioed that it was the worst he had ever seen - and had no idea what he was n the middle of: > 70m mph winds, 25 foot+ waves coming perpendicular, and a periodicity of 8 sec [from the article I am seeking]. he fetch was basically the entire length of Superior - and the article says Superior is capable of producing waves of 10 m [33 feet]. Every 8 sec, a wave would completely engulf the deck of the Fitz - with just the 2 towers visible above the water.

That image is terrifying to me, 40 years later, sitting here on dry land.

God Bless the men of the Fitz, and all who sail the open waters.


http://www.glerl.noaa.gov/pubs/fulltext/2006/20060016.pdf

Re: The Gales of November......

#10

Re: The Gales of November......

Michael Brady

It's evening on November 11th and one of those gales is sweeping across Lake Michigan right now. I live 40 miles off the lake but trees and structures are still at risk even here. Fall has been beautiful up to this point, however.

Re: The Gales of November......

#11

Re: The Gales of November......

roger lance

Wind gusts have been reported in the 50s with 20' waves at Grand Haven, Michigan. The police have closed the piers. But there will be a few that will go surfing today. Gnarly, dudes !!