8. Feeds....
Bruce McCrory
... the junk market for pre-prepared paper--yesterday's news--wood furniture. (We know that duct tape, screws-nails, epoxy and Elmer's Yellow will save a furnished apartment any day, or every day of the week....) 
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
8. Feeds....
Bruce McCrory
... the junk market for pre-prepared paper--yesterday's news--wood furniture. (We know that duct tape, screws-nails, epoxy and Elmer's Yellow will save a furnished apartment any day, or every day of the week....) 
Re: Here are some advantages others find
R. Payne
3, 4, 5 and 6 are all convenience. 1 and 2 are specialized cases, and even there hide is either adequate or can be modified to work. If you choose to use something for convenience, that is fine but that doesn't equal better.
Yes, but ...
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
For the sake of the observers to this conversation so they don't conclude that "yellow glue" has no advantages, yellow Titebond has these advantages:
1. Substantially stronger under ambient high temperature and humidity conditions (data reported from University of Maryland Furniture Conservation department)
2. Stronger in M&T joinery (data from Franklin technical manual on furniture gluing)
Ultimate strength is not always as important as strong enough for the purposes. The ability to undo/reverse the glued joint may far more relevant, which is what my situation demonstrated.
It may be useful to determine (I look forward to comments) what is important to have reversible and what is not. For example, glueing up panels (edge glueing) may be something where yellow glue is preferred over hide glue (for strength) ... but I can also see arguments for the case of hyde glue over yellow glue (e.g. ease of clean up and protection of finish, rubbed joints not needing clamps).
Regards from Perth
Derk
Some corrections to hide assumptions
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I got set straight on reversibility by the professional furniture repairer in our club. He stated that he can disassemble a yellow glue M&T joint with no more effort than hide glue joint. Skeptical, I tried it and he is correct. Actually, we should know that. Yellow glue washes out of clothes and glue brushes readily with warm water, so it follows that it will soften with steam and/or heat. We also know that it can act as a "hot melt" if veneering with an iron.
For example, glueing up panels (edge glueing) may be something where yellow glue is preferred over hide glue (for strength)....No significant strength difference in this application in a simple shear test. (Franklin data)
... but I can also see arguments for the case of hyde glue over yellow glue (e.g. ease of clean up and protection of finish, rubbed joints not needing clamps).
Rubbed joints work with PVA glue as well as hide. (statement from the Headley shop folks who use PVA glue for corner blocking, as well as my experience)
The loss of hide glue strength under the warm soggy conditions of our southern coastal states is not some, but substantial (data Delaware University )
One other advantage of hide glue
Paul in NJ
Joints slip together much easier than pva glue. Oh and another: you can modify the open time and not be so rushed gluing a complicated assembly.
Paul Dzioba
Question
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I have no experience with hot hide. Do M&T joints slip easily with this glue? Now liquid hide is wonderful for M&T joints or any slide together joint. It is like greasing a joint, as you say. I use it in complex assemblies that slide together. That said, I have learned to fit joints better than I used to. If they don't come largely together with hand forces or gentle tapping they get fixed before assembly (a lesson learned in the Headley shop, maybe the most useful lesson).
Any PVA glue set time can be retarded once! by the addition of 5% water with no loss of joint strength (Franklin technical publication)
Re: Question
Paul in NJ
Joints made with hot hide glue slip together easily just like liquid hide. However it gels quickly depending on temperature. Sometimes you need to warm the wood beforehand.
Paul Dzioba
Re: Some corrections to hide assumptions
R. Payne
Hide glue can be made water resistant.
I've never had any success reversing a PVA glue. I've weakened the joint so it could be taken apart but that isn't the same as reversing the glue. If I reverse a hide glue joint I can use the very same glue that was in the joint before to re-glue the joint. So far as my experience goes, that can't be done with PVA but rather all the old PVA has to be removed for the joint to hold.
I've also not had either Tightbond 1 or Tightbond 2 was out of clothes. Haven't tried 3.
You've chosen a glue that is adequate for many things because it is convenient but that doesn't mean it is superior. Neither is hide superior in all applications.
glue removal
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I think you are confusing what is being washed. Titebond II cross links during cure and it is indeed irreversible, and, as is the case of all cross linked polymers it is insoluble in everything. Titebond regular forms a reversible crosslinking during cure. This crosslinking is temporarily destroyed upon heating with moisture. I have washed countless glue brushes containing dried Titebond. My pants are a handy place to wipe fingers and they too have had countless applications of glue washed out.
One of these days I am going to explore the possible myth that cured PVA glue must be removed before anything will stick. I pre-seal miters with glue and I have sized veneer with glue prior to permanent adhesion. There is nothing that I know about the molecular details of PVA adhesion that would prevent regluing a cured glue surface but it remains to be seen if the claims are true. If anyone has data lets hear about it.
Re: Here are not a single advantage
TomD
"1. Substantially stronger under ambient high temperature and humidity conditions (data reported from University of Maryland Furniture Conservation department)"
That is funny. Hide glue comes in various strengths, the weaker of which are normally preferred. The 180. Stronger varieties are capable of spaling glass. Certainly hide glue is better in high strength applications like lutherie, though Titebond 1 is a yellow glue that is well regarded for that use, but not superior. High heat and humidity are not places I would use T1 I would go for a high glass transition temp epoxy. Mostly these conditions are not that condusive to fine woodwork.
2. Stronger in M&T joinery (data from Franklin technical manual on furniture gluing)
Consider the source. I would find that doubtful since M&Ts can work without glue, I would think the failure mode would be fatigue where hide glue excels.
3. Shelf life of years in ready to use condition (my experience)
I just chucked out a whole large bottle I thought was only a year old. I couldn't read the date info. I don't know what happened to it. What I would say is that many high end glue users buy a 50 pound bag of hide glue and learn it' character, and they will have a lifetime supply. Titebond is not easy to find around here though I have one source nearby. Today was a busy day and to re-up the glue was a hassle compared to dipping into a bag. The thing with the DIY glue approach is yeah, maybe an individual pot goes off, but you are in control and know where you stand., I was convinced I had a fresh unopend litre bottle. I buy one at once a year, and the dregs go to kids and their crafts. But something went wrong, presumably I forgot how old it was, and now I am running around spending money and taking time on a busy days with birthdays, university applications, a graduation etc...
4. Easier to use in a cold shop, but not too cold (Franklin technical manual)
Turns chalky around joints. Hide glue is a means of adding heat to the joint, and excess glue can be recycled, not seeing the problem.
5. Essentially no learning curve to successful usage
Not true. Or we wouldn't have this thread. Glue is a constant learning experience. One thing you need to learn is to use Ti, it is the only stuff I use, and very easily confused with stuff in the T line and other junk out there.
6. Preprepared and ready to use.
Sure if you don't do much woodwork. And another way of putting this is that it goes downhill badly from the moment you get it, and you never know when it will hit the air to volume point and go bad. It is convenient until it isn't, but it isn't fresh, depends on your standards I guess. I imagine part of it's reputation relies on the fact that in larger shops they run through gallons/drums of the stuff so the perishability isn't a problem. Hide glue is like maing a fresh cup of coffee or tea. They sell both in a can for people who want it, but fresh has it's point. The whole reason I got into the habit of buying more than a year's supply and tossing it whether I had used it or not was to avoid exactly the problem I just had.
I expect that 5&6 are the reasons most people use it.
Re: Some corrections to hide weaknesses
TomD
"I got set straight on reversibility by the professional furniture repairer in our club. He stated that he can disassemble a yellow glue M&T joint with no more effort than hide glue joint. Skeptical, I tried it and he is correct. Actually, we should know that. Yellow glue washes out of clothes and glue brushes readily with warm water, so it follows that it will soften with steam and/or heat. We also know that it can act as a "hot melt" if veneering with an iron."
You are contradicting yourself, where earlier you pointed out that you couldn't wash out, only dilute, so the fact yellow doesn't glue well to yellow is still an issue. With hide you have several means of reversing, or can go direct to a restoration by merely reactivating. And in some restoration work you need to use original type materials, which is a separate issue, but hide glue gives you all the options.
My main quibble with the restore thing is that it depends on finding the right level of restoration. one can go all hie glue but someone may still hit your masterpiece with chair doctor.
"For example, glueing up panels (edge glueing) may be something where yellow glue is preferred over hide glue (for strength)....No significant strength difference in this application in a simple shear test. (Franklin data)"
One problem with all this is that there isn't just one hide glue, there are many. Another is a simple shear test? What is that? Failure modes in gluing panels that cause me the most trouble are elastic creep. And I am not alone in this there is plenty of science out there you can read up on. T1 is good, but hide and epoxies are better.
"... but I can also see arguments for the case of hyde glue over yellow glue (e.g. ease of clean up and protection of finish, rubbed joints not needing clamps)."
While I do plenty of rubbed joints with PVA. There is a difference in at least the stuff I use. When a hide glue joint grabs it is done, when PVA grabs it can easily be separated. This is key when doing stuff like rubbing the braces on the inside of a guitar. In practice, I notice folks use go-bars and vac to place PVA braces, but there is tons of history of just rubbing hide glued braces. I would not sell a rubbed guitar, though I rub my soundboards center joint and I would sell those. More learning curve stuff. Having a failure of a brace in an internet world would not be a good deal. People know that isn't supposed to happen.
"Rubbed joints work with PVA glue as well as hide. (statement from the Headley shop folks who use PVA glue for corner blocking, as well as my experience)"
Why do they prefer the PVA?
"The loss of hide glue strength under the warm soggy conditions of our southern coastal states is not some, but substantial (data Delaware University )"
There is some woodwork that needs to be kept in constant climate control, and then there is epoxy.
Re: glue removal
TomD
"One of these days I am going to explore the possible myth that cured PVA glue must be removed before anything will stick. I pre-seal miters with glue and I have sized veneer with glue prior to permanent adhesion. There is nothing that I know about the molecular details of PVA adhesion that would prevent regluing a cured glue surface but it remains to be seen if the claims are true. If anyone has data lets hear about it."
That would be interesting, there would be a range of criteria like what activates it, would heat have to be involved, and how would that work. You dangled an interesting idea about heat activating these glues. My experience with T1 is that it is not easy to get out of stuff. Hide will reverse very easily, but is stronger than T1 in use. Liek if you glued a plate on a violin with T1, just how much heat and steam are we talking about. Neck resets on guitars are an area where it's no huge problem, there is plenty of containment for the steam, and there is room to rebuld and refit if one had to, but not everything is that forgiving. There would be issues like shrinkage rates, betwen the new and old.
I have a wide range of reasons for having switched to T1, part of it was to use a glue in guitars when I was doing that, that I would not have to worry about that was industry standard. One thing there, like single blades, and breakers, and all that faddish stuff. I switched at the wrong time. The other guys caught up. Now one has to defend using plastic glues. So at the end of the day, if that carries on, it may not mater what the lab says if the fad, and reality marks T1 as second class. There fact there are serious makers like Derek who have been put off from the struggle (and if you aren't in the US sourcing all the hide related clutter is expensive), shows that some of the reasons that people stick with plastic is convenience not quality.
Hot and liquid hide glue learning curve
wilbur
As part of a Bible box group build project that our woodworking club did a few years ago, we had a session on learning how to use hot hide glue to do hammer veneering.
How easy is it? After the guys leading the build demonstrated how to do hammer veneering, my older boy was the first one among us to give it a try. He hit it out of the park.
There you have it. Hot hide glue — so easy to work with, even a nine year-old can do it!
As far as the learning curve for liquid hide glue, I pretty much open the bottle and use it. That’s the learning curve.
Some alternative information
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
In the case of your class presumably someone prepared the glue ready for use and the ambient conditions were acceptable as judged by the experienced instructor. Additionally, the experience required to assemble a case piece under varying shop conditions might be greater than for sticking a piece of veneer on a flat surface.

At the recent SAPFM meeting Al Breed demonstrated hot hide veneering a banded oval into the center of a mitered field for a curved Federal drawer. The hot hide glue made achieving the final pattern straightforward but I would need lots of practice to do it myself. The veneered pieces were small, yet Al had to deal with some stubborn bubbles under the larger pieces. Once mastered there is no doubt that hide glue was the best way to do this pattern. If I was to desire building a drawer of this style I would master hot hide veneering. But I sure would not attempt it for the first time on a finished and fitted drawer.
At another SAPFM meeting Al Sharp (Cartouche winner) demonstrated hammer veneering a large curved drawer. He failed to get one end to stick properly. I have no doubt that In his shop he would have eventually got it stuck, but I concluded that what he was trying to do was not trivial to do with hot hide.
A friend hired Bob Millard (famous Federal maker) to stick some spectacular crotch veneer to two secretary doors. After 2 days of trying he failed, concluding in his blog that the veneer had some problem. I took the two spare pieces of this veneer to my class with Jeff Headley. He cut it to shape, slathered white glue on it with a paint brush and stuck it into a vacuum bag. It stuck fine. I can do that I concluded.
From these experiences I bought a vacuum bag and have since successfully stuck everything I have tried to stick using the information and technique I learned from Jeff. (see my Gallery pictures and furniture building posts for proof of results)
I presume these discussions are helpful to woodworkers that build stuff who are in the process of deciding how to do this or that. At least that is the target audience for me. I have no desire to change someone's mind that already has mastered some technique.
Re: Some corrections to hide assumptions
Warren in Lancaster, PA
I got set straight on reversibility by the professional furniture repairer in our club. He stated that he can disassemble a yellow glue M&T joint with no more effort than hide glue joint.
On Wednesday I disassembled a frame and panel door that had been put together with hide glue. A few sharp blows and the glue shattered, I put fresh glue right on top of the old and put it back together. Taking the door off the hinges and screwing it back on was the greater part of the repair. No warm water, no chemicals, no heating up the joint, no steam. I don't think you have much experience with this stuff.
Last week I repaired a similar door that was put together with yellow glue. I did not take the door apart, so I had to do a much more awkward repair. It was for a very dear friend, otherwise I would have rejected the work. Life is too short to fool around with junk.
The use of hide glue does take skill. Once in while some guy will write on this forum that he needs a half hour of "open time". Or you see a glued up assembly with more than a dozen clamps. To glue a large carcass with hot glue one needs some experience and an assistant, even a six year old, is helpful.
How hard it is to make hot hide glue
wilbur
Pour some hide glue in your glue pot.
Add water until it’s about 1/4” above the glue. Soak it for a while.
Turn on the glue pot and wait 15 minutes or so.
If it’s too thick, add more water.
That’s it.
My son can do this as well. Of course, this is the exact same process for making rice in a rice cooker, and we’re Chinese, so I guess we do have an unfair advantage. 
Is this more involved than opening a bottle of PVA glue? Sure. But it’s not rocket science, either. I like to provide this information because it might be helpful to woodworkers that build stuff who are in the process of deciding how to do this or that. At least that is the target audience for me as well.
Re: How hard it is to make hot hide glue
Bruce McCrory
I let my son cook the rice.... 
Thanks, Wilbur, for both laughs....
Re: glue removal
R. Payne
I know very well which glue was which. After I got out of the army I spent a couple years working as a trim carpenter where Tightbond 1 was used and I didn't have a shop of my own so I know the jeans that had glue stiffened spots until the jeans wore out was from Tightbond 1. It didn't wash out of the clothes. Maybe you do laundry with stronger chemicals than I do.
ron
Are you using clamps?
Tom Colligan
When using hide glue in the situations being discussed are you also using clamps?
Would there be a difference whether using hot hide glue or Franklin hide glue?
Re: Are you using clamps?
Warren in Lancaster, PA
For hide glue I sometimes use clamps just to pull things tight, and sometimes leave a clamp in place for a minute or so. I think historical work was often done without out clamps; it is certainly feasible and reasonable to work that way.
I received a free bottle of Franklin "liquid hide" glue around 1983. My recollection is that it did not work well for rubbed joints and that it needed clamps for a significant time. Probably someone with more experience could handle it better. I would say that concerning assembly, the advantages of hide glue are lost when using the liquid stuff.
Re: Are you using clamps?
TomD
I sometimes wonder with liquid hide glue if we should really think of them in the same sentence with hot. Certainly there a similarities, but the are similarities with T1 and hot hide. To me it is a different thought process. I think this shows some of the issues, assuming it is liquid which seems to be the case.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ug3Tsn45Ao0
Re: Some alternative information
North of the Border
Your point is well acknowledged by my peers as we do a lot of complex glue-ups. To many (amateur) woodworkers, glue is glue and how hard can it be, largely because their builds seldom are complex in the eyes of production furniture makers.
Ask Michael Fortune and he'll tell you if glue-up is that simple as some think, everyone can build furniture like him.
When someone says you open a glue bottle and apply it to the mating pieces, the assembly is done; you can be sure they have never really done enough difficult glue-ups. Why? Because they have had success with their projects (limited in terms of scale and difficulty) and never have to deal with failures. Ask any seasoned furniture makers who handle not just small scale or straight and flat assemblies and they'll tell you the glue-up is a nerve-wrecking and difficult stage of woodworking.
I use liquid high glue for difficult glue-ups, but no longer hide glue and I like it.
Re: Some alternative information
TomD
Talking about difficult and nerve racking assemblies. Just finishing up a small cabin for a boat 6' x 6' x 3'.
Using multiple different version of epoxy. It's like cutting hair where you are balancing several tools in various parts of your hands, while working with stuff like sticky honey, while particularly in the hot weather there is a clock ticking all the time as one juggles several different pots of goo, while making all sorts of decisions on the fly as to what needs to happen next, you have endgrain that needs sizing, surfaces that need coating, fillets that need making and structural glass to get into place.
I was looking at the inside of the thing and determined there were 200 feet of interior seams, no wonder the glueing took several days. And it isn't over yet.
Re: Some corrections to hide assumptions
North of the Border
I was surprised by your assertion that yellow glue could be reversed. The glue manufacturers have stated the otherwise.
But you didn't say whether the glue was cured (over 48 hrs?) before you tired the reversing. I doubt it. My peers who tried to take apart a glued joint (after 24 hrs?) with water and heat gun got the expected result: glue was stronger than wood. No one in my trade has ever succeeded in reversing yellow glue. Was the glue you used fresh or spoiled (without you noticing it)?
We have a few restorers we work with here and none of them have been on record to say they have had the experience of the restorer about yellow glue you quoted. I would have them try out such possibility.
to repeat
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
If you are skeptical you could do as I did and try it. It is no more difficult to undo a mortise and tenon glued with yellow or white glue than hide. Drill a hole, insert needle, apply steam and in short order the glue softens and the joint can be pulled apart, just like Buddy Floyd (FurnitureWithHistory.com) said it would. Your skeptical furniture restorers can contact him directly for confirmation, or they could simply try it themselves.
I forget to wash glue brushes all the time. Not a problem. Some hot water and the glue softens and comes right out.
I have a detailed knowledge of the yellow and white glue chemistry. There is nothing about it to suggest that it should not be easy to take a joint apart with steam. No permanent chemical bonds are formed when the glue cures. So it is simply a matter of getting the glue polymer above its glass transition temperature with water and heat and the glue becomes a viscous liquid and flows.
"I was surprised by your assertion that yellow glue could be reversed." The glue manufacturers have stated the otherwise. " Where can I find this claim? It is not made in any of the Franklin literature I have.