New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

Posts

Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

#1

Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

Gary

Is anyone out there woodworking strictly by hand?

First off a disclaimer; I'm not a true Neanderthal. I've been a professional woodworker for 15 years, but I've relocated recently. I'm currently renting a house, and have a very small garage work shop area. Too small for any stationary power tools to speak of. Our shop at work is geared for melamine, laminate and plastics...not solid wood.

What i do have is a solid 7' antique bench, with a front vise and end vise, and my assortment of hand tools...(joinery saws, chisels, planes, etc.) Can I add a few tools and make a go of it? I'm not planning on making kitchen cabinets or anything crazy, but I'd like to make some smaller pieces of furniture.

I was thinking of adding a good rip saw (5 1/2 point?), and something like lee valleys small plow plane for grooves. Comments from the forum are welcome!

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

#2

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

Steve Voigt

Hi Gary,

I think there are very few who earn a living from handtools only, though Warren Mickley, who frequents these boards, is one of them. But there are lots and lots of people who use handtools only for hobby woodworking. Is that what you are talking about?

Anyway, there are plenty of people on this board who work only by hand, like Warren and Wiley Horne, and others (like me) who work mostly by hand. There are lots of good blogs too, by Joshua Klein, Zach Dillinger, Bob Rozaiski, and others. So, plenty of information to help you on your way. Go for it!

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

#3

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

Gary B

Hi Steve,

Sorry i didn't clarify. Yes this is for my hobby only...I'd love my cnc routers at work, but it seems it would be good for my soul to decompress with hand tools as a hobby. I'll look into those you mentioned! Thanks again!

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

#4

Another good source for handtool only ww......

roger lance

is Tom Fidgen on YouTube....look for summertime handtool essentials - the unplugged woodshop.

Tom has a number of videos on youtube that make for relaxing, educational viewing. However, he also has some videos that he sells.....and we know how that can induce some negative emotions in some.....

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

#5

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

Brian Holcombe

I'm at about 95% hand tools at this point, and once I acquire a few more I should be at 100%. It's taken me about 5 years to make the transition and I'm glad that I have. It is much more satisfying to me to feel as if I'm raising my abilities rather than continuously looking for hobby level machinery which leaves a lot to be desired and in itself requires a huge investment in space.

It has caused me a few addictions, chisel addiction, sharpening stone addiction, Gennou addiction, and hand plane addiction. Unfortunately there is no such group as 'hand tools anonymous'.

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

#6

Yes and no.....try it and see

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Can one? Of course. There has never been finer furniture built than what was made in the 1700 and 1800 with only hand tools........and lots of highly experienced and skilled labor, acquiring this experience many hours a day for I suppose 6 days a week.

Could I? No. I lack the skill and time to learn and build only with hand tools. The typical pieces of furniture I have made in the past 10 years will have about 75 separate wood parts. I can not imagine the time to size each by hand. It takes me long enough to do the fitting by hand.

No one can answer this question for you. Try it and see. If your motivation is life style wood woodworking you will figure out something to build that will only involve hand tools, chairs for example. If your motivation it to make stuff, you will figure out how to get grunt work done on a machine somewhere.

In the end, have fun.

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

#7

Re: Another good source for handtool only ww......

Joe shelton

I've seen some of Tom's video, and he's interesting.

He and Mark at Bad Axe have a venture now that goes to the question of working only with hand tools. They've collaborated on a frame saw and kerfing tool to 'spool up' ripping. My expectation is that, if Mark is doing it, it is impeccable.

But I'm not selling my bandsaw.

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

#8

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Gary

When you build for production, machines save you time. When you are older, machines save you energy. If you are willing to learn the methods and strategies that go with handtools, the work you produce will be as accurate as a machine. A few on this forum build exclusively with handtools, but the majority use machines as well in varying degrees.

My own hobby workshop has added a few machines over the past few years to aid in preparation and dimensioning of larger timbers, and I focus my handwork on shaping and joinery. There is no longer any romance for me in the basic preparation of boards. I have the space for a combination jointer-thicknesser/planer. If I did not, I would try and squeeze in a 14" bandsaw for rough cutting, ripping and re-sawing (aka thicknessing). The remainder is fun to do with a bench for planing, bench hooks for sawing, shooting board for squaring, and a Moxon dovetailing vise. Handplanes, scrapers and spokeshaves provide a finish that cannot be matched by sanders and often are quicker than the time taken to set up machines. I would much rather create grooves, dados, rebates, and moldings by hand than machine - faster, cleaner, and more pleasant by far.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

#9

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have worked by hand all my life. I think those who have started with machine work are at a little disadvantage. They often start with the machine techniques and work backwards, rather than taking a fresh look from a hand tool perspective or looking to historic methods. It seems like I am occasionally saying on this forum "That is machine tool thinking" rather than hand tool thinking. I am afraid that if I gave examples others would argue about the specific examples rather than looking at the broad concept. Hand tool workers can also work at a faster pace, partly because the risk of injury is so much less that they can work without so much caution.

Of course there is some tiring work and some drudgery with handwork, but I would say two things: one is that if you are sawing long cuts, it makes you a better sawyer and improves your sawing on more delicate work. Likewise planing for stock preparation makes you a better at planing when skill is helpful. So the time is not really wasted. The other thing is that hand work is dependent on finesse. It is working in such a way that material is removed efficiently, that the edge of the tool is preserved, that the workers energy and strength is preserved.

Years ago my Dad used to tell a story about forking hay onto a wagon. He was 16 working one side, his grandmother was 74 working the other. Somehow she was always faster than he, but she never seemed to be working as hard.

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

#10

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

Gary

That's a great story Warren,

I've seen that too. We have a older guy at the shop that never looks like he's working too hard, but two younger guys can't keep up with his productivity....he's developed a cadence that works for him in that area. This is an area of the shop that is 80% operator and 20% machine.

Yesterday afternoon, I took some 3/4" pine and ripped a 20" long piece with the 8 pt handsaw I recently refurbished. I don't have a saw bench so I tried overhand with the piece dogged to my bench. It wasn't as smooth as I'd like, I think I'll be making a saw bench soon. I can see I'll also need to make some bench hooks and other "Jigs". Anyways, when I "jointed" the sawn edge with my #5, I realized after the fifth stroke my iron was set much too shallow. After I deepened it, 1 swipe left the edge nice and straight, then 1 more got it square to the face. 2 swipes with a smoothing plane made an edge that made me smile!

Last night I watched some videos on the Shannon's website about his higher bench with the moxon vise, seems like a great addition if you have the room. He also mentioned he uses a hybrid milling technique, flattening the boards, then using a thickness planer. I may consider purchasing a small lunch box planer (and dub it "the apprentice" hahaha) , and doing this. I also read about a great way to make octagonal handles for old chisels (have two that need this) on Mr Dillinger's site.

Thanks for all the great advise on this forum! It's truly a great site. I look forward to updating you all with my progress. Let the Journey begin!

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

#11

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

Charlie

Of course it's feasible. It was done that way far longer than it has been done by machines. If you don't have room for power tools in your home workshop then what is your other choice, just give it up altogether? That would be a real shame. Don't get caught up in what I call the 'time comparison' game, where your mind constantly compares the time to complete a certain step with the time it might have taken had you used a machine. Just go out in the shop and do the work and let it proceed.

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

#12

That is machine tool thinking

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This thinking extends to the design phase as well. When thickness and sizing is trivial there is little consideration in project choice and design detail for whether the result has lots of precisely made pieces with lots of thicknesses fitting into precisely machined spaces, or not. While I don't know this to be a fact I suspect that someone building a Period chest on chest from a picture in a power tool equipped shop would come up with design details, especially in the internals, that were substantially different from the original. I am speculating that the original would be more efficient.(I have never seen this topic discussed/ researched, hence the speculation)

The opposite I know to be true. Some operations and designs are trivial to the skilled hand tool user and these operations/designs will be employed in a piece executed by someone with at least some hand tool skills, and avoided by the power only shop.

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

#13

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible? *LINK*

JDK

Here is an excellent contribution to this discussion by Paul Sellers, who is a hand-tool evangelist. If you search his blog for "hand tools vs machines" you'll find many more such entries.


Paul Sellers on Hand Tools vs. Machines

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

#14

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

Brian Holcombe

I can attest to what Warren has said, I have taken to dimensioning entirely by hand. The effort is quite intense, but it has greatly improve my awareness of the tools. The extended effort has put myself and my tools through the paces and in doing so has shown me what is important and what is unimportant in order for me to accomplish the task well.

It has certainly caused me to change up a lot of how I was doing things in planning and processing.

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

#15

Couple things

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi all,

Better start with a disclaimer: I do many operations by hand, but depend on the bandsaw for rough ripping and anything curved. Also, it's slightly embarrassing to be mentioned in the same sentence with Warren.

On the main question, I think Warren makes a telling point about starting with machines, and then substituting. Hand work and machine work are really two different environments--almost everything changes if you go full handwork. Full handwork is a reenactment of 18th century strategies (though the tools have changed, the strategy would not). It is amazing to me to study the old Price Books, where furniture prices and descriptions can be combined with knowledge of wage rates at the time, so as to back out a rough estimate of how many hours of heads-down work went into a 4-drawer chest, say, with cockbeaded drawers and molded top or stringing on top (options were listed with prices for each). As I recall, a piece like this might work out to four days labor or so.

You can't do what they did back in the day, if you make machine-work by hand. The strategy is different. You can of course do it as a hobby, where time doesn't matter. To do handwork as a professional, I suspect it would take a fairly lengthy apprenticeship with someone already doing it.

Wiley

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

#16

Re: Yes and no...try it and see - did they really

TomD

"Can one? Of course. There has never been finer furniture built than what was made in the 1700 and 1800 with only hand tools........and lots of highly experienced and skilled labor, acquiring this experience many hours a day for I suppose 6 days a week."

I have wondered about that, and those of you with many friends in the history biz might comment, but I am not sure to what extent earlier folks did it all by hand. So there are several levels to this.

- one would be whether they had other hands that did stuff. Apprentices, wood suppliers, slaves, oxen whatever.

- The other would be the existence of actual machines. I was surprised to come across a reference in one of CS's books to a large grinding machine someone had set up in town, and how it was worth a look. Machines existed at an earlier time also, though exactly how early and in what overlay to the period of the "greatest furniture" I don't know.

- A third would be skills related. It may have all been done by hand but to what extent by the same hands. When I say today I built a piece, whether by hand or not, I don't mean me and the five most experienced folks I know built it. I mean I did. But to what extent in the period of greatest furniture was stuff built by different trades: Cabinet makers; carvers, painters, polishers, guilders etc... So if by made by hand you mean the skill side, that is one thing, or the effort side, that is another.

"Could I? No. I lack the skill and time to learn and build only with hand tools. The typical pieces of furniture I have made in the past 10 years will have about 75 separate wood parts. I can not imagine the time to size each by hand. It takes me long enough to do the fitting by hand."

Time is an issue, then as now, but skill there isn't any greater skill to either side of the fence. Particularly in simpler stuff. I can't carve, and I am not sufficiently interested to learn, but just making boxes, guitars and ... stuff, not sure it is any harder by hand.

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

#17

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

TomD

I certainly do various projects entirely by hand, particularly in the summer when I move to the farm, and have ready access to green wood, and minimal access to tools.

If you are concerned about a method, that tends to imply you are less concerned about the result, not in the sense you would accept bad work. But it is like a bike trip. I just came back from the farm the other day 1600 KM overnight in a car. I have done the same trip twice by bike. Clearly if you have the option of doing it by car the reason you go by bike is the experience, or the exercise, something related to the method. Not only can I go by car, but I can tow a yacht. the car is a far more efficient method. The car method only lasted a few hours, but I wouldn't say it was easier, or less challenging. It is tough to go at it for 16+ hours at 110KM with hardly a break. The bike is also tough, particularly head winds, and hills, but just different.

I built my first hand saw resaw back in the 80s, and when something broke at the farm, my Uncke would send my dad out with an axe and directions to a particular tree. Are supposed to be impressed if someone does something with hand tools? Try sculpting with a disc grinder. In essence the hand tool revival has reduced hand tool woodworking to power tool woodworking, in the sense that it is currently easy to learn how to leverage a few tools to get good results. What people previously did with table saw and router.

It just depends what you want to do and expect to get out of it. If you have a good bench you have what most people in the past (1970-80s) didn't. I remember trying to get one when mostly all I had was hand tools and it is a big job. (plus back in the hand tool era, someone else had a bench and tools one could use to make the bench, while today, people are often building the shop and acquiring tools and skills all at once. Even with the internet that isn't nothing) Funnily enough I ordered a stack of raw beech and the guy used my cut list and delivered every piece to dimension including laminating. I hadn't thought I could afford to ask for that, and I wanted the experience myself, but probably would have dragged the project out over a long time if I had had to do it all by myself. Even on this board I would say 5 years ago a lot of guys were still dealing with solid core door benches.

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

#18

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

TomD

Or do get caught up in that game because factoring the cost of power tools, the space they require for efficient use, the installation, maintenance and clean-up, it is far from clear that they save much if any time. This is another thing about our favourite tool (from the sound of it), the bandsaw: set up vertically so small footprint; easy to extract; quiet as these things go; does not have a big X axis due to throat restrictions; etc...

But I also think this is part of the objective thing. If you want to say limit yourself to fly fishing, and make a living as a commercial fisherman, that might be a limitation, but you can find situations to fish, in which fly fishing is highly effective, and if you enjoy it more than other forms, go for it. As an experience it is not limiting, and as a tool it isn't either. Fly fishing allows you to pick the whole line up and drop it back down in one motion. That is more efficient than casting if the structure you are fishing is highly defined, like the middle of a river, or the edge of lilly pads. You just have to choose your situation. Splitting wood is a lot more efficient than re-sawing it, and for efficiency sake, you would have to choose an activity like windsor chair making, or ladder back chairs where the hand tool methods are more efficient. Don't get caught up doing power tool woodworking by hand. So last fall for fun, I cut out a 16 foot plywood strake for my Flats Boat project with a Japanese hand saw, it was easy to do, but it is a material and process that really begs for a jigsaw (or CNC). I do use planes a lot to fair the jigsaw edge, though.

Re: Is Hand tool only woodworking feasible?

#19

No, not anymore..

Joe shelton

I just (finally) looked up William Duffield's sticking board, and I've seen the light. I must have a Festool Domino. The big one.

Thanks, William, that's a great idea, beautifully executed.

Joe