Re: Yes and no...try it and see - did they really
TomD
"Can one? Of course. There has never been finer furniture built than what was made in the 1700 and 1800 with only hand tools........and lots of highly experienced and skilled labor, acquiring this experience many hours a day for I suppose 6 days a week."
I have wondered about that, and those of you with many friends in the history biz might comment, but I am not sure to what extent earlier folks did it all by hand. So there are several levels to this.
- one would be whether they had other hands that did stuff. Apprentices, wood suppliers, slaves, oxen whatever.
- The other would be the existence of actual machines. I was surprised to come across a reference in one of CS's books to a large grinding machine someone had set up in town, and how it was worth a look. Machines existed at an earlier time also, though exactly how early and in what overlay to the period of the "greatest furniture" I don't know.
- A third would be skills related. It may have all been done by hand but to what extent by the same hands. When I say today I built a piece, whether by hand or not, I don't mean me and the five most experienced folks I know built it. I mean I did. But to what extent in the period of greatest furniture was stuff built by different trades: Cabinet makers; carvers, painters, polishers, guilders etc... So if by made by hand you mean the skill side, that is one thing, or the effort side, that is another.
"Could I? No. I lack the skill and time to learn and build only with hand tools. The typical pieces of furniture I have made in the past 10 years will have about 75 separate wood parts. I can not imagine the time to size each by hand. It takes me long enough to do the fitting by hand."
Time is an issue, then as now, but skill there isn't any greater skill to either side of the fence. Particularly in simpler stuff. I can't carve, and I am not sufficiently interested to learn, but just making boxes, guitars and ... stuff, not sure it is any harder by hand.