New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

Posts

Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#1

Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

david weaver

(hand tool woodworking community, that is).

Off topic, I've cut back on my forum viewing to mostly this forum, because discussions on here stay on track and there isn't an overarching editing machine trying to keep the views up at the cost of content, which also limits ridiculous responses from people who have little or no experience but assert that "everyone is correct".

But I saw something today that confirms why I don't attend woodworking events and why I so value being able to get advice from the warrens and the georges far above and beyond social gatherings.

I was reading another forum, and noticed that someone said they had tickets to see the studley chest and bench for sale.

Tickets? Like Pay? Are you kidding me?

I looked it up, and it's $25 to just look at (and photograph, apparently) the chest and talk to curators. Not $25 to see several dozen things, but to see pictures of a chest and bench that have been talked to death. It is advertised that the ticket revenue is the cost of providing the items to look at, and they very well may be, though I don't know what "the cost of providing the event" might be, it probably includes renting space from someone, apparently in "a barn" this time, and transporting and insuring a one of a kind item or two.

But, say you go into the event with your spouse or a child, you drop $50 to see something there are already a million photographs of?

And add this to the cynical part of me, I'm sure that at least one person (or a dozen) will take a video of it and use it to promote themselves on youtube, and attempt to insert themselves in the information flow as some kind of authority without a tiny fraction of any true accomplishment.

The amount of "the customer is always ripe" and shameless self promotion (often trying to sell things, like plans or videos or to generate views on youtube) by the unaccomplished is really disappointing to me. I think it's extremely misleading to beginners, especially.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#2

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT

Steve Voigt

Hmm. I agree with you in general about the amount of "shameless self-promotion" in woodworking, particularly when it comes to monthly video subscriptions, "premium" content, etc. But I don't agree in this specific instance.

The Studley chest has to be worth 7 figures, or I am way off. Transporting something like that across the country is very expensive; you don't just load it in a van; you contract with companies who only do that kind of work. You need security around the clock; when the exhibit closes for the night, you don't just lock the door and go home. So, I think the people putting this on really do need to get a bunch of revenue for the exhibit, otherwise they will get soaked.

I believe another purpose of the tickets is to control the number of people viewing at any particular moment, so you don't get a scrum of people trying to stick their heads in the chest.

And sure, you can look at photographs, but you can also look at photographs of every painting in MOMA or the met, but people still go to those museums, because seeing the works in the flesh is something else entirely.

No, I understand your ire, but as I say I think it's better directed at people who are using blogs and web pages designed to suck you into "premium" content and paying $20 a month for things you can learn for free via the public library.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#3

Re: I agree...

david weaver

..there is an element of the studley chest that is legitimate way above and beyond some amateur or never-producing "pro" woodworker showing their bench build with lag screws and router jigs.

It's not so much just the studley chest and the $25 fee for 50 minutes of wonder but don't touch, but the relative circus atmosphere or "pay to know" things that aren't very spectacular. In this case, the chest is fairly spectacular as far as individual items go, but it is not, for example, any better than the type of work that a George would do (and there are many Georges, we just don't get to know them).

One thing that irritated me about leg vises before coming here was a complete lack of technical discussion about a leg vise in practical use and what it will be like in two decades. I'm not surprised that warren answered the questions exactly as i had them, I expected he would.

It's funny that I had seen lars's video and it was one of the few where he didn't just copy something someone else did and attempt to insert himself as the personality (as in, I don't remember any other video that I thought was interesting).

Sort of reminds me of people authoritatively talking about what they do with their benches and planes and then taking a bunch of random smoother strokes on a white pine board.

Separate and apart is the entire discussion of starting people right from the start on understanding visual standards in their work, and that they can learn to see what looks good and what doesn't right away - without having to know who the maker was or what particular style it is.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#4

Re: I agree...

RK near Boston

Let them pay. It is a social event.

My grandmother was taking care of a farm and she always wondered why people pay money to watch 22 grown men running after one ball for 90 minutes. That was 80's, now people pay many more millions to those men and so it goes:)

Talking about design, just look around. I always wonder who designs our strip malls and ugly developments, hard to develop a good eye growing up around stuff like that. I am in Northeast so there are quite many good looking old houses, but went to grad school in Texas and lot of stuff is just not pretty.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#5

Re: I agree with that, too!..

david weaver

That a lot of what is built now is just horrific looking.

I can't imagine what people will think of it in 30 years.

The comparison here in the city, the buildings that were built in the early 1900s still look excellent. The buildings that were built in the 1960s are hideous.

Design up to that point (the early 1900s) seems to have been an incremental thing, pulling from principles who knows how many centuries old. Then, and it's fairly common given the age of buildings in this city and a lot of others, suddenly the 1950s and 60s occurred and the buildings started to look like upside down bathtubs or who knows what.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#6

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT

wilbur

"But, say you go into the event with your spouse or a child, you drop $50 to see something there are already a million photographs of?"

As one of those foolish enough to drop money for this event, here’s my reasons to lay out the cash for this trip.

First, the Studley chest isn’t in a museum. It belongs to an individual who has not really made the chest available for people to view except for a few occasions (New Yankee Workshop episode, photographers for the FWW poster, and maybe a few other occasions that I’m not aware of). I’m not sure that this opportunity is going to come along again anytime soon, so now is the time that the iron is hot, and I’m striking.

Second, regardless of how many photos there are, it’s not like looking at the real thing. I’ve been lucky enough to get a glimpse of some of the photos that are going into Don Williams’ book on the Studley chest, and even though they are of extremely high quality and show a greater degree of detail than any photos of the chest that are available now, there’s nothing like looking at the real thing live and in person.

I learned this lesson when it came to Greene and Greene furniture. I’ve always been of the opinion that the inlays and ebony pegs that the Greenes used in their work were too showy for my taste, until I was able to see their work in the flesh. I learned that the photos that I saw of Greene and Greene furniture tended to exaggerate how much the inlaid elements and the ebony pegs were proud of the background surface. Greene and Greene furniture still isn’t my favorite, but I like it a lot better now than I did before all because I saw it in person.

Finally, I’m going on this trip by myself, which saves me $25, so there’s that.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#7

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT

david weaver

My wife would suggest that she didn't want to spend $25 to go in and look at the chest, so it would be $25 for me, too. It's a chest that I would observe in person for free, but not something I'd pay for.

It's a chest that if I owned, I would arrange for it to be shown without charging, even if i had to limit access to it to prevent theft (as the ticket sales do), I can't get on with the charging thing.

The explanation given of the $30,000 in ticket sales being "only to cover the cost of presenting the chest" doesn't sit quite right with me, either. It may be that some parties are uncompensated, but not all. It doesn't cost $30,000 to show something for a couple of days. Perhaps the owner wants a fee, I don't know.

It's not so much just this chest, though, it's the "pay to see" or "pay to know" vs. free sharing of knowledge and experience that irks me. More than just this chest.

It goes back to "the customer is ripe".

I don't have a whole lot to offer the woodworking community other than advice on obscure sharpening things and the workings of a double iron plane (wooden or metal), but I can't imagine setting up a site, putting up a teaser video and saying "give me $50 and I'll show you how to make one". Perusing pictures to get ideas for bench proportions, several times I ran into pictures that were clickable and prompted me to fork over $50 or $100 to "get access to learn more". (to see information on common work benches????)

It just astonishes me. And that is the crap that beginners are blasted with because those folks are the most eager to get to them (I experienced the same thing a decade ago as a beginner). thus we have a whole community that's oriented again, back to what's marketable to beginners. It leads to the situation that warren described, where people acquire skills to build things but never learn what looks good. I suppose that's a bit harder to market.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#8

Re: As an old Ron White Joke Ends...

david weaver

..."maybe it's me?"

It could just be that my level of cynicism encompasses a much wider swath than most peoples'.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#9

I'm coming 1200 miles

McKay

I think that $25 bucks is a bargain. Some folks will go to France to see the Mona Lisa (is that where she is at?) I would not pay to see her, but I think that my trip next month is worth every dime of fuel and motels. I feel that this cabinet is WAYYYYYY beyond a cabinet, but rather part of the legacy that we should embrace and perpetuate in our own furniture.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#10

Re: I'm coming 1200 miles

david weaver

It's only my opinion, of course, but I think if you travel 1200 miles to this show, you ought to be able to see this cabinet without paying to see it.

It is fine work, of course, but it's no finer than the fine work that makers are making now. I've certainly seen things that George has made that would be much more difficult to complete.

It's funny that people nearly worship this tool chest, and there are a few of us who appreciate how good and how accessible George is, but many more who criticize him merely because he is direct about his achievements and the weight of the opinion of someone with such achievements (and he rightfully has little patience for people with no experience who believe that their opinion is equally relevant). The difference is you can send George a picture (or show him a picture) of something you do, he will offer an improvement, and unless you are on his level, your work will improve. Even if you are a hack like me, he's perfectly happy to talk through things on the phone and only hopes that we gather some sense from what he's telling us (and more so on design than execution - which I've noticed is quite often, or almost exclusively, what fine makers talk about).

The whole thing reminds me of a PBS special I saw years ago, it was about how we treat people while they're living and worship things they did after they're dead, or possessions they have while they're alive.

I agree with your logic that if you're spending a boat load of money to get there, what's another $25.

I would probably spend that money on sharpening stones, though. Certainly not rationalizing that, either!

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#11

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT

JDK

Sometimes, David, you're truly a bore.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#12

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT

david weaver

I prefer wet blanket, and one with no entry fee.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#13

Somebody pinch me or tell me april fools joke


Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#14

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT

William Duffield

David, You don't know what you're talking about.

Everything that Wilbur states is true for myself as well.

The Studley tool chest exhibit will not be in a barn. Don explains the venue on the website. It will be in this building:


If all the tickets were sold, which is far from assured, the exhibit might break even.

I've seen the Mona Lisa, kinda, It was in an incredibly small, crowded room. What I really saw was the backs of a lot of a lot of pushy, rude tourists' heads. That won't happen in Cedar Rapids. I'd rather gaze on and study in person the Studley chest, bench and vises any day.

I've seen the proofs of the book, "Virtuoso", that will be released concurrently with the exhibit. Even with the excellent photography, (and even if you count every frame in the low quality video on the NYW), there have been nowhere near a million photos, and I'm sure almost everyone has not seen them, anyhow. Most everyone's experience prior to this exhibit and book, has been limited to the aforementioned video and the one poster from the Smithsonian exhibit. As far as we have been able to determine, everyone followed the "no pictures" directive when the chest was displayed at the Smithsonian in DC. No additional photos of that exhibit have turned up, and I can assure you that if there are any, they are not nearly of the quality of the photos in the book, and they don't show the workings of the chest, or the tools, or the artistic embellishments.

Almost no one has had a chance to see Studley's workbench in person, much less the piano vises. I have seen and handled some of the piano vises that will be exhibited, and I can assure you they are technically a world beyond the archaic wooden jaw and screw leg vises that most people here are so enamored with. They need to be seen and operated to be appreciated. They have no issues with racking, they don't need a pin or other gizmo to get them to close, and they operate at least as smoothly as any of Benchcrafted's excellent vise hardware. They work even better than my Record 52-1/2.

In addition to a ticket to the exhibit, I paid for a copy of the book, which I intend to get autographed by the author, the photographer, and the publisher while I'm in Cedar Rapids and Amana.

An extra $25 is small change, especially when compared to the price of airport parking, airfare, auto rental, hotel room, and meals in restaurants, that I'm going to pay to go to the Handworks event in nearby Amana. Heck, a ticket at that price is almost free, and it is a lot less than a live experience of an equivalent work of art by Beethoven, Brahms or Rachmaninov, especially if performed by a virtuoso like Itzhak Perlman or Joshua Bell. I pay that much for a performance by a local orchestra, chamber ensemble or soloist, and I can't even buy a CD to take home from one of those performances. A CD or even a DVD of one of those performers in no way compares to being in the concert hall.

I'm not even going to try to imagine what people pay for a ticket to a rock concert, which is more like my "free" Mona Lisa experience.

Sour grapes, perhaps?

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#15

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT

david weaver

Sour grapes, are you kidding? If I wanted to go see the chest, I would have bought tickets, nothing is stopping me. I've seen pictures of it, but I don't participate in the object worship that comes along with the sense that it's an artistic piece. I also have no connection to the masons, but maybe there's something there that would drive a mason to go see it.

You are missing the point and so are many, it's not just this particular instance, it is the pattern of all things of the like. It's pretty rare that I don't know what I'm talking about, and this isn't one of those times.

I don't care that much about Studley's chest, it's fine work. There are people doing finer, and you, me and everyone can find those people and learn from them. Often they are RWA to share what they know, especially if most of their career is behind them. I would much rather have met HO studley and seen him actually doing work rather than wondering over a chest that he's left behind.

What I am less than enthusiastic about is the huckster wagon culture of most of the "instruction" and personality promotion in woodworking, and that combined with "I have something special, pay me to see it". The studley chest thing on its own is not a real big deal, it's just the part of the larger culture of "pay me to see it" that it's part of.

Like I said, if it was mine, I would display it for free if I were going to display it, I'd feel obligated to.

As far as picking things that I would spend time and money to do, if I were to take 3 days or a week off of work and focus on going somewhere where the point was not me doing something in the shop, it would without exception to be to go to spend a part of a week or a week at George's shop. The experience would be a thousand times more valuable than looking at a chest where pictures of it already exist.

Like I said, maybe it's me to some extent (I'm sure there are others who feel the same way, but most people are uncomfortable saying something negative. I'm not). There are obviously people who value seeing the studley chest more than I do, and long before I posted this, I wouldn't guess that they couldn't easily sell the $25 tickets to 1200 people. I would not spend that effort to view an object, though, I would spend it to meet people and learn.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#16

Re: I think, also..

david weaver

that you're creating this false comparison where you're positing that people think that a common leg vise is similar to the studley vise. I don't know anyone who has said that the leg vise is something other than a common method to make a vise, the discussions are about functionality, not elevation to god-like status.

It seems like you're enthusiastic about the studley stuff, and by all accounts, it's very fine work.

Why it, as fine work, is so much better than any other fine work, or so much better than the fine workers who are left and who are accessible is well beyond me. There are probably several thousand or ten thousands of examples of similar fine work in the US and Britain, but they don't have the branding that this chest has. We literally have a member on the forums who could not only make the chest with relative ease (or something like it), but turn around and make every one of the tools in it with relative ease - and we sit and watch half of the forum members discard his free opinion and advise because they think he's arrogant for having as much achievement as he's had.

There's another interesting dynamic about this, and that is your pride in having handled some of the vises. It's as if there's a creation of pride around "I have done something you haven't", but it's sort of a competitive game where there is no opposition (if the implied leverage is around something that I haven't had the chance to do, I don't care, and I wouldn't expect you to care).

I do find a morbid fascination in all of this stuff, and while you're not in the group of people making videos about everything they see, pretending to be an authority (at least that I know of), since this bench and chest may be photographed (video, I don't know), I'm sure the "experts" will be out showing us what they saw, positioning themselves between us an the bench and chest to let us know that the story is only good with their presence. Hucksters and shysters seem to be around every corner offering something else if you buy their book or pay for memberships on their sites. I guess they are somewhat enthusiastic about woodworking, but only if it elevates their sense of self at the same time and makes a few bucks, too.

I'm not a target for the book, either, I guess. The pictures I've seen elsewhere have been satisfying enough.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#17

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT

don stephan

You've made your point many times over.

One of the things that make some forums especially valuable is the opportunity to hear from a number of different people because everyone has different points of view and different ways of explaining things.

In this situation you seem unwilling to allow people to have an opinion different from yours, responding to each and every one. Forums and life in general would be much less valuable and enjoyable if everyone had to be the same. My two cents.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#18

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT

david weaver

I clarified my point several times, because it keeps coming back to focusing just on the charge to see the chest. That's only what triggered the post.

If others like to see the chest as art, by all means, i'm not intending to stick my hand out and wave it in the way so that they can't take their tickets.

Personally, I'd rather see people who have clear opinions of things and are satisfied to disagree than wishy washy "let's all agree on something, and nobody question anything, that's impolite" kind of talk that generally takes place.

This thread is more of a statement, and not something like the long discussions in the past about single vs. double iron planes where all involved seemed unwilling to budge (and still are). Those are the discussions that I've learned far more from ....far more.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#19

Re: I think, also..

William Duffield

OK, it's not sour grapes*. I just asked. I'm not even going to pretend to try to identify your motives. They are beyond my comprehension.

George does not post on WoodCentral, unless it is under a pseudonym, but even then he would be easy to recognize.

Now, you are resorting to character assassination, and insulting not only me, but every professional woodworker, every professional teacher, every professional art conservationist and every professional writer, publisher and cinematographer, and a few amateurs and retirees, as well. Obi-Wan has taught you well.

I will not respond to any further posts written by you, either on WoodCentral or other woodworking forums. Henceforth and furthermore, I also will not read your posts, nor any post in direct or indirect response to any post you have made. I will trust Ellis, Bill Houghton and other moderators to deal appropriately with any further attacks.

N.B. I had already responded to your leg vise post before reading this. My new policy does not apply retroactively to that post.

* Rhetorics: Making a false pretense to form a rationalization …Wikipedia

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#20

Re: I think, also..

david weaver

More conclusions that are beyond what I'm talking about.

If we're talking about the folks at places like NBSS or (I can't remember what the one is called in PA, is it Thaddeus Stevens where Steve Latta teaches?), I've got no negative opinion on those types of places. The instructions can do fine work, and the work turned out by students also shows good design.

My ire is the aggregator of all things without discretion and the beginners pushing themselves as a source of great information, and "pay to subscribe to me" type things. The folks who never have made anything of note, and may really not be able to without learning from someone who does.

The phil lowes, etc, that do and have done years and years of fine work, not included in any of this.

The guys who make a bench, then package the plans without having a history of even using it, and then go beginner hunting....that's what I don't like. I see you do fine work. I'd seek your advice if I was doing anything similar to something you've made. I'd assume you didn't start making things in the last two years, and you have a good sense of proportion and design.

Someone new to the hobby isn't going to know much difference between you and the guy who sets up an internet show and charges you to learn to make something they don't make well and that they don't have a very long history of using (if it's shop hardware) to make much. The information has little or no credibility.

It is the blog and publishing atmosphere that has devolved into a lot of this. Articles used to be written by authorities, I guess that's gone. Now they start with sky is blue stuff in a lot of cases and don't have much appeal - it's the market.

(and you're right, george doesn't talk here. he can't follow the format, or he would. I think that's too bad, but it is what it is).

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#21

Re: I think, also..

JDK

I'm joining you on this William. I'm simply sick of David's ridiculous postings. If I didn't see it with my own eyes, I wouldn't believe that any person who loves the craft of woodworking could possible find fault in the work of Henry Studley. Even worse, to denigrate the tireless work of those who've spent years studying and documenting Studley's tool cabinet and workbench is beyond comprehension.

I'm done with David Weaver. I hope others follow your example.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#22

Re: Reading...

david weaver

... you can reread my posts 10 times and not find any part where I faulted the work of studley. It's fine work (i can't think of a better compliment to anyone than saying that their work is fine work). I said I'd be able to learn more from studley himself than I can from his work, it's a shame that's not possible.

And I said that his is not the only fine work, and that we literally can talk to someone who could duplicate it and make all of the tools in the chest, too (or better). It strikes me as odd that the chest is worshiped, but if the man had the personality that other fine makers often have (pride and self-assuredness), he'd be cast off by the same people.

I don't have any demands that you read my posts, I hope that day in and day out, you do whatever you like and draw your own conclusions. Please do so without asserting that I've said or implied things that I didn't say or imply - i'm certainly not foolish enough to refer to the studley work as anything but fine work.

Since you've fixated on the studley thing as the point of my post and I've stated several times that's not really the issue, but the circus atmosphere and the personal self promotion by folks who've never made anything of note, I can't really do much other than reiterate that one more time. HO studley's work is the tool being used at this point, his work is not the fault.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#23

An Example...

david weaver

..aside from the "we're friends if you pay me at the door" kind of thing...

While I was looking at pictures of benches (which to me is less of a critical thing to get perfect or to turn into cabinet work than some), I ran across videos on youtube.

One of the more ridiculous ones that I saw had some kind of arcane advice to make some gigantic router jig contraption to flatten a bench top that really didn't need much work.

Any accomplished woodworker, even one who rarely uses hand tools, would've seen that the work was far more appropriate for a jointer plane (or any plane), and that for those rarely inclined, a skill of planing could be learned or practiced doing it. I mentioned that in the comments. I knew that fanboy shout downs would swiftly follow, and of course they did. If a handful of people read my comment and think "ghee, it might be a better idea to hand plane this", that's all I was looking for. I feel sorry for the people who go out and buy a bunch of framing lumber, or better lumber, and who waste their time with the "advice".

Not long after, still perusing the internet, I clicked on a picture in google image, and clicked through to the link to get a closer look at it, and got a "sign up here for this project, $100" (!!!), the items shown weren't particularly inspiring, and it turned out to be the same person suggestion to the throngs that they should make this gigantic contraption to make a bench.

Many other references were folks (some with blogs, etc) advocating certain bench designs, but at the same time, right after they built their bench (fill in the blank for bench - the topic is whatever they built last), and the same thing - "you can have plans for my bench for $XXX". They are the first things you see and with the most views.

Some of these gurus are writing articles for magazines, etc. This kind of stuff is out there in droves. Fish in a barrel shooter kind of stuff.

We've all been around long enough to know who the real makers are. Personally, I would pay them for some of their knowledge if I had a burning desire to take a course from them to learn to make something specific and do it finely. The rest of the stuff catches far more beginners on a "oh, later, I'll figure out that was a waste of money and learn that the guy making the content probably doesn't give as good of advice as I can get elsewhere for free".

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#24

Well, you did find somethings that.....

roger lance

made some folks get a little cynical......

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#25

Re: Well, you did find somethings that.....

david weaver

Thanks for the chuckle, Roger :)