New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

Posts

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#26

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT

Paul in NJ

"It's pretty rare that I don't know what I'm talking about, and this isn't one of those times".

Gotta love that line!

I think you picked the wrong example, event, item, person(s) to rail about. In fact it is insulting to all the people involved. I don't believe anyone personally involved is going to make money on this. The only people that will make money are local businesses (hotel, restaurants, etc.), airlines, car rental, and oil companies. There has been a lot of effort put in to this that was done for the love of the craft. No one is forcing anyone to go! Nothing is free, even free public education, parks, museums (tax dollars).

I have to agree that there is a lot of trash woodworking on the web with ill-informed instruction. Again no one is forced to use it. Perhaps we could all proclaim you as the WWW woodworking monitor. :D We just have to learn for ourselves who to trust.

David, I really appreciate some of your informative posts on plane making, cap irons, etc. I just think you were off base using the Studley tool chest and event as an example. Maybe you were just having a bad day, or not? I do hope you continue with your informative posts.

Regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#27

Re:very fair and accurate..

david weaver

..what lets the air out of my balloon is the circus culture, or maybe I should call it the bob ross method painting type culture (something that's a quick sell) more than it is the genuine concern about giving people really good information and moving them in the right direction.

Bad timing, I guess, studley thing is just what I saw yesterday in a long line. It's like the grain of sand in a dump truck full, the last grain that keeps the hydraulic cylinders from being able to lift the load. When what really is more responsible is the 25 backhoe buckets that came before.

I would like to clarify that I don't think anyone is getting rich, and there's a sentiment that "the barn" is an inferior venue from the way I framed it. I'd put a refinished barn on equal footing with any other venue (at least the ones I've seen are more like office and event complexes). Not implying it was just dropped between a few piles of hay.

You're exactly on, though, the irritation from the studley stuff in general was very little, just the idea that it can only be seen if paying to do so is part of the same culture. That pales greatly in comparison to amateurs asking significant sums to see their aggregation of information on something they aren't an authority on.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#28

Now I've got to go.


Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#29

Should I go or should I stay home?

BrianMonumentCO

When I first started browsing this thread, I had no idea what was afoot.

There is a web page that explains more about it.

"There is a $25 admission fee for attendance to the exhibit. To maximize the experience of visitors, each admission ticket will be for a fifty-minute window, where 60 visitors at a time will have a unique opportunity to observe and photograph the cabinet and workbench, and interact with the project’s principals."

With a limit of 1200 tickets.

According to this web page it is the actual cabinet and the workbench, NOT photos as I seem to recall that some have suggested.

With the poster that I got from FWW, FWW article, wikipedia page and the New Yankee Workshop episode on a tool cabinet that showed this cabinet, I will not be going on this pilgrimage. This cabinet is only a tool cabinet, amazing in organization and complexity, yet not a religious artifact as some appear to treat it. I am puzzled by why I have not seen ANY pictures of any of the pianos and organs made by Mr Henry O. Studley are displayed. Normally we celebrate the work of the maker be it cabinets by a cabinet maker or some piece of art by a painter.

Rather I will wait for the book. Hoping that there will actually be a book about this cabinet.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#30

Re: Should I go or should I stay home?

david weaver

I'm not sure what would suggest that it's photos, I understand it as this:

* you pay, you get 50 minutes to go look at the stuff (no touch) and talk to curators. It appears that you can definitely take pictures, too, which should result in a flood of additional pictures. I don't know if you can take video, but if you can, there will be plenty of people with selfie sticks looking to become part of the story (that was part of my ire).

* the pictures were taken for a book that is being written (a separate thing from the showing of the chest, bench and other things as part of the pay exhibit).

Apparently, the pictures that have been taken so far are not up to snuff (I thought they were quite nice, but maybe the pictures will include taking things out of the cabinet and getting better pictures of the tools).

There's a fascination with a chest that's been seen in pictures that I anticipated as a matter of it being popular and often discussed (just like a nakashima table), but the strength of the fascination is greater than I'd have guessed.

All of this is just my opinion, the negativity about the posturing, and the separate negativity for the buyer beware stuff all over the web and in print. I get the sense that people feel I've concluded that their opinion should be the same as mine, and that's definitely not true!! Other than folks providing their own opinion (which could be exactly the opposite, and that's fine), that's about all I expected to do. It would be a pretty dull place (the forum, the woodworking hobby, the world) if everyone had exactly the same opinion.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#31

Re: Should I go or should I stay home?

BrianMonumentCO

The concept that it might only be pictures comes from YOUR (David Weaver) first post, the paragraph that begins "I looked it up ....". Second sentance as quoted below.

"Not $25 to see several dozen things, but to see pictures of a chest and bench that have been talked to death."

I have no interest in getting sucked into a debate of morality or any other concepts concerning the sale of the right to look at the CABINET (it is not a CHEST) and associated workbench.

I do have a conceptual problem with people owning things that are of interest to others and not allowing viewing or even photographing, This event as well as permitting a book to be made are good cures. I hope Don's book is a good one.

In my noble opinion, this kind of cabinet with its fame should be in a museum.

And I am NOT interested in any other topic such as posturing, etc.

I do agree you are entitled to your own opinion.

And if you post it publicly you are also entitled to see MY opinion as well as others.

Speaking only for myself this does not necessarily mean that I want to debate the differences.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#32

On the costs for the Studley exhibit

wilbur

My wife has a background in marketing, advertising, and event planning. I ran the details of the Studley chest exhibit by her. Assuming that this is going to be an exhibit on the level of a viewing in an art gallery or a museum, she says that $30,000 is certainly a reasonable estimate for the costs of the weekend, including transporting the Studley chest to and from wherever the owner keeps it.

It should also be noted that Don Williams spent many years working at the Smithsonian, and has overseen similar exhibitions and installations over the course of his career. I am sure he has a good grasp of the costs involved in such an undertaking, and if he says the costs are $30,000, I would believe him.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#33

Re: I agree...

Sgian Dubh

"... but it is not, for example, any better than the type of work that a George would do (and there are many Georges, we just don't get to know them."

Who is this 'George' that you mention in a few of your posts? I can't associate the name with a well known woodworker or furniture maker that you appear to hold in some regard. I'm just curious because the mystery is bugging me.

Incidentally, I don't think I'd be persuaded to pay $25 to look at this tool chest, especially as I wouldn't be allowed to handle the contents. I've seen scores of tool boxes or storage solutions over the years I've been making furniture, everything from excellent to pretty poor, and I don't really understand the fascination some people seem to have for this one. I grant it looks like it packs a lot into a small space, but it does just make me wonder how much fiddling is required to extract and replace tools so work can proceed efficiently. Of course, I can't answer that, but it is a question that goes through my mind, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#34

Re: George

david weaver

George was the master instrument maker at Colonial Williamsburg for a while:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zuUqbdTDjcw

(though this video is 45 years ago)

Then the tool maker and jack of all trades master of most (he hasn't said that, i make that comment based on him being the maker of many items, and even though he only makes one of many of the things he makes, they turn out spectacular.(this one a compass for a stateside celebrity who had an interest in measuring and surveying devices)

http://www.practicalmachinist.com/vb/general/i-found-detailed-pictures-david-brinkley-s-compass-i-made-1986-a-238552/

Some other instrument items:

http://www.cybozone.com/fg/wilson1.html#wilson6

The one thing he doesn't make much of is furniture, it wasn't his area at the museums and it's not his interest, I guess.

To show the above and suggest that he's a maker of any particular thing is sort of a slight, there are many others (finely made knives, 18th century guns made from scratch - including making the lock set, jewelry (especially dies), scissors, fine machining ...)

But the one thing in all of it is that the design is very pleasing to the eye. Even if the period of something he makes is not your favorite, the design elements don't offend the eye.

I bring him up because he's accessible to anyone. Someone accomplished like you may not get much from him other than the curiosity of some of the things he's made that are different from what you'd make on a day to day basis, but to most of the rest of us, his advice is exceptional - especially when it comes to general design advice that is really lacking in most informal type places like forums and publications.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#35

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David

I would very much like to see the Studley Tool Chest and benches, however I would want more than just a viewing and informal discussion. What I want is to examine their construction, have a demonstration of the way they work, be shown the contents of the chest, and receive as well a lecture on the history of Studley and his life and the reason behind the choice of his tools. I would be prepared to pay much more than the asking price for this. I do have the Studley book on order, which I imagine will contain all this information, however for me this is still missing from the public showing.

I do not wish the above comments to be a statement about costs, either that they are exorbitant for this show or elsewhere. Personally, I have no problem with what is asked here as I believe that the administrative expenses are going to swallow up all. All I am saying is that I want more than a viewing, and would be willing to pay for it.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#36

I hope he does make some money.

Chuck Nickerson

Then he's more likely to do something similar again.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#37

Also agree...

John in NM

I was never one for attending classes, viewing exhibits, or going to trade show type venues - but that is because I am cheap and I know it. The popularity of all these things, along with blogs, videos, and forums does still benefit me even if I don't utilize them much myself. Interest in the hobby/profession provides income for unique tool makers/vendors, and a wealth of information available for just the cost of an internet connection and the time to look stuff up. Heaven for a cheapskate :D

I don't really understand the complaint with charging for entry to see a famous work, though I've not even been paying much attention to this event so perhaps I've missed the nuances. As far as I know, free museums are more or less a thing of the past, just like free camping and entry to national parks, along with who knows how much more.

Only free activities I know of in most cities are a visit to the library or sitting in a public park (and around here, both tend to attract the homeless as well).

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#38

Re: George

Sgian Dubh

Thank you for the additional information David. George Wilson demonstrates a great deal of skill ... and exceptional patience in the three months required (by three makers by the look of it) to put together the spinnet, and I'm not sure how much time went into the violin. I found it interesting to note how many of the techniques and tools he (they) used there were similar to those I've used many times myself, particularly during furniture restoration jobs I used to undertake frequently at one point in my career, but much less so in the contemporary style furniture I tend to design and make myself. Slainte.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#39

Who is publishing the Studley book and when?


Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#40

Never mind - found and ordered.  Lost art press.


Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#41

Re: what I've learned

david weaver

When I wrote the original post, I thought that this $25 fee was for something that was connected to handworks. I didn't know that the event itself was being run by Don Williams (who I don't know and haven't heard of before) and not as part of the handworks.

It makes sense given that it's a separate entity that he would have to charge admission, since it's financially separate. That I didn't know - I thought it was more along the lines of the extra charge room type of thing going on a coney island.

It also sounds, from several people (including the moderators here), that the impression is that I was lumping the studley chest and bench themselves into mediocre work like that shown on the various websites. That's not the case.

So, my apologies to Don Williams (even though I seriously doubt he'd ever see any of this), given that he's the one running this thing out of his own pocket, at his risk, and it's not part of the handworks show as I thought.

I stand by the rest of it (the personalities, etc) and won't be posting here further. Sensitive individuals, you can crack open the champagne.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#42

Re: what I've learned

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I ... won't be posting here further

Dave, I certainly hope that you mean this thread and not the forum.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#43

Re: what I've learned

Charlie

I believe the Don Williams in question is Don Williams of Clark & Williams/Old Street Tool. Surely, you've heard of them?

The rest of this has an eerie Holden Caulfield-ish irrational cynicism as a prelude to a breakdown -- all of this over a $25 admission fee that can't possibly net the promoters anything but the covering of the overall costs of putting on the exhibition.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#44

Re: what I've learned

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Actually, the Don of Clark and Williams is Don McDonnell and the Williams is Larry Williams. Don Williams is/was the senior furniture conservator at the Smithsonian.

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#45

Re: what I've learned

Charlie

Thanks for the clarification.

Smithsonian -- even better!

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#46

Re: what I've learned *LINK*

Larry Barrett

And here is a link to Don William's website. Lots of interesting info.


DonsBarn

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#47

The current flavor of buildings...

John in NM

I think a lot of them won't be here in another 30 to 50 years. I see a lot of commercial buildings being torn down and replaced with ones that better fit the standard layout of a Target store or whatever is going in. Seems like a waste until one considers the design effort required to work with what is there compared to bulldozing it and putting up a clone of 100 other stores for which the design work is done. Strip malls tend to be ugly, but aesthetics is not always part of their goal.

I've seen the same thing happen with 40 to 50 year old housing in popular areas of a growing city - either individually or en masse, the stodgy old tract houses sometimes get pulled down in favor of stodgy new tract houses :D That is not as common as in commercial building, but I have seen it done.

One can only suppose that these trends will cease if we ever again start building structures worth preserving! :D

Re: Things that make me cynical re: wwing comm (OT)

#48

Re: what I've learned

Charlie

Thanks for the link.