Re: Leg Vise (Parallel Guide) Question
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
.. most of the reason I'm building a bench at this point is to be able to get a good grip on wood to be resawn - it has always been a struggle in my inexpensive bench, whereas everything else has worked fairly well. simplicity and strength are what I'm looking for.
Hi David
I've been reading through the posts kind of trying to work out the reason you want a leg vise. I understand that you would like something that requires the least amount of work, and does not cost much. However, I do not have a good feeling about a chop that can wiggle side-to-side, especially if you plan to use it for resawing. I think that you would be better off with a wider, rigid vise, such as a double screw or even a Record 52 1/2, one that will not rack (deliberately, at least).
I think that it is important to decide whether a leg vise is the design for you. Do it right and do it once. The reason I use a leg vise is to clamp long boards for edge jointing. In this regard it is best considered in partnership with a sliding deadman. One without the other is half a vise.
I deliberately made my leg vise rigid. This allows me to clamp boards along one side without it losing grip, or plane the edge of a longer board (without the sliding deadman being used) without it tipping.
While I do not resaw at the bench (I would use a bandsaw), holding a board in a vise seems to require moving it about, extending it out, and creating pressures/downforce at angles that will weaken the grip on a board held unevenly.
My leg vise closes square, and is suited as is to parallel boards. However out-of-parallel boards are easily held with wedges.
I found that keeping the chop square maximises clamping force. To this end I built everything with minimal play.
The chop rests on the parallel guide, which in turn is supported by a small roller.
The wooden screw has slop built into it, and so I built a guide for the parallel guide to minimise side movement (and it also enables tuning of the chop) ..
http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/ParallelGuideGuide.html
I also added a chain adjuster, which is a pleasure to use, but not something for everyone. It does add to maintaining even pressure.
What I have ended with is an easy-to-use vise that excels at holding wide boards square to the side of the bench. It is not designed for resawing, but it would work well for this. I am not so confident about a design where the chop racks to hold out-of-parallel work. But perhaps I am misunderstanding how these work.
Regards from Perth
Derek