New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

Posts

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#51

I suspect...

John in NM

That the grit equivalent designation is made by manufactures for marketing purposes, and thus has little basis in reality. I think they know that most of their market will judge by speed of sharpening and thus they attempt to fit it into a framework that will make sense to the consumer.

Equating stones with grit tends to make sense to consumers who use sandpaper.

As Bill says, measuring grit size is trivial. Establishing consistency between various methods is where it gets confusing - micron sizing is really the most sensible, but many manufacturers do not use it since their consumers have little notion of what a micron is. On a coarse scale, like for sandpaper, any method is more or less equivalent to the next. On small scales they start to diverge.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#52

Re: I'll make a wager.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

you will not see any metal missing on a Western chisel. A good western chisel doesn't chip or at least I have never seen this kind of dulling in a Western chisel. At the tip it will be deformed and these deformations can be straightened .

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#53

Re: Laminated Steel Colonial Edge Tool

Steve Voigt

I have a reproduction hatchet made in January of this year by Steve Mankowsky, Colonial Williamsburg blacksmith. He told me it is cast iron welded to 1080 steel, and was typical of the methods they would have used in Colonial times. He then showed me a large pile of 1080 steel in various shapes just outside the door of the new armory. It appeared to be salvaged. I don't know what the difference is between 1080 and 1070, or how close either would have been to steel available in the mid 18th Century colonial America.

Cool axe, William.

Forgive me if I'm being over-obvious here, but…the difference between 1070 and 1080 is 0.1% carbon. The "70" means 0.7% carbon, and so on. The numbers are not absolute, and can even vary from one mill to the next. For example, Aldo Bruno (the NJ steel baron) sells a 1084 that is advertised as being .87% carbon. But the numbers definitely get you in the ballpark.

1080 is probably not that different from what was available after 1750-ish, namely crucible steel. Before that, it would have been shear steel, which is different. Shear steel is like a plate of vegetables, while crucible or the later cast steel is like the vegetables pureed into a homogenous substance.

You actually bring up something that I was hoping to talk about, until this got derailed into Yet Another Thread about old vs new steel. The few figures and chemical analyses I've seen suggest that vintage (late 18th-19th C.) steel was right in that .7-.8 percent carbon range. I've also seen a number of people say that Aldo's 1084 is closer to the feel of vintage steel than anything else you can currently buy. So apparently 19th c. toolmakers didn't feel the need for super-high levels of carbon; to use David's terminology, they were content with eutectic rather than hyper-eutectic steel. But it's definitely true that my vintage steel tools don't have the toughness of good japanese steel, so I guess that supports what Wilbur was saying.

Not sure where I'm going with this, so I'll stop rambling.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#54

Re: Laminated Steel Colonial Edge Tool

david weaver

I think it's interesting, even if you've lost interest in it! :)

There are some vintage tools that are either cleaner or just harder than what most 1080 type steels would provide. Specifically Ward. There are others that you could convince me were made around the eutectic steel carbon limit and I could be easily convinced that through trial and error, someone found that the "finest grained" steel that was available at a decent cost on a large basis was somewhere around that limit, because it wouldn't be so sensitive to annealing and preventing the fe carbides from becoming large.

Also, I don't think vintage japanese tools were likely made with something much different, they were probably just more selective about what steel was used from the sand iron, and if So's narratives are correct, a lot of the tools were made of substandard steel. The tamahagane that came out of the sand process was just the best steel of a very large batch. In the US, that steel went to razors. So pretty bluntly says that most modern steel is better than the tamahagane that (going in many directions here) stu tierney mentions tested to have 0.7% carbon left in it.

As for japanese tool hardness in reality, the 65 and 66 hardness numbers that are bandied about are overblown. There are a few makers now who are making tools of that hardness, but even that is uncommon. Alex Gilmore at one point was selling NOS japanese tools from the 1950s and following few decades and he was RC testing the irons in each plane. I don't recall one over 62, most were 61 or 62 which in reality is a very good hardness for something like white II or one of the boutique swedish steels (and anything else).

There are makers now making tools that are a few clicks harder than that. I really don't know what the reason was for that hardness, if it was really where the steel was practical to work with in a woodworking tool for toughness reasons, or if it was for sharpening reasons. If anyone out there sharpens something that is close to 65 hardness on a japanese natural stone, you find out pretty quickly that the jigane (soft part) wears away on the stone quickly and the hagane (hard part) takes on a bright polish because the steel is barely cut by the stone. Steel that's a click or two softer sharpens much better on those stones, and the craftsmen would've known it. It also wears nearly as long at a click softer, and is probably less apt to chip.

That leaves only one thing outstanding in terms of vintage steels with high carbon, and that's the wootz steel. As people attempt to create a process that is not high tech that creates a good result with a 2% steel, it seems likely to me that they might chance into something that works, but it might not be that likely that it's actually what people did.

There are a couple of tokyo makers who made glass hard chisels and plane irons, and probably the makers now of premium stuff are a lot closer to the hardness claim than most vintage tools were. It's a spec book thing, because a chisels that's really only (!) at 62 hardness but that's in the hand of an experienced user lasts an awfully long time. It wouldn't move the needle of an experienced user to have something a couple of clicks harder, but to see someone successfully make something that hard (like ouchi probably does, and my KI's seemed to be near their hardness spec, and certainly the ultra high end tokyo smiths who had a reputation for hard tools built tools much harder than a typical historical example), it's a testament to the quality of the materials and the skill of the maker at the same time.

As to modernity, I think the quality of the Yasuki steel (the cleanliness of it) is just as responsible (or more so) for the ability to make new japanese chisels very hard as is the maker's skill. If you watch Ouchi making a chisel in the mahogany masterpieces videos, the subtleties are just right, but it's not as if he needles away at each one. The hagane is placed on the jigane, and a couple of whacks and it's done.

And one more thing about that, the modern blue steel irons made by tsunesaburo are just, as far as I can estimate, factory laminated material that is just cut and hardened, and the same is definitely true of the low cost japanese knives (below about $150, but some of the very expensive ones, too). Rikizai, and the quality of the edge of those steels is almost indistinguishable (and maybe in a blind test it would be indistinguishable) from steel that's been hand (power) hammered by a smith.

Short answer, I think it's the quality of the work done at the steel mill more than the quality of the work of the smith (for all but a very few things that are white I or other very hard to work with materials) that allows the hardness that isn't so common in vintage japanese tools - even those made of yasuki steel or imported steel in the past.