Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussi
david weaver
I'm going to pose more questions and suppositions, though I know it seems like even metallurgical engineers argue about some of this stuff:
I used to think you could pack the grain and save some of that through heat treatment (refining the grain structure by hammering below critical). George tells me that's not the case.
I mistook that for thinking that heat treat was the most important part and all else was less important.
Wiley pointed out that general knowledge is that what's done before heat treatment is also important, above and beyond just saying "anneal" steel.
So, knowing that there are two microstructures (after reading prompted by wiley's comment of pre-heat treatment) that change state at two different temperatures, it looks maybe like the carbide size is determined by careful annealing (so that the carbides can't get large before the eutectic microstructure also changes state), and forging smashes everything together.
It's not clear to me if forging offers as much benefit if the annealing and heat treating are done perfectly.
It's also not clear to me if the two state change temperatures (or whatever you'd call them) for chromium carbides vs. iron carbides are different differentials (e.g., fe carbides and eutectic structure may have closer change temperatures than chromium carbides and eutectic structure - maybe they grow large easier just by the nature of what they are?). I've never seen anyone have a negative opinion of iron carbides unless there are too many and you get cast iron-ish properties of brittleness.
Here's what I'd like to know:
* it's clear that the annealing process is critical to getting a eutectic steel with a good second microstructure of carbides that are kept small
* forging deforms material at the grain structure and adds ductility, but is it that important if step 1 is perfect, and hardening is perfect?
* how much of the forging effort is lost with proper heat treating? Presumably only the eutectic structure is affected if the 2nd critical temperature (the one where the carbide microstructure is set) is not breached? George also has mentioned before, and I don't see most other people saying it other than japanese blacksmiths, that he does not heat material above a cherry red when forging, and certainly not to the flux point that larry advocates. George's words are "you'll ruin it", and presumably by that he's suggesting both carbon migration and growth of the grain structure.
The classic japanese blacksmiths advocated lowest possible temperature heat treatment, and the high end knife makers still do the same.
here's yet another question. the forge welding done on japanese tools in the videos that I've seen is at very high steel temperatures. Is the forging required because steel is above the second critical temperature at the forge weld point, and then cooling not done scientifically? I've also seen some mention of some blacksmiths having marginal forge welds on some blades because they prefer even to do that at as low of a temperature as possible.
It gets hard for us to see the difference between the hand makers of japanese irons (like kikuo kanda and kengo usui) vs. the modern process makers like tsunesaburo because the hardness of the irons aren't all the same, despite the claims of hardness all saying they are.
I sure am glad that it's easier to figure out what tools you (I) like by use than it is to understand what actually makes them that way.
And that doesn't even touch on cryo treatment, which is easy to see as effective when there are chromium carbides. It's the only thing that makes henckels able to make a usable 440C straight razor (and those are quite fine when shaving).
And one last comment - I don't know that there's any particular advantage to repeated hammering vs. something more industrial like die forging that occurs when making razors. the die forging is probably more for shape convenience, but who knows (as in the razor blanks go through two or three progressive dies to get a basic shape so that the cutler doesn't have to do much grinding). Anyway, I've not had any tools that are any finer grained than even the US maker razors. The heat treat process is different because the blanks are small, it's done in (the heating) in molten lead and the quenching is done in oil. I have had white II and swedish steel kamisoris, and they are no finer at the edge than a common german or american maker razor.