New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

Posts

Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#1

Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

Steve Voigt

This is mostly a shout-out to Wiley, but anyone is welcome to join in, of course.

Wiley, in the Kiyohisa/Kiyotada thread, you wrote:

white steel no. 1 or blue steel no. 1 has 1.2% to 1.4% carbon, depending on which grade of No. 1 they're using. But only 0.77% C can be dissolved into the iron. The difference, even allowing for some carbon loss during heating/forging, becomes Fe3C carbides. So the Japanese steel is carbide-rich. I suspect a lot of the 'handwork' we hear about is trying to get all that carbide distributed.

I am struggling a little to understand what this means. Is the .77% figure a hard limit for all carbon steel? Are you saying the un-dissolved carbon is a good thing, or a bad thing, or that it depends on how the steel is worked?

I stress that I am not disagreeing (or agreeing), I just want to add to my own understanding of how this all works.

Man, for such a dirt-simple substance that's been around for eons, it's amazing how complicated HC steel can be.

Thanks in advance,

Steve

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#2

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussi

wilbur

The distribution of the carbides from the forging process is one of the main reasons I think (well-made) Japanese tools have the properties that they do. It’s one of the main points I’ve been making in my talks on Japanese tools, including the one I did at Woodworking in America.

At this point, I’ve talked to a good number of toolmakers, blacksmiths, and metallurgists, and at least so far no one has told me I was full of crap. ;)

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#3

an addtion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"difference, even allowing for some carbon loss during heating/forging, becomes Fe3C carbides"

I would add "can become carbides of any of the alloying elements". This result is particularly important in the case of blue steel which has significant levels of alloying elements that are abrasion resistant carbide formers. It is the carbides that provide abrasion resistance to the steel which translates to edge life. About everyone uses highly alloyed steels in lathe tools to get longer edge life, for example. The extreme in carbide formation and dulling resistance is tungsten carbide that doesn't have any iron. Tungsten and vanadium are the most abrasion resistance of the carbide formers.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#4

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussi

Warren in Lancaster, PA

How are these toolmakers able to make money if everyone knows what the composition of their steel is?

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#5

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussi

david weaver

It's a hard number (the 0.77%), meaning that all of the constituents in a 0.77% carbon steel will melt and change properties at the same temperature. Search google or wiki for the term eutectic.

The microstructure of mid-carbon steel below the 0.77% level should be uniform and all similar.

When you get above 0.77%, then you get various microstructures in the steel that change properties at different temperature.

I don't understand it past that, I believe the carbides in the steel that aren't dissolved into the 0.77% cool first when hardening, and if the steel is good quality, they should be small and frozen in place. If the steel isn't treated properly before hardening, the structure of the components that cool first are large precipitates and thus a large grain (where the precipitates are much higher carbon than the remaining 0.77% amount - something more like 7% carbon and the complement everything else).

Carbon/iron carbides, whatever they're made of (cementite?) are more wear resistant than the remainder of the matrix, which is why W1 has better wear properties than 1070.

It's my assumption that if the carbides in the first microstructure that cool before the rest of the steel are too many, the steel becomes brittle until the point where it's so loaded with preciptates that you have cast iron.

The skill must be (with carbon above 1%) in getting the microstructure that cools first to be small enough and uniform enough not to affect ductility when the rest of the structure cools at a lower temperature. If it's not small and uniform, the steel ends up being more brittle.

Not that it has anything to do with this discussion, but George is the only person I have ever seen talk about the wear resistance added by additional carbon. I think most woodworkers dismiss that because they think carbides only come as chromium carbides, vanadium carbides, etc, something much much harder than ferric carbides (or whatever you call the ones that are just plain carbon and iron).

(side comment, I think the term upper critical is where all constituent microstructures can be reset/dissolved. If annealing doesn't get above it, carbides are not fully dissolved - which goes back to the comment wiley made a couple of months ago about the process before hardening being very important to the quality of the steel after hardening. Stu tierney told me a couple of years ago that the better makers relax their steel before using it, they don't just hammer it and call it good from there. I really have no clue what that means, though).

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#6

Re: prompted to go look for terminology

david weaver

...it appears that cementite isn't "made of" iron carbides, but instead it is iron carbide.

This stuff interests me less in steel competitions and more in why certain abrasives work the way they do with steel.

https://www.tedpella.com/Material-Sciences_html/Abrasive_Grit_Grading_Systems.htm

Silicon dioxide is the predominant abrasive in most sedimentary stones (about 60-65% in japanese natural stones, maybe somewhat less in other slates?), and a transformed version of it in novaculite. You can see the hardness of it, it is above surface hardened steel but below the iron carbides (but not by much).

All of the other carbides are well above (chromium, vanadium, molybdenum).

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#7

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussi

TomD

"At this point, I’ve talked to a good number of toolmakers, blacksmiths, and metallurgists, and at least so far no one has told me I was full of crap."

I find that hard to believe, not because there is anything wrong with your theory, I don't know anything about that, but because in conversations with those groups I very rarely see much agreement. Metallurgist presumably know the science. My sister was married to one of those for a while, and did her PHD on stats related to some research they were doing. It did surprise me what they didn't actually know, but that was around 1980. Weakness of M.'s is in applications they will tell you that you can't do stuff that is done by thousands of people every day.

Toolmakers work in a structured environment where they have products that are designed to economically give controllable results in accordance with known procedures, and there is also a hierarchy thing at work at times.

Amateur blacksmiths (of the tool type) are the most independent craftsmen I have come across in my travels, they will figure out a way to make it, they don't care what you think is impossible.

They all work in the same universe, but it would be like conferring with a union carpenter, an epoxy boat-builder, and properly trained cabinetmaker.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#8

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussi

TomD

Same way the carpenters make whatever money they do knowing what each other use for wood.

An interesting example of the way it works is Forest products lab VS the Gougeons bros. Forest products, awesome, but roughly the same western softwood influences, and the Gougeons added all kinds of stuff to the trade.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#9

Re: Laminated steel

TomD

One thing that interests me about Japanese tools is that when they weld the steel to the iron, it changes the way the tool hardens. You can take a steel that would shatter if quenched that fast, and quench it fast, and the result (for whatever reason) is that you get what you get. From the practical small shop perspective this is very alluring. While there is some skills ramp to learning to weld, it isn't very high, and to swap out that hassle for the expense and danger of quenching in oil is a trade I would make any day, if I could.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#10

Re: Laminated steel

david weaver

The big challenge now if you want to do that is finding good quality wrought iron and a hammer big enough to smash them together.

Stan Covington relayed to me that a lot of the planes being made in japan right now are just big rikizai heated and stamped out in then shape of the iron and then ground.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#11

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussi

wilbur

You may find that hard to believe. That doesn't mean that I'm making it up.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#12

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussi

TomD

That never even occurred to me, and it's a two step from where I was. It may well be factual what you relayed, I am very concious that I probably carry a lot of errors around in my head, and like the rest of us would be interested in eliminating them.

I don't jump to conclusions about lying, which doesn't even come into it here, as unless you actually know a lie for sure it is bearing false witness to suggest one does, and a lot of very bad things start from that. In fact being overly tendent to assuming others are bearing false witness is also bearing false witness, and isn't all that pretty either. In a situation where that is implied. It can be hard in the modern world where being slow to assassinate others' character can mark one a dope, but nobody said it was easy.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#13

Re: Laminated steel

TomD

Interesting. There is old iron around. I found a place in ruins with a lot of bars that had been used to hold it to shore, and it is available for sale also. though too expensive to ship up here. It can also be expensive to handle. A while back there was a guy in the NE who had some chain, but the pieces were huge as far as bandsawing or otherwise reducing.

I don't know if iron is required for the heat threat thing to happen (if it happens). Guys are getting all kinds of stuff to stick together these day. I have my O1 and bucket of oil, so far it hasn't spilled all over the shop. That will see me through.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#14

Re: Laminated steel

david weaver

Just going by what George told me, the best iron is clean and is not necessarily structural iron. A lot of the structural iron is filled with slag and sometimes not that supple.

The reason to use it (despite industrial rikizai coming with mild steel or soft iron, and things like HSS literally glued to something else) is that getting a good clean forge weld on anything other than good wrought is apparently hard with high carbon tool steels.

They must have wrought at CW, but I think George mentioned that the blacksmith shop was making irons with 1070, and he had made some modern irons to the coopers, who were pleading for something with better durability.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#15

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussi

Steve Voigt

The distribution of the carbides from the forging process is one of the main reasons I think (well-made) Japanese tools have the properties that they do.



Thanks for the replies, everyone.

I have no trouble whatsoever believing what Wilbur said. :D But I'm not at all clear on the how or why. Maybe it's not important, but I'm still curious.

Putting Wilbur and Wiley's statements together, the claim seems to be (if I understand correctly) that the excess carbon is distributed by forging to form carbides, and this results in an edge that is both fine grained and wear-resistant. This raises two questions for me:

1) The forging takes place before hardening. And hardening completely reshuffles the molecular structure. So, how does the effect of forging survive the hardening process?

2) From what I know, A2 has a lot of carbides. They supposedly are what make A2 very wear resistant (as well as a pain to sharpen on certain media), but also cause it to be less fine-grained, and more chip-prone, than high-carbon steel. So then why are carbides in white steel a good thing? And conversely, if white steel has a lot of carbides, why is it so obviously fine-grained?

Again, I stress that I am not disputing anyone's conclusions here; just trying to understand what's going on.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#16

Some misconceptions discussed

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There are three steel attributes of primary importance to wood workers.

Wear resistance- the variable most affecting wear resistance are the alloying carbides present. Put some vanadium in the steel, for example, and these vanadium carbide "rocks" resist the abrasion of the iron matrix. Abrasive wear resistance is readily predictable from composition. The higher chromium in A2 leads to its better wear resistance compared to the low chromium content O-1, for example(presuming each is optimally heat treated).

Resistance to deformation ( usually given the confusing descriptor of "hardness")- This property is most affected by the Rockwell hardness of the steel ( a deformation test) which in turn is primarily determined by the heat treatment schedule.

Toughness (resistance to chipping)- Composition as well as the details of the microstructure of the steel determine toughness. This microstructure is determined by heat treatment and the mechanical processing (forging, freezing and whatever) the steel has experienced, as well as composition. But for a simple carbon steel the processing is the major variable to be tinkered with.

The challenge to make a woodworking blade is how to get high hardness and toughness. Harder leads to less toughness. The best Japanese chisels retain toughness at Rockwell hardness above 60. Hence, these tools resist micro, or not so micro, chipping and micro edge deformation(bending) which leads to dulling or gross failure. Apparently the mumbo jumbo of the boutique Japanese fabrication processes enables this optimum combination of high toughness at high hardness. Slip some on the toughness and the result is the Japanese chisel that chips at a bevel angle of 30 degrees. Slip some on the hardness and the result is the Sorby chisel whose edge folds at 30 degrees.

An alternative to complex fabrication is complex steel. The Lee valley PMV11 steel as well as other (CPM3V or M4 for example) steels demonstrate that high toughness at high hardness can be achieved without mumbo jumbo forging or whatever process goes into the best Japanese chisels. If one is only interested in the result, the cheaper route to a good tool is through better steel, not boutique processing.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#17

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussi

david weaver

I'm going to pose more questions and suppositions, though I know it seems like even metallurgical engineers argue about some of this stuff:

I used to think you could pack the grain and save some of that through heat treatment (refining the grain structure by hammering below critical). George tells me that's not the case.

I mistook that for thinking that heat treat was the most important part and all else was less important.

Wiley pointed out that general knowledge is that what's done before heat treatment is also important, above and beyond just saying "anneal" steel.

So, knowing that there are two microstructures (after reading prompted by wiley's comment of pre-heat treatment) that change state at two different temperatures, it looks maybe like the carbide size is determined by careful annealing (so that the carbides can't get large before the eutectic microstructure also changes state), and forging smashes everything together.

It's not clear to me if forging offers as much benefit if the annealing and heat treating are done perfectly.

It's also not clear to me if the two state change temperatures (or whatever you'd call them) for chromium carbides vs. iron carbides are different differentials (e.g., fe carbides and eutectic structure may have closer change temperatures than chromium carbides and eutectic structure - maybe they grow large easier just by the nature of what they are?). I've never seen anyone have a negative opinion of iron carbides unless there are too many and you get cast iron-ish properties of brittleness.

Here's what I'd like to know:

* it's clear that the annealing process is critical to getting a eutectic steel with a good second microstructure of carbides that are kept small

* forging deforms material at the grain structure and adds ductility, but is it that important if step 1 is perfect, and hardening is perfect?

* how much of the forging effort is lost with proper heat treating? Presumably only the eutectic structure is affected if the 2nd critical temperature (the one where the carbide microstructure is set) is not breached? George also has mentioned before, and I don't see most other people saying it other than japanese blacksmiths, that he does not heat material above a cherry red when forging, and certainly not to the flux point that larry advocates. George's words are "you'll ruin it", and presumably by that he's suggesting both carbon migration and growth of the grain structure.

The classic japanese blacksmiths advocated lowest possible temperature heat treatment, and the high end knife makers still do the same.

here's yet another question. the forge welding done on japanese tools in the videos that I've seen is at very high steel temperatures. Is the forging required because steel is above the second critical temperature at the forge weld point, and then cooling not done scientifically? I've also seen some mention of some blacksmiths having marginal forge welds on some blades because they prefer even to do that at as low of a temperature as possible.

It gets hard for us to see the difference between the hand makers of japanese irons (like kikuo kanda and kengo usui) vs. the modern process makers like tsunesaburo because the hardness of the irons aren't all the same, despite the claims of hardness all saying they are.

I sure am glad that it's easier to figure out what tools you (I) like by use than it is to understand what actually makes them that way.

And that doesn't even touch on cryo treatment, which is easy to see as effective when there are chromium carbides. It's the only thing that makes henckels able to make a usable 440C straight razor (and those are quite fine when shaving).

And one last comment - I don't know that there's any particular advantage to repeated hammering vs. something more industrial like die forging that occurs when making razors. the die forging is probably more for shape convenience, but who knows (as in the razor blanks go through two or three progressive dies to get a basic shape so that the cutler doesn't have to do much grinding). Anyway, I've not had any tools that are any finer grained than even the US maker razors. The heat treat process is different because the blanks are small, it's done in (the heating) in molten lead and the quenching is done in oil. I have had white II and swedish steel kamisoris, and they are no finer at the edge than a common german or american maker razor.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#18

I think it more complicated than just "carbides"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The "special property" of the best Japanese chisel is its toughness at high hardness. The question is the what and how that enables the Japanese fabricator to achieve this toughness? It most certainly lies in the resulting microstructure of the steel after fabrication ("forging" or what ever they do interacting with composition). More than just carbide distribution is involved, although the importance of this factor is not to be denied. The size, composition, maybe shape and atomic structure of every crystal type as well as the distribution of these crystals in amorphous regions of the steel affects toughness. And of course all these attributes are affected by the details of fabrication- forging, heat treatment, etc.

Of the steel properties that are of interest to us toughness is the property hardest to understand and predict. When a piece of steel is impacted this force can be concentrated in some structure(crystal, grain boundary, etc) of the steel and lead to fracture. Or ideally, the microstructure of the steel is such that these structures (crystals, boundaries, etc). give a little, wiggle some etc. and dissipate this force over some volume of the steel. The best Japanese tool fabricators have figured out how to achieve these ideal structures through composition and fabrication of the tool. Alternatively, the best commodity steel manufacturers have figured out how to get there by composition and processing of the bulk steel to yield a commodity steel that anyone with the motivation to do so can turn into an exceptional tool.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#19

Re: cheaper, no

david weaver

V11 chisels are the only western made chisels I've seen that can hang with something pedestrian like a white II chisel properly made (exclude white I, the temperature ranges for making it properly are narrow and there aren't many guys who can do it right).

White II is a little cleaner and with a little more carbon than W1.

The cost of a white II chisel right now (koyamaichi, which is the lowest cost properly made chisel that I know of) is

$41 for 1/4 inch, to

$51 for 1 inch

I would imagine the edge holding for V11 would at best be similar, but the sharpenability of the V11 is less.

White II is not pored over by KI or Ouchi when they forge the chisels, you can see videos of ouchi. The forging process is quick and then the chisel is ground.

The difference is that the labor needed to do what KI and ouchi do is ultra skilled labor. The labor needed to do what LV does is much less so.

There's still a large cost gap.

The difference in performance between KI's chisels and most much more expensive chisel is pretty small, but KI's finishing is pretty spartan - it looks like it's put in grinding jigs and ground to shape to a reasonable grit and that's it. Ouchi chisels are more expensive, and finished better. I don't know if they actually last longer in use. Above and beyond that, until you get into the few makers who actually do white I steel well (are there any left?), much of the cost is in aesthetics, or trying to refine the processes to create a chisel that really has a superb combination of durability and sharpenability.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#20

don't overlook compostion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What is made and how fast it is made (crystals, grains, boundaries and the like) depend on the bulk composition of the steel. As I understand it you can not make a high vanadium and hence high abrasion resistant steel by conventional means. The crystals grow too fast and get too big and the toughness sucks. Hence, particle steels processing got invented to enable small grain size and whatever else at high alloying of some elements.

Other elements retard these processes. The result is that a modern steel is a boggling complex formulation of minor amounts of this and that elements to achieve some combination of properties. To there credit some Japanese fabricators get there with a relatively simple steel and complex processing of this steel into tools with optimum properties.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#21

Re: don't overlook compostion

david weaver

I agree that powder metal limits the size of the particles.

I think the discussion was on how to get iron carbides small, though. You certainly don't get the wear resistance from an iron carbide that you get from a vandium carbide, but vanadium carbides are harder than silicon carbide, so it's sort of a limiting thing in steel sharpness for most people if you put them in, especially if the particles can be 4-6 microns large or whatever.

Lee valley's given us a high chromium fine steel (at least I'm assuming that's what it is, it could be some other alloying element that allows it to stay bright), but it feels like a refined 440C to me. Is it any better than a friodur blank - which is non particle 440C that is cryo tempered? The edge is no finer, but it's probably harder.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#22

Re: Laminated Steel Colonial Edge Tool

William Duffield

I have a reproduction hatchet made in January of this year by Steve Mankowsky, Colonial Williamsburg blacksmith. He told me it is cast iron welded to 1080 steel, and was typical of the methods they would have used in Colonial times. He then showed me a large pile of 1080 steel in various shapes just outside the door of the new armory. It appeared to be salvaged. I don't know what the difference is between 1080 and 1070, or how close either would have been to steel available in the mid 18th Century colonial America. The curly maple handle came into the shop as firewood, and he decided it was too nice to waste, even though that was not typically what would have been used for axe or hammer handles, due to durability issues.


Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#23

The red herring of sharpenability

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Anyone choosing to not be wedded to 1720 steel technology does not have to be wedded to 1720 sharpening technology. A fact: Any modern steel can be sharpened as easily as any 1720 steel composition using similarly modern abrasives and techniques.

While it may be a valid personal choice to freeze the technology in one's shop at 1720 ( or pick a date, or country) this personal choice should not be a basis for disparaging the attributes of a steel , tool, abrasive to someone willing to adapt what ever is available to their woodworking.

I completely understand someone that has invested years developing a successful shop routine not being interested in changing. That said, if a statement is made that A2, or whatever, is "difficult to sharpen" this claim is misleading to some unless the claim is qualified by the abrasive choices involved.

This red herring of sharpenability is holding back the development and acceptance of modern steel in woodworking. Anyone willing to spring $500 for a new set of quality chisels should find the expense of the optimum sharpening media irrelevant no matter the steel they were made of. I offer the example of the commonly bought Tormak at $$$$ to illustrate that sharpening media should not be a limitation to buying tools made from high performance steel.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#24

Re: Laminated Steel Colonial Edge Tool

david weaver

Cast iron is an interesting choice over mild steel if wrought isn't available.

1080 and 1070 would probably make a better hatchet and axe than W1, speaking about axe as in something you'd take outside vs. a carver's hatchet that wouldn't ever be subjected to flotsam and jetsam that is on outside wood.

I don't know about the average vintage iron, but I'd bet that there were many tools that were made over the eutectic limit in the old days. Razors certainly were, and they have the greatest demand on ideal grain structure.

The big change in razors technologically had more to do with grinding and heat treating, though, and that wasn't figured out until probably the late 1800s. Razors before that were heavier and more clunky and had to be taken back to a cutler as their gradual hollows caused fattened edges and spine wear.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#25

Re: Not red herring, more like luxury

david weaver

There's little that's more convenient when doing something like excavating a row of half blinds than being able to sit down and refresh the edge of a chisel with a single finish stone, or to be able to resharpen your planes with one stone.

It's of particular interest to me because I'm lazy.

I haven't found the equilvalent to refreshing a vintage stanley plane with a washita stone (or a vintage laminated plane), nor the equivalent to refreshing a modern japanese chisel with a single japanese finishing stone (while sharpening).

I don't think there is a lack of acceptance of modern steel in woodworking. I'd imagine those with the money choose it every time.

I think the fallacy is that it offers some sort of functional advantage in the context of work. Of my own accord, and not to be a contrarian, I went with wondersteel first and gradually migrated to vintage steel, which is something that I thought (the vintage steel) was counterproductive early on.

You can replicate maintaining a wondersteel chisel with diamond in the shop, but it's not the same experience for me. Plane wear is too great to use a single abrasive, and the edge quality of even a 3 micron diamond edge is not the same as a washita (the washita is perfectly acceptable for paring, and though less sharp than ultra fine abrasives, it's very even in the cut whereas modern abrasives that are too coarse just make a very abrupt and gross feeling cut).