New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

Posts

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#26

the point was

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

that alloying elements affect what carbides are formed as well as their rate of formation, size and who knows what else.

Lee Valley was close to developing a steel for tools that was more abrasion resistant than what they wound up with. In concert with the steel development they were working on abrasives as I recall. Again from memory(potentially unreliable) I recall they had a "water stone" that handled M2 acceptably. M2 can be successfully ground on aluminum oxide wheels. It's nice because one does not have to be pickly about over-heating the edge.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#27

Re: the point was

david weaver

I guess that's fine, but it doesn't solve any actual problems in the shop.

I thought I had m2-ish tools at one point, because I have several mujingfang planes and a set of mujingfang HSS chisels, but I'm not sure if the composition of the chisels is a M series HSS or of it's more similar to the vintage HSS that had a finer tungsten based composition. The latter is more expensive, but makes a better woodworking tool.

At any rate, the assumption that any of these solve any real problem over even basic stanley plane irons is relevant only for a rank beginner who finds sharpening to be a many minute process. If anyone thinks that there is a practical advantage in a plane, then they are fiddling with shavings too thin, even if they are just smoothing (they're literally taking longer even if that's all they do).

T series steels have been around for a very long time, and some were tried in razors, and I'm sure that tool makers experimented with them in hand tools, but they never found any favor when the workers using the tools were more than hobbyists. The only thing absent to someone was diamond powder, but that's not a big deal with t series tools - oxide pigments and friable silicon carbide stones down to a very fine level have been available for a very long time, and the silicon carbide stones were the same price as the natural stones. Oxide pigments to refine their work would've cost almost nothing.

We're still using the same oxide pigments. And the same base abrasives in stones, some sort of alundum or carborundum-ish abrasive. Both of those have been available, even in large format resin bound hones for a very very long time. Swaty and others tried making 8x3 format versions of their bound aluminum oxide razor hones, which would be comparable to current ceramic stones, and perhaps better to some degree, but nobody wanted them.

It's a brochure problem (the notion that there is some deficiency in edge holding to be solved), the pot of gold at the end of the rainbow for a beginner who has a false notion that competence and achievement in the shop will occur with less sharpening. But it's experience that they lack, not gimmicks. Experience brings satisfaction and increases in efficiency that are on a scale of 20 times that of gimmick fixes.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#28

Very confused...

John in NM

Are you actually comparing a relatively coarse stone to 3 micron diamond?

Try comparing a Washita to 30 micron, those should be roughly the same.

If the goal is a single grit sharpening set up, you can do that as easily with diamond as with anything else, you have to make the very same compromises as you would with natural stones or waterstones.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#29

Re: Very confused...

david weaver

A good washita stone will easily make an edge as sharp as 3 micron diamonds, but it takes a sharpener who knows what they're doing.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Aa0pBnph9q8

The problem with the particle size sheets floating around is they don't do anything to describe how a competent sharpener will use an abrasive and what results that abrasive will provide. Particle size doesn't do well to describe what a washita stone is, or even an arkansas stone - washitas are a matrix of novaculite with pores in it. It's the pores that allow them to cut as they wear and not jagged particles.

Here's more use of a single washita sharpening. I don't even like a 15 or 10 micron diamond plate that's broken in for any kind of use. I have tried them, though, to see if I can find anything else that's as convenient as a single washita stone.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=04iTo9rrfbw

Pardon the fairly close set on the cap iron and the herky jerky on the planing, I was a bit conservative and at the same time wanting to take a coarse shaving to blow both OWTs that you can't plane figured wood without thin shavings and razor sharpness, but I don't do multiple takes on videos as such a thing is not very authentic. Would've been easier to plane with the aid of the vise on the other end of the bench, but there's nowhere put the phone to record a video if I do that.

(pardon also the inability to get a good look at shaving hair with the chisel in the first video)

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#30

Avoid plates like the plague

John in NM

Loose grit is the way to go, nickel bonded plates are a waste of money as you have discovered. Resin bonded plates would be my first choice other than loose grit, but as far as I know, no one markets them for blade sharpening. Perhaps I've missed it though, my experience with them is purely in lapidary work.

I have no problem with your preference for a Washita stone, it just doesn't make any sense to me to compare it to such fine grit diamond.

I'm a little surprised to hear a Washita described as a novaculite, I'd always thought it was a quartzite. Strictly speaking, cherts (novaculite is a chert) are not porous. Given that the two are often interbedded, it wouldn't surprise me a bit if the distinction is lost on quarrymen and woodworkers.

I suppose I should watch your videos.... have I mentioned how I hate videos? :D I'll give it a try though.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#31

Re: Avoid plates like the plague

david weaver

I think the video, first or second, would provide some evidence about why what a washita stone does is similar to a coarse diamond grit. the groove shape is shallower than diamonds, and the ultimate sharpness of a broken in washita is probably at or a little better than 3 micron diamonds, but with a quality to the edge that's better.

It's a bit of a misnomer for the charts and the stone marketers to call cheap soft stones that are low density the same thing as washita, as the only true washita stones that I know of come from the pike/norton mines. Anything else labeled as such is a soft arkansas stone.

It's my understanding that both are novaculite.

http://arkarcheology.uark.edu/novaculite/index.html?pageName=Novaculite+as+Whetstone+Rock

I'm no geology expert, so I'm not totally sure what any of them are, except that they aren't simple sedimentary hones like slates and japanese stones (not to suggest that simple SiO2 hones aren't very capable, they just vary a lot).

I think this thing about a washita stone making a coarse dull edge must have legs, because when I suggested on SMC a year ago that I had come to appreciate sharpening with a single washita stone, I got several insults from members about how I was employing a hokey methods and fiddling with dull tools.

There's a second thing with washita, too, and that relates to the abrasive being about the same hardness as very hard steel. That is, the relatively large pores and structure actually make blindingly sharp white II steel when used as a polish stone, and they make a wonderful finish on the jigane/hagane combination - indistinguishable from an expensive japanese stone that has a favorable hardness for providing an attractive finish.

(I did, by the way, manage to take a shaving of half a thousandth off of a washita edge - that is one indicator that they're not that coarse unless they are abraded into a coarse slurry with a diamond hone. they're a very multidimensional stone, whereas diamonds only do one thing).

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#32

Terminology

John in NM

Unfortunately, grit size is a very difficult thing to measure, and there are many contradictory standards.

However, most references I have seen place the average Washita stone around J600, 30 micron, 360 grit.

Any grit in a matrix will behave differently than loose grit however, and I believe it is here that the discrepancy resides. I am tempted to dig out some resin bonded laps and try swiping some steel across them. I bet they will behave a lot like your favorite Washita stone. Maybe I'll mail you one if you want to compare it, though that would be more useful if anyone made similar products for honing chisels.

I use two bench stones for sharpening, a Crystolon as a coarse stone and something roughly like a soft Arkansas for fine. I'm sure the SMC crew would look upon that with some contempt as well. I have a hard Arkansas too but it is rarely used. Someone gave me both of those. I may have one of those black surgical stones around too, but I don't find it any more useful than the white one.

The soft Arkansas is not a novaculite, it is a quartzite and is quite porous. Novaculites and cherts are not porous by any petrographic definition of the term. I can only speculate, but I suspect there is some confusion over surface roughness and porosity. Unfortunately, there is no rigorous and repeatable measure of that property applied to sharpening stones either.

Both of my hard stones are what I would call a novaculite, though neither are especially nice examples as they lack the surface roughness needed for fast yet fine cutting.

I have an old slipstone that is a fantastic piece of translucent chert. If all stones worked like that one, life would be good. For the most part, I find there to be far too much random ignorance and unpredictability when it comes to Arkansas stones and marketing, however. That alone keeps me from buying any that I can't get my hands on first.

It could well be that most of my dislike for novaculites has to do with only owning examples that people gave me - no one gives away good stones :D

That fantastic slipstone is one I inherited, so the gift was involuntary.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#33

Re: Terminology

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I get the idea you don't have much experience with Arkansas stones. My Washita is used after the 1200 grit stone. It gives a finer edge. I would put the soft Arkansas around the 6-8000 equivalent. People without experience often have a different idea.

If you expect the soft Arkansas stone to cut like a 1000 grit water stone, you will be disappointed. If you expect the 1000 stone to polish like a soft Arkansas, you will likewise be disappointed.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#34

Re: Terminology

david weaver

I don't know what the difference is between quartzite and novaculite. I guess as dan's describes novaculite, it's quartz crystals. I've read elsewhere that novaculite is silicon dioxide that's undergone a chemical change.

A while ago, I took a microscope picture of the surface of two stones. One (here) is a fairly fine washita stone. The particles are not distinguishable. The idea that they are 30 microns is false, and where such a notion would come from, I don't know.


Again, it's the fallacy of reading one of those grit charts and thinking that it's instructive. They are not particularly so, other than comparing like abrasives.

For example, I can get a finer razor edge (by far) from a translucent oilstone (with 3-5 micron size particles) than I can from any sythetic stone with 1-3 micron particles.

here's another consideration with these things, take a look at these razor edges:

http://straightrazorplace.com/srpwiki/index.php/Edges_produced_by_various_hones

Look at the edge produced by the norton hone (first picture, aluminum oxide, probably 2-3 microns). Then look at the edge produced by a thuringian hone, again, silicon dioxide probably in the 3-4 micron range. The bevel on the razor looks fairly similar, but look at the edge. It's torn up by the norton hone, but not the thuringian.

You can't take a lap with synthetic abrasive and think that it's going to compare to a novaculite hone, the edge that comes off of it won't be as good unless the particle size is many times smaller, it doesn't matter how long you use the particles - they are too much harder than the steel compared to the novaculite.

I think you are correct about not using the stones enough. What I gather from what you're saying is that you don't have any experience with them, at least substantive, and that's the problem. You can toss the grit charts, they are not instructive when the grit gets away from synthetic abrasives.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#35

Of course not...

John in NM

You can get that idea just by reading my post :D

I have even less experience with water stones as I have found them less useful than Arkansas stones.

I do find the soft Arkansas stone useful, so that is the one I use. The hard ones I have are junk. The slipstone is an amazing little piece of rock - I suspect it is the type of stone on which the hard Arkansas reputation is based.

I'm assuming that your grit comparisons are based on JIS numbers? So the 1200 you mention is J1200 as opposed to ANSI 1200?

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#36

Re: Of course not...

david weaver

King 1200, old JIS format. Not that I'm warren, but I've seen him talk about it before.

Soft arkansas are usually substandard stones that are a step in a process but not an endpoint at either (they're not particularly fast - unless the steel is very soft, and not particularly fine, unless the steel is so hard that they can't cut it).

The slipstone you have is probably indicative of translucent, I took a picture of a bone colored trans stone, too.


I also took a picture of a cheap soft, compare this to the washita and have a look at how the particles in the matrix are actually distinctive.


The difference in the looks of some softs vs. the washitas is small to the naked eye, but they are much different in operation.

When washita stones were widely available, soft arkansas stones were sold at about half of their price as a low priced (but also functionally inferior - you get what you pay for) alternative to the somewhat expensive and desirable washita.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#37

Re: One more..

david weaver

This is the surface of a woodworker's delight, which by my estimation was a true washita (and I've seen others say the same).

Notice how the surface is very vague. So much so that I think the scope had trouble figuring out what it was trying to see.


Me, too. When a washita is brand new and a bright white soft is brand new, it can be difficult to tell them apart until you actually use them. If this were a soft arkansas, the particles in a stone as porous as this one would be very distinctive.

This stone has a wide range, it can be abraded and cut fast, or it can cut very finely and almost put on a bright polish to hardened steel (it certainly easily shaves hair off of your arm).

One of the things I did when i made planes was to make several, including one out of cocobolo, sharpening with a washita stone. It was sufficient for everything including a paring chisels, and really the paring chisel was the only place where I noticed that it came up a little short of something like a translucent. The shaving coming out of the plane sizing a blank isn't quite as waxy as that of a plane sharpened with translucent, either.

I can only say this, as a pig who has bought every type of stone I can find that is remotely reasonable, from volcanic stuff from japan, to english stones, to german, belgian, scotch, american of all types, chinease, as well as a huge array of synthetics and everything from CBN, to diamond, to iron oxides to chromium oxides, and loose alumina - those charts that bloggers refer to are pretty pointless as a reference for practical sharpening value of stones.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#38

Novaculite

John in NM

Is nothing more than a variety of microcrystaline quartz of sedimentary origin, in other words, a chert. Chert is generally thought to have been altered by low grade metamorphic processes after deposition, though I have also read theories that it forms as some kind of silicious precipitation. It could well be a combination of the two.

A quartzite is a sandstone that has been fused somewhat by heat and pressure, basically a natural sintering of quartz grains. It wouldn't surprise me a bit if a lot of the "soft Arkansas" out there were this stuff rather than a chert material - the examples I have are certainly that.

Ah well, I believe we are discussing this using different definitions, and different levels of experience with the various options. Kinda makes it completely pointless.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#39

Quartzite

david weaver

When I look at pictures of some quartzite, it looks vaguely like the solid areas found in some washita stones.

However, they are not flaky or fractured in those stones. The only novaculite stone that I know of that has that flakiness is crete stones.

I get the sense that you're not grasping what warren and I are saying, but I hope you have taken from this that a washita stone and 30 micron diamonds are not remotely similar. they're not similar in particle size, and even if they were, the results are vastly different. You can sharpen a razor with a washita stone, but you can't come close to getting an acceptable shave off of 3 micron diamond. Even 1 micron diamond is harsh and undesirable because it beats up a razor edge.

Regardless of terminology, semantics aren't valuable, what the stones can actually do vs. how they're presented on simplified charts is much more important.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#40

What I've concluded from this...

John in NM

Is that a Washita stone is not more coarse than a soft Arkansas, contrary to my earlier supposition. I suppose that would be more relevant if I ever planned to try one.

I suspect that the difference you see in grit vs. stone has a lot to do with the mechanism of abrasive polishing vs. what could be described as chemical polishing. You see the same thing when polishing stone with fine aluminum oxide vs. diamond grit. With some minerals the difference is pronounced enough to seem magical, though it is really just chemistry.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#41

Re: What I've concluded from this...

david weaver

Yeah, there's nothing magical about it.

The "trick" is that the abrasive and steel hardness in novaculite and the slates are relatively similar, so the action of the grit cutting is less deep. That means its less deep at the edge, too, which means after removing the false edge with a strop, what's left is more even and less jagged.

There isn't a natural abrasive that I'm aware of in a natural stone form that's got particles below about 3 microns, and the smallest I'm aware of is the stuff mined in kyoto. But that's sediment, and the surface is far different than stones that underwent a change. Here's a picture of a tsushima stone, roughly equivalent in final finish to a washita stone with experienced use.


Particles are distinctive.

What's important with this (or maybe it's not, i don't know) is that there is no magic, it's literally the physical properties of the stone and how it works with metal that's important. A chart with numbers doesn't satisfy, because natural stones have a wider range and are much more dependent on the skill of the user and the selection of steel.

As a former buyer of everything, my suggestion is that people who like to put an iron in a guide and drag it across an abrasive will not find much satisfaction in a washita stone or really any natural stone. that's more suited to the graded abrasive crowd. Same for people freehanding who are only worried about having a stone that cuts everything they have equally. Go for diamonds on a lap, it's the only thing that does.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#42

Charts

John in NM

I've no idea which bloggers you speak of, my distaste for bloggers matches my distaste for youtube :D mostly for the same reasons.

I do not mention said charts in an attempt to say that they establish and equivalency, only to try to guess what you are talking about when you compare a Washita stone to a specific micron size of diamond.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#43

Re: Charts

david weaver

There is a growing bunch of charts that get tossed around on woodworking and knife sharpening blogs that describe the grit size in various stones.

For a while years ago there were various assertions made about how "a translucent oilstone is 4000 grit", and how coarse india stones were based on the particle size they use.

One other chart that gets referenced is stone grading charts that shows washita as a less dense or coarser grade of soft arkansas. That leads people to believe that it's going to be a coarse and fast cutting stone. Its density is less than an arkansas stone, but a simplified assertion that the density relationship with arkansas stones can be extrapolated to drop true washitas on a grid is inaccurate.

There are plenty of people with a lot of experience who say otherwise, but the desire to comment off of a spec sheet (not yours here, just forum talk in general) leads to people believing the spec sheet over reality.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#44

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussi

Steve Voigt

"George also has mentioned before, and I don't see most other people saying it other than japanese blacksmiths, that he does not heat material above a cherry red when forging, and certainly not to the flux point that larry advocates. George's words are "you'll ruin it", and presumably by that he's suggesting both carbon migration and growth of the grain structure."

Yikes, this thread is getting off track.

I'm pretty sure the above is not correct. What most people do is to heat the steel to non-magnetic. This assures that the phase change has taken place. If this temp is not exceeded by much, and/or if you don't hold the steel above non-magnetic for a long time, then grain growth should not be an issue.

What Larry is trying to do with his pools of carbon demo is to identify the point, just slightly below non-magnetic, where the phase change has taken place. The difference, IIRC, is only around 25-50 degrees.

If someone is heating the steel below the point where the carbon pools, they are not getting a phase change and are not hardening the steel. I think George is just confused about what Larry is doing.

For the backyard heat treater, as least in my admittedly limited experience, not getting hot enough is a much bigger problem than getting too hot.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#45

Aha... *LINK*

John in NM

Never seen one of those.

I've been talking about something like this one in the link. It's the sort of thing that is useful when someone is talking about mesh sized grit and you are accustomed to thinking in microns.

They are far less useful if one is talking about comparing loose grit to some kind of Japanese wonder stone.

If nothing else, you and Warren have dispelled the notion that a Washita is a coarser grade of soft Arkansas. I wouldn't blame the bloggers for that though, that notion comes from marketing, probably right from the quarry.


grit conversion

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#46

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussi

david weaver

Underheating has been my problem, too. I think George probably has a lot more experience and can be closer to upper critical than I can, just by judgement.

Same as the japanese blacksmiths who harden in the dark would be.

I had a mosaku (kikuo kanda) plane that Wilbur now has, and I have to say that it was incredibly incredibly hard compared to some of the commodity planes I've had. I also have a boutique plane (Ogata) that is highly regarded and in all honesty, isn't really very hard. It's a beautiful plane to use because it's super easy to sharpen and dulls in a way that doesn't degrade a wood surface (very finely grained). I would rather have not sold the marvelously hard Mosaku, but I can't keep everything that I don't use or things start to rust. Ogata is probably not far off from being found with rust, and put in the mail.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#47

Re: Aha...

david weaver

Here's one that was tossed around on the blogs.

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/10/GritComparisonChart2.pdf

The strange thing about it is that you can't really blame PWW for saying the washita is 35 microns, because norton themselves said that. It's strange that norton would actually believe that because they are the only ones who have a mine that has legitimate washitas in it.

It's a small segment of their business, I guess they just don't care.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#48

Concepts and comparisons

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

the particle size (distribution) of loose grit is trivial to measure. I suppose when some grit size is fused into a "stone" the stone is described as being this grit size? How fast this stone abrades depends on how the particle and matrix wears, with its grit size being only part of the determining factors of how fast it removes material by abrasion. Consider a silica deposited atom by atom to yield the final material like the ARK stones and I don't see that grit size is a concept that applies to describing the stone. What is being measure to get this number? Given the interaction of particle hardness/shape and metal abrasion resistance one can't even make any meaningful statement about scratch equivalent between stones without specifying the metal and other factors.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#49

I'll make a wager.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"There's little that's more convenient when doing something like excavating a row of half blinds than being able to sit down and refresh the edge of a chisel with a single finish stone,"

I'll bet you are using a chisel that dulls by micro deformations of the edge and this finish stone is straightening the edge to render the chisel sharper. I do the same with my CPM 3V chisels using some sort of dense white ARK stone. I have followed the situation by microscopy so I know with confidence what is going on in my case. I am, of course, speculating your case. Metal does not go away when chiseling unless it chips away, and I have yet to see a good American made chisel that dulls by micro-chipping other than the M2 chisel I made.

Re: Let's have another mind-numbing steel discussion

#50

Re: I'll make a wager.....

david weaver

Maybe I should take one off of the bench at some point and put it under the microscope to see what's actually going on at the edge. To some extent, it is probably a micro scale of what a knife edge looks like, where some metal is missing and some is bent.

Nice thing about those types of stones, the sharpness isn't too transient, so they have the same feel under the mallet the whole time. Whereas something that is done up on chrome ox powder has an initial jolt of slipperiness in a light cut, but it's very transient.