Re: Terminology
david weaver
I don't know what the difference is between quartzite and novaculite. I guess as dan's describes novaculite, it's quartz crystals. I've read elsewhere that novaculite is silicon dioxide that's undergone a chemical change.
A while ago, I took a microscope picture of the surface of two stones. One (here) is a fairly fine washita stone. The particles are not distinguishable. The idea that they are 30 microns is false, and where such a notion would come from, I don't know.

Again, it's the fallacy of reading one of those grit charts and thinking that it's instructive. They are not particularly so, other than comparing like abrasives.
For example, I can get a finer razor edge (by far) from a translucent oilstone (with 3-5 micron size particles) than I can from any sythetic stone with 1-3 micron particles.
here's another consideration with these things, take a look at these razor edges:
http://straightrazorplace.com/srpwiki/index.php/Edges_produced_by_various_hones
Look at the edge produced by the norton hone (first picture, aluminum oxide, probably 2-3 microns). Then look at the edge produced by a thuringian hone, again, silicon dioxide probably in the 3-4 micron range. The bevel on the razor looks fairly similar, but look at the edge. It's torn up by the norton hone, but not the thuringian.
You can't take a lap with synthetic abrasive and think that it's going to compare to a novaculite hone, the edge that comes off of it won't be as good unless the particle size is many times smaller, it doesn't matter how long you use the particles - they are too much harder than the steel compared to the novaculite.
I think you are correct about not using the stones enough. What I gather from what you're saying is that you don't have any experience with them, at least substantive, and that's the problem. You can toss the grit charts, they are not instructive when the grit gets away from synthetic abrasives.