New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Kiyotada

Posts

Re: Kiyotada

#51

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

david weaver

The lacquer on the sides of the stone is a type called urushi. I have had stones that have urushi on them, but I've never put it on myself. it's not a bad idea, and it does make especially the green tomae stones look classy. Some of the more color desirable stones, I'd hate to seal them unless they need it, but if they start to delaminate anywhere, they need it.

I think it may have been David Wong, but maybe it was someone else, who I sold my ohira tomae stone to, and then it subsequently delaminated, and if it was David, he sealed it and described the process well.

I haven't tried shellac, but shellac that I've had on things that have gotten wet hasn't held up too well.

Re: Kiyotada

#52

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita.. *LINK*

David Wong (in Cupertino, CA)

You can search for "Repairing a natural waterstone" on sawmillcreek to see how I used cashew lacquer and persimmon paper on a delaminating stone. I have been using the stone daily since then and the lacquer has held up. The most important preventative measure I implemented was to attach my natural stones to a permanent base. I feel this prevents stressing the stone when lifting it around. I am careful to only lift the stones by the base. I have a nakayama asagi that I did not seal. The stone is very hard and did not seem like it needed it.

There seem to be places in the US that sell cashew lacquer now if you want to go that way.


hyper-cafe.com

Re: Kiyotada

#53

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

Alex Grigoriev

By a curious coincidence, Lee Valley has always recommended 35 deg bevel on their A2 plane blades

Re: Kiyotada

#54

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

david weaver

Is that true for all of them, BU planes included? I thought Derek had concluded that you could get away with less on BU planes.

Derek?

I'll bet that if one looks around, lots of places will recommend 35 degrees.

I came across it in use, but only because the first honing method I set up was based on David Charlesworth's DVD, where the final bevel is 35 degrees. I went to freehand after that and noticed that around 30 degrees, I was always fighting tiny chips (which are a problem when you're trying to finish a surface with a plane, it's full of tiny lines).

And then went back to charlesworth's method for a while when honing smoothers because of it.

I also found out incidentally testing irons that were sent to me several years ago that the iron that microchips first is going to be the iron that fails to cut at all the fastest. thus, an iron honed at 35 degrees (for A2) will cut longer and wear better than one at 30, even though you're starting with less clearance.

I think Steve Elliot put something like that, the reasons behind it, in a formal study but don't have time to go look. IIRC, he recommended 34 or something similar, and showed that chipping was still a problem around 32.

I have to say thanks to David Charlesworth for putting out a video that a rank beginner can get a shave sharp edge with the very first time they try to hone something, and one where all of the irons on the market hold together well.

(all of my fiddling with various irons was with BD LN planes)

Re: Kiyotada

#55

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Fellas. I'll leave them go for now and if anything strange develops I'll coat them in the aforementioned lacquer.

Re: Kiyotada

#56

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

Alex Grigoriev

Their BU blades are 25 deg, though

Re: Kiyotada

#57

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

Brian Holcombe

Got my stone!! Going to put this to use quickly.

Nice that Takeshi ships from Hawaii so there is no need to be concerned with customs hang ups.

Re: Kiyotada

#58

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

Brian Holcombe

And the result, on the wood is looking pretty sweet. That mark is from wax on the plane sole.

I ordered a good strop today to round out this routine, a kanoyama cordovan attached to wood from Takeshi. I know from my satorial interests the nice characteristics of shell cordovan, so looking forward to finishing with that and doing away with the palm stropping method.


img

Re: Kiyotada

#59

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

david weaver

Looks good!

Kanayama's cordovan is a much better cordovan for tools than would be something like Horween.

That's high class tool stropping, though!

Re: Kiyotada

#60

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

Brian Holcombe

Awesome! looking forward to putting it to use. Arrives Wednesday....so long as the Post office cooperates. I see they have grits listed on many of his strops, I assume this has something to do with his processing. Luckily there was only one choice for strops mounted to wood.

Re: Kiyotada

#61

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

david weaver

You mean kanayama's large razor strops? (I think the story is on aoki's site that I'm spelling it wrong, but that's how it's spelled on the strop - that naomi (the maker) would rather just stick with it)

He has a numbering system for his razor strops, they are all shell cordovan, but of various qualities and various backing strops. The firmer cordovan is used on the higher numbered strops, and the softer on the low numbered. The rest of the variances are length of the strop and what's attached to the top cordovan.

I had the shorter of the two best (the 80,000 - which is a full sized strop, the 90,000 is oversize) and sold it, it was a fantastic strop, but I already had a nice broken in horse butt strop and wanted a vintage linen instead of what was attached to the kanayama. Sort of a picky thing. I also didn't want to hold it long enough for it to get damaged, or getting most of the cost back wouldn't have been doable.

That said, shell cordovan is really high quality, and it's not dependent on a surface treatment like horween so it will be durable. if it gets contaminated, you can scrape the surface and keep going. The initial surface on a horween strop is fantastic, but the leather below is thin and hard, not quite the right thing for tools in my opinion (and at $300 for a shell, it's not a threat to show up for tools). The surface treatment on the horween is also not very durable.

Re: Kiyotada

#62

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

Brian Holcombe

I believe so. Oddly enough the wood mounted strops have it spelled Kanoyama, but the razor strops have it spelled Kanayama. When I first saw this I did some searching on it and found the same explanation.

The horween shells must be finished mostly for shoes. I'm fairly certain that AE, Alden, and Crockett and Jones use Horween, so I wouldn't be surprised to find that they gear the finish to suit the needs of the shoe companies over other uses.

I appreciate the explanation on the grits.

I feel I should get into straight razors as well at this point...that way everything is doing double duty. hehe...

Re: Kiyotada

#63

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

david weaver

I'd be glad to point you to a good place to start with straight razors if you want to get into that. I'm sure that suita would finish a razor, and there has been a big glut of NOS razors on ebay from nichiri razor company (razors that were made when standards were still high).

I never share strops, though, the edge of a razor is only at about 17 degrees, and thus susceptible to anything that could contaminate a strop. A decent razor strop can be made easily, though.

Once you shave with a straight razor, everything else will seem inferior. It just takes a little bit of time to get used to it so that you can do it quickly. The benefit of it is that you have control of all sorts of variables, and your razor will be the same sharpness every day. No initial harshness and no progressive dullness after the sweet spot of sharpness.

Re: Kiyotada

#64

we've taken a left turn into shoes and razors...

Brian Holcombe

Thanks David, I will keep those in mind, they look awesome and are pretty reasonable. I expect to make a smooth recovery from my stones addiction and move right into straight razors in the next few months.

That is the issue I have with my current razor setup, I use those japanese throw away razors (double edge) and they're awesomely sharp out of the box and for a shave or two, one of the few things that will cut my beard hair without issue (a downside of being partial italian). I really dont keep after how many shaves I've made with it, so I'm not tossing them in the trash until I notice them pulling.

A nice cut all the time would be better. I've got a vintage Keen Kutter from my grandfather that I've rehoned but it awaits a good stropping to make it really cut cleanly (I hope) and once I get medium/good results out of this I'm sure I'll be hooked on straight razors.

Re: Kiyotada

#65

Re: we've taken a left turn into shoes and razors.

david weaver

You'll probably not match a feather blade, but you'll be able to match the closeness of the shave (if that makes sense - there's a level of additional sharpness that ends up not cutting hair any better, but it does make weepers because it cuts everything in its path).

The ideal thing for really heavy hair is, well, two things:

* a first pass where you're not that particular about the closeness

* a razor that has some size and heft. Often the vintage US razors are 5/8 size and thinly ground, so are a lot of the vintage german razors, and they are light. I think those razors are preferable for a barber who will use light strokes. The japanese cutlers had various grinds, and the good dealers on ebay will show you the profile of the razor at the end. You can find a heavier grind without getting a "wedge" profile, but the best (and uncommon) will be a razor that's got a lot of weight in the spine but that is thinly ground toward the edge.

I don't want to be an enabler or anything, the KK will do fine. If you figure out what aspects of it you don't like (if any), I'd be glad to point out a type of grind that eliminates whatever the issues might be. A vintage razor used to be about a day's wage or a good part of one. There are a lot of good NOS razors that can be had for half of that equivalent now or a little less, and some vintage types that are really expensive. I haven't noticed a great deal of difference between the marked and well ground razors that are $80-$100 and the ones that are $300, only that there are a few cutlers who were very adept at a very thin grind without threatening the straightness of a razor. I'd avoid brand new straights, they are OK, but they cost as much or more than NOS and they just aren't as skillfully ground.

Re: Kiyotada

#66

Re: we've taken a left turn into shoes and razors.

Brian Holcombe

Thanks David! Matching the feather would be quite a feat, but exactly as you mention basically looking to minimize pulling and get a clean pass. I do the light pass first even with the feather blades, it slows me down a bit but it makes for a better shave with my beard.

Thanks for your offer, I'll work out the KK as best that I can and after a few shaves figure out what I dislike about it then go from there into finding a good profile.

Enable away, lol, this is one of the things I've been kicking around for a while so I figure it's time to go ahead with it.

Cheers!