Re: Kayoko Kuroiwa
david weaver
I had that exact stone, and sold it not because there was anything wrong with it, but because I was turning stones over trying things. I had a shoubu that was almost identical, and I sold it and was glad to see it go.
I'd say that it's middle of the road for *quality* stones, not middle of the road per se compared to a lot of what's out there (there's a lot of reject stuff being sold right now). But middle among quality stones.
It is one of the ohira stones, and I can't read kanji, but I'd guess that it says ippon-sen on it and probably either shohonzan or honyama or shohonyama.
I'm no expert on mines, either, I know that most of them are closed. I can't recall if ohira is still open or shoubu, I do know that the resurgence in razors has led to mining or use of material that was previously thought to be too hard to use - IIRC, some of the mines have some surface mining going on. Whether it's mining or just picking, I don't know.
So, anyway, I would assume those are tomae strata stone, and if you'd compare it to cars, you'd say it's a toyota or honda of natural stones. Does the job, good quality, consistent and reliable (if you got 10 of them, they'd be similar).
If I say I'm nonplussed by tomae strata stone (though they might be a strata adjacent), that's only in comparison to a good suita of similar fineness. But good suita cost more. No free lunch.
Shoubu are the other common stone, and like I said in one of my other posts, they have a funny tendency to get scratched up every easily by tools - it's very strange to use them. I've had three, and all of them are like that. It's like the stone bursts around the scratch line into a little line of dust, too.
I guess there's lots of other common ones, too, like ozuku, but shoubu and ohira are probably two types that we'd run into as woodworkers.
Anyway, a good middle of the road stone. Better than the multitude of soft stones out there now that used to be considered junk and are being sold as knife stones. Not quite as good as the very high dollar nakayama and choice okudo/shinden suita types.
I'm convinced the reason that most japanese tools sharpen better on the japanese stones is because those stones have particles that are a bit sharp for western tools, and no natural stone particles that I know of are smaller than about 3 microns, which would be pretty large for a synthetic particle in a super finisher. They can cut deeper edges in western tools and leave a coarser edge. Most of my stones leave somewhat mediocre results in western tools, but experimentation might lead to better results.
I did notice that the ohira that I had put a very nice even finish on tools with a nice contrast between hard and soft steel. And it did so without leaving scratches - not all stones do.