New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Kiyotada

Posts

Re: Kiyotada

#26

Re: Kayoko Kuroiwa

Hank Knight

David,

Have you ever done business with Kayoko Kuriowa? I have ordered chisels from her on several occasions and have been pleased with her service. On the recommendation of several people, I asked her to select a natural stone for me. I was told that she occasionally is given the privilege of selecting stones from a large supplier for her customers and is good at matching stones with her customers' needs. She found a very nice Honyama (correct term?) for me, but I do not know its origin. it is a very hard, clear stone with a greenish - khaki color. It leaves a wonderful matte finish on my blades. I have been very happy with the stone and, again, happy with Kayoko's service. Just curious since I haven't seen her name in this or other recent discussions.

Hank

Re: Kiyotada

#27

Re: Kayoko Kuroiwa

david weaver

Is Kayoko the person who is or was running Misugi designs? If so, I have gotten a stone from her, but indirectly. She had a gigantic pile of ohira tomae stones that hida sells as labeled "ippon sen", which means "select / specially selected" or something of the sort.

I believe when she had to go back to japan (and I could be way off with this), she sold her stock of stones to hida, and it looks like someone else is selling them on ebay now - same exact stones with what looks like an imanishi label.

There are still a lot of stones around from ohira, and many from shoubu, too, they look similar but of the middle of the road stones I like ohira better - shoubu stones sometimes have a quality where the surface gets scratched easily by corners of tools and fractures up in a powder.

Honyama is sort of a generic term given to finishing stones, I don't know what it means other than it shows up on a lot of finishing stones.

I think a lot of people probably aren't using Kayoko because it's hard to find her, I didn't know she was still in business.

Re: Kiyotada

#28

Re: One Other Option I've Bought From

Brian Holcombe

Thanks again David! I appreciate the insights, I think I will also avoid stuff that makes the stone appealing visually, since appeal to me is all in how it performs. I'm happy with an ugly stone that does a fine job, then at some point if I'm collecting these guys I will find some admiration in how they look.

I just received my Gennou from So and a handle in ebony. Both are great pieces, I fit the handle tonight and can honestly say it's one of the best pieces of Macassar ebony I've seen. Dark through and through so bad for furniture, but very tight grained.

Re: Kiyotada

#29

Re: Kayoko Kuroiwa

Hank Knight

Thanks David. I have a contact email address for Kayoko after she returned to Japan to take care of Yataiki san. I haven't' used it in a couple of years so I don't know if she can still be reached at the address.

I know next to nothing about natural Japanese stones. I received this stone from Kayoko. I would like to know if it is a good /decent stone or a mediocre one. Is it one of the stones she left with Hida? I am totally lost with Japanese kanji and I can't make heads or tails out of the ones on this stone. As I mentioned, it makes a real difference in the final quality of the edge on my Japanese chisels, but has little effect on my Western ones.

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Woodworking%20Tools%20003a_zpsbidqre4b.jpg.html][/URL]

Thanks for any info you can give me on it.

Hank

Re: Kiyotada

#30

Re: Kayoko Kuroiwa

david weaver

I had that exact stone, and sold it not because there was anything wrong with it, but because I was turning stones over trying things. I had a shoubu that was almost identical, and I sold it and was glad to see it go.

I'd say that it's middle of the road for *quality* stones, not middle of the road per se compared to a lot of what's out there (there's a lot of reject stuff being sold right now). But middle among quality stones.

It is one of the ohira stones, and I can't read kanji, but I'd guess that it says ippon-sen on it and probably either shohonzan or honyama or shohonyama.

I'm no expert on mines, either, I know that most of them are closed. I can't recall if ohira is still open or shoubu, I do know that the resurgence in razors has led to mining or use of material that was previously thought to be too hard to use - IIRC, some of the mines have some surface mining going on. Whether it's mining or just picking, I don't know.

So, anyway, I would assume those are tomae strata stone, and if you'd compare it to cars, you'd say it's a toyota or honda of natural stones. Does the job, good quality, consistent and reliable (if you got 10 of them, they'd be similar).

If I say I'm nonplussed by tomae strata stone (though they might be a strata adjacent), that's only in comparison to a good suita of similar fineness. But good suita cost more. No free lunch.

Shoubu are the other common stone, and like I said in one of my other posts, they have a funny tendency to get scratched up every easily by tools - it's very strange to use them. I've had three, and all of them are like that. It's like the stone bursts around the scratch line into a little line of dust, too.

I guess there's lots of other common ones, too, like ozuku, but shoubu and ohira are probably two types that we'd run into as woodworkers.

Anyway, a good middle of the road stone. Better than the multitude of soft stones out there now that used to be considered junk and are being sold as knife stones. Not quite as good as the very high dollar nakayama and choice okudo/shinden suita types.

I'm convinced the reason that most japanese tools sharpen better on the japanese stones is because those stones have particles that are a bit sharp for western tools, and no natural stone particles that I know of are smaller than about 3 microns, which would be pretty large for a synthetic particle in a super finisher. They can cut deeper edges in western tools and leave a coarser edge. Most of my stones leave somewhat mediocre results in western tools, but experimentation might lead to better results.

I did notice that the ohira that I had put a very nice even finish on tools with a nice contrast between hard and soft steel. And it did so without leaving scratches - not all stones do.

Re: Kiyotada

#31

Re: Kayoko Kuroiwa

Hank Knight

Thanks David, the information is very helpful. I realized after I bought the stone that I had entered into a world of esoterica, about which I knew nothing and very possibly had blown a large sum of money. Your view is reassuring. The stone behaves very well, so I was reluctant to believe that I had a dog. The cost of these things is so high, I will probably not buy another, even tuough it would be fun to experiment with others. I can be content with the one I have and not harbor doubts that I had been taken to the cleaners. Thanks again.

Hank

Re: Kiyotada

#32

Re: Kayoko Kuroiwa

David Wong (in Cupertino, CA)

"大平礦山合� �石" - Ōhira kōzan gō toishi

Means Ōhira mine whetstone. The kanji on the left is "ippon-sen", according to my wife

This is from Google translate. The kanji 合 is usually "aa" or "ai". Don't know why it is showing as "gō". Also can't seem to get the kanji for whetstone to display.

Re: Kiyotada

#33

Re: Kayoko Kuroiwa

david weaver

It's a wise decision to stop at one!! No worries about getting taken. If you had a junk stone, you'd know it when you use it - it would either slough off slurry in droves, cut too slowly, or be scratchy.

It looks like Kayoko threw in a tomonagura (in the small box) or something similar, that's a nice touch.

Re: Kiyotada

#34

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

david weaver

...but I don't know, I've never had one. I looked around this morning at the different ones, including the two that kuroda has, but others, too, and they do look like pretty strong cutters.

Of course, if a stone dealer told me they had an ohira suita for less than okudo by a significant amount and it was just as strong of a cutting stone, I'd be inclined to go with the dealer's sentiment.

Sort of makes me want to buy one to try, but I'm trying to get away from doing that!!

Re: Kiyotada

#35

Re: Kayoko Kuroiwa

Hank Knight

Thank you, David, and your wife too. That is very helpful.

Re: Kiyotada

#36

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

Brian Holcombe

Hah, certainly gets expensive, especially along with a healthy tool addiction.

Re: Kiyotada

#37

nashiji

david weaver

In looking around, not that it's really worth the trouble to even post this, but just in case someone reads it and cares - I found this morning that nashiji, which I have seen as spots with black dots in them, refers to the light spots (and the black spots are not the part that is named nashiji, rather the larger light spots).

All of this talking about natural stones causes me to fall into bad habits keeping a window open at the various dealers and dreaming of more stones - but also corrects some of the things I think I know but don't.

Re: Kiyotada

#38

Re: Kayoko Kuroiwa

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

"It looks like Kayoko threw in a tomonagura (in the small box) or something similar, that's a nice touch."

I doubt anyone ever got stung by Kayoko. She'll short herself before she'll short you.

Wiley

Re: Kiyotada

#39

Re: Wiley, I'd love to hear your opinion...

david weaver

..on the various stones.

Most people have the sense to only try one or a couple, and I am vocal with my opinion, more vocal than my experience of a couple dozen stones should suggest.

I don't know how much experience you have with them, but I vaguely recall a long time ago that you mentioned that you had (paraphrasing) "only found one natural stone that cuts super blue".

Common wisdom that I've been told is hard stone for plain steel and softer stone for more complex steels, but I like a good suita better than either of those, pretty much for everything. I do like the very hard stones for razors, though.

Re: Kiyotada

#40

Also...

david weaver

...I'd love to see any pictures of stones that you might have that border on the sublime. I promise I won't beg them off of you! :)

Re: Kiyotada

#41

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

Brian Holcombe

David,

Made the move to 34 degrees on my A2 blades....world of difference in how well they remain very sharp. Thank you!

The Japanese stone is next, just sent Takeshi an email....

Re: Kiyotada

#42

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

Brian Holcombe

Another fallow up.

I ordered the Shinden suita that you suggested, so when it arrives I'll give it a try.

Re: Kiyotada

#43

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

david weaver

Good deal. I thought about buying it if you didn't, but it's not like I need it.

I still would like to have a suita with nice cream color. Maybe someday!!

(now you're obligated to tell everyone who ever talks about A2 chipping about the 34+ degree final bevel on a BD plane. I found it out firsthand, then went steep and fortunately later saw confirmation on Steve's site. I'll bet I've said something to a dozen people about it now, same thing. It's an OK steel if it's set up how it likes to be, but if not, it's just something that chips early and isn't very easy to sharpen compared to carbon steel - not a good combination!!)

Re: Kiyotada

#44

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

Brian Holcombe

Hah, I had a feeling that it would be tough to resist. These things are truly addicting. Takeshi recommended a nagura for me as well, so I bought that along with the stone event though it may not really be required.

LOL, I think even mentioning it on SMC will cause about 10 pages of debate. The plane is initially slightly harder to push, but on the whole it is much easier to use because it stays a good sharpness for much longer.

Re: Kiyotada

#45

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

david weaver

I don't think they're required, you're right, but they are not that expensive and if he recommended one for that stone, you'll know you have a good match.

Nagura is the classic method to generate slurry, and diamond hone is the new method.

Sometimes it's nice to cut up stones too soft to make a good stone, they make nice tomonagura if they are soft and fairly fine. I learned from experience that you can't set up a hard stone and expect it to make a nice tomonagura, it and the base stone just burnish each other.

If you do like the nagura and it and the stone glaze each other, though, you can take a hack saw and just cut a grid on the surface of the nagura, just grooves like a mm or half mm deep, and it will work well.

By the way, I couldn't resist, I wanted a cream colored suita and decided against the okudo type since I already have one in shiro-ish color, it's just misshapen. And for cost reasons, bought the nakayama suita further down the page. It's a little irregular and I might have to build a base for it, but that satisfies the jones without robbing you of the stone I thought would be a good one!!

It prevents me from doing something more damaging, like waiting until I see some giant suita with a whole bunch of renge for a huge $$ amount.

Save the picture of your stone with the stamps on it. If you ever decide to flip it for a bigger more expensive stone in the future, it will help to have the stamps on it to resell it. I don't know if I said it already. Since takeshi takes such nice pictures, you shouldn't have to take your own, you can just save his on your computer.

Re: Kiyotada

#46

Re: Wiley, I'd love to hear your opinion...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David,

Apologies for the non-response--I've been besieged with various things for the past few days and couldn't get back. And now that I have, I have to plead incompetence in regard to stones for the most part. Not that I haven't been bitten by the bug, but for the money that quality natural stones cost, would usually end up with another saw or a Konrad Sauer plane.

However, will share what I can...

1. My best stone. It's from Kayoko, who picked out of a collection of a friend of Yataiki's. I had given her a ballpark of $1,000 give or take, and she sent a pale yellow/beige stone, mostly clear but with a scattering of orange flecks in it. No holes or other inclusions. I'll get a photo in the next few days and post it. Normally I use it without slurry, but it's very fine and a 1,000g Atoma diamond self-slurry speeds it up.

2. High alloy steel. John McDonald up the Bay Area (used to post on Badger Pond years ago) sent me a stone, after I complained about Funahiro super blue steel. He just said, 'try this one'. It worked pretty well; however, I ended up Tormeking those Funahiro chisels, and now use either John's stone or another mystery stone that Scott Nehring sent (will photograph it too), or 1/4micron diamond. Usually diamond, to be honest with you. But in general, high end Japanese steel I find too hard for diamond--gives it too much tooth. John's stone also works with CPM 3V, but it is hollow ground also.

3. Natural vs. manmade. If it's a matter of getting a sharp edge on a high carbon tool, I find manmade (such as Sigma Power to take an example) as good as the natural stones I own. The thing is, the natural stones are more fun because they tend to be different and require different touches and sometimes nagura. The naturals wear more slowly. And I have personal associations with them. But if I go back and forth between my best stone and a 13K Sigma Power, I don't notice much difference in the the edge, but I use a different touch, a little lighter, on the natural stone.

4. Touch. One of the things I've learned over the years is that touch--and mainly a steady but light touch on finish stones--is really important.

I'll try to get some photos taken in the next week.

Wiley

Re: Kiyotada

#47

Re: Wiley, I'd love to hear your opinion...

david weaver

Look forward to it, wiley. Be it a suita with renge or a kiita finish stone, yellow is an expensive (but very pretty) color to fancy in natural stones.

The razor guys swear by the better kiita stones (those that are hard like you describe), but it takes deep pockets to get a nice one. The ones that are softer and come from upper layers are more common, but not nearly as fine in use.

I don't disagree with what you say about fineness, a sharper edge can be had with synthetic abrasives if one is willing to chase them all the way (it's not hard to find iron oxide that is less than 0.1 micron). It is the whole process with the naturals, but it is a risky and expensive game - first risk being that nobody buying their first has a chance of even knowing what's out there, and the second being that even stuff that looks like it should be good can be fraudulently labeled and colored.

The Alex and Kayako's of the world will not be a source of those stones, but with the recent explosion of the inexpensive stones with maruka stamps, fakes abound.

Re: Kiyotada

#48

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

Brian Holcombe

I liked using the dedicated nagura for Cho's more so than using diamond stones, so I figured it will work out nicely to have it as an option if needed. Thanks for the tips on using them!

Nice! Curious to here of how you that stones works by comparison to the others.

I'll definitely keep a photo of the stamp for reference, as I'm sure this is the beginning phases of a new addiction.

Have you built a pond for these stones by any chance?

Re: Kiyotada

#49

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

david weaver

No pond, splash and go on the stones and they don't make much mess. You'll find that the shinden suita you go works well for both knives and tools, it'll be an exceptional knife stone, you'll be pleased with it if you use it for that also.

Anyway, you'll also find that there's two lifetimes worth of stone there, probably will force you to be sparing on honing a little more than synthetics and prolong the life of your tools as well as the stone. There's enough there to outlast 10 king stones if you don't drop it and monitor it over the years to seal any cracks that may occur (they probably won't delaminate - in 8 or 9 years, none of my good ones have, but one that I sold to someone later delaminated partially - an ohira tomae which is a good stone).

Anyway, I have an old bench that the stones are used on, and below them is a 12x18 piece of granite. It gets a buildup of flotsam on it over time and I let it dry, scrape it off with a chisel and dump it in the trash. It's nice to have an area that doesn't have to stay clean. I never use more than a spray bottle in the shop, partially because I never have a very wet stone like a knife user might use, or wash slurry off, etc, because the stones are not soft enough to slough off huge amounts of slurry.

The big stones are poreless, so if you ever get anything on the surface (other than oil, oil is a bad thing), you can just wet the surface and brush it off.

Re: Kiyotada

#50

Re: I could be wrong about ohira suita..

Brian Holcombe

Awesome, I am glad not to use a pond. The Cho's pretty much require it, but if I can minimize how often I am using them by using this more often then it will simplify things.

I've seen to shellac the sides of the stones to minimize the chance of cracking, is something you do as well?

Oh yes, this will be put to use straight away on kitchen knives as well, looking forward to that in fact.