Re: Kiyotada but not Kiyohisa
david weaver
Telling what the kanji is is totally beyond me. I have to rely on other people to tell me that they're shimamura and then just trust them.
As far as stones go, I have a suggestion because I have bought a lot of them for a hobbyist who really has no business buying them all. Okudo suita are usually expensive, but my stone is irregularly shaped, so I got a 3 pound stone for $225 or so.
An ideally shaped similar stone would've been more than twice as much.
I have had ohira, nakayama, ozaki, ozuku, okudo, hiderayama, narutaki, shoubu (several from each mine in some cases)...and maybe something else I'm not remembering (those are finishers, I have other medium stones like tsushima, tanba aoto(avoid), iyo nagura, etc) . Of those, if I were buying as a practical user, I'd get an okudo suita from takeshi, one that he says is a strong cutter for tools that doesn't have too fine of a particle size rating - for reference, if aoki says it's an 8 particle size, it's coarse for a finish stone, and 9+ is very fine. I'm thinking somewhere in the middle makes a good strong cutting but still fine stone. I fell into the trap early of buying very hard finishing stones to try to get the best edge, but when you're working on something, you want a stone that is stronger cutting and a little less fine.
Takeshi aoki gets at least some of his stones from imanishi, who supplies a lot of retailers of natural stones, and the prices will be a lot less than so or alex gilmore (who sell nice stones, but charge a hefty price. I don't know about so, but alex will work with you and let you try stones and ship them back, I think so will for known customers, but he is not always available).
http://yhst-27988581933240.stores.yahoo.net/natural-whetstone.html
Anyway, what Aoki says about the stones is accurate, and I once thought I'd sneak a large ozuku for razors because most are very hard and fine, and saw a large one that aoki said was for tools. He was exactly on, it is an excellent tool stone and not good for razors.
I'm not bashing alex gilmore, I have used alex before and every stone I've gotten from him has also been good, I just didn't know early on that the stones he has that are $3000 may not necessarily be multiples better than a $300 stone from aoki. I've made requests for alex to find the ugliest stone that he has that is the most fantastic in use and ended up with a vintage barber stone for reasonable that is spectacular...understanding what you want from a dealer and how to communicate with each is practically a language of its own.
I'm not suggesting you need to get rid of the ohira and get a more expensive stone, just if you want to get something different that I'd focus on something that aoki (or another dealer) says just barely self slurries, and that has very strong cutting power. A stone that doesn't slurry at all will have you forever lapping it (which I don't do at all, and don't like to), and a stone that slurries to easily will not ever allow you to get the best edge. Anyway, you can learn with skill to make a strong cutting stone cut finely, but you can't make a fine weak-cutting stone cut strongly. What is enticing as a challenge (getting a super fine brightly polished edge), is not quite so fun when you are in the middle of working on something and want a fast cutting stone.
Of mine, Okudo is the only stone that cuts close in speed to synthetic stones, but it has much more dimension.
Beware the stones that are $750 to sky is the limit, they are often that because of attributes that make them uncommon (large with good shape, nice color, karasu pattern), but there are a lot of stones in the $300 level that are definitely as good for day to day work, and one that the jigane conditions (the soft steel peels a few particles off of to keep the surface fresh) is ideal.
It's a very expensive thing to start fiddling with different stones, though, and you will be hard pressed to get your money back unless you have something extremely rare. Avoid maruka stamps that are not on very old hatanaka stones, I have heard that some of the distributors in japan have been faking those stamps. The mine stamps themselves are often now put on unidentified stones by dealers and distributors, that was a change in how they decided to do things last year, so there are stones now stamped "nakayama" that were never stamped by the miners.
All of that contributes to my suggestion to keep the price reasonable, and rely on a good dealer to describe the stone properly. Ebay sucks as a place to buy stones, so avoid it - there are a lot of flippers selling pedestrian stones for very high prices, twice what aoki asks.