New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Kiyotada

Posts

Kiyotada

#1

Kiyotada

Allen Fulmer

Im looking for input on Kiyotada chisels. Not so much if theyre any good, they've been known to be the best, but a comparison. I have a set of Kiyohisa, that I haven't gotten a chance to use yet, however they were a dream to flatten. Im looking for personal experience of a comparison between the two makers. I know Wiley has some chisels of each maker, so Im really hoping you chime in on this Wiley. Anyone else who has experience with either maker is more than welcome to add in their two cents.

Re: Kiyotada

#2

Re: Kiyotada - Wiley Horne


Re: Kiyotada

#3

Kiyotada but not Kiyohisa

david weaver

I've got three kiyotada chisels. They are the most precisely made fairly plain looking finely finished chisels I've ever seen and they are monstrously hard steel. They are extremely accurately made (one I got was new - new old stock of course, the other two were not new, but the ura remains on them and describes them as accurately made because it has not lost its shape from having to grind a lot off.

Kiyohisa chisels look nice, but I've never seen one in person. They have the same plain but super clean aesthetic, one that I find extremely pleasing.

Oh, and if you're looking for kiyotada, make sure the smith is Shimamura. I think this was discussed on here recently. Kiyotada is a name used by Suehiya (tool dealer in tokyo) and there are examples of it not made by Shimamura.

My new old stock came from Suehiya thanks to Stan Covington, I believe Stan has an entire set of kiyotada chisels plus many more. He may have had some exposure to Kiyohisa tools, too, if Wiley hasn't come across Kiyohisa.

Chisels of this level make you feel like custodian more than owner, that coming from someone who routinely drops chisels, and as tom D says, lets them touch each other. I don't do the former or allow the latter with the kiyohisa/Shimamura tools.

Re: Kiyotada

#4

Re: Chisels and being a beginer

TomD

There is a lot of variation in Japanese chisels, only rarely got a bad one. I did buy a very expensive set of Oucii chisels that were at one time said to be the best (not really sure where that comes from, I don't trust it because we only see a fraction of available tools, so I think it has a lot to do with importers), but anyway, I never liked them as much as some others. So unless the using of a particular purchase doesn't mater to you, you might want to actually try them. What I did was buy a set of 12, I think it was, or 15, and bought some other sizes. I should have bought the oddballs first then I would have known I didn't like them. But back in the 70s they weren't as easy to get, and I had to grab them on a drive by.

Another issue, for the general audience, is I bought a couple of sets of HSS japanese chisels first. These were the ones I learned to sharpen on, along with the Iyoroi ones LV was selling at the time. The Ouchii were very different, and I must say out of step with some I have bought since, in my defence. But back them I spent about a year on my knees learning how to sharpen like the books said you should, and I never really put the same into it since. I don't think one is supposed to have to. If you do all that with the "beginner" set you bought, to see how it would go, I think the early chisels are imprinted like a duckling on a foot, and you can't really shake it. Like making good or bad friends early in life.

Re: Kiyotada

#5

Re: Kiyotada but not Kiyohisa

Allen Fulmer

Hey David,

I knew you had atleast one Kiyotada chisel from reading around on different threads/forums. Im glad you chimed in. I actually talked to Stan, via email, months ago when I was in the market for a set of Ichihiro. Im glad I did, he gave me some invaluable advice and it paid off tremendously with a little patience as I ended up getting a fantastic set of Ichihiro. I brought up Kiyohisa with him, before i knew he had already made his opinion on them publicly, and he just thrashed them. Now like he mentioned it certainly could have been because he was trying to compare another maker to Kiyotada/tokyo chisels, which like you said, are incredibly hard. Most chisels these days aren't made like that anymore.

My initial post was simply to try and get feedback from actual users, not tool sellers, on a comparison between kiyohisa and kiyotada. So san obviously rates kiyohisa as one of the best, if not the best in Japan and going as far as being better than Ichihiro/Kiyotada. Im not saying Kiyohisas haven't surpassed the tokyo trio, however hearing it from a tool SELLER isn't exactly reassuring especially since he can still sell Kiyohisa and not Tokyo chisels. Im 100 percent confident my set of kiyohisa would last my lifetime, and be an amazing set of chisels, however thats not exactly how my mind works. If it did, I would have never sold my set of koyamaichi, as they would have done everything I asked them to do as well. I take pleasure in using and collecting these masterpieces(Ichihiro,kiyotada,kiyohisa,funahiro,etc) I originally asked because Im able to get a set of Kiyotada(new old stock), however I have to give up my set of Kiyohisa to get them, or atleast I'm going to.

It sounds like you really like your Kiyotadas, David, and flattening/sharpening them is a breeze. I was pleasantly surprised when I flattened my set of kiyohisa, as most of them only took a few seconds on my tomae to flatten and the rest not more than a minute or two, where as my Tasais took a considerable amount of effort to flatten/sharpen.

Re: Kiyotada

#6

Re: Kiyotada but not Kiyohisa

david weaver

I'm not nearly as demanding as Stanley is. I've got a lot of pedestrian stuff that I consider to be superb, which leads me to conclude the following (again, not being that hands on with a lot of really nice stuff) - that so san may prefer kiyohisa over kiyotada (of shimamura origin) and stan may feel exactly the opposite.

When I think of chisels as high end, I think of a chisel that has no compromises and no problems. that means I expect the backs to be accurate and either lazer flat, or more preferably just the tiniest bit convex. I expect no stray marks on a chisel other than use related stuff, and I expect the ura to be even and wear evenly as the chisel is sharpened. Those things are often not perfect on a $60 chisel. I value a full hardness chisel like the kiyotada chisels soley because it's a demonstration of skill, but certain rules apply. I've not used any of mine heavily enough (I guess I've been a wuss, and two of them just arrived, anyway - though I hope to use them a lot more than the tataki nomi I've had for a long time) to really form an opinion other than that they are very hard...I'll get to that. At any rate, full hardness chisels are harder to sharpen when you're not using modern abrasive, and they are demanding about where you keep their angles and what you use.

The two paring chisels I have below are vintage kiyotada, the two that I recently got. I was coy about what they were in that thread, they look like anything to anyone else who isn't interested in this stuff (anything being any other chisel shown at a given time in a JWW catalog). I set up the bevel on the larger of the two chisels, not because there was anything wrong with the way they sharpened, but because I sharpen freehand and I like to be able to use my technique without thought, so I have to set them up the way I use them. they are so hard that natural stones barely cut them, and only my okudo suita would do so, and even then it was marginalized a little bit.

In terms of hardness with white steel chisels, I can tell japanese chisels are around 62 hardness when a washita stone just barely cuts them. I can tell they are 3 or 4 clicks harder than that when most of my japanese natural stones start to decline to cut them, but instead burnish. the okudo is cutting, but it's on the transition between cut and burnish, so I know they are super hard. Also, their behavior when I set the bevel, for the edge to shatter and need to be reset - off of a carborundum stone for the bevel set, also indicates they are extremely hard. that just means adding a little bit of angle until they are stable, and then you're rewarded with a very long wearing chisel that takes a fine edge.

I wouldn't at this point get rid of your kiyohisa chisels if you can swing having both. When you get into that rare air, you just never know what's going to float your boat.

For comparison, I also have iyoroi mokume that I got as a sale item from fujibato years ago. there is no way they are close to their hardness spec, because a washita cuts them fine. That said, they sharpen like butter, are not similar to the hardware store iyoroi stuff other than the hardness, and the wrought is very supple. They would be completely unacceptable to stanley or anyone wanting full hardness chisels, but in workflow they are a delight to use (for me) because the balance of use time to sharpening in an overall flow, and predictable sharpening, are what I really like.

I have a NOS set of ouchi, and no clue if they are white 1 or white 2, but they are also very hard, and will not sharpen on the washita.

It probably seems extremely ridiculous to most outside japanese tool users that I would sharpen a japanese chisel on a washita stone to begin with, but the result is that the washita is only cutting marginally on the iyorois, and thus the edge that is created is much finer than the size of the grit would suggest. It's certainly twice as good as the edge I get on a western chisel where the washita cuts more deeply, and as far as the wrought goes (or any soft backing on any chisel), the washita blisters through that. I really enjoy using those iyoroi chisels with a washita stone, it creates a nice workflow and they stay sharp indefinitely that way giving up very little in sharpness to what I'd have if I ran them through a full progression stopping at a hard kyoto-origin finisher. that said, if I only had my ouchi set and used them with a washita, it'd be frustration because they are just too hard for it.

I need to part with some of my tools, I have an excess problem, but I just don't know what to part with. I don't want to sell ouchi-sr's efforts, and I don't want to sell my iyorois to anyone, either. I don't want to sell old ward chisels, eskilstuna origin chisels, buck chisels, or the miyanaga mortisers that I have. Something may force my hand someday, and if any get rust from disuse that will, too, but for now I'd rather just put the decision off.

But again, if you can keep the kiyohisa long enough to compare, unless the kiyotada set is like a car price and they are shimamura at the same time, you may decide you like kiyohisa better and if you do, I think you'll have no problem finding a buyer for shimamura's efforts, even if they have to go back to japan.

Re: Kiyotada

#7

Re: Chisels and being a beginer

David weaver

I'll bet saying ouchi was best had something to do with the retailer selling them here. I do think the ones I have are excellent, but any time an importer says something is the best, I get Japan woodworker wariness (that being that when I'd read the catalogs pretty woodcraft, I felt like the text was selling me something, and not something good.

Re: Kiyotada

#8

Re: Kiyotada but not Kiyohisa

Allen Fulmer

David, I was aware of the fact "kiyotada" was being used by another tokyo shop, but only because Ive read threads(that I'm sure you were a part of) that it was mentioned in. What I'm not sure about, is the Kanji the same as Shimamuras? or is it completely different?

I will consider keeping both, I don't really want to, but I do have the option to if i really wish.

My finishing stone is a Ohirayama Tomae, but Ive been wanting to get a suita, although I don't know if ill be fortunate enough to get a Okudo.

And on a completely unrelated note, Where in PA are you from? Im about 15 minutes west of King of Prussia, and I grew up between Pottstown and Reading. Anywhere near there?

Re: Kiyotada

#9

Re: Kiyotada but not Kiyohisa

david weaver

Telling what the kanji is is totally beyond me. I have to rely on other people to tell me that they're shimamura and then just trust them.

As far as stones go, I have a suggestion because I have bought a lot of them for a hobbyist who really has no business buying them all. Okudo suita are usually expensive, but my stone is irregularly shaped, so I got a 3 pound stone for $225 or so.

An ideally shaped similar stone would've been more than twice as much.

I have had ohira, nakayama, ozaki, ozuku, okudo, hiderayama, narutaki, shoubu (several from each mine in some cases)...and maybe something else I'm not remembering (those are finishers, I have other medium stones like tsushima, tanba aoto(avoid), iyo nagura, etc) . Of those, if I were buying as a practical user, I'd get an okudo suita from takeshi, one that he says is a strong cutter for tools that doesn't have too fine of a particle size rating - for reference, if aoki says it's an 8 particle size, it's coarse for a finish stone, and 9+ is very fine. I'm thinking somewhere in the middle makes a good strong cutting but still fine stone. I fell into the trap early of buying very hard finishing stones to try to get the best edge, but when you're working on something, you want a stone that is stronger cutting and a little less fine.

Takeshi aoki gets at least some of his stones from imanishi, who supplies a lot of retailers of natural stones, and the prices will be a lot less than so or alex gilmore (who sell nice stones, but charge a hefty price. I don't know about so, but alex will work with you and let you try stones and ship them back, I think so will for known customers, but he is not always available).

http://yhst-27988581933240.stores.yahoo.net/natural-whetstone.html

Anyway, what Aoki says about the stones is accurate, and I once thought I'd sneak a large ozuku for razors because most are very hard and fine, and saw a large one that aoki said was for tools. He was exactly on, it is an excellent tool stone and not good for razors.

I'm not bashing alex gilmore, I have used alex before and every stone I've gotten from him has also been good, I just didn't know early on that the stones he has that are $3000 may not necessarily be multiples better than a $300 stone from aoki. I've made requests for alex to find the ugliest stone that he has that is the most fantastic in use and ended up with a vintage barber stone for reasonable that is spectacular...understanding what you want from a dealer and how to communicate with each is practically a language of its own.

I'm not suggesting you need to get rid of the ohira and get a more expensive stone, just if you want to get something different that I'd focus on something that aoki (or another dealer) says just barely self slurries, and that has very strong cutting power. A stone that doesn't slurry at all will have you forever lapping it (which I don't do at all, and don't like to), and a stone that slurries to easily will not ever allow you to get the best edge. Anyway, you can learn with skill to make a strong cutting stone cut finely, but you can't make a fine weak-cutting stone cut strongly. What is enticing as a challenge (getting a super fine brightly polished edge), is not quite so fun when you are in the middle of working on something and want a fast cutting stone.

Of mine, Okudo is the only stone that cuts close in speed to synthetic stones, but it has much more dimension.

Beware the stones that are $750 to sky is the limit, they are often that because of attributes that make them uncommon (large with good shape, nice color, karasu pattern), but there are a lot of stones in the $300 level that are definitely as good for day to day work, and one that the jigane conditions (the soft steel peels a few particles off of to keep the surface fresh) is ideal.

It's a very expensive thing to start fiddling with different stones, though, and you will be hard pressed to get your money back unless you have something extremely rare. Avoid maruka stamps that are not on very old hatanaka stones, I have heard that some of the distributors in japan have been faking those stamps. The mine stamps themselves are often now put on unidentified stones by dealers and distributors, that was a change in how they decided to do things last year, so there are stones now stamped "nakayama" that were never stamped by the miners.

All of that contributes to my suggestion to keep the price reasonable, and rely on a good dealer to describe the stone properly. Ebay sucks as a place to buy stones, so avoid it - there are a lot of flippers selling pedestrian stones for very high prices, twice what aoki asks.

Re: Kiyotada

#10

Re: Kiyotada but not Kiyohisa

david weaver

Western PA, by the way. North of steelerville.

Re: Kiyotada

#11

Re: Kiyotada but not Kiyohisa

Allen Fulmer

David, thanks for that link. I had not stumbled across that site before. He has a lot of stones. I sent him an email, and told him what kind of chisels i was looking to sharpen etc and see what he recommends. I mentioned i was looking around for a suita.

Whats your opinion on stones with lines/cracks? I've always strayed away from them, but one of the tool vendors i deal with assured me they don't affect sharpening at all.

Re: Kiyotada

#12

Re: Kiyotada but not Kiyohisa

david weaver

It depends on what's in the lines. If someone has a stone that has toxic (scratchy) particles, I'd rather not have that. If the lines are superficial, as are those on an okudo or shinden suita, and are not really cracks that would hold particles, then I don't care.

The large lines that have inclusions/toxic particles can be picked to get the toxic particles out, but I can't imagine that's something I'd want to do, thus the comment about toxic particles.

All of my suita stones have something that looks like superficial cracks. the only stones I've had that had real cracks were nakayama, and I sold my large ohira tomae stone to someone years ago and it began to develop a large crack in the middle of the side. Sometimes it's not the cracks you see that end up causing problems...

I would tell aoki that you want a suita stone that doesn't need tomonagura, but that isn't too soft, and you'd like one that is fast cutting and capable of finishing tools. There are good suita from narutaki, nakayama, shinden, okudo, ohira suita, etc, so you're really relying on the dealer to pick a good one, and not just any one, and not necessarily one from a particular mine.

Re: Kiyotada

#13

Re: Kiyotada but not Kiyohisa

Allen Fulmer

Thats exactly what Ill do. I was eyeing up a Nakayama Kiita and/or asagi. He has them very reasonably priced, which surprised me, as i thought Nakayama stones were all very expensive. He also has a Nakayama Suita, but I will tell him exactly what i want to do and see what he recommends.

Re: Kiyotada

#14

Re: Kiyotada but not Kiyohisa

david weaver

Nakayama are all over the board (cost wise and quality wise). A hatanaka stamp nakayama that is vintage can be in the thousands, but they are not as practical as suita.

I have not bought a kiita stone, because they are generally a bit soft. Not always, but almost always, and they are fine and soft stones. It's funny, people love them and love the color, but they don't like green (asagi) stones if those are soft. I don't know if it's the kiita color that's rare.

I think the maruka stamp stones of very vintage probably gave nakayama mine the reputation of having all expensive stones, but there are also worthless nakayama that are very scratchy, and small and odd shaped stones. Aoki wouldn't sell a stone like that (a defective one), but that's a risk if buying something labeled nakayama on ebay from an unknown person. The very hard ones can be hard to use without tomonagura.

Anyway, don't be surprised to see a $300 and $3000 stone right next to each other and not be able to tell too much looking at them visually, they could look very similar.

The nakayama stamp is one that I know for certain will be stamped on old stones of unknown origin where distributors suspect a stone may be nakayama. It's not necessarily a guarantee that the stone came from that mine like an older stamp may be.

Re: Kiyotada

#15

Re: Kiyotada - Wiley Horne

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Allen and all,

Sorry, I was away for a couple days. I have one Kiyohisa, a chu tataki from So. It is riveting to look at, beautifully simple. It came to me sharpened by So, meaning it's laser sharp, and I haven't had a use for it, or done anything other than strop the edge a pass or two over a sheet of LV 1/2-micron paper. I had two Kiyotada, also from So, now with David. The 36mm slick I used only for knifing in the corners of channels for ebony stringing on a satinwood table shown here recently. The wide slick provides a good long registration, so you maintain the straightness of the stringing channel all the way into the corner. Then the waste is dug from the channels with a mini-chisel, 25 or 32 thousandths (minus clearance).

This is a long way to say that I love the chisels, but can't compare them, other than to say they both take a wonderful edge, and are very hard, as David has already laid out.

I have a strong feeling that you would regret selling or trading your Kiyohisa. They're in demand, the waiting list is long, and there's plenty of time for regret.

Coupla three other stray thoughts:

1. I think one has to think twice about what chisel is 'the best'. The winds blow different ways from time to time--if you say shimamura or Kiyohisa is the best, what about Tasai who went through a period of glorification, or Funatsu-san (Funahiro) after he put on a great show at a kezurou-kai event a few years ago? Ikeda (Kunikei) is highly regarded, as are many others.

2. I find all the Japanese chisels to be hard and good edge-holders. This is judging from Funahiro, Tasai, Imai, and some older Miyanaga mainly, but also cheaper JWW dovetail chisels I had years ago. They're all great doers. One big contributor to this is that white steel no. 1 or blue steel no. 1 has 1.2% to 1.4% carbon, depending on which grade of No. 1 they're using. But only 0.77% C can be dissolved into the iron. The difference, even allowing for some carbon loss during heating/forging, becomes Fe3C carbides. So the Japanese steel is carbide-rich. I suspect a lot of the 'handwork' we hear about is trying to get all that carbide distributed.

3. Personally, I use very few oire-nomi. 95% of my chisel use is either (1) mortise chisels for joining cases, drawer boxes, or frames for panels or glass, or else (2) push chisels for paring dovetails to the scribe line, given that I fret saw the waste. And 95% of this is done with 3/16" and 1/4", and to a lesser extent, 1/8 and 5/16". In other words, smalls in sixteenth gradations. I see advantage in a maker who will provide the in-between sizes of 3/16" (4.5mm) and 5/16" (7.5mm). I like my Imai push chisels because I was able to order them 1/16" apart up to 1/2", with sides beveled 10 degrees (80 degree slope), so they fit like gloves into the corners of dovetail sockets. And similarly with in-between sizes of mortise chisels, because for example I'd rather make two 3/16" mortises, than one 3/8".

So, for me, and others' mileage may vary, the 'best' chisel is the one that fits best into what I do. Like David's comments on 'work flow'--very appropriate IMO. In my experience, all of the name brands are good users on their merits.

You asked after push chisels. What I find is that if you saw dovetail waste, they're the very thing for paring to the scribe line. They give you a good long sight line, plus you can grip the chisel at the end, put your hand between jaw and collarbone, and just lean on the chisel to make the cut--the power and control is perfect because you're not muscling the chisel, just leaning on it. If you like to chop dovetail waste, the above does not apply.

I wish I could help on the Kiyohisa/Kiyotada comparison. Either and both are great.

Wiley

Re: Kiyotada

#16

Re: Kiyotada - Wiley Horne

Allen Fulmer

Thanks Wiley, I appreciate the feedback. I too wonder if Ill regret selling the Kiyohisa. If i can avoid selling/trading them, I'm going to. Im just not going to pass up the opportunity to get a set of kiyotada.

Re: Kiyotada

#17

Re: Kiyotada but not Kiyohisa

Brian Holcombe

I have been hearing the siren song of Natural stones, so I appreciate this post.

I'm thinking of buying an Okudo Suita as a finishing stone to use after 8k snow white. Is this a good choice to fallow up the snow white?

Re: Kiyotada

#18

Re: Kiyotada but not Kiyohisa

david weaver

You'd probably use it in place of.

I can't remember if I said....I probably said something about okudo suita on here.

My opinion (and I no longer have my stone listing) is that okudo or shinden suita (or if you see a video of another stone and it's a really strong cutter) are the most practical day to day type stones. They cut stronger than most tomae or hard green type stones labeled as asagi, but they can cut very finely and like an oilstone, the edge loves a bare leather strop.

Okudo suita from a reputable dealer isn't cheap, but I wouldn't buy anything from someone who doesn't have a large reference and test each stone and describe it. I wouldn't buy anything like that on ebay, either, the people selling stones on ebay are selling a lot of questionable stones that I don't think they can sell in japan for much money, and often without much description.

My favorite dealer is:

http://yhst-27988581933240.stores.yahoo.net/natural-whetstone.html

(I don't ever return stones, I don't know if Aoki takes them back. Alex Gilmore allows trial of as many stones as you'd like, but his prices are a lot higher. Same with So. Aoki - at the link above - is getting his stones from imanishi, so they aren't just a pile of stone painted to look like something more expensive).

Anyway, with a good middle hardness suita, you can go from any middle stone, or if you sharpen the lazy way like I do, straight from a 1000 type stone and get an edge that's very good (at least the equal of a snow white), but the feel of the stone is indescribable, and it gives you more headroom - like an oilstone - to surpass that level.

The stones that are described as super fine and very hard are better left for razors. I've been there and done that, there's an urge to try to get the finest stone you can get, but the feel is off for tools, you have to slurry them all the time and they aren't that fine with a thick slurry. With no slurry, they often have stiction issues and are better used as a burnisher after something else initially finishes an edge. But a slab of jasper can do that nearly as well for $10. The thing that makes them wonderful for razors doesn't translate well to tools.

You will so a lot of shoubu and ohira stones, those are common, but not as strong cutting, and they may have you just putting the stone in the drawer and losing a lot of money if you try to resell (I have had both).

Of all of the things floating around out there right now, this is probably what would get my first consideration:

http://yhst-27988581933240.stores.yahoo.net/shinden-yama-renge-suita-natural-whetstone--11264g--211264278.html

It is $380 instead of $600 because it is about 20mm shorter than most full sized stones. Any way you look at it, a good stone is going to be a lot of money. Shinden and Okudo stones give you a good chance of getting most of it back if you want to go a different direction later on. For about the same as an ohira or shoubu large stone, you'll appreciate the cutting power a lot more than you'll ever miss 20mm. Edge quality from mine is excellent no matter how soft the carbon steel, but it will cut things my oilstones won't, like HSS.

If that amount of money is intolerable, I think it's better to wait for small or irregular shaped stones (takeshi will probably have something again in the future more in the price range of mine). And something where the dealer comments about how strong cutting a stone is without either being too soft or too fine.

If you just want a burnisher to follow the snow white, I'd spend $10-$20 on ebay and find a really large precut slab of owyhee or biggs jasper.

Re: Kiyotada

#19

Re: Most people will choke..

david weaver

...when they see that a "regular" suita from a desirable mine is $600 and one with compromises in size or shape is half of that amount.

Those are people who probably shouldn't buy a japanese natural stone. They are definitely not for everyone, because the good ones aren't common enough to make them very affordable.

Re: Kiyotada

#20

Re: Kiyotada but not Kiyohisa

Brian Holcombe

Thanks David! I appreciate the detailed response.

When it comes to my Japanese tools I'm pretty happy with the current level of result, and maybe a hair of improvement would be good, but not necessarily required. So adding a Natural finishing stone is as much about enjoyment as it is being able to keep a stone in the workshop that doesn't want to be soaked.

The biggest issue I'm having is that I feel that the edge on my A2 blades degrade rapidly in anything but smooth grained wood. For instance, I flattened my bench last night and had to touch up my blades twice...a bit excessive for an otherwise simple job which took maybe an hour's worth of planing.

The edge doesn't chip so much as it simply rolls over, so a quick lapping brings it back to life. Which leads me to believe that this may be a practical solution for maintenance between sharpenings.

Re: Kiyotada

#21

Re: Kiyotada but not Kiyohisa

david weaver

Most of the slower cutting stones won't tolerate A2 or anything like that or more alloyed. So for a range, I'd definitely stick with okudo or shinden, or another stone that a dealer says has very strong cutting power.

Of course, the stuff that's in japanese stones is some kind of silicon dioxide or something, I think it might be volcanic sediment, so even at its fastest cutting, it's not like fresh aluminum oxide or anything. But it is much nicer feeling. The snow white is a nice feeling stone, and better than some crappy natural japanese stones, but it's coarse and gritty feeling and one-dimensional compared to a good suita stone.

I don't use synthetic finishers on anything any longer, the control a suita provides, and the quality of the edge is just nicer - it doesn't provide a transient type of initial sharpness like you're describing. If I use anything more than washita, it's bouncing back and forth between suita and an old translucent arkansas stone. Either is an indulgence, both are capable with the right stuff of edges as good as any synthetic stone available, but with a better edge quality and visually far superior (especially if you have japanese tools to look at).

AS far as A2 goes, Steve Elliot did a pretty good summary of it (and, I guess, others too), IIRC that the final angle needs to be somewhere around 33 degrees in order to not have any chipping. When I used to use it a lot, I resigned myself to putting the final bevel at 35 degrees and then it behaved well and didn't have that very transient initial keenness followed by something less than desirable for a very long time. Less clearance to start, of course, but still had overall better long wear.

Re: Kiyotada

#22

Re: Kiyotada but not Kiyohisa

Brian Holcombe

Awesome, that sounds like pretty much what I'm looking for. From his description of being the stone that carpenters will bring to the job for maintenance during the day it further points to this stone being a practical stone for users. I appreciate the advice as always, it's good to get the practical perspective as I find it's easy to trip down the rabbet hole of always searching for the next best thing.

I hate A2, I quite like everything about my planes with exception to the blades. I'll bump the angle up to 33-35 and see how it does. Really drives me nuts to constantly keep after these blades. I may dump them at some point and put in the blue steel replacement blades that Tsunesaburo makes.

Re: Kiyotada

#23

One Other Option I've Bought From

david weaver

Takeshi Kuroda....that makes two Takeshis.

http://www.metalmaster-ww.com/

Takeshi Kuroda doesn't release stones too often and he usually sells them out quickly (no natural japanese stones are particularly cheap, but his prices are low among them in relative terms).

In his stone levels, you want something "4.5" hardness or so in a suita, all of the stuff below 4 is soft stones that are suitable for knives, but not tools. Avoid anything from hiderayama and avoid uchigumori (which is a middle stone for swords and knives, and thus is probably a lot more appropriate for kitchen knives)

I think Aoki (aframestokyo) is more detailed in his discussions of how fine a stone is and mentioning stones that are very strong.

I've bought from:

Alex Gilmore (honest, but very expensive)

Takeshi Aoki (Aframes Tokyo)

Takeshi Kuroda (Japanese Metal Master)

Fujibato (can't remember his real name, but he calls himself 330_mate)

I never bought from So Yamashita because his site was always not accepting orders, and he's also very high priced. If he would've been more accessible, i probably would've tried something from him, though.

The two takeshis will have nice stones for the price, with Aoki often having some nicer stuff and kuroda (metalmaster) often having a lot more accessibly priced stuff.

Maybe I'm in the weeds about ohira suitas, the two that Kuroda has in stock right now look good and the swarf suggests good things (there's a lot of it and its dark black). And the price is good and they're not too hard.

I'm partial to Okudo, though. I had an ohira tomae (a common stone that is green and very functional). It was OK, but not worth the $400 that it cost from hida, at least not in my opinion. Hida still sells them. I think they are lacking compared to good suita for day to day work as they are slower by a good bit but not finer and the feel isn't as good.

One last comment, the reason I insist on not getting the hardest finest thing listed is because the first probably 4 stones I bought were of that type, I wanted to spend money on the finest gritted stones I could buy, and fortunately they are good razor stones. They're not very practical for tools because they only cut fast on slurry, but when slurried, they are less fine than a good middle hardness suita stone. The more you use a middle hardness stone - one that isn't too soft or too hard - the better you get at making an edge with it that's just right. It's obviously an entirely different theme than finding the brashest artificial stone available and dragging something on a guide backwards a set number of times.

Re: Kiyotada

#24

Re: One Other Option I've Bought From

Brian Holcombe

Makes perfect sense, a straight razor is benefiting from a level of fineness that is a total waste of effort in plane irons I presume.

What are your thoughts on Okudo Suita as compared to Okudo Renge Suita?

Price doesnt offend me much, but since this is my tip-toe into Natural stones I'd like to start under $400~.

I bought a hammer from So recently, I like working with him, he responds quickly, but he has had a family issues and has not had the ability to devote a lot of time to his website in my understanding. It has extended wait times, which can be slightly frustrating when one is very excited about receiving something. That being said I always give the small dealers the go-ahead before buying from the larger companies.

Re: Kiyotada

#25

Re: One Other Option I've Bought From

david weaver

Renge just suggests the spots on the surface that you can see.

http://www.thejapanstone.com/images/kami2452.jpg

They're usually red and they are often seen on stones that are fast cutting (and therefore desirable). It doesn't guarantee that they'll be faster cutting than a stone without renge in my experience, but it's just one of those things (you'll see terms like karasu, nashiji, kiita, ..) that's a physical characteristic of the stone that's desirable.

All of the terminology can be confusing. Suita is a strata of the stone, Asagi, I believe means green, karasu means a pattern on the stone that is sort of patchy, nashiji means black dots, kiita means a yellowish characteristic color.

So might have stuff that's not so expensive if you ask him for a good okudo or shinden suita. IIRC, I was asking around at one time and he was offering decent stones around 80 yen per gram, and had increased from 60 yen. Full sized bench stones an inch thick or a little more are usually about a kilogram, so that'd be 60,000-80,000 yen for such a stone, but there are more factors that affect value. If you have a nice square stone that is both thick and geometrically nice, as well as having nice color it can be more per gram.

The times so was available, I was too cheap to ask about price, and the times I was in a buying mood, he said he wasn't taking orders. When I order from alex (which I've done twice), I've always asked for stones that have good cutting characteristics, but that are either unknown mine or have other undesirable visual characteristics. I've gotten two stones really reasonably that way, but certainly not cheap - they are nice stones too use, but it'd be a challenge for me to get more than about 1/2 to 2/3rds of what I paid, and prices have gone up since I got them.

This is just my opinion, but for a typical stone in the 2 1/2 to 3 pound range that has good shape, is full size on the surface and has nice cutting characteristics, if it gets over about $600, you're paying for something that probably doesn't have much to do performance, but instead with visuals. A large kiita (yellow hue stone, especially from a desirable mine) would cost a whole lot, but it wouldn't necessarily be better than anything else except for its rarity.

Also, you'll notice stones will say renge, kiita, nashiji, iromono, or whatever and not be very visually stunning sometimes. The more striking the feature, the more its worth. If it's very light (often greenish stones that have the least bit yellow tint to them are labeled kiita, or stones with a tiny patch of renge are labeled renge), it's not too exciting.