We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
How useful are the specialized pins for snugging the joint?
Is there a real difference between eccentric section pins and simple tapered pins?
How do you gauge the offset between the two holes, and do you use the same interference in soft wood as in a harder wood?
I just did a few, in pine frames, mostly because I wanted to try it. The joints were bridle joints (did that fact make the pins specious?) and I just eyeballed something less than a sixteenth. I didn't use any prep of the joint, just tapped the pins in. Seemed to work, but it was in pine, and thin sections.
Last time I looked, stepped pins were the norm on timber frames. Not eccentric, or straight. In that case the pins do all the work. eccentric would be better if that means no shoulder and less waste wood.
I don't use them on cabinetwork, and don't really see the point. Unless I didn't use glue. I have bridal joints in the bathroom that are probably 30-40 years old, they have not moved at all, only glue, probably not waterproof, not a good ceiling fan, lots of moisture cycles. They will get tossed by the next person who moves in as the "look" is way out of date, so another century is not in the cards.
Well, Joe, I can only speak from experience, but I do it much like you do, with subtle differences. One, I seldom use bridle joints, so... The only joint I pin id an M&T joint, so that is what I'll speak to.
I think a specialized pin might help in some instances, but I don't have any. I have always just cut my pin material long, put a gradual slope on them, and hit them with a light hammer until the diameter is the same on both sides. Cut, smooth, and forget.
The offset distance will vary with the density of the material. I know this sounds simplistic, but Pine crushes so much easier than White Oak, for example, and may not draw the joint together as well at the same offset. So, it's a judgment call. Another variable is the accuracy of your joint.
That being said, in an Ipe through mortise, the offset may be in the thousandths and be effective if the joint is tight, and Pine may take 1/32nd, or more.
Seasonal movement will really show up if your offset is too large. The exposed surface of the pin will be higher away from the join, and lower on the near side, because the pin will become bowed from expansion stress. DAMHIKT...Please!
I don't think I have ever used more than a 32nd, successfully, but your wood and your joint may be different.
Looking for a definitive answer is kind of a crap shoot, but using the hardness of the material as a guideline, I have only screwed them up once, so...
Give it your best guess, and see how it turns out, I guess, which is totally appropriate, because it is always a guess, in my experience, or call it a judgment call, but one that isn't really that hard once you know the hardness differential.
Drawbore pins prep the hole for pin insertion.Also they help align the holes where there is a little movement side to side.I have driven a peg into a hole and it would stop when it hit the ledge inside,the aligning pin smooths the entry for easier insertion.
I aim for 1/32 in hardwoods but I usually just eyeball it.You can use a little more in soft woods like white pine. You don't need much offset .You just make your joints tight and the offset makes sure it is.Undercutting the shoulders helps.
I don't own eccentric pins but I plan on getting one to try it. When I use them I twist them into the hole. I believe the oval shape would help with alignment.
As Jack mentioned the offset is dependent on the situation: the tenderness of the timber and the scale of the work being important factors. I like to make the pins of the same material as the frame material so that there is a small amount of deformation in both the tenon hole and the pin. This seems to be the historical practice.
I have made thousands of pinned joints over the last forty years without iron drawbore pins. They are not on my list for future purchases. I would rather purchase more carving tools or more moulding planes, tools which expand my versatility. Drawbore pins did not make it into the inventory for the Seaton Chest (1796), which has well over 200 tools, many of which I would like to have.
Jay Gaynor illustrated an early drawbore pin in his book, calling it late 18th century or early 19th century, but I have not seen the term in use before Nicholson (1812). Although pinned mortise and tenon joints were perhaps more common in the 17th century than later, I would be surprised to see a reference to iron drawbore pins dating from that time.
Those were the type responses I'd hoped for. I think that, for now, I'll be better off concentrating on good fit. Great opportunity to improve my sawing skill, huh?
Just to add: I do not see that drawbore pins are a necessary tool for preparing the joints. Where they are useful is when you have a long stretcher and need to clamp the m&t together to test the fit and/or to hold parts together. The steel pin gets pushed in to squeeze and hold the join tightly, then is pulled out when you dissemble.
I have no idea whether this is historically correct; it is just how I find the steel pins useful. I do not tend to check how the joint will go together, but when it is sawn, chopped and drilled, I just drive the peg in. I do not have a lifetime of experience here, but what I have done this way works for me.
Most of the tools in the Seaton Chest have been used, but not heavily. I don't think there are any holes in the inventory that suggest it was not complete enough to do real cabinetmaker's work. You ought to read the book and have a look for yourself.
The inventory of the Monticello joiner shop also contains around 250 tools and no drawbore pins. The inventory was made in 1809 by James Dinsmore whom Jefferson hired and called a "joiner of the very first order".
Ditto for what everyone else said. I might add the following: while making a joint stool about a year ago, I did find that the set of 4 drawbore pins I made were useful to test each of the four frames of the piece. The pins were made from a pair (two pairs, actually) of old dividers I had purchased with the idea for making a set of 4 pins. I hacksawed the legs from the divider joint and epoxied them into walnut handles I sawed out and planed to tapered octagons.
If you have some nice straight grained white oak, you could rive and plane out some long tapered round pins to use as drawbore pins. Wouldn't last as long, but would also work.
That also does not mean that a cabinetmaker of the period would not have wanted a set of draw bore pins.
As I mentioned documentation before 1812 is lacking. I you have any, I would love to see it. I could perhaps give 100 inventories and not convince you. Dictionary.com puts the earliest use of the term at 1815-1825. If someone wanted drawbore pins in 1760 it would have been easy to make them. A lot easier to make than a chisel. The biggest argument is that they are not needed. A wooden pin will bring the joint into alignment without all the fuss.
There was a fellow who demonstrated making decorative banding at Williamsburg a few years ago. He was convinced that it could not have been done without a table saw. Maybe his own hand saw skills were lacking. The evidence suggests banding before the 18th century, table saws after the 18th century. Anyway this fellow went so far as to invent a hand cranked table saw and pass out diagrams so we would know how they made banding in the 18th century. Working backwards to reinvent history is not very productive.
Did the furniture maker in 1750 have nail sets? I would think so given the stuff that got nailed back then. Something that always strikes me when in a shop where its owner is making a living from wood working is how efficient they seem to be when it comes to tools. Whatever can be pressed into service to do a job is fair game. If a tapered nail set was common and a tapered pin was needed occasionally the nail set could be a solution to the need.
I have not seen mentioned any reference to draw pins in the shop inventories listed in Schiffers book on Chester Co. furniture makers. But it may have been such a trivial item as to not merit mention.
I never have seen the need for drawbore pins so it doesn't surprise me that they are not included in inventories. If I need to temporarily hold a joint together I use the same pins for the finished joint, I just don't drive them home. It is trivial to back them out and re-use them. The historic joyners and cabinetmakers probably did the same and saved their hard earned money for a pint of ale.
1. you have not found any reference to the use of draw bore pins prior to some date.
That is not complete evidence that they were not in use. No I don't have documentation,
but neither is the conclusion drawn complete and total. It looks good. BUT is still not complete.
2. I doubt strongly that the history of the use of any item from that period would be complete.
Back to my original point about the chest and its usage, I remembered that there was a passage about its useage but I did have my copy near my computer.
Now I do. So I submit the following quote from the BOOK.
The Tool Chest of Benjamin Seaton isbn 0 947673 07 5 page 14
"It is probable that Benjamin never used the tools. Although a small number of tools have been damaged or lost, we may safely assume that these have been used casually, in ignorance, by some later keeper of the chest."
My main point here in this discussion is that finding documentation on the use of or inclusion in a tool chest is not necessarily complete proof of use or non-use by professionals of the time.
Historians have a very difficult time being able to construct an definitive and accurate idea of what was used at a given time in history. This is due in part to the lack of real information or the reliable dating of such material.
I do the same. Steel draw bore pins are easy to make by adding a handle to inexpensive tapered alignment pins, but the wooden pins that will be driven in are the easiest thing to use to check that everything lines up.
I don't think drawbore pins are necessary but they are useful and if not existent in the far past they must have used something similar to perform the task. I came upon this little bit in Chris Schwarz blog.---Jack
Schwarz is talking about hook pins. Filibien illustrates hook pins,Cheville de fer pour assembler(iron pins for assembly), in the carpentry section of his 1667 work. He does not mention or illustrate any pins in the corresponding joiner section.
Here is Felibien's engraving:
Moxon 1678 likewise mentions "hook pins" in his carpentry section and talks about their use. He also illustrates a hook pin. He does not mention hook pins or darwbore pins in the section on joinery.
Hook pins are also illustrated in Diderot (1763), again in the carpentry section termed Cheville d'Assemblage; no illustration in the joinery section. Roubo (1769) does not discuss carpentry and I don't think there is any mention of pins in the three volume work. Certainly no illustration.
The first mention of drawbore pins is in Nicholson (1812), in the carpentry section where he says hook pins are used by carpenters, drawbore pins by joiners. Nicholson says hook pins are made of iron. In the section on joinery there is no mention, no illustration.
Felibien, Moxon, Diderot, and Nicholson all illustrate a hook on the end of the pin for removal.
This thread has lots of information that just plain isn't correct.
1 - Drawbore pins are illustrated in Smith's Key (item 160) (1816). So they exisited as least that far back. There might be earlier material but I don't have it.
2 - The most obvious reason that they are not in the Seaton chest is that they are a specialized tool needed mostly by some chairmakers, Doormakers, and housewrights. Not worth the space for a general cabinetmaker just starting out.
3 - They are not iron pins - If you take an iron pin and shove it in a pair of offset holes you distort the holes. Drawbore pins have a profile of an oblique cone. You can't just take a tapered pin and get the same result. Some catalogs even draw in the offset. Historic sets have them.
4 - They are still used in the steel girder industry for pulling joints together.
5 - All they are is clamps. With them you can trivially lock assemble a drawbored joint, twist close, check alignment on other joints, and shoulder fits on the tenon and have the joint fall apart with another twist. They are much faster and more convenient for this specialized purpose than bar clamps, and on really large stuff like doors, bar clamps are awkward for one person to use. If you do one or two large pieces a year it might be hard to justify the cost and space in the tool box. If you are a production doormaker for example you will most certainly have them.
6 - Most antique drawbore pins found are fairly large, reflecting their use on doors and house construction. Smaller sizes exist, which would be more appropriate for furniture and chairs.
As I mentioned above, I made a set of drawbore (DB) pins from round cross-section, tapered divider legs. I say round cross-sectioned, because you suggested above that true DB pins are elliptical. My round pins DO indeed work to pull a MT joint together temporarily to test. Are elliptical DB pins better? Maybe. The plain round ones do work just fine. I've also used round cross-section metal automotive alignment pins and they work fine as well. They are just shorter than divider legs.
Are dedicated metal DB pins needed? I really don't think so and I enjoyed Paul's comment that maybe folks simply used extra tapered wood pins and saved the $$ for an extra ale!
As I said draw bore pins are an oblique cone - not an ellipse.
I am glad you are happy with the tools you made, although to really say one style works better than the other you need to compare both and see over time if there is an advantage to you.
For me, having draw bore pins is an advantage over wooden pins or a drift pin because - in order for a draw bore to work wooden pins need to distort and removing them is a pain. In my case, while I don't have a lot of projects, I find myself assembling and disassembling joints more than more experienced hands. So having a fast clamp - that does not distort the hole or get stuck in the joint a real boon. And their historical use, lots of M+T joints in a production environment is also a boon for people who need them. But is it a required tool for most people - no.
This thread has lots of information that just plain isn't correct.
1 - Drawbore pins are illustrated in Smith's Key (item 160) (1816). So they exisited as least that far back. There might be earlier material but I don't have it.
Twice in this thread I noted an 1812 reference to drawbore pins. Where is the false information?
3 - They are not iron pins - If you take an iron pin and shove it in a pair of offset holes you distort the holes. Drawbore pins have a profile of an oblique cone. You can't just take a tapered pin and get the same result.
Not iron pins? see above. Not round? here is Smith (1815)
An Iron pin is different from an iron pin that is also an oblique cone. it's subtle but important. Your written description while contemporary is wrong. The obliqueness part of the cone isn't obvious unless you look for it, but it's the reason why they lock with a turn not a push. and you get huge mechanical advantage. Modern ones - used in the steel girder industry don't even have a long handle, just a place for a wrench to turn it (a long handle for leverage would be very dangerous on the top of a skyscraper). I don't fault the writer, it's an obscure tool used for specialist purposes and it's not even an obvious geometric difference.
While some catalogs show the obliqueness drawn in to the cone, not all do. And since you mention you don't use them or plan to get them (and there is no reason you should) and it's not something readily documented so you wouldn't necessarily know about it. I only know about them because I accidentally discovered one day that my joint closed up just by turning the pin, something that wouldn't happen if my pins were just a cone. Then I started looking around and all the antiques I found for tool companies had the same geometry, and then Ray Iles looked at dozens more samples and found the same thing - and originally we thought the bend was from use, but too many samples and too hard to bend prove otherwise.
But the clincher for me - that it wasn't an accident - was two fold - Ray pointed out that the ends of historic pins are never beat up as they would if you tried to force them in a hold and needed to bang them to remove. and finding that the exact geometry (exaggerated a little) is used in the steel industry for the same purpose was the clincher. Later I found catalog illustrations that showed the correct geometry it but it's not universal.
An oblique cone doesn't work, because it is everywhere circular in cross section. It only works, relatively ineffectively, by being pushed further into the joint, but not by twisting it.
What you want is an elliptical cone. (See drawing.) You insert it with the major axis parallel to the tenon shoulders and twist it in either direction. A bent handle works even better, because it gives you immediate visual and tactile feedback to the orientation of the major and minor axes of the ellipse, in addition to increasing the torque you can apply to the tool.