Hey Bill, Thought we were talking dovetails.
Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
Posts
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#27Re: Likely not.....
BrianMonumentCO
That was sort of my point.
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#28Re: This information supports my speculation
TomD
Interesting stuff.
I think Brian has probably tripped onto the modern inevitability of wasting less time by refusing to get caught up in the discussion that clearly doesn't mater. (combining two answers in one post)
Bill, how did they remove the non-pin waste. Either way, you have to chop one board width to do any dovetail, regardless off how you proportion it. Except if a given proportioning allows you to saw the waste (etc...), and making the sockets small does make it easier to go at the pin board. Just wondered if he had a technique for that, otherwise it is sorta 6 of one and half a dozen of the other.
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#29Re: OK--Flickr shots
TomD
Not sure what the argument was, but that settles it!!
Nice double gloat with the chest in the back.
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#30Re: Torture
TomD
One of the counter arguments to the idea that various imperial powers sponsor schools of torture, is the idea that if you survey methods of torture there isn't actually a consistency of style, or at least not in all cases. Just happened to be reading about this, and in fact there are other reasons to reject that argument. But in the case of furniture making, is there any mechanism that would establish a national culture? There are apprenticeships, and rules governing guilds and so forth, but apprenticeship is not necessarily based on the idea that there is a national curriculum as it is on the idea that whatever the master does must be working for him. Of course there can be prizes and such... There are different schools of martial arts based on the imprint of a particular master. Maybe the same thing applies here. And then there are completely different trades that each use dovetails.
Should we expect national similarities, particularly given that in this technical case, neither approach seems supreme.
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#31A third option
markhennebury
You can mark out both pins and tails and cut them independently to the lines instead of cutting one and scribing the other.
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#32Re: OK--Flickr shots
Steve Voigt
Wow. Gorgeous work, Wiley!!!
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#33Re: OK--Flickr shots
markhennebury
Beautiful work! I would like to see more of both pieces, and construction photos.
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#34I want everyone to know ...
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
... that Wiley could not have done ANY of that work - either the dovetailing or any of the fitting - without my knife. He owes it ALL to my knife (no extra skills needed)! 
Extremely .. extraordinarily excellent work, Wiley!
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#35Second that request
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#36It must be true
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Using my knife I have no doubt that I would have sheared off one or more of those pins while chiseling near them.........or.......maybe its the chisel?
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#37What can you say!
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#38Well, it is not
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
"6 of one and half a dozen of the other"
And the reason would be clear after doing it. We are talking about a production shop, 6 drawer per day quota. Sharpening chisels doesn't make product, among other considerations.
The tiny pin hole is cut in the hard white oak. Three saw cuts and a paring cut and done. The large waste is removed from mahogany which is the most pleasant wood to chisel there is.
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#39Meaningless
Warren in Lancaster, PA
And the reason would be clear after doing it. We are talking about a production shop, 6 drawer per day quota. Sharpening chisels doesn't make product, among other considerations.
Without knowing just what they were doing and the quality involved, such a quota is meaningless. If they were making the drawers with all hand work from rough lumber, six drawers in a day would be remarkable. If they were just dovetailing the six drawers it would be kind of pitiful. And if sharpening a chisel did not increase efficiency, you have to question their sharpening ability. One would have to actually inspect the work to have an opinion.
There is a woodworking factory near where I live. New recruits are given two weeks to make their quota. The website says "highest quality". Maybe they deserve a cartouche award.
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#40Wow.....
roger lance
So, you equate cartouche winners with guys with two weeks of experience. Can't tell if you think so lowly of cartouche winners.....or just highly of someone whose been at it for a couple of weeks.
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#41Re: Wow.....
Warren in Lancaster, PA
Sorry you missed my point, Roger.
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#42Re: Wow.....
roger lance
Warren.....I'm getting old and I'm not as perceptive as I use to be.....but sometimes, I get the underlying motivation in things.
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#43Re: Well, it is not
TomD
Of course another one of those old saws is the idea that tiny pins where cabinetmaker dovetails, of the highest quality. But you are basically saying that they chose their method because it was cheaper to produce. Maybe the two just go hand in hand in this case.
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#44just repeating Alan ......
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
......what Alan Batty said in a class.
Like I said, Alan is noted as a turner, the best I have ever encountered I might add. But then he did it many hours a day for many years. When he taught he was the most entertaining person I ever took a class from. He was also good teacher too. He had me using a skew with confidence in a short time.
He never stopped telling tales from his experiences working wood. The time they were turning an architectural column, interrupted the job to quick turn a newel for a carpenter in need and forgot to re-adjust the pulleys on the line shaft, was priceless, but that will wait for another day. It ended with a destroyed tea cart and an apprentice never being seen again.

And he entertained with turning demonstrations - making a jar with wood threaded screw cap, turning a billiard ball (that was amazing, but he allowed that that was how they were made in the day), furniture feet of several kinds. The pine foot was turned in seconds. He said he made thousands for lamp bases for a factory. The bun foot is mine that he fixed. Mine looked not right but I knew not why. A little smidgen removed here and there and it was perfect. The main change was making the cover asymmetrical.
Apparently during his journeyman years he worked for a time at a factory that made mahogany furniture. He talked of logs on the yard as thick as he was tall. His job there was making drawers. Someone asked him about skinny dovetails and that was the answer I remember he gave. It made perfect sense to me. Later I emailed him for more drawer construction details and got a friendly letter back from him with more details on approach, how the slips were done, etc. I have since seen what he described on English furniture at a shop in Shelbyville, KY.
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#45Concur - our training also
Andrew F in Australia
Just a 'me too' post -
This is our trade training also
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#46Thanks to all that reported their experience
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I was under the apparent false impression that pins first was more common than it appears to be.
Nailing two drawer sides together, fitting them to the opening and then making tails on them is efficient for me. It is what I learned in the Headley shop.
Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
#47Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
BrianMonumentCO
Thank you for your post.
It confirmed what I had already suspected.
It paralleled what Jim Kingshott said in his video on cutting dovetails.
But with a twist.



