Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?
TomD
Tails first seems to be the rule these days. But the reverse was true when I started. The first person I really heard of doing Tails first was Becksvoort. The early articles he wrote on that were as though he was an outsider, he said the only reason he started was because his dad had told him it couldn't be done, I think his dad was a proper cabinetmaker. Everyone I grew up copying was pins first. Some of the reasons were ridiculous, like that the scribe or pencil follows the grain better, which is true, but if you are cutting dovetails you can handle a detail like that. Another favourite was that the mark from tails is eliminated in the first cut of the saw, which is also, true, but again, if you can cut dovetails you can handle that. Back then with the absolute crap saws we had it could happen that the saw would stutter, and erase the line before the cutting had even started. But today the saws are fine.
Another advantage, it seems, is that with pins you can just drop the part vertically on the end of the tail board, and it will balance there under it's own weight, you can see all around it, and you can easily draw in the lines. It seems that with tails first, you see a lot more jigs, or complex set-ups to get the unit copied off.
Also, in the pins set up, you can do an accurate transfer from a non-flat board. You can rock and spin the piece to a decent approximation. Not sure how you do that with tails first. But most of us had dead flat assemblies, but in carpentry, you can't always work with straight boards, one can get pine to mark off, when it is pretty bad, then hammer it together, and the joint glues shut and looks good.
The only advantage I have heard that is convincing with the tails first is the idea you can gang cut boards which seems to appeal to beginners. I think they see the advantage to getting a wider surface to saw, to only cutting once for two boards. Obviously some pros like that also, but if you have good skill, you are still hard put beating Klausz when he goes pins first. And people really aren't in that much of a rush. If you suggest techniques to go fast, they don't care much, but technique that are hand tool techniques, and also not jig, but are easier, that sells. So we seem to have converted full over to tails first.
All the early guys I read, like Krenov, Frid, Klausz, Kirby, were all pin first guys. The early influences seemed more European back then, but oddly, a guy called Schwartz has tipped the balance and most people are more English in practice with French benches.
I have heard the practice in England was more tail first, but I have nothing much to base that one. I think I heard that here.