New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

Posts

Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#1

Tails or pins first?  Nurture or nature?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Not looking for personal advice. Is there a cultural factor?

Background: Our club has some good woodworkers so I was far from first on the list to ask to demonstrate through dovetails, but apparently I was the first to agree. For background I would like to say something about the pin vs tail first choice. Indeed I don't get out much for I have only encountered three people that did pins first- Klause(video), Kirby (book) , and Alan Batty who worked building drawers in an English furniture factory, who when asked, acted as though there wasn't any alternative, Maybe there isn't for their tiny pins. So, from my limited data this choice appears to be derived from European trained vs home grown in the US, for I have never met anyone else that did pins first.

Is there anything to this limited observation that tails first is more a US trained choice?

Are there advantages of pins first, other than the obvious difficulty of marking the tiny pins characteristic of English drawers?

Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#2

Re: Tails or pins first?  Nurture or nature?

wilbur

If you’re not going to do tails first, how do you half-blind or full-blind dovetails?

Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#3

Maybe that's the origin of rebating

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

the tails board. Gives you a registration for the pins board, if you go pins first.

For what it's worth, Ernest Joyce in 'Encyclopedia of Furniture Making' states three things (p. 171 of my paperback copy):

1. In practice 'it hardly matters' whether pins or tails are made first;

2. The general practice is tails first; and

3. For secret mitered dovetails or tall carcase sides, you have to go pins first.

He doesn't mention the lapped dovetails issue that Wilbur raises.

Can someone explain why tall carcase sides would require pins first? I get that the sides carry the pins. But it strikes me that, whether pins or tails first, the essential point is that the transfer has to be made with the long carcase side flat on the bench, with the short top and bottom stood vertical--seems like you could manage to transfer marks either way.....?*

Wiley

*Yeah, I know Bill's talking about drawer construction, but maybe there's a short answer.

Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#4

Re: same way

david weaver

same way you do any other pins and tails if you cut tails first. Lay the tail board over the end of the board, butt the end of the tails up to the depth line for the thickness of the front under the HB and trace them.

Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#5

carcase sides would require pins first

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Not the way I do it. I dry fit the dovetailed dividers in a few drawer positions to fix the sides in place and put the tailed top on the case and mark it. The picture shows some clamps holding a false top in place to be marked. (I don't like slipping tail boards and no amount of effort to prevent slipping is too much for me.)


Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#6

Re: carcase sides would require pins first

david weaver

that is exactly what I was attempting to describe.

No matter what, the marking of the second cut on something large like a case is a cumbersome undertaking.

Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#7

Re: Tails or pins first?  Nurture or nature?

TomD

Tails first seems to be the rule these days. But the reverse was true when I started. The first person I really heard of doing Tails first was Becksvoort. The early articles he wrote on that were as though he was an outsider, he said the only reason he started was because his dad had told him it couldn't be done, I think his dad was a proper cabinetmaker. Everyone I grew up copying was pins first. Some of the reasons were ridiculous, like that the scribe or pencil follows the grain better, which is true, but if you are cutting dovetails you can handle a detail like that. Another favourite was that the mark from tails is eliminated in the first cut of the saw, which is also, true, but again, if you can cut dovetails you can handle that. Back then with the absolute crap saws we had it could happen that the saw would stutter, and erase the line before the cutting had even started. But today the saws are fine.

Another advantage, it seems, is that with pins you can just drop the part vertically on the end of the tail board, and it will balance there under it's own weight, you can see all around it, and you can easily draw in the lines. It seems that with tails first, you see a lot more jigs, or complex set-ups to get the unit copied off.

Also, in the pins set up, you can do an accurate transfer from a non-flat board. You can rock and spin the piece to a decent approximation. Not sure how you do that with tails first. But most of us had dead flat assemblies, but in carpentry, you can't always work with straight boards, one can get pine to mark off, when it is pretty bad, then hammer it together, and the joint glues shut and looks good.

The only advantage I have heard that is convincing with the tails first is the idea you can gang cut boards which seems to appeal to beginners. I think they see the advantage to getting a wider surface to saw, to only cutting once for two boards. Obviously some pros like that also, but if you have good skill, you are still hard put beating Klausz when he goes pins first. And people really aren't in that much of a rush. If you suggest techniques to go fast, they don't care much, but technique that are hand tool techniques, and also not jig, but are easier, that sells. So we seem to have converted full over to tails first.

All the early guys I read, like Krenov, Frid, Klausz, Kirby, were all pin first guys. The early influences seemed more European back then, but oddly, a guy called Schwartz has tipped the balance and most people are more English in practice with French benches.

I have heard the practice in England was more tail first, but I have nothing much to base that one. I think I heard that here.

Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#8

Re: Tails or pins first?  Nurture or nature?

TomD

Wilbur, it is the same, you just align the pins over the tail board, the pin board is vertical over the tail board, so the view isn't blocked. You can align the face of the pin to the edge of the tail, or use scribes.

Frid did the Half Blind video for FWW, and he was almost of the opinion that it was impossible to cut the tails first. Sorta odd. Wouldn't you therefore need to be a highly superior woodworker to pull off this amateur stunt? :)

I think what happens is pros get more comfortable doing it their way, so they don't want or need to try something else, and there may be tradition involved also. If you can't do it either way, both ways are equally hard. Have a thousand joints under your belt one way, and the other way is almost harder for you, relatively.

Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#9

Re: Tails or pins first?  Nurture or nature?

BrianMonumentCO

Jim Kingshott, was a tail first guy. He also made the point about the dovetailed secret mitre joint needing to be pins first. He made a deal out of that.

Jim was English.

Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#10

There is an advantage to pins first ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

This is not a "cultural" answer, more one of ease.

Let it be noted that I saw my dovetails tails first, but I am not adverse to going the other way as well.

I am also an amateur, and do not have to make many. I enjoy the opportunity when I can, so extra effort is not a problem. Further, I am set up to saw them tails first, and for these reasons continue this practice.

However ... if I were a professional, and the dovetails I made were for high-end drawers, that is, involved slim "London" style tails, then I would cut the pins first. Why? Because doing so does not rely on a skinny bladed knife and extreme care how one runs said skinny blade along a difficult-to-access tail wall when transferring the marks to the pin board. Just saw the pins - which requires no special effort to create tails of any width - and transfer these without extra fuss.

If they were not skinny dovetails, it makes no difference which way when it comes to transferring marks, but tails first is preferred for the option of gang sawing.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#11

Re: Or the reality is

TomD

No idea, because as you say we are the amateurs, worse still furniture today is so simplified. I would assume if there is a reason to do pins first it would have something to do with stuff we never think of. For instance, let us just suppose you finished a gilded, etc... drawer front, would you want that to determine the side nobody sees? Let's say the apprentice you passed it off to messes it up which would you prefer to have him working on the front or the sides? Would you be more influenced by the fab time savings of ganging the tails, or the possibility of keeping his jammie dabs for the most part entirely off your piece.

But then again you can argue, that in a shop that did that kind of work, their apprentice would never muff the piece... Hard to know, but it isn't likely to have to do with the way we think of stuff today.

When my cousin came back from getting her OBE at the Palace she had video that included in-the-background shots of furniture, in the public waiting area, that was so far beyond anything I have ever seen in the homes of the wealthy around here, or in the auction catalogs they keep, that it really scared me. I will never even know what that level of stuff looked like, let alone be able to imagine the processes of the people who made it.

Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#12

Re: There is an advantage to pins first ...

BrianMonumentCO

Could you not making an excuse for not having the right kind of marking knife?

Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#13

Re: Tails or pins first?  Nurture or nature?

BrianMonumentCO

Pro or amateur, once you do it one way enough times, you will develop familiarity with that way.

And the other way will appear harder as you are not practiced in that technique.

Yet that also assumes that you actually make all different types of dovetail joints as some are harder to do tail first than pin first. As Jim Kingshott says in his dovetail video we cut the tails first for all the dovetail types except that the pins are cut first for the secret dovetailed miter joint (some of those words may be in the wrong order but you get the idea).

I wonder if one was apprenticing would one learn just the masters way and not learn the other way.

(Assuming that there are actually two ways that pros do it.)

As a self taught person, I expect to try different techniques that I see until, I find one that I find most comfortable.

Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#14

Re: Tails or pins first?  Nurture or nature?

Sgian Dubh

Brian, as a UK trained and UK based professional I was taught that either tails or pins first were fine, whichever suited your work methods and the job in hand. Common through dovetails could be done either way for a one-off, but we were taught the advantage of stacking multiple pairs of tail pieces together to cut the tails first where it made sense, e.g., a pair of drawer sides, or two, three, or even four pairs if the parts were all the same. I think the maximum number of pieces I've stacked together to cut the tails all in one go is four pairs, but I can't recall for sure. In the case of the common through dovetail I don't remember when last I cut the pins first, probably some time back in the 1970s.

With lap dovetails for things like drawer fronts it's always tails first for me- it's easier to transfer the rakes of the tails to the pin piece, and there's the opportunity for gang cutting, always done even for a pair of drawer sides, and once ganged I do the dovetails at front and back (front lap and rear through) at the same time. Doing the pins first just doesn't work well because it's very hard to transfer the rakes where the length of pins on the drawer front and the back are only 8- 10 mm to match the drawer side thickness, the same, just about, as the pin length. It becomes do-able where the pins are longer, say, from about 14 or 15 mm upwards because you can reach into the space easier with the knife used to score the lines. But why bother when you can save time ganging together pairs of tail pieces? It's pretty rare to make just one corner that's dovetailed together with either lap or common through dovetails where it would perhaps make sense to me to cut pins first, but not unheard of.

Secret mitre and secret lapped dovetails have to be done pins first because it's the only way the rakes can be transferred from one part to the other. It's been a long time since I cut either, possibly twenty or more years, and that's primarily down to the relatively long time required to execute the job with a matching labour charge to the client. Economically, it generally becomes difficult to sell such high costing joinery incorporated in a piece of furniture and more economical joinery methods tend to be used. Naturally, for the hobby or amateur woodworker this sort of economic or business calculation is likely to be of lesser (or even non-existent) importance, and there may be other priorities, e.g., the satisfaction of doing the job, skills development, just even the fun of it, etc. Slainte.

Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#15

This information supports my speculation

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Alan Batty described to me his experience working in an English furniture factory where he made drawers with mahogany fronts and oak sides. My notes of this conversation say that it was standard practice to make pins first. Furthermore, the skinny pin holes were not for fashion. Oak is hard to chisel. Three saw cuts and one paring cut established one pinhole in the hard oak side.

The quota for the workmen at the factory was 6 drawers per day. Obviously they got good, and efficient, at it.

Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#16

Likely not.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I'll bet there is no style of knife that Derek lacks.

See my note about Alan Batty.

Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#17

Re: This information supports my speculation

CJ in MPLS

I was already getting a Monty Python vibe from this discussion with the whole Judean People's Front v. the People's Front of Judea aspect to this topic that so often arises.

But your statement that "[o]bviously they got good, and efficient, at it" created a bit of constructive interference with the famous line: "it got better".

Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#18

Certainly not.....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

I recently did three drawers worth of single entry pins, going tails first. The tails were all transferred to the pin board (drawer fronts) by knife, marking through the narrow and sharply tapering sockets in the tails boards (drawer sides).

All the transfers were made using a Derek Cohen knife (a most kind gift from the man himself), with a blade thickness of about 1/32". It's similar to the Blue Spruce small marking knife. I didn't have any trouble about it--transferred each tail wall to the drawer front end grain by making two headings, i.e., cutting from each end of the socket into the middle. I can visualize someone making a hook bill knife--like a parrot's beak--which could simplify making this mark, but for me it isn't worth it to go make a separate tool.

Derek's knife works just fine. I think he's being modest in his post above. In fact, I know it :) .

Wiley

Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#19

Documentation?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

We have not seen any photo documentation of this claim of making skinny pin drawers for whatever the drawers are for :)

Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#22

Now that's documentation!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Ok, I'm now convinced the pins are indeed small.

But it just raises yet more questions. What is the finish? What is that lurking behind the table. How did you cut the troughs for the unrevealed species of black wood banding? How is the drawer front constructed. That doesn't look like conventional cock beading?

Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#23

Re: top shelf,  Wiley!!


Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#24

Another county heard from

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

My experience is nowhere near Alan Batty's, or many here, but I find that the use of single-entry pins simplifies the job, even if you start with tails first. The main reason for this is what is happening at the tails board. If you're ganging sides (as Sgian Dubh points out), after you make the first cut, that's also your entry for the matching cut--the start of the cut has already been made. It's almost like making half as many saw cuts, it goes so fast. Not that fast matters so much, you just have the feeling of efficiency.

On the pin side, making them is no more difficult, except that you have to be very careful of the apexes (or is it apices?) of the pins during casual handling and stacking, etc. Once they're inserted, no problem, they're protected, but until they are, they're very delicate.

Wiley

Re: Tails or pins first? Nurture or nature?

#25

Nice Job!!!