New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

Posts

Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#1

Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

One thing lead to another, and I wrote a series of articles ... four in all.

It just seemed to flow in that direction.

It began with the idea that if one could design a plane of their dream, what what they include? Lee Valley recently released the Custom Bench Plane concept, and I have a jointer and a smoother. I also have a bunch of parts ... and together they offer the opportunity to explore different combinations. And then compare these with BU equivalents and Stanley equivalents ........

You get the message. It became bigger than Ben Hur.

I'd like the articles to be a springboard for discussion here. Some of it is old stuff, but there is also new stuff. I can add, modify, include what is written to the articles.

1. Introduction: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/VeritasCustomPlanes1.html

2. Designing a Plane: tips on choosing and tuning: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/VeritasCustomPlanes2.html

3. Designing a Plane: Knobs and Handles - or how we really use a plane! : http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/VeritasCustomPlanes3.html

4. To Chipbreak or Not to Chipbreak: frog angle choice : http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/VeritasCustomPlanes4.html

Happy New Year and ...

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#2

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

roger lance

Derek......There is an overuse of a term here in the US that really applies to the efforts you make in these evaluations.....amazing. I am amazed at the work you have done here and I'll be studying these articles much more closely learning what I can.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#3

Question?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have convinced myself that positioning of the cap iron is less critical (less fiddly) with a 50 bed angle. Anyone have experience to support, or not, this notion?

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#4

craigd

Re: Question?

craigd

I have convinced myself that positioning of the cap iron is less critical (less fiddly) with a 50 bed angle. Anyone have experience to support, or not, this notion?

Of 16+ planes I have with 50°+ cutting angles, none have cap irons. And don't need them (in my use on the woods I work anyway). My rack of Stanley's are the only planes with cap irons (well, one Japanese plane and an old wooden razee that see no use).

If you wish to see the kind of work I do, here are a couple of video; one with Stanley #7, followed by a single iron panel plane.

http://youtu.be/Phusogf5wMs

http://youtu.be/F_LfmcjOOQ4

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#5

Re: Question?

david weaver

Everyone can work differently, it's not like any of us are challenging the minions of computer powered power tools in terms of output.

I would've done both of the operations you showed with one plane, though.

You don't need the cap iron, but it would've sped up the process. that's where the contention comes on the forum, when someone says something like I just said there, but it's the case, because a second plane with a double iron or backing off the set of the first one would allow an equivalent finish level with a thicker shaving until the very last pass.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#6

craigd

Re: Question?

craigd

Exactly - I do this because I like doing it, not because I need to do it to eat. I do it because I like the tools just as much as the result.

On this wood, a hand power planer [Makita, my scrub] leaves as good a finish as any of the other planes, I happen to like the progression and each plane is tuned to that step (and both planes are taking about the same amount of wood off).

On my Stanleys, I can't set cap iron close enough to the edge to be all that effective (due to shape, clearances, etc) and I find it fidgety (I have a custom plane w/custom cap where I can set the cap close), I just find my temperament is much better suited to a single iron.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#7

Re: Question?

TomD

Interesting thought. One way to look at it is the 50 is doing part of the work already, so you can open up the cap iron range and it works because the cap iron is sorta tailing ths having, not required to do all the work.

Another way of looking at it is with the more upright blade the cap iron gets a better trap on the shaving, and presses it down better, so to get the same result as with say a 45, you have more leeway.

I sorta like the second answer better, though it could be both or other answers. But if you think of a conceptual plane with a zero degree bedding angle, it would not press the shaving into the cut at all, all the force would be parallel to the cut, short of maybe some buckling down force. In that case the cap iron does not hold the shaving down till it is cut. So the angle of the plane would affect cap iron performance, which just ads another band of functions in which it is not of any particular aid.

Bill did you find it easier to plane at 50 degrees with the breaker, meaning did you find resistance any different, or just the fitting less fiddly.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#8

That right there...

david weaver

>>I just find my temperament is much better suited to a single iron.<<

That's plenty reason enough.

That and whatever it takes for max enjoyment.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#9

Re: For other than heavy work..

david weaver

..it's probably a little bit easier. I only have one plane with a cap iron at 50, and I've not used it extensively with the cap.

I wouldn't like to use it at 50 for heavy work when 45 is available, though.

Most people don't do heavy work with planes, so it probably doesn't matter much.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#10

Re: Question?

TomD

I don't think the main issue is that the situation you describe does not exist. The question is how large a window it is. We are in the usual honeymoon phase, and whatever people believe is the be all and end all, will moderate, as all the fads presented by the fast movers have moderated over time. It only has a net efficiency advantage in a few situations. And while it may be an unfair squelch, the hand tool folks are not seen as being obsessed with speed in the first place.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#11

Re: For other than heavy work..

TomD

"Most people don't do heavy work with planes, so it probably doesn't matter much."

Doubtless you are correct in that, but it is a real miss. The small stuff isn't safe on most power tools unless you jig up for it, and the large stuff is too heavy to move to machines. So while I do push stuff through the planer when I can, it has it's decided limitations. As you know.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#12

Re: For other than heavy work..

david weaver

I don't even know what people do with small stuff on power tools, that's definitely true. Do they order their work so that there's little chance of having small pieces to work with?

I never competently made much in my power tool phase, and what I did make was a lot of long trim and mitered corners and plywood carcases with glue and screws. Doing something even like a gradual curve was torture and required stuff like router templates, etc.

The guy I did woodworking with, I'll bet he and I would've solved as many of those as possible by starting with a larger stick and then cutting off the part we needed.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#13

Good grief!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I didn't ask if I needed a cap iron. If you go to the Gallery section you will find that I build stuff, a lot of stuff, only a fraction of which I have posted so far. It doesn't fall on a receptive ear being told what I need to build the stuff I build, the way I build it. Well, it might fall on a receptive ear if the advice givers offered some evidence that they too built a lot of stuff and didn't have but an inexpensive plane or two to employ in the building of the stuff they build. Sorry, but a video of flattening a piece of oak didn't do much for someone that would have done it on a jointer in a few seconds and gotten on to flattening the dozens of other pieces of wood necessary to make something.

I find a cap iron useful. Period, end of story. I have no interest in a discussion otherwise, though others are encouraged to argue its merits, in your own posts, and not hijack mine trying to ask a question. I would be delighted if the irrelevant posts to my question were deleted and resumed in a separate discussion of cap iron merit.

I'll get it stated by asking why the hell they were invented if they weren't useful to the people earning a living making furniture using them. Maybe one has to build stuff to discover the answer, I don't know. Answer elsewhere.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#14

craigd

Re: Good grief!

craigd

Since you seem to be replying to my reply, I feel compelled to [politely] ask what the hell you want to hear. I believe I answered your question regarding the importance of the position of the cap iron on a 50° cutting angle by showing it doesn't matter at all by removing the cap iron. You asked for experience, I gave it. I even provided videos so you could evaluate if my experience was of value to you. And I get a load of crap about how you build zillions pieces while all I do is flatten boards with expensive planes. You know, I could crank out your work quite a bit faster [than you do] by using CNC machines, line and berries included. Why the hell are you giving me ch!t about using hand tools in the Hand Tools forum? Why do you post "in process" articles when you obviously don't give a rats hinny about my "in process" articles? Just because I don't post to the Gallery doesn't mean I haven't built stuff, you need to get out more, there is a whole world outside your head.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#15

Ellis Walentine

Let's lighten it up

I have great respect for all you guys. I'm asking that you act with more deference to each other if you want to discuss this topic here. Everyone is entitled to his opinion. Let's keep it civil.

Thanks in advance.

Ellis

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#16

Answer to question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)



I have convinced myself that positioning of the cap iron is less critical (less fiddly) with a 50 bed angle. Anyone have experience to support, or not, this notion?

Hi Bill

This is one of the many points I could have included in the article, but omitted as there was already too muh detail.

I did state at the start that my reason for recommending to LV that the 50-degree frog be included in the line up was that it was the ideal mid ground. For many - those who use relatively uncomplicated wood - it would not be necessary to use the chipbreaker at all. And for those who do use complicated wood, the chipbreaker can come into play.

A couple of years ago, when we were still debating the chipbreaker, and there was experimenting and videoing going on, one of the pieces I did was to demonstrate that thebed angle and the chipbreaker were additive. That is, the higher the cutting angle, the more it reduced tear out, and this went up exponentially with a close set chipbreaker.

The question you ask is whether a higher bed angle makes the distance to the edge of the blade less critical. My thought, which is based on some experimentation here, as well as the research recently published by Kees, is that the angle at the leading edge of the chipbreaker is a central element. Keep in mind that the higher the bed, the more the angle increases at the leading edge (of the chipbreaker). A higher angle may be pulled back a little further - which is all to say that a 50-degree frog should be less critical to set up.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#17

Re: Question?

Steve Voigt

I have convinced myself that positioning of the cap iron is less critical (less fiddly) with a 50 bed angle. Anyone have experience to support, or not, this notion?

That is my experience as well. I have made a bunch of double iron planes at 50° and it is my preferred angle, though I am currently dabbling with, and possibly preferring, 47.5°, which is the angle that the original English double irons were built at (see Seaton book for example).

I like 50° because it's like a nice car with an extra gear. The plane will handle most of the things I plane without about the chipbreaker too much, but when I need it, it's there. Hit a little tear-out, drop into low gear--er, I mean, set the chipbreaker a little closer, problem solved.

Kees has some experimental data on Steve Elliot's site that supports this as well, maybe he'll chime in. The gist, IIRC, was that a 50° plane with the chipbreaker set at 2 mm behaved like a 45° plane with the breaker set a 1 mm. Or something like that. Anyway, my own experience agrees with his conclusions.

I have to push back on David a little; I disagree completely that a 50° is not suitable for heavy work. All of Larry and Don's planes, AFAIK, are either 50° or 55°. Regardless of what you think about single vs. double, I hope you would agree that those guys are designing their planes for heavy work. Given the work they do for Williamsburg, there are probably more people using those planes for heavy work than any other plane maker I can think of.

For myself, I do all my jointing and nearly all my thicknessing by hand, and I use 50° or 47.5° for everything.

Anyway, that's my $.02.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#18

Re: Question?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Steve

I agree with all your comments.

Just to clarify a point: my recommendation to Lee Valley was to include the 50-degree frog among the standard choices. I believe that most work could be done with this minus the chipbreaker. A 50-degree cutting angle on a BD plane requires no noticeable extra effort to push than a 45-degree cutting angle, and has a slightly better ability to cope with tearout. So why bother with 45 degrees?

For the woods I use, I need either significantly more than 50 degrees, or I need to use the chipbreaker. Since I was choosing the chipbreaker, I wanted to drop the cutting angle as low as possible, and in doing so I was also prepared to accept the extra care needed in setting it. Hence I went for a 42-degree frog. That makes it a smoother that is dedicated to use with a chipbreaker.

The same comments apply to the frog choices for the jointer.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#19

Re: Question?

Kees

Indeed, higher cutting angle and the close set capiron are two different things that can be combined. You can add a tight mouth to that. A higher cutting angle works to prevent tearout because it reduces the lifting force on the shaving, the capiron works because the shaving is supported during the cut. they work from oposing sides of the shaving, so to speak. And at 50 degrees the extra force to push isn't too bad.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#20

Re: suitable...

david weaver

I should've probably clarified what I mean by that.

Not suitable means not as good for, at least that's how I meant it. I see how it could be taken as "not good enough for at all".

I did all of my heavy work with single iron planes back when I was a fanboy. I had a single iron jack and a nice JT brown single iron jointer bedded at 50 degrees.

It's just much faster to do the work with a double iron at common pitch. There's less resistance and more tearout protection. I had to sharpen the JT more often (which isn't a big deal because it was single iron), and it had less ability to stay in the cut (thank goodness kees did that study to actually prove that or I'd be excoriated for saying it).

If nobody else ever said anything about double irons other than warren and I never figured it out, I'd still be using them. It was just a little less easy to and took a little longer.

I'm not sure where Larry got some of his ideas about the double iron, but they are definitely coast to coast AM quality. I'm pretty sure with a day and some lumber to mill start to finish, I could convince him (well, I don't think he's looking for convincing!).

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#21

Useful information

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The consistent objection I hear from persons avoiding effectively using the cap iron is that setting it precisely seems too fiddly to adapt. This information on the effect of bed angle, or any other that makes setting the cap iron less forbidding, would be useful information to those that have considered trying it, or tired it unsuccessfully. I hope the confirmation you provided doesn't become lost in the other discussion.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#22

There is an important point here.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What works, what's best, must be tempered by the work environment that led to the experience, that led to the advice or conclusion. As an example, my needs for planing equipment and technique for leveling a drawer divider or fitting a drawer could be worlds away from someone striving for a ready to finish surface, or sizing a rough sawed plank.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#23

Re: I agree..

david weaver

..it gets lost in the shuffle, but I've said before a couple of times (in a video somewhere, and on several forums) that if someone is just putting a finish surface on a machine dimensioned board or panel, then my advice is probably no good unless they want to do all of their smoothing on the cheap.

The rest of the speed advantages are for people like me trying to do most of the rough work with hand tools.

I noticed on a video on FWW that in the Hay shop, they mentioned that it would take hundreds of hours to do the dimensioning of 120 board feet of wood in one of the large pieces. I was a bit confused by this, but they show workmen in the background working very slowly to get to finished dimension on what is probably mahogany. certainly machine planing would be faster for all of it, at least close to finish size, but it's my opinion that a lot of their time consumption has to do with being subsidized by the museum, and that if time mattered, they would be dimensioning much much faster, leaving only the final finish work to be done so deliberately.

But for the smoother only type of person, anything is fine.

Well, and craig's "i do whatever pleases me" point is fine, too. I think that's what we all do.

My drive for efficiency in dimensioning is to get that same flow, same physical satisfaction that you get when you learn to move and stack hay manually and efficiently, and can work at a good rate without completely wearing yourself out like a newbie in a barn would do. There's a physical and tactile satisfaction there.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#24

Re: Question?

Steve Voigt

Derek,

Makes sense to me. I mostly work American domestic hardwoods, but I can see how with your native woods, the situation would be quite different.

I have been pretty busy and haven't had a chance to read your reviews yet, but I certainly will. Between that and Dave's videos, it looks like my weekend is spoken for!

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#25

Re: Center of effort?

Lars Parrington

Having read through this series of articles and your previous article devoted to "Center of effort", I can't understand what you mean by the term. It seems like it could be the angle off horizontal of the line formed between the users rear hand and the tip of the blade. But, if so, I fail to see how there could be a difference in value between for example a BU and BD smoother if both are cast iron and have the same handle and similar handle position. I do understand that those two planes would have different centers of gravity.