New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

Posts

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#26

Re: Center of effort?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)



Having read through this series of articles and your previous article devoted to "Center of effort", I can't understand what you mean by the term. It seems like it could be the angle off horizontal of the line formed between the users rear hand and the tip of the blade. But, if so, I fail to see how there could be a difference in value between for example a BU and BD smoother if both are cast iron and have the same handle and similar handle position. I do understand that those two planes would have different centers of gravity.

Hi Lars

In a nutshell, "centre of gravity" refers to where the stability lies, for example, a low centre of gravity would see the weigh distributed low down. "Centre of effort", on the other hand, involves a movable centre of gravity, that is, we can direct where the centre of gravity will be. This can be low down or raised up high. When low down, we create stability (and power); when high up, we create instability (and an inefficient use of power).

Using our arm/hand, we create a force vector. In this instance the design of the handle, and where we direct force on the handle, will determine this vector.

Stanley planes create a higher centre of gravity by raising the blade up high on a vertical frog. One of the design factors for the custom planes that I did not mention in the article (as there was already too much info), was the construction of the body. What Lee Valley did was lower the centre of gravity on the custom planes with a convex floor, that is, adding extra mass along the length of the centre of the body. The blade is also shorter and its centre of gravity is also distributed lower. The BD Custom Plane still has a higher centre of gravity than the BU range, where the bed and blade is placed low on the body.


This combined lowered gravity along with the lowered centre of effort from vector on the handle design combine to create a different feel to a Stanley plane.

I found it interesting and ironic when Chris Schwarz posted on his blog his observation about the replacement Stanley handle (made by Bill Rittner) for his Lee Valley LA Jack: "I bought one of the first sets he made in cherry and put it on my Veritas jack yesterday. It dramatically changes the way the plane feels (and looks). With Rittner’s tote installed, it feels like I’m holding a Lie-Nielsen No. 62 that has a lot more mass.". What I have been emphasising is that one can help the Stanley/LN planes to feel more like Lee Valley by changing the handle to encourage a different vector.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#27

Re: Center of effort?

Lars Parrington

Derek, thanks for your response. Unfortunately, it didn't clarify things for me very much, if at all.

What I'm gathering from your response is that the "center of effort" could be defined as the height at which the user applies a horizontal force to the plane in order to move it forward along the workpiece. It seems self evident that this height would be best measured relative to the sole of the plane.

Consider a diagram of the forces acting upon a hand plane in the middle of a long stroke. Here the plane is being pushed at constant speed and so the forces are in equilibrium. It would show forces exerted by the user through both hands (each with both horizontal and vertical components). It would also show normal and frictional forces exerted by the workpiece upon the sole of the plane, as well as a force upon the cutting edge. Additionally, it would show the force of gravity, with an downwards arrow pointing to (or from) the plane's center of gravity (CG).

In the above case (and assuming the plane is being used on a level surface), the height of the plane's CG is irrevelant. However, if the plane were being accelerated (or decellerated), then an inertial force could be added to the diagram, which would act horizontally upon the plane's CG. During a very vigorous planing stroke, the height of that inertial force might begin to significantly affect how the plane moves, especially if the height of the CG is quite different from the height at which the user is pushing on the plane.

This is the only way I can see to relate the above definition of "center of effort" to both CG of the plane and to the "feel" of the plane. But it seems like a tenuous relationship at best, as it requires a highly energetic stroke and a large discrepancy between the heights of the CG and CE. So, I doubt this is what you are referring to by "center of effort".

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#28

Re: Center of effort?

TomD

Based on other fields, and this may be what you are saying, center of effort would be the point upon which the vector was applied. Not some variability in centre of gravity.

In the case I am suggesting, CG of japanese plane would be as you describe, and the weighted average position of the blade and the dai CG. You can apply the force to the plane below the center, when you grab the dai so they would be similar. On a Stanley, the center of gravity is low, the center of effort is higher up on the handle.

The only effort I can see that goes into a plane is the hand force, and in some cases, gravitational forces. There are also various drag forces, but they are not efforts.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#29

Re: Center of effort?

TomD

"the "center of effort" could be defined as the height at which the user applies a horizontal force to the plane in order to move it forward along the workpiece."

That is reassuring. I didn't get that at all, but that is what I think it should refer to. Except it is more than height, it is position along the plane, and any vector in any direction off dead straight ahead. Though in many cases the discussion might be simplified to include only height, and a simple forward direction.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#30

Re: For other than heavy work..

TomD

I made sleds with destacos, you can crank out parts. Or I tried to do it on the big machines, and on occasion I got it wrong and the machines barked at me.

Guitarmaking is an eye opener, they will have a jig for almost every part. You can make a huge percentage of the oddball parts on a 12" disc sander, with jigs. Not what most people think of when woodworking comes to mind.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#31

Re: funny you mentioned disc sanders...

david weaver

..the guy who got me into woodworking always troubled with mortises (this is before I used handtools). We put them into a multirouter and used card shims to get them tuned.

And then he saw someone use a disc sander, and next thing you know, both of us had disc sanders.

I've used mine exactly one time - to grind the front of an infill plane that I have.

I've seen some of the things guitar builders make, and get a stew mac catalog from time to time. There's ridiculous amounts of gadgets in those catalogs.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#32

Re: I agree..

TomD

"I noticed on a video on FWW that in the Hay shop, they mentioned that it would take hundreds of hours to do the dimensioning of 120 board feet of wood in one of the large pieces. I was a bit confused by this, but they show workmen in the background working very slowly to get to finished dimension on what is probably mahogany."

Depends what is meant by dimensioning, but given that they could in the old days order the wood cut to common dimensions for case work, as I understand it, yeah that sounds really slow. Basically they are saying it takes them as long as it takes a compentent guy to build 6 guitars to level the easiest wood you use in a guitar. It takes them over 1 hour per 2 square feet (both sides) of mahogany. That is pretty crazy.

Expressed as half a week to dimension the parts of a table top, maybe less crazy, but still not a several day job.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#33

Re: Center of effort?

Lars Parrington

Yes, "position along the plane, and vector direction off dead straight ahead" would have a big effect on the feel of the plane. But I think only when picking up or putting down, or starting and stopping the cut at the ends of the board, or waving the plane through the air, or planing with a skewed angle. I.e., only a fair amount of the time. But in all those instances, it is not the height of the CG or CE that matters, it is the horizontal placement. And it seems to me that Derek is concerned with the heights, since he is drawing a distinction between CE in BU vs BD planes.

I don't believe that "position along the plane, and vector direction off dead straight ahead" makes much difference during the bulk of a simple straight planing stroke.

For those two reasons, I specifically did not include position along the plane, and any vector in any direction off dead straight ahead in my suggested definition of CE.

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

#34

Re: Veritas Custom Planes - more than a review

TomD

I did read through your articles. Tough job to take on.

I exit the whirlwind of choices wondering if the marketing is correct. If you don't know you need a custom plane, or what you need, I wouldn't say you don't need one, but it is within the realm of possibility. It does seem that they have developed some interesting features along the way, and I found myself thinking it looked better than either of my bevel down, LV planes.

I don't doubt they did get the marketing right, like on the 50 degree thing, too close to 45, makes them look grasping had they made it standard. But maybe most people would still be better off to follow a species chart, or get a standard configuration, and let the customization be a mater of need. They should sell a ton of these planes just because they are better, and it would be a pity if they didn't because people found them confusing.

If they are sold out already... Never mind.